4 ms·
Wait, if Linus is happy about supporting undocumented hardware, then does he like NVidia now too?
by amelius 4y ago
Wait, if Linus is happy about supporting undocumented hardware, then does he like NVidia now too?
- rowanG077 4y agoNvidia is actively hostile. Apple is slightly willing to get Linux to work. It's not comperable.
- AshamedCaptain 4y agoBut it's still discouraging to the companies that actually support Linux.
- rhodysurf 4y agoOk it’s on them to make a laptop that can compete with an Apple Silicon Air then
- ztrww 4y agoApple provides no documentation or any other resources. Nvidia at least provides their closed source drivers and has put in some effort in open sourcing some parts of them. Obviously Nvidia is not great but it is still much, much better than Apple which just totally ignores Linux and there is no guarantee some exec might decide that they need to patch the ‘security holes’ which allow Linux to even run on m1 at some point in the future.
- mattl 4y agoI believe Apple has been making changes to actively support the Asahi community in regards to bootloaders and such.
- bombcar 4y agoThey have, though it's not clear if it's "engineer at Apple realizes with one small change they can make it easier for Linux" or "internally Apple is fine with supporting Linux on their hardware but they're not openly doing so". I'm actually moderately surprised they are not actively helping, as often having a second OS option allows for various fun legal tricks when importing, bidding on government contracts, etc.
- GlitchMr 4y agoI think Apple would have to be stupid to block booting other operating systems on the devices they already have sold. This could easily lead to lawsuit, similar to one that Sony had when they removed OtherOS functionality from PlayStation 3.
- rowanG077 4y agoApple actively helped Asahi Linux by changing the boot process. NVidia actively works against Linux by using things like the GPL condom. Nvidia is like that kid that is forced by a teacher to do something and then proceeds to do it in the most shitheaded way but just enough for it to work while actively working against the spirit of the request of the teacher. Apple in contrast has helped Asahi Linux for literally no reason. It wasn't requiest, it wasn't even required. It just made life easier for Asahi Linux.
- capableweb 4y agoApple helped Asahi allegedly. There is no explicit support of Asahi from Apple, just to be 100% clear. The change you're talking about is likely to have been for Asahi, but no statement from Apple so far about it.
- rowanG077 4y agoAllegedly? Apple added a feature useless for themselves but something Asahi Linux benefited from greatly. Can't really make it more clear then this. Or do you expect Tim Cook to announce Asahi Linux in the next keynote?
- capableweb 4y agoMaybe the "allegedly" is misplaced, I hope my overall point is clear anyway. Apple haven't "officially" helped Asahi, the change could have be made by a single contributor to the kernel for example, or more of a "why not" change without regarding Asahi specifically. We (unless you work at Apple) don't really know at this point.
- sbuk 4y agoAsk marcan_42 for how much support Apple have provided. When it has come up, they have been pretty open about it...
- 4y ago
- matthewmacleod 4y agoThis is a specious argument. Supporting undocumented hardware is fine and always has been - what’s not is supporting gross non-free kernel blobs.
- amelius 4y agoWhat if Apple provided a better GPU driver, as a non-free kernel blob?
- matthewmacleod 4y agoI have literally no idea – but since it hasn't happened and isn't likely to happen… who cares?
- bombcar 4y agoWe can guess - the blob wouldn't be in the kernel, and the interface to the blob would reluctantly be added (or not added at all) and the installer would work against particular kernels.
- amelius 4y agoI care. It's kind of strange if you're against undocumented software but still run on undocumented hardware. I'm hoping the providers of the tools I use can see this too.
- TingPing 4y agoHardware doesn't change. The Linux kernel and related userspace move fast. Proprietary kernel drivers are painful for users and developers alike. Nvidia has held back the entire desktop and been a massive PITA for laptops.
- phendrenad2 4y agoI find it hard to believe that Nvidia has held back the entire desktop, when >50% of computers don't use Nvidia GPUs.