4 ms·
I just got access to the DALL-E 2 beta, and it's a ton of fun to make pictures out of everyday occurrences as prompts. Someone else here on HN observed that ev
by jiggawatts 4y ago
I just got access to the DALL-E 2 beta, and it's a ton of fun to make pictures out of everyday occurrences as prompts.
Someone else here on HN observed that everyday people don't "get" how huge this all is. I experimented with asking random acquaintances at a local cafe for prompts and showed them the generated pictures. All but one person was totally unimpressed.
If everything feels like magic, then what's one more piece of magic?
This scared me more than the implications of DALL•E 2 itself specifically. People think of the technology in the world as mysterious black boxes that do inexplicable things, and they hence no longer understand relative complexity, progress, or change.
My impression is that to most people DALL•E 2 is not "substantially" different to, say, Google Image search. Text in... image out. What's the big deal?
- dorkwood 4y agoThe thing is, regular people have been under the impression that computers are capable of generating complex imagery by themselves for quite some time already. About 10 years ago I was visiting family, and my uncle -- an older guy who enjoys tinkering with technology -- asked me to draw a picture on his new tablet. Now, I've spent a fair chunk of my life drawing, so I was able to sketch a pretty decent face quite quickly with just the basic pencil tool. When I handed it back, he was so amazed that he grabbed my grandmother as she was walking past. "Look at this! Look at what your grandson drew!" She glanced over, completely unimpressed, and said "yeah, but that's on the computer".
- ragazzina 4y ago>asking random acquaintances at a local cafe for prompts and showed them the generated pictures. All but one person was totally unimpressed. I think this is because people reason this way: the computer has many pictures in its archive, saved as "dog.jpg" and "hat.jpg". If your prompt is "dog with hat", the computer just combines them. I think this is what people think is happening, so they are less impressed.
- atwood22 4y agoMost people are objective dumb (i.e. less smart than the median/average) so this doesn’t surprise me.
- cheschire 4y agoHow can most of any quantity be less than average? Edit: ah, I think I was thrown off by the use of “median/average” as equivalents.
- pgreenwood 4y agoIt is true in every right skewed distribution. Furthermore almost every distribution is skewed.
- grammer__ 4y agoThe median is the midpoint where 50% of people are above/below the threshold. If there are outliers, and perhaps we can agree there are outliers on the smart/dumb scale, it can skew the average above or below the median.
- jks 4y agoAnd I guess being extremely dumb carries a larger risk of death than being extremely smart, so if people start out symmetrically distributed along this scale, the distribution will skew right over time.
- IIAOPSW 4y agoThanks to a few billionaires in a small town, the majority of people living there have a below average income.
- atwood22 4y agoThe median and average are equivalent in a normal distribution.
- cheschire 4y agoBut then would you still be able to say “most” are below average of the distribution is normal?
- Gigachad 4y agoNone of us are immune to that. The amount of magic we all rely on every day is incomprehensible. We just take it for granted that there is power to our house, the trains arrive on time, the bridge doesn’t collapse, the coffee tastes nice and costs little.
- koudelka 4y agoif you enjoyed this comment, you may also enjoy the The Trigger Effect episode from James Burke's Connections series. https://archive.org/details/james-burke-connections_s01e01 https://archive.org/details/james-burke-connections_s01e01
- purist33 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- MichaelDickens 4y agoThe commonplace thing that amazes me the most is the availability of food. My mind boggles at the complexity of getting hundreds of types of foods to a grocery store on a regular basis. I have no direct access to food, and if the food supply chain breaks down, I die. But it doesn't break down.
- powersnail 4y agoThat is totally natural. People don't have a strong reaction, because they don't have the context of why it's impressive. How do you know something is impressive or surprising? You compare it to the previous status of the industry, which is something you know, but the random people in the coffee house don't. I doubt they really believe it's truly inexplicable. Most layman know that somebody knows what's going on in their device. And nobody has an explanation for everything they use, but it doesn't mean they get attributed to magic. I have no idea how a bridge is designed and built, but I don't believe it's magic, it's just something beyond my knowledge.
- numpad0 4y agoSomeone was describing it "lacks natural depth", "cause grinding feeling in the brain". It also seems unable to generate good manga-styled images. I think what those means is DALL-E 2 lacks syntaxes and contexts of arts. I agree that People think of technology as black boxes that do inexplicable things, but I think that only matters if boxes interferes with their contexts and scopes. It seems it is understood a threat to digital artists, but at the same time, it is possibly less relevant than Google Search as it is.
- IIAOPSW 4y agoI was generating some images of parrots for a friend that's into bird photography when it occurred to me, Prometheus stole fire from the gods and was sentenced to be pecked at by birds. Today is the first day of forever in the infinite aviary. Pictures of birds are no longer scarce. Every bird that ever was, is, or could be is mere key strokes away. When Prometheus stole fire, he couldn't have actually known what fire was before he stole it. Likewise, only a small niche even seems aware of the profound change which is now being ushered into the world. The generation of birds is now the purview of man. Forget selling the rope to hang us, the birds that peck us will be made in our image. .-- .... .- - / .... .- ... / --. --- -.. / .-- .-. --- ..- --. .... - ..--..
- jrh206 4y agoMorse code translator: https://morsecode.world/international/translator.html https://morsecode.world/international/translator.html (WHAT HAS GOD WROUGHT?)
- hipjiveguy 4y agoyou rock
- tooltower 4y agoIt's the same underlying reason for https://xkcd.com/1425/ https://xkcd.com/1425/. These tasks have always looked similar. The only reason we are amazed is because we know why one task is harder than the other. Understanding that is not easy.
- ralfd 4y agoRandall Monroe himself didn't know how hard (easy) the task was. The Flickr team released a month after the comic this (sadly offline now): https://code.flickr.net/2014/10/20/introducing-flickr-park-or-bird/ https://code.flickr.net/2014/10/20/introducing-flickr-park-o... Today a hobby programmer could do it by themself.
- punnerud 4y agoWhat if Google just at it to Google image search, and create new content for you without copyright?
- Deriveur 4y agoI though of that but I think it's still wayyy too expensive. But I hope in a few years or even a few decades it will be the case
- perfopt 4y agoBut I have only 40 free credits and I used them all up with prompts :-(