27 ms·
“Anti-racism is usually structured around conscious efforts and deliberate actions which are intended to provide equal opportunities for all people on both an i
by Retric 4y ago
“Anti-racism is usually structured around conscious efforts and deliberate actions which are intended to provide equal opportunities for all people on both an individual and a systemic level.”
Actually being color blind rather than having the appearance of being color blind is a tricky thing. Taken to an extreme, a collage which had a purely random acceptance criteria is non discriminatory, but it would feel like discrimination if you had a high GPA.
- fallingknife 4y agoYes that is the technical definition of discrimination, but when people say something is "discriminatory" they usually mean discriminatory in a way that it isn't supposed to be. To your example of a college, it is supposed to discriminate on academic performance, so nobody has a problem with discrimination on GPA (of course comparing GPAs is still an implementation problem). And to say it's hard to be colorblind is not true. You just don't factor in race. You will probably fall back to the line that black students would have had a higher GPA if they weren't discriminated against in other areas of society, but then it's not the school doing the discriminating. And this is the core of the problem. Instead of selecting the best students, universities have decided to select who they think hypothetically would have been the best student in a perfect world, and doing a very poor job of it. And their arrogance in appointing themselves the corrector of all societal ills and their myopic focus on only gender and race differences in doing so has pissed a lot of people off.
- Dylan16807 4y ago> You will probably fall back to the line that black students would have had a higher GPA if they weren't discriminated against in other areas of society, but then it's not the school doing the discriminating. And this is the core of the problem. Instead of selecting the best students, universities have decided to select who they think hypothetically would have been the best student in a perfect world, and doing a very poor job of it. It's more complicated than that. If someone is in a bad environment, they can have a worse GPA and be a worse student at that moment, but once they get into the college environment they will be a better student, not just "could have been". > And their arrogance in appointing themselves the corrector of all societal ills and their myopic focus on only gender and race differences in doing so has pissed a lot of people off. Appointing themselves the corrector? For anyone that does have that motivation, they'd probably gladly welcome more cooperation. And those two getting most of the focus is because they get most of the discrimination.
- fallingknife 4y ago> but once they get into the college environment they will be a better student How, exactly? Not that this really matters b/c universities today are credentialing scams where no one fails out. > And those two getting most of the focus is because they get most of the discrimination. Citation needed. And if they were being at all quantitative about this, at least I would have some sympathy. The giveaway is that they are being completely dishonest about what they are doing. Harvard fought like hell to prevent their admissions process from coming out in discovery. If they were honest, they would make it public anyway. What do they have to hide? Well, just that they weren't running any remotely reasonable process to model how good of a student someone is under normalized conditions. They were artificially lowering the "personality scores" of Asian students to keep them out.
- crooked-v 4y ago> How, exactly? Consider two students with equal intelligence and equal skill at studying. One lives in a rich suburban neighborhood where schools are well-funded and the parents have the time and money to supply constant extracurricular attention to their children. The other lives in a single-parent household in a historically redlined urban neighborhood where the school budgets are peanuts and he has to work a part-time job on the side to help support his family. Which one is going to have the more impressive transcript in college applications?
- fallingknife 4y agoYes but how is that going to be equalized by another 4 years of the same?
- Retric 4y agoIt’s not that people will be exactly equal but rather you can validate admission criteria by comparing graduation rates and GPA’s. If men and women graduate at similar rates and have similar GPA’s then your admission criteria are presumably reasonably unbiased. If men have lower GPA’s and graduate at lower rates then presumably their admission criteria should be raised to account for biases you aren’t aware of. If however you underrepresent men relative to the general population you may want to focus on attracting more of them through advertising. From an outside perspective this might seem unfair. Why is the school spending so much money mailing to young men while requiring more extra curricular activists to be admitted? It’s a question of equal standards vs equal opportunity.
- crooked-v 4y ago> You just don't factor in race. You may not want to factor in race, but society already has. People aren't spherical cows in a vacuum.
- toolz 4y agoNo one argues discrimination is bad, they argue discrimination based on something as arbitrary as skin color or gender is bad. It reads to me as very disingenuous to frame the conversation as if there was an argument to be made that college's discriminating on unrelated, unchangeable, inherited characteristics is fair or just.
- fsckboy 4y ago> No one argues discrimination is bad, they argue discrimination based on something as arbitrary as skin color or gender is bad. you're wrong. being in favor of "equitable outcomes" today frequently means arguing that discrimination on the basis of math or other test scores is bad. Google "math is whiteness" or see the elimination of gifted and talented programs in public schools
- Dylan16807 4y ago> Google "math is whiteness" That's about how teaching methods are failing some children, and then they're being judged for it unfairly. It's not against proper education and testing and using that to sort.
- fsckboy 4y ago> teaching methods are failing some children if you assume that all children are equally capable of learning everything then you are forced to conclude that teaching methods are failing some children. But if you "believe in science" (it's quite popular today to profess belief in science), you don't believe assumptions like that.
- CuriousCosmic 4y agoAll children are equally capable of learning but different children are receptive to different teaching styles and approaches. Only teaching children with a small selection of approaches that were primarily refined with middle to upper class white neuro-typical children can be considered discriminatory. That's the point of those studies. It would be like forcing a kid who is growing up in middle-to-upper class western society to solely learn mathematics via ancient greek visual proofs and then blame them for not understanding maths because they "just aren't trying" or "they aren't smart". Everybody has equal capacities to learn but only if you can find the style of learning which works for each person.