2 ms·
> The other OS functionality is totally unnecessary for MacOS or probably even Apple tools their store/repair techs use. Both of those statements are probably
by smoldesu 4y ago
> The other OS functionality is totally unnecessary for MacOS or probably even Apple tools their store/repair techs use.
Both of those statements are probably true, but it's not the same for hardware calibration/testing from the factory. It totally makes sense that Apple would add this as a convenient way to use a single testing image for multiple Macs, or as an entrypoint for Microsoft to start supporting Bootcamp. Hell, maybe it was a mistake and they're too embarassed to admit. Apple doesn't have that kind of dialogue with their community though, so we don't know. Until they release a statement acknowledging that they made this change for Asahi, nobody can say they're "helping" with any certainty.
> Surely allowing the other OS functionality is at least a tiny security weakness because it makes it easier to get a foothold to attack from.
Not really? You should go check out the boot flow on the link in this thread, I can't really conceive of any way that an attacker could abuse that process. Sure you might be able to boot malicious software, but you're not going to get it to persist (certainly not in MacOS), and it can't really read any sensitive information since your APFS volume is still encrypted. There's effectively no security tradeoff to their implementation, particularly for MacOS users.
> I just have a hard time seeing any reason any of this exists unless they purposefully chose to allow it. It’s can’t be happenstance.
I agree. I just don't think it was done for Asahi, and it certainly doesn't seem like deliberate help.
- MBCook 4y agoYeah I’ve read how the boot works, and in theory if it all works perfectly then they should be 100% irrelevant. What we know software has bugs. And it seems like if you can execute kernel level code on the machine, you’re more likely to be able to find one of those bugs somehow from the other 0S then you would if you were having to attack from a macOS process. Total 100% assumption on my part. Apple knows what happens. No matter what they do someone was going to try and put Linux or BSD on the machine. That plus the way things are setup makes me suspect Apple is purposely allowing this in the closest to a wink-wink-nudge-nudge approval they’ll ever give us.