6 ms·
Appetite for Destruction: Indigenous Americans knew how to avoid starvation
- dieselgate 4y agoWhat a great article if not for only the context of what Native populations of the American northeast would eat! Boiled horse hoof is making me laugh because it sounds horrendous, but hey don’t know til you try. I also got a kick out of the woman saying something like “first week captive I couldn’t eat, second week I ate a little, third week everything tasted amazing”. Of course the Native population knew how to eat well and had an incredibly diverse food system! Even Native people in comparatively extreme (elevation/desert etc) environments like modern Mexico City or the American southwest (and beyond) thrived.
- RajT88 4y agoThe early settlers, as they point out, also had a far more diverse diet than we do now. In fact, they (partly) ate passenger pigeons out of existence. It seems to me that China still has this kind of diversity somehow. Going to a large Chinese supermarket is dizzying in the variety of vegetables, dried fungus, seaweed, spices, etc. on display. I wish I knew more about it, and how they maintained that diverse food culture.
- corrral 4y ago> In fact, they (partly) ate passenger pigeons out of existence. Mann's 1491 suggests this may be a myth, as passenger pigeon remains are nearly non-existent in native refuse piles, so they don't seem to have been a normal part of their diet (at least, before contact). Rather, he paints both their incredible abundance and subsequent demise as consequences of contact with Europe: the boom in the passenger pigeon population may have been a sign of an ecosystem experiencing a catastrophe, resulting from large areas of cultivated land falling out of use as entire cities were depopulated by disease, causing a temporary but enormous increase in easy, available calories for animals positioned to take advantage of it, and of course their decline and extinction is entirely a post-contact event. [EDIT] I misread you as having written that the native people contributed to the demise of the pigeons, but I think the info's still broadly relevant so I'll let the post stand.
- kennend3 4y ago"I wish I knew more about it, and how they maintained that diverse food culture." My ex-wife is Chinese and I might be able to assist a bit. China is a massive country and each province has their own "special dishes". For the Chinese out there reading this - you can guess where she's from when i tell you their speciality is "Guìlín mǐfěn" Anyhow, when you go to a large Chinese grocery store in North America you are looking at the fruits, vegetables, etc from a large number of provinces. So if someone from Guangxi goes there for Hot Peppers they can find it. If someone else is looking to make Peking duck can find what they need as well. Back in China, someone from Guangxi wouldn't be making a lot of Peking duck... Hope this helps?
- kurupt213 4y agopigeons are delicious
- bergenty 4y agoA lot of people eat slow cooked goat hooves and it’s absolutely delicious, probably my favorite part of the goat. There’s plenty of meaty fat on the feet and lots of delicious bone marrow. The soup is always very rich because of the fat. Maybe horse hooves are similar? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paya_(food) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paya_(food)
- dieselgate 4y agoI believe it thanks for chiming in! When you say “slow cooked” it certainly has more appeal. Oh gosh now I’m curious
- bergenty 4y agoThough I should add it’s never just the hooves but the bottom 6 inches of the foot including the hooves.
- dieselgate 4y agoWas wondering about that part..
- pvaldes 4y ago(Hey, want a laugh? lets give the worse bits to the prisoner to see if he vomits)
- itsoktocry 4y ago>Indigenous survival methods have persisted, like their keepers, for hundreds of years against invasion, disease, and ecological catastrophe. Colonizers could learn a great deal from Indigenous resilience... I find interpretations like this strange. Sure, there's lots to learn from cultures of all kinds, and it's particularly relevant to hear from Natives of NA if we're talking about North American agriculture. But there's an implication that the European colonizers bumbled their way through history, as if they didn't face and overcome their own issues with starving populations. I think it's objective fact that Europeans have been quite resilient themselves, being as how they managed to settle most of the planet.
- tchalla 4y ago> I think it's objective fact that Europeans have been quite resilient themselves, being as how they managed to settle most of the planet. I am sure you would notice the difference of resilience pointed out by the article in comparison to the European world wide "settling" resilience.
- bergenty 4y agoThis is a straw man that you proposed and then go on to refute. No one is implying Europeans didn’t face challenges and “bumbled through history”. Saying colonizers could learn a lot is sort of what ended up happening anyways, especially in the early days of colonization where plenty of skills to survive in a brand new continent came from the natives.
- kennend3 4y agoI'm not sure how you came to the conclusion this is a "straw man"? Did you read the article? his comment was directly copied from it : "Colonizers could learn a great deal from Indigenous resilience, as we all confront a twenty-first century that feels hauntingly like the seventeenth: beset by violence, disease, hatred." By stating they could learn a great deal does imply they "bumbled along". It also isn't very accurate as there was a lot of technology sharing at the start of things. The FN shared a great deal with the newcomers on how to survive here.
- 4y ago
- corrral 4y agoAn aid for anyone else who found the usage "knowledges" unfamiliar and distracting: Knowl"edge (?), n. 2. That which is or may be known; the object of an act of knowing; a cognition; -- chiefly used in the plural. There is a great difference in the delivery of the mathematics, which are the most abstracted of knowledges. Bacon. Knowledges is a term in frequent use by Bacon, and, though now obsolete, should be revived, as without it we are compelled to borrow "cognitions" to express its import. Sir W. Hamilton. To use a word of Bacon's, now unfortunately obsolete, we must determine the relative value of knowledges. H. Spencer. - Webster's 1913 I figured it was some probably-from-critical-theory-because-aren't-they-always liberal-artsism, but looks like it's just an unusual-bordering-on-archaic sense.
- claudiawerner 4y ago>I figured it was some probably-from-critical-theory-because-aren't-they-always liberal-artsism, but looks like it's just an unusual-bordering-on-archaic sense. I don't think that's correct (and the age of the dictionary quoted probably isn't helping); if you search Google Scholar for "knowledges", even since the year 2000 you get about 85,000 results. It's a term of art in sociology and anthropology fields, and marginally within philosophy too. It points to multiple understandings of the world which are disparate enough to be their own 'system' of knowledge; multiple such systems are known as knowledges.
- chis 4y agoThis article is such an odd mix of interesting Native American facts and overwrought critical theory. Mostly makes me want to go read the actual source (Sovereignty and Goodness of God). I always wonder if the academics writing this stuff actually believe it or whether they start by writing a normal essay and then throw in all the critical theory stuff at the end so it can get published.
- akamaka 4y agoI think the problem is simply in the varying writing skills of academics. Of course they need to take into consideration current theory and political viewpoints if they want their work to be relevant. But it takes an unusually skilled writer to weave theory and facts into a compelling story.
- claudiawerner 4y agoIt's interesting how "critical theory" is used as a prejorative not only going on a hunch, but also that the very use of it degrades the quality of any article without question. Personally I've come to enjoy quite a lot of work which many would categorize under 'critical theory' and a lot of work which many would mistakenly categorize under 'critical theory' simply due to the topics covered.
- taeric 4y agoTo be fair, the complaint is against "overwrought" critical theory. A critical eye is important. It can also be overdone.
- RappingBoomer 4y agoyeah, what started out as a good piece of writing devolved into a dogmatic narrative
- rdtsc 4y ago> throw in all the critical theory stuff at the end so it can get published. It’s how it was done in the Soviet Union. You’d read a cooking recipe book and there might be some paragraph about serving the party’s goal or other stuff like. The personal beliefs were more cynical towards the later years and it was done mostly to appease censors or gain a few virtue points with peers and superiors. Here it could be the same. Write whatever, but make sure to insert a few critical theory du-jour points just in case.
- causality0 4y agoIndigenous survival methods have persisted, like their keepers, for hundreds of years against invasion, disease, and ecological catastrophe. That would depend on the people in question. The list of indigenous tribes who wiped themselves out by destroying their environment is extensive. The Maya, the Anasazi, Easter Islanders, the Nazca, and countless more we'll never know about.
- WalterBright 4y agoFrom what I've read about the archaeological evidence of bones, Indigenous peoples suffered from famine now and then.
- colechristensen 4y agoWhat weird patronizing tone. >Indigenous Americans knew how to avoid starvation. Colonists were too hungry to notice. What's the point, civilization(s) that lived off the local land were better at subsisting in difficult situations than people from a different continent not very familiar with local food sources? An exposition of native foods contrasting with colonial foods could be interesting but it's wrapped up in weird reverence and arguing against a centuries old idiot.
- lazide 4y agoThe trope you’re identifying is the ‘noble savage’.
- WalterBright 4y ago> as we all confront a twenty-first century that feels hauntingly like the seventeenth: beset by violence, disease, hatred. The 17th century was far, far worse off with violence, disease, and hatred. Life expectancy was short in those days.
- bslorence 4y ago>In the early seventeenth century, for example, the French Jesuit missionary Pierre Biard complained that the Wabanaki did not have to work hard enough to feed themselves ... “Had he ever gone fishing…? Gathered nuts, or berries deep in thorns and mosquitoes? Ever tracked a deer through snow, skinned a rabbit…?” Huh. Seems probable that an early 17th-century missionary to North America knew a little bit about roughing it, maybe even more than the OP's poet... who also seems to have missed his point. Here's something he actually said: "They are never in a hurry. Quite different from us, who can never do anything without hurry and worry; worry, I say, because our desire tyrannizes over us and banishes peace from our actions." [1] [1] https://www.gutenberg.org/files/46218/46218-h/46218-h.htm#XIV https://www.gutenberg.org/files/46218/46218-h/46218-h.htm#XI...
- pvaldes 4y agoThe myth of the good savage that lives in harmony with the nature ... after, ahum, erasing a third of the megafauna of North America with their ecological and wise techniques 13000 years ago Same as natives did in South America 11000 years ago. And same as Australians did 30000 years ago in the rainforested Australia And same as Africans did in the green land of thousand lakes, Sahara And the same thing as Europeans did in Europe Lets face it, we all are complete morons in that sense. Every culture by equal. Hey a winter without gas could be coming!, lets set fire to the forests in half Europe this summer so we don't have neither gas nor wood in winter!.
- dqpb 4y agoI would bet it’s pretty common for people to know how to feed themselves in their indigenous land, and struggle in a foreign land.
- xchip 4y agoTypical article that could have been 2 tweets but the inflated it to make it 3 pages. They did a good job by scattering the answer all over the place. This is becoming a classic.