7 ms·
America's new favorite pastime: The lottery
- OrangeMonkey 4y agoTake this for what its worth - there appears to be a relationship between economic downturns / recessions and lottery spend - https://taxfoundation.org/does-lottery-revenue-rise-or-fall-during-economic-hardship https://taxfoundation.org/does-lottery-revenue-rise-or-fall-... Given the current sour economic forecasts and inflation concerns, I don't think the lottery spend increasing is surprising.
- jacquesm 4y agoAnd correlation with poverty as well. Rich people don't play the lottery.
- etrautmann 4y agoIs that true? I remember seeing somewhere that it’s surprisingly flat across income, though obviously a larger proportion of income for lower earners.
- throwaway1777 4y agoYeah because they don’t need to and the $3 ticket isn’t a noticeable expense if they do.
- yieldcrv 4y agothat is a distorted interpretation of assumptions it doesn't matter when rich people play the lottery, whereas it does matter when poor people play the lottery as its a meaningful proportion of their available earnings
- Bubble_Pop_22 4y ago> Rich people don't play the lottery. They do. It's called "incorporating a company" or "investing in the stock market" often with leverage. I would guess that for a regular non-connected, non-ivy league folk the chance of becoming a billionaire is roughly the same creating a startup vs. the lottery. At that point it makes sense to play the lottery if you are a "swing for the fences" kind of guy, that's because when odds are kinda the same it makes way more sense to throw 500$ monthly in lottery tickets than throwing 14h/6d/52w yearly in precious time to build a company or reading balance sheets of publicly traded companies
- jacquesm 4y ago> It's called "incorporating a company" or "investing in the stock market" often with leverage. We were discussing the lottery.
- rwmj 4y agoAnd very strange things like the Dance Marathons of the 1930s: https://www.historylink.org/File/5534 https://www.historylink.org/File/5534 Dance Marathons (also called Walkathons), an American phenomenon of the 1920s and 1930s, were human endurance contests in which couples danced almost non-stop for hundreds of hours (as long as a month or two), competing for prize money."
- tdeck 4y agoThis was fascinating and definitely merits its own post. There are some pretty clear parallels with today's reality TV.
- JumpCrisscross 4y agoWe’ve got a broad and growing addiction & attention problem in America. Ad-fuelled social media, crypto, day trading and useless financial engineering. A growing fraction of the labor force, moreover, is dedicated to these cancers.
- TechBro8615 4y agoPeople who learn to resist this onslaught of stimulation targeting our limited attention span will be the winners of the next few decades. I estimate that about 5% of people aged 20-30 currently have this ability.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> People who learn to resist this onslaught of stimulation targeting our limited attention span will be the winners I agree. One hopes they have a civilisation to come home to.
- sokoloff 4y ago> dreaming of what they would do with a post-tax lump sum estimated at more than $600 million. Post-tax lump sum would be closer to $450M for a solo winner whose state does not tax lottery winnings. > Statistically, that means this drawing is a rare positive-sum game... Not unless you are exempt from federal income tax. > ...if at least one person wins the jackpot. That's not how statistics works.
- adamrezich 4y agoif we were in a recession maybe this would make sense but I've been told we're not so this is completely baffling
- ARandomerDude 4y agoSilence, pleb! Don't question the authorities.
- exogeny 4y agoI don’t think it’s particularly baffling to believe that potentially winning $600mm is attractive to a lot of people in a country where the top 1% control 15x the wealth as the bottom 50% in sum and where wages have stagnated to such a large degree.
- jshzglr 4y agoRight because 600m wouldn’t be attractive elsewhere.
- elefanten 4y agoGp is referencing US political slap fights from the last week (Biden admin declaring US is not in recession). It’s a joke comment.
- adamrezich 4y agoin the words of a wise man, "not a joke"—I truly thought we were in a recession, but the updated definitions and Wikipedia article lock proved me wrong!
- lesuorac 4y agoRecession is one of those words like Abortion where everybody has their own definition. The US officially [1] goes by what NBER says and NBER doesn't call recessions/etc until several quarters after it starts. So any talk right now is speculation and you may speculate correctly but you might not. [1]: https://www.bea.gov/help/glossary/recession https://www.bea.gov/help/glossary/recession
- fortran77 4y agoTwo of those dollars are mine. When the jackpot is over a billion dollars, I easily get two dollars of entertainment value from buying one ticket.
- nr2x 4y agoExactly, there’s a big difference between “I’ll grab a ticket at the gas station as a laugh” and poor pathetic exploited gambling addiction. I used to sell tickets at a convenience store and I’ve seen some pathetic people for sure. But for these mega jackpots I think it’s mainly casual people buying a fantasy for a couple days of day dreaming.
- JustSomeNobody 4y agoMy SO and I used to travel to see family (they've moved) and there's a fillin' station on the way that we'd stop at. We always bought a single ticket just for kicks. It broke up the drive and got us talking and laughing for the second leg of the trip. I totally get the entertainment value.
- ksaj 4y agoMy SO and I often buy the Crossword scratch cards. It's not because we ever think we'll win (we're definitely in the minus), but because we scratch two letters at a time and pass the card back and forth. It's a mindless game that only costs us $3 to play, and we get a lot of conversation in - often influenced by words in the game or letters like J that nearly never complete a word. We spend a lot more than $3 on our other entertainment outlets, and its better for the relationship than retiring to the living room to stare at a laptop screen. So we get what we pay for with scratch tickets.
- nr2x 4y agoRoad trip scratchers!
- anewpersonality 4y agoAny way to hack the $1bn lottery prize?
- barbazoo 4y agoBuy more tickets /s
- anewpersonality 4y agoAre you aware of any syndicates?
- undersuit 4y agohttps://www.cnbc.com/2017/06/30/mastermind-of-lottery-fraud-admits-he-rigged-jackpots.html https://www.cnbc.com/2017/06/30/mastermind-of-lottery-fraud-... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1980_Pennsylvania_Lottery_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1980_Pennsylvania_Lottery_scan... You need to be in the business. I think every drawing uses new numbered balls, maybe go for the supply chain if you can't get in the lottery organization itself.
- X6S1x6Okd1st 4y agoOf course there's always the chance that there are multiple winners which affects either it's expected positive roi
- bryanlarsen 4y agoThat is in the article, which mentions there's a 50% chance you're going to share the prize. So let's do the math. 35 cents go to non-jackpot prizes, so the ROI on that is 35 cents, leaving 1.65 for the jackpot. ROI on the jackpot is $1B / 400M odds. That's $2.50 shared amongst the winners. 50% of that is single winner, 50% is shared so $1.25 + $1.25 / 2 = $1.875. $1.875 is greater than 1.65, so the ROI for this lottery is slightly positive. (I don't have the numbers on odds of 3 or more sharing, so the ROI is actually slightly less than $1.875, but it won't be much of a reduction).
- 8n4vidtmkvmk 4y agoArticle also said only 75 cents go to the jackpot. the rest goes to the government
- bryanlarsen 4y agoThe jackpot accumulates. It grew so high because there are many weeks worth of 75 cents. It's an average. Most weeks 0 cents goes to the jackpot because nobody wins, so on the weeks somebody wins, it's often significantly more than 75 cents. This is obvious because they're selling $400 million worth of tickets to a $1B jackpot.
- hdjrudni 4y ago> The jackpot accumulates. It grew so high because there are many weeks worth of 75 cents. It's an average. Most weeks 0 cents goes to the jackpot because nobody wins, so on the weeks somebody wins, it's often significantly more than 75 cents. This sentence does not compute. If nobody wins for a week then however many tickets that were sold times 75 cents get added to the jackpot. If somebody wins, the jackpot is reset to $0. > This is obvious because they're selling $400 million worth of tickets to a $1B jackpot. $400M this week? Because they should have sold about 1.33 billion $2 tickets without a winner to reach a $1B jackpot, however many weeks that takes.
- jeffrallen 4y agoLotteries are criminally stupid, and running them is criminally evil. Shame on all governments that do so, including mine.
- cowpig 4y agoAlternative take: there's strong demand for numbers games, and the government, whose spending is at worst weakly correlated with social goods, and who is not profit-motivated and therefore will do less to encourage problem gambling, is better than the alternative in practice.
- Ericson2314 4y agoIt would be nice to end the drug war and put lotteries under the same management as Portuguese-style state drug distribution. Also nationalize coffee chains for same reason lol.
- Jtsummers 4y agoThe government may not be profit-motivated (debatable), but it is still cash-motivated. Lottery money in many states go to a variety of services, like education and state parks and such. This does create a motive to encourage spending on the lottery as those services end up relying on the lottery earnings as much or more than conventional taxes and fees for their funding.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- r3trohack3r 4y ago> and who is not profit-motivated and therefore will do less to encourage problem gambling, is better than the alternative in practice. When a government taxes vice its now depending on those revenue streams. It creates an incentive system where the regulator for advancing social good is depending on tax income from the failure of regulating. Illinois is doing this right now with their gambling industry. Those little gambling machines are in every restaurant and there are dedicated e-gambling buildings everywhere in Springfield. You see folks go in and dump their life savings into those machines. I know a restaurant owner who has customers park out back to hide their gambling from their spouse. But gambling tax revenue is bailing out the failing state. At the end of the day, it seems like the government of Illinois is the true addict.
- tristanj 4y agoThe first sentence of the article is not necessarily correct since anyone worldwide can legally buy tickets though a ticket-purchasing service. For example, in 2015 a man from Baghdad bought a ticket through a service and won a $6.4m lottery without leaving Baghdad. The article assumes everyone buying tickets is an American, which is not true.
- undersuit 4y ago>Fantasies of dynastic wealth are one of the few things you can buy with $2 these days — a price that hasn't gone up since 2017. Yep, I'll probably go buy a ticket today after work. I only buy MegaMillions or Powerball when it reaches these outlandish amounts. Read somewhere in an outdated article that Powerball only reached an expected $2 payout per ticket when it's a +$550 million pot. That graph of the tickets bought in the article is pretty amazing too. If the pot isn't won tonight I would love to see an update.
- secabeen 4y agoThe challenge with that hockey-stick graph is that it greatly increases the chance of multiple winners. That kills any chance of a +EV. The best lottery drawing is the one just before the one that makes news; by definition, it had no winner, so if you had just picked the right numbers, you would have won it all.
- yieldcrv 4y agoAlso every drawing (twice a week) has had one or more million dollar+ winners People focus waaay too much on the jackpot! I love the privilege of not being poor enough to be criticized for buying a ticket. I pay for a lot of fleeting entertainment. What's a $2-3 ticket? Or $20 worth of those?
- undersuit 4y agoThe math for the expected payout reaching $2 per ticket was only for the jackpot. The lesser prizes and bonus modifiers are the losing propositions that get you into a gambling addiction.
- yieldcrv 4y agoI expect a negative expected value game, and I get a negative expected value game.
- m_ke 4y agoI wonder how that compares to all of the sports gambling going on these days.
- btkthrowaway1 4y agoI've always found it funny when sales skyrocket when the jackpot is unusually high. 10M isn't that appealing but suddenly 1B is? I understand the lizard brain mentality, not trying to knock anyone, I just get a little chuckle out of it
- sushid 4y agoYou're surprised that sales increase when the EV increases?
- cehrlich 4y agoEV decreases as sales increase though
- btkthrowaway1 4y agoI don't care what the EV is, when your chance of winning is 1 in 302,575,350 you're better off selling your house and betting it all on black
- jtbayly 4y agoNo, because you're not homeless if you don't win the lotto. Definitely not better off doing that.
- mateo411 4y agoPfft, there's only a 52.6% chance of losing a bet on black, which means there is 47.4% chance the you could win and end up with two houses minus real estate transaction costs. And that's without going to Monaco where you can play on a 37 pocket wheel.
- darth_avocado 4y agoPersonally yes. I am a realist where I know the odds are almost 0 and wasting my money on an almost 0 percent chance doesn’t make sense at all. But when it’s 1B I still know I won’t win, but it’s also an amount where I at least feel like I should put my name in just in case. Not a lot of tickets but maybe like $10. Seems irrational but I believe that’s what most people are thinking.
- tareqak 4y agoIn Canada, the Canada Revenue Agency considers gambling winnings to be windfalls that are not subject tax, so any winners receive the full value of the advertised prizes [0]. [0] https://www.canada.ca/en/revenue-agency/services/tax/technical-information/income-tax/income-tax-folios-index/series-3-property-investments-savings-plans/series-3-property-investments-savings-plans-folio-9-miscellaneous-payments-receipts/income-tax-folio-s3-f9-c1-lottery-winnings-miscellaneous-receipts-income-losses-crime.html#toc11 https://www.canada.ca/en/revenue-agency/services/tax/technic...
- joenot443 4y agoWe also have a fascinating legal relic called the "Skill Testing Question" which allows for games like Roll Up the Rim or guess-the-jelly-bean-jar to exist without being subject to our otherwise very restrictive gambling laws. I'm not sure how it was decided, but the "skill" being tested is usually order of operations. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skill_testing_question https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skill_testing_question What's funny is that the law doesn't say if you're allowed help, or if you need to answer correctly on your first try, simply that they wrote the correct answer on a receipt which the merchant is supposed to keep. When I worked at McDonalds and it was busy, we were encouraged to just tell people the answer so they could redeem their free muffin and keep the line moving.
- mattheww 4y agoFYI, if you make a realistic calculation (including tax and multiple winners), the EV of a lottery ticket is still negative. Depending on your tax bracket, the non-jackpot prizes have about $0.19 of EV. In a state where you don't pay tax on lottery winnings, like CA, you cash option post-tax is currently estimated at $408,403,045. My estimate of the multiple winner correction to the EV is 0.8, based on numbers of winners for prizes >$500M. Your jackpot EV is therefore $1.08 and the total winnings EV is therefore $1.27, meaning the overall EV is -$0.73. For there to be positive EV, that delta needs to all come from the jackpot, so the headline jackpot number would need to go from $1.1B to $1.8B to get it there.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jallen_dot_dev 4y agoGreat analysis. I want to share my thoughts on EV because they seem to go against what pretty much everyone else is saying. I think even if the EV was >$2, it would still be irrational to play. I say this because I think it's silly to talk about the EV of buying a single ticket when the odds of winning are 1 in 300 million. Like, you still aren't going to win the jackpot. Your odds didn't improve just because the jackpot got bigger. I guarantee you are going to find out tonight that you wasted $2, just as you would have wasted $2 at any other time when the jackpot is/was smaller. I think it's just people rationalizing what they know is an irrational behavior. They're fooling themselves into believing they are making a rational choice because they want in on the fun/excitement despite paying the "poor tax." Anyway, good luck to anyone who decided to buy a ticket and enjoy a few hours of fantasizing about what you'd do with the winnings :)
- tmaly 4y agoYou could flip the perspective and look at it as helping out the winner. Still for most people, their biggest return is being able to day dream for 5 minutes what it would be like to win.
- 4y ago
- BiteCode_dev 4y agoDoes Lottery Revenue Rise or Fall during Economic Hardship? https://taxfoundation.org/does-lottery-revenue-rise-or-fall-during-economic-hardship https://taxfoundation.org/does-lottery-revenue-rise-or-fall-...
- imwillofficial 4y agoThe lottery = Poor Person’s Tax
- Balgair 4y agoTrue, but it's kinda fun too. Buying the ticket and letting yourself fantasize a bit is part of the 'joy' of it. Could you do it another way? Of course. But actually plunking down $2 and dreaming about the winnings in the car feels more 'real'. To me, it's fairly harmless fun, probably for most people too. Edit: Also, it's a voluntary tax.
- beej71 4y agoA guy I knew was a statistician for Loral. He always bought a lottery ticket. He knew the exact odds and expected value and played anyway.
- teeray 4y agoYeah, I know the expected value is negative. But the variance is what makes the occasional purchase worthwhile.
- tamaharbor 4y agoAll you need is a dollar and a dream. Or in this case, two dollars.
- tamaharbor 4y agoDang it, not even close.
- beej71 4y agoThought experiment: add more numbers. We get these huge jackpots because the odds of winning are so low. What happens if we add more numbers so the biggest jackpots end up at $10 billion... Or $100 billion or $10 trillion? When do things start to break? And what breaks?