5 ms·
> Redesigning cities so that most people won't require a car to work and live is the real solution. That is simple to say, but what does that actually mean? I
by kube-system 4y ago
> Redesigning cities so that most people won't require a car to work and live is the real solution.
That is simple to say, but what does that actually mean? I think some cities simply wouldn't exist if being navigable without car was a requirement. People will never move around Phoenix like they move around Amsterdam.
- nicoburns 4y agoWhy not? A lot of europea cities went car-centric (building highways through city centres etc) in the 20th century, and a lot of those changes have been rolled back. It won’t happen immediately, but it could easily happen over say 50 years. The barriers are political not technical.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nradov 4y agoWeather and terrain. Amsterdam is fortunate in being flat, and in having a fairly moderate climate where it's rarely extremely hot or cold. That situation doesn't obtain in most large North American cities. Sure it's possible to ride a bike up a steep hill in Philadelphia in the middle of an ice storm or across Phoenix in a 40 °C heat wave, but it's simply unrealistic to expect most people to do so. We ought to do more to improve bicycling infrastructure in most cities but that will never fix our fundamental transportation issues.
- nicoburns 4y agoWeather I’ll give you, but plenty of people ride bikes in hilly cities in Europe. It would still be possible to improve bus services in hot cities.
- kube-system 4y agoThere is a very significant difference between a dense city with a highway through the center of it, and a city that never had a dense center to begin with. Many places that people live in the US only exist because of cars. Without cars, they'd cease to exist. There are not many cities in Europe that are predated by the ubiquity of cars.
- nicoburns 4y agoSeems to me that it shouldn’t be that hard to increase density. You just need zoning/planning regulations that allow for: 1. Shops/bars/cafes/etc in residential areas. 2. The replacement of existing housing stock with multiple residences.
- kube-system 4y agoNo, it's not really easy to drastically change the density of an established metro area. Zoning/planning is forward-looking. It won't change the status quo that millions of people in a metro area already live (and work) in sparse suburban neighborhoods far from city centers.
- nicoburns 4y agoI think you are imaging that you would need to move the people closer to the city centres. My vision is more that you could: 1. Create smaller town centres within the suburbs 2. Increase the density of the suburbs so that serving them with public transport becomes more economically viable.
- kube-system 4y agoThis really isn't much different than what already exists. Office parks are already commonly placed in US suburbs. The problem is, because good highways already exist, people don't choose to live in the same places that they work. It is common to live in one suburb, and commute to another suburb.
- acdha 4y agoMaybe, but Phoenix is not every city in the country and it’s possible to make a lot of improvements even if you’re not perfect. For example, many cities have marginal finances because a large chunk of their resources have been dedicated to suburban commuters who contribute little other than pollution. Reclaiming public space for residents, removing density restrictions, and especially doing quick things like dedicated bus or bike lanes can make a huge improvement in desirability at modest cost.
- kube-system 4y agoThe second most populous state in the US is Texas. How would someone possibly redesign any major metro area in Texas to work without cars? Tear everything down and start over? It was all built to work around the automobile as primary transport. There's no patch fix.
- acdha 4y agoYou don’t need to ban cars to reduce usage. The Texans I know would like more bus & bike infrastructure and even in Texas, most city dwellers make a ton of trips which are within bike range. As a simple example, think about how much the average family could do with the extra $10-12k a year they’d save by having one car instead of two. In a lot of places, people buy 2-3 ton SUVs so mom can drop the kids off a couple of miles away - a distance even a 4-5 year old could bike if it was safe.
- kube-system 4y agoOf course there are people want it. The question is, how disadvantaged are public transit projects given the barriers imposed by the existing choices that have been made, and the marginal cost and benefit of that project compared to existing choices? Sprawl is difficult to cover with public transit, so you end up with a system that costs 2x as much, covers 1/2 as much area, and takes 2x as long to go anywhere. The most successful public transit systems in the world area all places where driving is car is not a viable alternative for many. In a world of 10 lane highways and free parking in a sea of strip malls, it's going to be hard to convince people to stand at a transit stop.