7 ms·
Those had immediate, obvious value which were held back by the technology: every military in the world wanted flight (remember those Civil War hot air balloons?
by acdha 4y ago
Those had immediate, obvious value which were held back by the technology: every military in the world wanted flight (remember those Civil War hot air balloons?), as well as things like postal services, etc. There was zero question that as soon as the technology was functionally available, people would buy it. Similarly, the earliest photographs had unquestionable demand but were held back by the technology — again, zero question that people would buy it as soon as that matured.
Finally, the Internet was useful by 1982 — there's a reason why universities, governments, etc. all jumped online and agencies like NSF were funding this to support other research, not just development of TCP/IP, by then. The other big trend to keep in mind are the BBS scene and especially online services like CompuServe (which was already 13 years old by 1982) which had profitable businesses selling access to people who found it was useful to have in their lives for many reasons not related to developing or selling computer networking. Again, there was zero question of demand: computer hardware was expensive and networking was positively usurious but it was clear that growth would accelerate as soon as that changed because normal people found it useful for various parts of their lives.
Cryptocurrencies are different: since these systems rely on the now-pervasive web, most people on the planet have had access immediately. What hasn't happened yet is most of them having a reason to bother with it. Speculation has been the biggest driver but buy-and-hold is toxic to developing a useful currency and few people have built a business or life which depends on it except for gambling like that.
- tremarley 4y agoBitcoin and crypto has an immediate, obvious value that was previously held back by technology. Similar to the rest of the examples you've listed. We live in an age where we are forced to own nothing and be happy. Bitcoin, Blockchain and crypto solves this.
- Group_B 4y agoCrypto does not bypass in any way the ability for a company to charge me a subscription instead of offering me an option to buy something outright.
- tremarley 4y agoIf you keep money in the bank. You don't own it, the bank does. You need permission to access it and are limited on what you are allowed to use it for. If you keep cash or gold in a safe place. You are only allowed to keep a certain amount. It can be seized at will. Your will that declares what assets go to your children. The deed to your home. The lease for your car. Certificates. Art. Tickets. Contracts. Money. We do not own any of these things without the requirement of having to trust a person, a comp ay or a government. Blockchain technology allows us to own anything that can be documented on a ledger. Indefinitely. Trustlessly.
- Group_B 4y agoA ledger is only useful if the money it points to is actually useful.
- 4512124672456 4y ago> Trustlessly With cryptocurrencies, you need to trust: * The exchanges (and other ramps for getting useful money into the system and out of the system) * The developers of the chain * The developers of the smart contracts * The developers of wallets * The miners * The internet providers * The hardware manufacturers * The government (yes, they could punish usage of cryptocurrencies hard if they wanted to) > Your will that declares what assets go to your children. The deed to your home. The lease for your car. Certificates. Art. Tickets. Contracts. Money. Which can all be lost or stolen easily without a central authority and a judicial system. Do not underestimate the power of phishing, especially if it is directed towards specific people.
- tremarley 4y ago> With cryptocurrencies, you need to trust: * The exchanges (and other ramps for getting useful money into the system and out of the system) Decentralized Finance, Protocols and Apps do not require trust. The frontend and backend of every protocol you are expected to use is open source. Things can only go wrong, without the fault of your own if you use something closed-source or custodial. Cryptocurrency allows you to take responsibility. > Which can all be lost or stolen easily without a central authority and a judicial system. Do not underestimate the power of phishing, especially if it is directed towards specific people. Blockchain gives the world the ability to not rely on the local central authority. Your data will not be edited, removed, lost, stolen or damaged either. You can write up a contract, leasing me your land for 99 years, on paper, with a witness and kept a copy with the local central authority. This can go well, until it goes wrong. In 99 years, my estate may refuse to give the land back to you without proof of the paper it was written on. We could claim the paper is a fake. The local central authority can be bias, corrupt or dissolved. Which many authorities are. If you used blockchain instead of paper. The contract remains unchanged, and ready to read at any time, until the very last computer on this planet is turned off.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gotbeans 4y agoYou forgot to explain how
- weej 4y ago>> "we are forced to own nothing and be happy. Bitcoin, Blockchain and crypto solves this." Serious question, what/where does this apply to? I get NFTs for digital authenticity, but PKI solves this too. How does one "own nothing without blockchain" when we have property deeds, automobile titles, jewelry and fine art certificates of authenticity all without blockchain? Your comment comes off as a solution looking for a problem.
- tremarley 4y agoAll of those things requires us to trust somebody, which is a glaring single point of failure in the system. Things can go wrong. When any of these deeds, titles or certificates are lost, burnt or stolen. You have to rely on an outside body to keep a backup safe for you. Blockchain allows us to be super efficient too. Which is a perk. Rather than the need of waiting for someone to certify, deliver, inspect, notify, return, process. Depending on the industry, this could take years. Blockchain tech allows everyone to see the validity of a claim in real time. My family sold out family home a few years ago. It took 6 years of unnecessary admin work to get it sold. If we relied on blockchain tech, it would've been processed in a day.
- Diesel555 4y agoThe problem with blockchain implementation is that most of them still rely on us to trust someone. It is not implemented in the distributed self hosted way people think. The top hacker news submission about Web 3 (blockchain) points out that NFTs and other blockchain technologies are centralized and reliant on trusting someone in practice [1][2]. [1] https://moxie.org/2022/01/07/web3-first-impressions.html https://moxie.org/2022/01/07/web3-first-impressions.html [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29845208 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29845208
- tremarley 4y agoThis is true. Many NFTs (not all) rely on trusting some random server. People are doing it, but it doesn't make it right. It's a bad business practice. There are enough reliable methods to not rely on trusting some random server, but some money hungry developers cannot be asked to implement them. Similar to how some websites do silly things, like storing plain-text passwords in their databases. People do it, but it doesn't make it right.
- acdha 4y ago> We live in an age where we are forced to own nothing and be happy. Bitcoin, Blockchain and crypto solves this. The first part is simply not true (ownership isn't exactly uncommon). Can you specify the problem more precisely and explain how blockchains solve this? I've been following the space since the day Satoshi's manifesto hit HN so please include as many details as possible.
- dorgo 4y agoIn 1998 I wanted to buy a router ( or a modem ) to connect my computer to the internet. I was asked questions like: why internet? What for? what do you gain from it? Nothing was obvious.
- acdha 4y agoI don’t know where that was but it’s at least a decade late for the United States - by 1998, Amazon was profitable in multiple markets (that year they reported $610M in revenue) and a ton of other companies, non-profits, and government agencies were seeing plenty of traffic. Here’s a list even earlier: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_websites_founded_before_1995 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_websites_founded_befor... In 1998, I was working for a web design business which had a mix of startups and established companies (a couple of F100s and some F500s, as well as smaller local companies). None of those were “web” companies - they sold things like pet supplies or knives, offered financial services, did biomedical research, etc. but what they all had in common was that they benefited from being on the web because their customers were moving there and they could offer them a better experience and/or lower costs this way. That still hasn’t happened for cryptocurrencies despite a much larger potential customer base, lower barriers to entry, and twice as much time. If Bitcoin abruptly halted today, almost no businesses outside of the field would even notice and the few who did would mostly be removing the least used payment option on their site. That’s the difference: there’s been just as much marketing, the same level of squandering VC money on Super Bowl ads and stadium naming rights, etc. but there doesn’t seem to be anything more than that sizzle this time.