17 ms·
You want to know something about how bullshit insane our brains are? (2018)
- weaponizedlinux 4y ago"So while I firmly believe we're basically just overgrown biological computers, we're apparently computers programmed by batshit insane drunkards in Visual Basic 5." This explains... everything.
- yencabulator 4y agoAnother oddity: You can read text just fine even if everything except one word is blurred. With eye tracking, unblur only the one word in the focus point of the eyes. The area of your sharp vision really is that small.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lake_vincent 4y agoFor those who hate Twitter threads as much as I do: https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1014267515696922624.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1014267515696922624.html
- ornornor 4y agoThanks
- stevenjgarner 4y agoSerious question : why do publishers break down their blog posts into umpteen tweeted microblogs? Do the engagement web algorithms give preference to the number of tweets in a thread? I see this is becoming more of a trend (e.g. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32296873 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32296873). If I tweet the 587,287 words of Tolstoy's War & Peace are more people inclined to read it, or at least have it come across their feed?
- samatman 4y agoYou jest, but I follow a bot which does this for the complete works of Shakespeare. A larger corpus, though by less than one might guess.
- dang 4y ago"Please don't complain about tangential annoyances—things like article or website formats, name collisions, or back-button breakage. They're too common to be interesting." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- zip1234 4y agoThis is why driving is the most dangerous activity most people usually do.
- spywaregorilla 4y agoPretty sure driving would be the most dangerous thing most people do without this
- tiborsaas 4y agoI highly doubt that, driving is dangerous because of: ego, technical failures, carelessness, sleep deprivation and other human factors. Probably our visual imperfections are the least important things to blame.
- zip1234 4y agoMy meaning is that, for example, ego and carelessness are tied into our visual system. People believe they are more attentive and have better reactions than they actually have.
- pyinstallwoes 4y agoWhy? The entire activity is within our simulated expectation of how time works vs how it really works. To the aliens we are using bumper lanes for time. Like bowling.
- zip1234 4y agoIt's not just saccades, it is the entire system of vision and all of the approximations that the brain is doing in order to process the information. The twitter thread only goes into a couple things. There is also inattentional blindness, which happens all the time in driving due to distractions.
- otikik 4y agoWe are using a system that was grown, trained and optimized for a ~80kg mostly-water biped with full proprioception and 5 senses to move a ~1900kg metal quadruped using only vision and hearing. A car routinely reaches 120 km/h. The fastest human who ever existed, Usain Bolt, can only sustain a third of that for ~10 seconds.
- kzrdude 4y agoThe user experience of vision is just great, good engineering all around.
- yencabulator 4y agoAll the bugs start really showing up after 40 years of uptime.
- orangepurple 4y agoArchive of thread reader https://archive.ph/RsBpI https://archive.ph/RsBpI
- spywaregorilla 4y agoThe tone of this is grating. That aside, I don't think this mechanism is all that surprising. Inferring the previous state of things helps you better predict its next state.
- bowsamic 4y agoWell, it is foone...no offence to them but it's kind of their hallmark
- xphx 4y agoWritten as though it's competing for the attention of fourteen-year-olds against meme scrolls, video games and online porn.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- fooqux 4y ago> Written as though it's competing for the attention of fourteen-year-olds against meme scrolls, video games and online porn. Well, technically they are. Only not just teens. Attention spans have gotten shorter; I doubt that many of my friends can make it through that without checking their phone at least once.
- giraffe_lady 4y agoThat's quite literally the exact context, so yeah.
- iakov 4y agoI've noticed the second hand "freezing" on a quartz watch when I glance at it since I was a kid. When I asked adults about it they didn't understand what I'm talking about and had no explanation at all. Weird, fascinating stuff.
- sshine 4y agoI also played around with this, making seconds go faster or slower. I understood something glitchy was going on with my perception. So it is funny to get an explanation.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lazyant 4y agoThis is the "stopped-clock illusion", an example of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chronostasis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chronostasis
- lloeki 4y agoWondering whether watched kettles never boiling is a similar effect, only at a larger scale. Time as we experience it is an illusion bordering on insanity, actually everything we perceive seems to be such a freaking illusion it's mind boggling the whole thing works at all.
- chasd00 4y agowow this is crazy. I had forgotten until now but, as a child, I remember looking at my watch and when the second hand finally ticked thinking "that was way longer than a second".
- rocgf 4y agoSame here. I remember seeing this as a kid and being perplexed, but haven't thought about it until reading it now. This is sooo interesting, I wonder how much stuff like this we have hidden away.
- dusted 4y agoI've read about this many times, I don't really believe it.. If I move my gaze quickly from one spot to another I distinctly see the movement as blurry trail.. I'll believe that people ignore it, or do not pay particular attention to it, but I don't believe they _can't_ see it..
- Retr0id 4y agoIt sounds like you might be the exception. I certainly do not see it.
- kayodelycaon 4y agoEveryone’s brain is a little different. It is possible the masking system in your brain is broken. I know I have a lot of busted mental equipment. :)
- withinboredom 4y agoYou can become aware of it, or ignore it. Just like you can become aware of your heartbeat, and even influence it. When I was a kid, I was fascinated with trying to control my heart. Even nearly 40 years later, I’m aware of my heart and it’s beating 24/7 and I can’t turn it off. I’m curious if you maybe did something as a kid that made you hyper-aware of your vision?
- micromacrofoot 4y agoIf you move your gaze quickly, yes. Just start erratically moving your eyes and it seems your brain can't keep up and everything will be a blur. But also keep in mind that even when you're looking at a stationary object, your eyes tend to move a lot. If you noticed the blur from tiny movements too, you'd have a very hard time seeing anything. Reading would be quite difficult, for example.
- withinboredom 4y agoI vaguely remember learning in school that the natives who saw ships arrive across the Atlantic for the first time saw the ships made of clouds because they had never seen anything like it before. No idea if it was a fact or myth, but it’s always stuck with me that so much of our understanding and what we see is based on what we expect and not on reality.
- lukas099 4y agoI suppose a ship with a lot of large, white, billowy sails against a clear blue sky would look a lot like clouds. Edit: I wonder, though, if native people didn't just use the word "cloud" because they did not have a word for "sail", and that was the closest thing they looked like.
- altruios 4y agothe chicken and the egg, or the thought and the word.
- exikyut 4y agoExpectation and also language. I've read that there are native languages out there with some large number of words for certain shades of color, and no words for other colors. Speakers of the language can very reliably distinguish the colors they have words for with high accuracy, but can't tell the colors they don't have words for apart very well at all.
- tacocataco 4y agoMaybe because the ships came from over the horizon?
- TheOtherHobbes 4y agoLuckily this only applies to vision and not at all to more abstract processes like world views and belief systems...
- pyinstallwoes 4y agoThis will pass the average sarcasm detector I’m sure of it.
- lebuffon 4y ago:-))))
- OscarCunningham 4y agoBut after they read your comment people will have always known it was sarcasm.
- pyinstallwoes 4y agoIf it passes the average sarcasm detector then is the average observer any less or more certain sarcasm’s afoot?
- prometheus76 4y agoDon't worry, it only applies to everyone else's world views and belief systems. Yours are accurate and reliable.
- jrh206 4y agoMine too. In fact, seven years ago I decided to stop moving my eyes. Since then, both my world views AND my vision have been completely reliable.
- exikyut 4y agoIt doesn't quite land the same way to have to explain it long-form, but... I remember learning years ago about an experiment some researchers did where they anesthetized some test subjects' eye muscles (don't remember how), bolted them into a frame so their heads couldn't move, and positioned mirrors above that could be moved with a handle. What this test setup found was that as long as the mirrors were constantly moving (even just a tiny bit), the participants could generally speaking see completely normally. But as soon as the mirrors stopped moving, the participants reported that their vision fairly rapidly went completely grey. (The ba-dum-tss here is the "completely reliable" in your comment... :D) I don't think the optic system in the brain is the only aspect that is "change-stimulated". A bit of a pet theory is that a lot of thought processes are quite similar at the low (and not so low) level. I'm hoping to come across that study at some point, just not sure what to Google.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- personjerry 4y agoThe most verifiable part if you want to check it out yourself: Look at a mirror (not your phone camera), and look at your eyes. Now move your eyes, and try to see the movement of your own eyes. You can't.
- sovnade 4y agoIt's amazing how much our brain does in the background to smooth out processing because it can't handle all of the data coming in. This example several others (the one where you look at the center dot and all others disappear - briefly mentioned in this twitter thread also, the one where you stare between two sets of rapidly updating photos of celebrities..but after a few, your brain gives up and just sort of makes them all look like ogres, etc). Awesome stuff and I will always do every one of these silly things.
- boomboomsubban 4y agoThis phenomenon made me convinced I was unable to move my eyes as a child. I thought I had some strange condition where I could move my focus without my eyeballs moving. I remember my elementary school teacher saying "don't roll your eyes at me" and me trying to explain I couldn't move my eyes and her awkwardly going "right..." Then continued to believe it for another few years.
- mgdlbp 4y ago> move my focus without my eyeballs moving This is a thing! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Visual_spatial_attention https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Visual_spatial_attention I discovered this when I accidentally performed an experiment that showed how paying attention to a bright light in my peripheral vision without moving my eyes caused my pupils to constrict. That was after I became aware that my pupil size affected how blurry things were from nearsightedness (the same effect as in cameras). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pupillary_light_reflex#Cognitive_influences https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pupillary_light_reflex#Cogniti...
- seri4l 4y agoIf I get really close to the mirror, so close I can barely focus, look at my dominant eye, then look at the general direction of my non dominant eye, but trying to focus some distant object, I can see it moving.
- muststopmyths 4y agoThat book recommendation at the end seems really interesting. (edit: I was talking about the SciFi book, Blindsight)
- zip1234 4y agoThere is a podcast call "You Are Not So Smart" that talks about all the ways our brain tricks us. https://youarenotsosmart.com/podcast/ https://youarenotsosmart.com/podcast/
- psyc 4y agoDennet's Consciousness Explained doesn't do what the title suggests, but it is great for stuff like this. I think there's at least one section on the brain retroactively time-stamping past events.
- jtwaleson 4y agoI’ve noticed that the speedometer or rpm gauge can sometimes move erratically when I’m making eye movements while driving. At first I thought the engine or the instruments were broken (I drive a crappy car). Since first reading this thread, it makes sense that’s saccadic masking instead. It’s pretty cool!
- pyinstallwoes 4y agoThe craziest thing about this is that it’s effectively an attack vector for any adversary to be active within that time window given it can measure eye movements or predict it. I’ve come across some material that shows some ML/NN stuff was trained on it to validate if it could pass human perception (yes, easily).
- giraffe_lady 4y agoThere's a pretty common street fighting move of stomping with the forward foot while you throw a punch. An untrained opponent will glance down and you pop them during the saccade. It's even explicitly part of the "proper" technique in some martial arts that allow both hand and foot strikes. After it gets you a few times you just learn not to look but there's no general defense against the idea I don't think, just specific applications of it.
- exikyut 4y agoI'm admittedly having a hard time figuring out practical attacks that could make use of this. Screen content manipulation (eg a desktop)? Exceedingly unlikely to be the simplest strategy. Real-world manipulation? Not sure what could be achieved. Hmm, information suggestion (displaying an onscreen message just outside the field of view, and changing it to something else when the user looks at that area of the screen) comes to mind, but that's not really up there either. Thoughts?
- pedantsamaritan 4y agoNot all people driving cars look left and right thoroughly before turning (but you can learn! [0]) This already leads to crashes and claims of 'coming out of nowhere'. So, practical attacks could be causing crashes. Could cause anxiety, injury, death, monetary loss, etc [0]: https://www.portsmouthctc.org.uk/a-fighter-pilots-guide-to-surviving-on-the-roads/ https://www.portsmouthctc.org.uk/a-fighter-pilots-guide-to-s... (been some past HN discussions, searching for fighter pilot got quite a few)
- lovehashbrowns 4y agoI’m picturing an automated turret of some kind with the ability to track saccades and aim and track their human target during those periods. Turret is placed in the corner of a room, for example, engineered in a non-obvious shape. The target it’s tracking can move around briefly as the turret continues to track the target and in the meantime it can analyze the situation, maybe even phone home for authorization to fire. The human target would have no idea it’s being aimed at, right? Could be useful for something like hostage rescue, maybe? My problem with this is that once we have machines capable of tracking and exploiting saccades, humans have already lost completely and there’s no need for that kind of ability. I feel like our brains are too slow to compete with silicon.
- refurb 4y agoThis is just the brain correcting for inputs and it does it all the time. My friend had a stroke which damage the occipital lobe (vision) and he had an "empty space" there (about 20% of the field of vision). After a couple years it was gone. It wasn't really gone, it was just "filled in" by the brain to an extent it wasn't noticeable at all. If you tested them using accurate equipment to see field of vision you could catch it. But if you asked him, there was no "empty" spot any more.
- batch12 4y agoIf this happens every time your eyes move, what happens during REM sleep?
- exikyut 4y agoHuh. This is all about the impact on vision as opposed to imagination (or whatever it is that REM does), but that really does pose some interesting questions about long-tail impacts. Mirror neurons come to mind...
- corobo 4y agoFor folks who want further info the wikipedia page on this phenomenon is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saccadic_masking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saccadic_masking
- qikInNdOutReply 4y agoGets hundreds of poor devils to confess to "running somebody over cause i was frozzen up" in court, meanwhile its simply you were driving to fast for your visual system and it made up a plausible story after your drove into a poor guy. Guilttrip included. Here be privatpersons posting about how actions must have consequences.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- corobo 4y agoI think that'd be called driving with undue care and attention here in the UK. Generally it's on you when you crash into someone without some super specific exception. If you want to read more on this though it looks like there's been a study specifically on saccades while driving: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6536025/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6536025/
- rlpb 4y agohttps://e-lawresources.co.uk/R-v-Whoolley.php https://e-lawresources.co.uk/R-v-Whoolley.php "The defendant lorry driver, was travelling on the M62 in a queue of slow moving traffic. He suffered a sneezing fit, losing control of his vehicle he knocked into the car in front. This car in turn knocked into the car in front causing a domino effect involving 7 cars. The Magistrates allowed the defence of automatism. The appeal court held that the Magistrates were right to do so and that an attack of sneezing could amount to an involuntary action for the purposes of the defence of non-insane automatism."
- jasonincanada 4y agoI wonder if this explains how I almost never see the minutes click over on a digital clock. I think of how often I check the time, say maybe 1 second at a time staring at the clock, it should at least every now and then be flicking over to the next minute, but it almost never seems to happen while I'm actually looking at it
- layer8 4y agoIf you normally glance at the time fir half a second, the switchover only happens every 120th time on average, which is infrequent enough that your brain simply doesn’t expect it in that context. Maybe it then just cuts out that “glitch” in the rare cases it happens.
- eru 4y ago
- stevenjgarner 4y ago
- corobo 4y agoFoone on Twitter threads https://twitter.com/Foone/status/1440695609913053194 https://twitter.com/Foone/status/1440695609913053194
- Karellen 4y ago> This is not a web trend I would like to encourage but alas it is catching on. Holy shit. My brain just did the saccade thing and made something that happened in the past feel like the present. My brain is telling me that the parent comment was written 35 minutes ago, but based on its content I have to logically conclude it's actually about 10 years old!
- blincoln 4y agoI have a lot of mixed feelings about Twitter, and resisted setting up an account for many years. But I realized that there are a lot of interesting people out there with AD(H)D, and a platform like Twitter is literally the only place that they can post their content in a way that works for them. I'll take "learn interesting things in a way that's maybe not my favourite" over "not learn those interesting things at all" every time.
- stevenjgarner 4y agoThis is not a comment about AD(H)D. For all I know I have it too. It takes me a long time to write content. When I write a blog post, I don't publish every one of my drafts, but I do write some specific content or thoughts in each draft. When I feel the draft has accumulated all my thoughts, I publish it. I get the opposite is just as valid. Was it Paul McCartney who when he was asked how long it took him to write "Yesterday", he replied "I haven't finished writing it yet"?
- shever73 4y agoIf you prefer blog format, Foone used to put their Twitter threads on their blog here: https://foone.wordpress.com/2019/03/01/the-eyes-have-it/ https://foone.wordpress.com/2019/03/01/the-eyes-have-it/
- dredmorbius 4y agoI've suggested that link be substituted to the HN mods (via email).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ivoras 4y agoThis is used to a very cool effect in Peter Watts' novel "Blindsight", about an alien species whose brains are so much faster than ours that they notice and exploit this deficiency in ours. It's also free to read, e.g. at: https://bookmate.com/books/WiShbinL https://bookmate.com/books/WiShbinL
- qikInNdOutReply 4y agoThere is also a audiobook on youtube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_R55gdpgwQQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_R55gdpgwQQ
- therealdrag0 4y agoAlso check your library. I listened to it on Libby.
- foobarbecue 4y ago, as it says in the original post.
- Godel_unicode 4y agohttps://mobile.twitter.com/Foone/status/1014286291314270208 https://mobile.twitter.com/Foone/status/1014286291314270208
- Freaky 4y agoMany of Peter Watts books and short stories - including Blindsight, and the short story set in the same universe "The Colonel" - are free to read on his website: https://www.rifters.com/real/shorts.htm https://www.rifters.com/real/shorts.htm There's also a non-free sequel novel - Echopraxia - together making the Firefall series. Be sure to check out the "Vampire Domestication" multimedia presentation on that page, for some background on the "vampires" in the series.
- exhilaration 4y agoBe sure to check out the "Vampire Domestication" multimedia presentation on that page, for some background on the "vampires" in the series. Thank you, that was a fantastic read, really fills in the universe that Blindsight was set it. Here's a direct link to the PDF: https://www.rifters.com/real/shorts/VampireDomestication.pdf https://www.rifters.com/real/shorts/VampireDomestication.pdf
- seri4l 4y agoYou can replicate the analog clock illusion without having to move your eyes. Open https://www.online-stopwatch.com/large-online-clock/ https://www.online-stopwatch.com/large-online-clock/ in a new tab and Ctrl+Tab, then Ctrl+Shift+Tab. It may take a few tries, but if you switch at the right time it will look as if the seconds hand freezes for more than a second.
- bilsbie 4y agoI’m confused how we can do thing like playing sports if our brains are mashing reality this much. How does a batter hit a 90 mph pitch if his vision can be delayed by half a second?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- austinjp 4y agoPrediction, operating at the limits of human ability in an extremely limited (but very impressive) application.
- personjerry 4y agoWhen you're focusing/tracking something your eyes do a different type of movement called smooth pursuit [0]. To see this in action, look around normally - notice your eyes move and then stop, taking in "still frames". Next, look at your finger and move your finger around. Notice that your eyes smoothly follow the finger around. When the batter is watching the ball, he is similarly tracking it. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smooth_pursuit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smooth_pursuit
- a_e_k 4y agoTo help the batter track the ball, MLB stadiums also have a darker, solid-color region called the "batter's eye" behind the pitcher and center field [0]. It's also why pitchers can't wear white sleeves or use white gloves (e.g., Eddie Butler getting his sleeves cut off before he pitches [1]). [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Batter%27s_eye https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Batter%27s_eye [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UR0nHFTWNnY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UR0nHFTWNnY
- fimdomeio 4y agoIf the batter is not looking at the ball at the moment it's leaving the hand I doubt he can hit the ball. Also as soon as the pitcher starts moving his body the brain probably starts creating all types of predictions of what will happen next.
- pluijzer 4y agoThe experiment whit the clock didn't work for me. I see no noticeable delay when looking back to the second hand. Maybe I do something wrong? Small anecdote: long ago in my teens I had a period where I didn't sleep for days due to an illness. One of the more freakish thing I experienced was a moment where I was watching television on the couch, stood and walk away but for about a few seconds my vision was frozen. Still seeing a frame of the orientation of me sitting down looking at the tv even though I already had a completely different orientation.
- exikyut 4y agoa) I personally find that looking at the second hand just as it clicks into position - so I'm looking at the frozen second hand for a whole second - amplifies the effect for me. So I watch the clock for a bit to observe the seconds passing, then look at the wall while still counting the seconds in sync, then look back right at the start of a tick. Preferably while not really thinking about any of that, and paying attention to my eyes and vision. b) Wow, that is really interesting, I have questions :) How long was everything frozen for? "A few" = 3, 4, 5 seconds? How did you stand and walk away without crashing into anything (or did you maybe stand up, take one step, and stop)? Were you somehow still able to know where everything was, or did you have to rely entirely on positional memory? Before you got up and you were watching TV, did the TV picture seem to be moving? Also, how did this fix itself? Did your vision switch like a saccade, like the replaced (correct) image was the most normal thing in the world (regardless that it happened late), or was it like waking up, or...? It admittedly sounds kind of like the vision system went to sleep from exhaustion - then took a couple seconds to boot back up :P I'm also very curious what the illness was, but it's quite reasonable that's irrelevant to the impact and this phenomena.
- pluijzer 4y agoa) Your tip actually did make it work. It is really a crazy fun experiment! b) It was maybe about 4 seconds. I stood up and actually only noticed it one second in. I took one more step just from memory. (Like I would for example walk to the toilet at night without turning the light on). The picture on the tv did not seem to move. It looked like a frozen frame. Yes, after those seconds I saw normal again. It was exactly like a video call that got stuck. Also I kept hearing the conversation on tv. The illness was 'Lemierre's syndrome'. I had it very bad as doctors couldn't find out what was wrong we with me. Also I should have been in hospital much sooner but that is a whole different story. I could not sleep for an extremely long time because of the symptoms. Also many of my organs where infected. So I was both physically and mentally exhausted. It was not my only weird experience I got because of it. Most notably where the out of sync memories and what I can only describe as 'hallucinations inside memories'. I was not under medication at that time. Your theory about my vision going to sleep seems very plausible.
- skizm 4y agoMy favorite visual trick is the chess board illusion. People straight up think you're lying. Even when you draw a line between the boxes with the color and your eyes adjust in real time, I've had people tell me it's a gif or I'm doing some other trick.
- foobarbecue 4y agoThe idea that the image comes in "upside down" has always seemed incorrect to me. Isn't it more likely that this is essentially a configuration variable that is initialized undefined, and then set correctly based on comparing the input to other systems (inner ear etc.)? Is there any evidence that it is ever set "incorrectly"? i.e. a baby reaching up instead of down for something? Edit: to clarify, I'm saying I don't see any reason to think anything in the vision system ever "expects" light from the world's up direction to come in at the top of the retina. Surely the developing brain doesn't know what orientation or flip to expect, and the whole system is constructed based on initial inputs. It was never upside-down.
- gfaster 4y agoIf you wear glasses that invert the image, your eyes will adapt to the image after a few days. There is some information on the Wikipedia page of the guy who discovered it (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_M._Stratton https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_M._Stratton).
- foobarbecue 4y agoYes, I know. That's why I called it a configuration variable.
- jakogut 4y agoI think it has more to do with the content itself, and the elasticity and adaptability of neural networks. There is no "up" or "down" with inputs. I learned this when working with a machine vision problem. A model will adapt to the orientation or format of a given input. The orientation itself is never a variable, the network simply doesn't care and adapts to it. If you train a model to recognize input in a given orientation, any other orientation will give a high error rate. If you train the model with _every_ orientation, it will be able to classify inputs that are upside down, sideways, mirrored, etc., all relative to the original orientation.
- 4y ago
- _xnmw 4y agoAnd this is the reason why Elon Musk made a mistake by saying LIDAR was unnecessary for self-driving cars by assuming that cameras could fulfill the role of vision (He used first-principle thinking: our eyes can drive, so why do we need anything more than cameras?). Our eyes and brains do way more than any camera. The part about estimating the size of baseballs depending on one's intention to hit it also shows that our brain takes our intent into consideration when making moves, something no AI/ML-enhanced camera could ever do.
- phkahler 4y agoThis fits with (not sure the term) the model of our brains constantly doing projection/simulation. Your consciousness is at the abstract level and the brain projects successive levels of detail, then compares to actual input at the lower levels looking for differences to correct the simulation. In the abstract this is very similar to how a Kalman filter works. There is a prediction component and a correction, with a (possibly time varying) adjustments for how much weight to give to measurements. The equivalent here would be to simply ignore the measurements when the eyes move since the input will be known to be messy, and just rely on the prediction. This turns out the be a very effective (and in some ways mathematically optimal) way to process sensor input even in human-engineered systems.
- frostwarrior 4y agoThis fits with my personal model of the brain composed of a distributed system made of millions of dumb organisms screaming in coordination to create a bigger, more intelligent being. Kinda like an ant colony, CUDA and Kubernetes mixed together
- outworlder 4y ago> Kinda like an ant colony, CUDA and Kubernetes mixed together Thanks for the nightmare fuel.
- benreesman 4y agoNo shit. Excuse me briefly while I go calm down on the demonic spaceship from Event Horizon.
- tootie 4y agoI think the author of these tweets is falling in to a common trap of trying to reverse engineer why our brains do what they do and try to ascribe intent to randomness. Everything our brains do is the product of a billion years of random evolutionary events leading up to a system that does something useful for our survival. Trying to explain how our brain processes "images" like a camera is the first mistake. The universe is a wild cacophony of matter and energy and what we see in our brains is just a rendition of the salient bits of data gathered from that noise. Looking at a second hand on a clock or a mirror was never an evolutionary selector. Neither was seeing infrared or ultraviolet. At least, not for humans. If you want to compare it to a system, then a neural network is actually pretty apt (no coincidence there). Data goes in, conclusions come out. The mechanism takes thousands of byzantine shortcuts to get from A to B and the result is a small number of egregious blindspots in an otherwise highly efficient system.
- mbg721 4y ago"Batshit" is the measure of insanity. "Bullshit" is a measure of inaccuracy, "chickenshit" is a measure of obscurity, and "holy sheep shit" occurs, as far as I know, only in the film "Repo Man".
- ryanschneider 4y agoI have a (thankfully mild) inherited retina disorder. If you read the part about lasers and eye damage it’s basically that, but the “lasers” are faulty genes rather than anything external causing the eye damage. And I can verify that at first my brain did an incredibly good job at error-correcting over it, but in the last couple years it’s finally been able to “peek through”. One day I was hiking and suddenly had black spots in my vision. Then after that I woke up one morning and noticed large black halos in my vision that went away after a couple seconds of being awake. A couple weeks later and I started getting flashing visual artifacts in the edge of my vision. Which is/was terrifying because I didn’t know this was a multi-decade process I was just becoming aware of and instead assumed that if I just noticed this much visual degradation in a couple weeks then surely I’ll be completely blind in a couple more? Thankfully that’s not how it works, the damage has been increasing at a slow steady constant, it’s just that the processes in place to correct for said damage do a _really_ good job at hiding it, until they don’t, so the rate of degradation seems much worse than it actually is. That said, please if you notice any new visual artifacts get them checked up on _immediately_, while my case is a slow genetic issue sometimes it’s a detached retina, which can happen for any number of reasons and can usually be reversed quite easily with surgery if caught early. I was “lucky” mine was genetic rather than physical trauma, since I didn’t go see someone until things got noticeably worse.
- lijogdfljk 4y agoI have self diagnosed (never saw a doc) Ocular Migraines, and the first time i encountered one it both amazed me and terrified me. I was working and i noticed something was off with my vision, i couldn't read a label. I went to the bathroom and didn't see anything. I eventually realized i had a large deadspot in my vision that my mind was just... autocompleting. It looked flawless, but then i'd pass my hand slowly infront of the deadspot and there would be this strange artifact. My hand would be missing a finger, or this odd blending with the mirror behind it, etc. It was like some poorly ML generated object removal. The scary thing was i had several, and had no idea. As i experimented with it further that day i was able to disappear entire vehicles (i wasn't driving thankfully), forklifts, etc. I've only had ~half a dozen in my lifetime that i'm aware of, but i'm still quite fearful of experiencing one while i'm driving. As i likely would not realize what was wrong with me, immediately. edit: Oh i should note, as the "migraine" clears, it turns the blindspots into this weird crystalline structure. Kinda like looking through a prism. It's a pretty crazy experience.
- linux2647 4y ago> and can even see polarization of light? our good friends the Cephalopods! I’m sorry what?? That’s possible? That’s incredible. Anyone have any speculation on what that would look like?
- Winsaucerer 4y agoThis is a question which I don't think anyone can even speculate at. It's similar to the question 'what is it like to be a bat?', [1] or, what might a colour that no one's seen before look like? Some people (such as myself) like to distinguish between the physical processes that are involved in the biology of (say) sensory perception, and then the phenomenology. The biology involves things like light waves, retinas, neurons, etc. The phenomenology is the "what it's like". The following is a controversial claim for reductive physicalists who believe everything reduces to the physical, but here goes: there is no way to go from the facts about the physical world alone to any statement about the phenomenology. The problem with answering the question of what that would be like to see polarised light is hopeless. It's so hopeless that if we had two separate species that could "see" the polarisation of light, we would have no way of even telling if the "what it's like" for one of those species is the same as the next. Maybe for one it's similar to how we see colours, and for another it's similar to what it's like for us to hear sounds. Or maybe it's a completely alien kind of phenomenology with analogy to human experience. The "easy" question is the biology. We can investigate whether an organism's sensory systems are sensitive to the polarisation of light or not, and if it's done via an eye-like organ, then we might say it "sees" light, even if we have no idea if the phenomenology is anything like our vision. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/What_Is_It_Like_to_Be_a_Bat%3F https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/What_Is_It_Like_to_Be_a_Bat%3F
- cromulent 4y agoIt seems to be well established that bees see polarized light. For example: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3049011/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3049011/
- otikik 4y agoYes, chronostasis is my favorite "evolution hack" (probably thanks to this tweet). The difference between a designed system and a "grown" one is that the Universe takes what works and discards what doesn't. It doesn't need for the thing to make any sense at all.
- mkeedlinger 4y agoAlmost ten years ago now I found a site that would help show you all these visual inaccuracies. It was like a more interactive version of the wikipedia article on our blind spot. I haven't been able to find it for years, but it was an awesome exposé into how non-objective our vision is. If anyone knows of this, please remind me! I've been looking for it for years.
- drnyet 4y agoPossibly this: https://michaelbach.de/ot/ https://michaelbach.de/ot/
- mkeedlinger 4y agoNot what I had in mind, but just as good (or maybe better, this has a lot more content)!
- russellbeattie 4y agoI just happened to be reading the article on my tablet at the exact distance needed to make the blind spot test work without needing to adjust. I've seen the effect before, but this time when I closed one eye, before I moved another muscle, the letter disappeared as completely and instantly as if it was done digitally. I knew what to expect and it was still amazing. A truly "holy shit" moment.
- 0xbadcafebee 4y agoProof that software doesn't need to be "well-designed" or "clean", it needs to be functional. What you think of as "insane design" is actually just functional design (or polymorphism, depending).
- LesZedCB 4y agoyes exactly! i thought insane design was such a weird way to describe it... the fact that it is functional and emergent means is has a satisfying cleanliness, even if we don't fully understand it yet. another natural phenomenon that gets me like that is the balance of the innate/adaptive immune systems. the fact it all works on chemical physics (don't know the right word here) just blows my mind in the best way possible.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- my12pence 4y agoIt's typically human to classify something we've just begun to understand as insane before time and deeper thought yield appreciation and in some cases, awe. Though I may just be describing dunning kruger here. That being said I don't agree with anything the OP said about these being "ugly hacks". As another poster said, the UX of the visual system is exceptional, we've built no system as elegant or functional. When you look at eyes and visual system from a systems design perspective they don't look randomly generated, they look purposefully engineered the way they are. Making educated tradeoffs against the limits of physics and organic chemistry.
- anm89 4y agoYou want to know how fuckin wiiiiilldddd science is fellow kids? Title should be changed.
- senden9 4y agoI've had cataracts since birth. It's a relatively dense area in the middle of my field of view. My brain interpolates information there as well as possible. Because of this I never see a stain. It's funny to spot the bugs in this process though. For example, objects may become visible because of eye movement that were previously invisible because they were completely obscured by cataracts.
- throw7 4y agoThey'll tolerate reading it on twitter?
- cromulent 4y agoI read this tweet thread here a couple of years ago, and it was striking how much of our vision is done in the brain rather than the optics, similarly to modern digital cameras. Since then I was diagnosed with amblyopia - a "lazy eye", which is not misaligned in my case but is simply not recognized properly by the brain. It's corrected easily when you are young, but not in adulthood. Apparently brain plasticity is the problem. The resulting double vision (diplopia) is quite annoying and sometimes debilitating when you are tired - and there is no surgery to fix your brain's learned behaviour. It's pretty common - get your kids checked. My parents had no idea, and I always thought being "right eyed" was normal. Apparently there are some promising new treatments for adults using VR headsets.
- e40 4y agoA much better way to read this: https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1014267515696922624.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1014267515696922624.html
- rekrsiv 4y agoGamedevs have known for quite some time that theoretical math is too slow to simulate the universe in real time and sometimes this is what works best.
- mwint 4y agoWait, hold on. I somewhat recently discovered I can “see” pulse-width modulation on dimmable LEDs by moving my eyes quickly over the LED and then examining the trail of dashes left by the light. How does this square with vision being “paused” during the movement?
- yencabulator 4y agoI can see the color wheels of most projectors[1] by the colored light bleeding out through the ventilation on the side. I only notice it when I'm moving my gaze, stationary the light just blurs into a steady white. [1] Except the pricier models, either with separate LCDs for three colors, or with very fast color wheels.
- TheCoreh 4y agoVision only seems to be paused briefly. If you repeatedly keep moving your eyes it seems to allow the blurriness through, there's probably a "timeout" mechanism. Probably better strategy to still see something in case your eyes are shaking for a long time for whatever reason than to not see anything
- rzzzt 4y agoIf you are following an object, the saccades routine itself is put on hold and you get more or less continuous eye motion, complete with smooth focus and field-of-view adjustments. I'm doing this for fun when walking alongside slow-rolling cars - the end result occasionally "looks like" a tracking shot straight out of a movie. Edit: ...OK, field-of-view doesn't vary that much, unless you are Colonel Steve Austin with the telephoto augmentation.
- mwint 4y agoNot following an object - this is the procedure: 1. Put LED at the bottom of vision 2. Look below LED, so now it’s at the top of vision 3. There’s a trail of light for a fraction of a second, seeming to start from the bottom of vision to the top. I’m not smoothly tracking anything, just looking at one point and then another. I can clearly see the on-off duty cycles, and I’ve been playing with training myself to estimate frequencies with this method.
- decebalus1 4y agoIs anyone else bothered by the gratuitous and wrong usage of 'bullshit'? English is not my mother tongue but bullshit would refer to a lie (horseshit would express disbelief, chickenshit - cowardice, dogshit - awful, etc..) while batshit would refer to something being crazy. Which would also make 'insane' redundant. 'Batshit crazy' would be acceptable as it's most commonly used.
- dang 4y agoRelated: You want to know something about how bullshit insane our brains are? (2018) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29769275 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29769275 - Jan 2022 (3 comments) “You want to know something about how bullshit insane our brains are?” (2018) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23591535 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23591535 - June 2020 (200 comments) You want to know something about how bullshit insane our brains are? (2018) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18850203 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18850203 - Jan 2019 (12 comments) You want to know something about how bullshit insane our brains are? - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17724178 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17724178 - Aug 2018 (2 comments)
- a-dub 4y agoi find that when i execute a saccadic eye movement while a dlp or similarly color strobed projector image is in view, at the end of the movement i'll see a brief artifact where the colors will briefly separate on certain edges. i've always assumed that this is probably the result of the inhibitory masking lifting with different response times for different rods and cones on the retina. i suspect this is related to saccadic masking as it does not occur with smooth pursuit movements. (only darts to new targets as opposed to smooth panning)
- sam_goody 4y agoIIRC, it takes time for the brain to synchronize the input of the ears, eyes and other senses. [eg sound reaches one ear before the other. The brain therefore gets two inputs, time shifts them to match, and gives you both sound and location based on the difference in time.] It then does the same to sync all the other senses. It also filters out the vast majority of inputs, so as not to overwhelm you, such as the tension from your socks. All of which take up to 100th of a second for adults, less for children. In order to not have a delay (which would totally impair regular actions such as catching a ball), the subconscious constantly sends imaginary scenes to the consciousness of what it expects to be happening in the real world, and updates them as things go along. So, the clock ticking are not just timed backwards as described in this thread; instead all along you were getting "imagined" reality. In fact, our entire life we are living in a contrived reality, that are being updated with a lag, in the next incoming imaginary scenes. (I have heard variations of the above from doctors, psychologists and magicians, and have read some articles, but am not actually knowledgeable - would love corrections if I am wrong)