6 ms·
Intel let the chips fall where they might
- throwaway4good 4y agoIntel stands get 20-30B out of the CHIPS act; so it is basically being bailed out. Question is whether this is enough.
- aaa_aaa 4y agoReal question is why bail out a loser? Actually, why bail out anybody?
- throwaway4good 4y agoNational security.
- azemetre 4y agoThere are very few companies that actually own fabs for mass production in the United States. AMD use to own fabs but they sold them quite some time ago. By virtue of being one of the five companies (while also being the largest) you’re going to easily get the money. As for why, fabs are a tremendous resource for a specialized economy and will easily become a national security risk due to how wide spread they are in the military and to sell advanced products. There’s also a de globalization movement that’s been underway for nearly a decade. Having a country whose neighbors aren’t in a politically stable region of the world is a future disaster. It’s also proven to be a disastrous domestic policy where supply constraints crunches every company. It’s likely going to take a decade to resolve the supply chain issues and it nearly takes half a decade to bring a new fab online. edit: spelling
- 999900000999 4y agoMaybe bail them out with conditions. Say force them to open source chips older than a decade. I wouldn't want us to fall behind on chip tech though.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoYou create the conditions for future complexity if you only allow winner takes all. AMD was bailed out for years as Intel was king, and it’s a good thing they were.
- guardiangod 4y agoWhen did AMD got bailed out?
- pclmulqdq 4y agoWhen Intel kept settling lawsuits with them for large sums of money to avoid being broken up. These generous settlements kept AMD alive.
- FatalLogic 4y agoBut that's not a bailout, it is compensation for harm that Intel had caused AMD by anti-competitive behaviors
- pclmulqdq 4y agoSettling for 1/10th those amounts years later (after the lawsuits look like they are going badly) would compensation for anticompetitive behavior. Settling early for the full price (or more) is a bailout.
- Retric 4y agoLawsuits aren’t limited to the exact damages, Intel settled early to reduce the risk of a massive loss in the future. It’s important to realize the lawsuit could easily have survived past the point where AMD failed as a company. Just as patents get sold off so too can potential damages from lawsuits.
- pclmulqdq 4y ago
- silon42 4y agoNo reason, if you're willing to nationalize+split the monopolies.
- HPsquared 4y ago"They may be a loser, but they're our loser."
- formerkrogemp 4y agoThe efficient market rewards inefficient stock buybacks, record debt fueled dividends, years of underinvestment, low wages, and most of all no strings attached bailouts. They may be a loser, but we'll pay for their loss. Socialize the losses/costs and privatize the gains.
- api 4y agoChina's entire industrial base is state subsidized. TSMC is a strategic asset of Taiwan. The US is still strongly dominant in aerospace, and there are few efforts or companies in that entire sector that are not subsidized (largely by defense spending and NASA). I could fill up several pages with this. If nobody subsidized their industries, then maybe we could do just fine without subsidizing ours. In today's world, not subsidizing key industries is unilateral disarmament. It'd be like the USA unilaterally giving up all its nuclear weapons while Russia, China, North Korea, etc. still have theirs and hoping everyone plays nice. Ask Russia how not having domestic chip fab capability is working out for them.
- sliken 4y agoBecause is TSMC was unavailable to the USA it would take many years for the USA to recover. This bail out gives the USA a head start on a TSMC replacement so that we don't have to halt production of GPUs, CPUs, phones, tablets, appliances, cars, trucks, cranes, tanks, missiles, etc. etc. etc.
- JonChesterfield 4y agoYears of taking spectacular profits followed by failing at engineering doesn't feel like something that should be rewarded.
- throwaway4good 4y agoAs it looks now we are heading to a semi slump with declining demand and oversupply while bailing out a disfunctional giant. My guess we are going to see fabs that are so challenged on revenue that they are unable to cover the operational costs. Let alone provide a return on the amount invested.
- duped 4y agoMore like parity with other countries that strategically invested in semiconductor manufacturing using government money and policy. We have to pay to play. Unless we're cool with not manufacturing chips domestically. Not to mention most bailouts don't have clawbacks like the CHIPS act.
- sliken 4y agoNone of Intel's current problems are caused by a lack of money.
- newaccount2021 4y agoIntel is the next Boeing...a "strategic" firm fed a diet of government pork Don't worry Intel, Google and their "strategic AI assets" are only a few years behind you in line, you'll soon have company
- acuozzo 4y ago> Intel is the next Boeing...a "strategic" firm fed a diet of government pork It's fitting given the name, no?
- ckastner 4y agoTangentially: The GDPR has been around for 4+ years now. They should know that a cookie consent popup where you have opt-out for 15 processing purposes individually almost certainly won't fly, and having to opt-out of 100+ vendors individually definitely won't fly.
- nikanj 4y agoThey’ve been flying just fine for 4+ years now.
- ckastner 4y agoThey've gotten away with it, you mean. There's ample precedent against this. Even Google added a "Reject all" button, eventually.
- MomoXenosaga 4y agoUntil EU starts issuing international arrest warrants (don't hold your breath) Americans will do whatever they want. Try to avoid doing business with US corporations.
- anonymousDan 4y agoWtf, I didn't realise they were shutting down Optane. Any alternative suppliers on the horizon for persistent memory?
- ksec 4y agoYes, but none of them are competitive. With Modern CPU you need Memory with ultra high bandwidth, which no persistent memory offers. With low latency storage it doesn't compete against Z-NAND or SLC NAND with special tuning.
- anonymousDan 4y agoThanks. Anything on the horizon that you are aware of?
- ksec 4y agoNot AFAIK, commercially speaking. At least not in the next 5 to 7 years. And I would love to be wrong. DRAM and NAND are so well optimised in terms of cost and scale ( Which was the reason why Optane failed to compete ). It is like the lithium Battery. Whenever there is a "Revolution Battery", it has to pass the check list [1]. [1]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26354453 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26354453
- dragontamer 4y agoThe writing was on the wall when Micron pulled out of the partnership with 3dXpoint / Optane.
- georgeburdell 4y agoMany foundries, including Intel and TSMC, offer MRAM through their foundries. As far as I know, no plans for a customer to use it in the Optane space though
- freemint 4y ago> The Holy Roman Empire was a pale shadow of the glory that was Rome. But still effective, mind you, give the times many centuries after the fall of Rome. Sigh ... Don't use history analogies if you get them wrong.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- MengerSponge 4y ago"The Holy Roman Empire was neither holy, nor Roman, nor an Empire. Discuss."
- r00fus 4y agoAre you my highschool history teacher? One of the few things I remember from that period - mainly due to this Voltaire witticism.
- galogon 4y agoI still don't understand how Apple, a lifestyle company, managed to beat Intel at their own game. It must be humiliating for the employees and the execs. I wonder what the morale is inside the company.
- raverbashing 4y agoAnd also AMD's market cap went above Intel's last week Can we call this "the Nokia effect"?
- throwaway4good 4y agoThe iPhone business sponsored Apple's chip development; and that business is bigger than the PC market.
- chmod775 4y agoIf with "PC market" you're limiting that statement to pre-built personal computers, that's a misleading claim. If you meant to refer to the entire computer hardware market, you're wrong by an order of magnitude. iPhone Revenue 2021: $191.9 billion Computer Hardware Revenue 2021: $1,129.39 billion
- r00fus 4y agoComparing a market for devices to all of computer hardware (including peripherals/components) is what's ridiculous. The more apt analogy is computers (PCs) to iPhones.
- chmod775 4y agoThrowaway4good was using the comparison of iPhones to PCs to allude that Apple has more money available to develop silicon, yet the pre-built PC market is a tiny subset of where money is made using semiconductors. That's why it's a misleading claim. I didn't expect I would have to elaborate this beyond what I said. My bad.
- 4y ago
- Panzer04 4y agoI’m always slightly confused at how easily intel is written off. They still generate more revenue than AMD and Nvidia combined, they have a huge foundry business attached, their processors are competitive and they are making the necessary investments to catch up. AMD and Nvidia will always be beholden to TSMC - yes, they avoid the capital outlay and risk of foundries, but they also give up the possible upside of owning the foundry. Perhaps intel will never be as dominant as they once were, but as the computing market grows there’s a growing pie to share in regardless.
- throwaway4good 4y agoApple is not going back to x86; and server side computing is also moving away from x86 - either to ARM or specialised AI hardware.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoSo far, I have been able to pull out a lot more perf/$ from Intel CPUs on AWS than from ARM. I know the ARM cores benchmark well for certain applications, but at the moment, the Intel SIMD instructions are a little too powerful, so if you can take advantage of them, you will win on x86.
- aNoob7000 4y agoI agree that Intel is in trouble on many front, but I don't see the x86 instruction set going away anytime soon. The desktop and server world is basically running on x86 at this time.
- dboreham 4y agoThere are big cracks appearing though in this edifice. Thanks to ARM Macbook, it's now expected that projects ship ARM packages, ARM containers etc. And therefor it's practical to deploy on ARM servers. Raspberry Pi also helped with this historically. Even Windows -- I use a Surface Pro X which provides a wonderful travel experience.
- foobiekr 4y ago