2 ms·
Bullshit. You're using legal terms that you don't even vaguely understand. Go talk to an actual attorney who deals with civil litigation and ask how this stuff
by nradov 4y ago
Bullshit. You're using legal terms that you don't even vaguely understand. Go talk to an actual attorney who deals with civil litigation and ask how this stuff actually works.
- mindslight 4y agoActually no, OP is basically correct. Their description is skipping a bunch of steps (eg bankruptcy), using a strong definition of "withdrawal" that implies a bearer instrument, and "illegal" doesn't necessarily carry a criminal penalty. But they're not wrong about the overall dynamic. Once money is in the financial system, it's legible to and thus controlled by the system. Of course once money is out of the financial system, then the system is suspicious of it when it does discover it (either by depositing it, getting it stolen via civil forfeiture, etc).
- idontpost 4y agoYeah, a lie is true if you change the meanings of words too.
- mindslight 4y agoI can't tell specifically what you're referring to, and each clause of my explanation is referencing a common use.
- nradov 4y agoActually no, paulpauper is spouting nonsense that he obviously doesn't understand. He stated that, "if you are sued for any matter no matter how frivolous, any attempt at withdrawing the money is illegal." That is factually, legally incorrect. Withdrawals by a defendant in a civil suit are only illegal in specific and rare circumstances that only apply in a small fraction of civil cases. Adding a bunch of weasel words to obfuscate the issue doesn't change that reality. Unlike some of you, I have actually been in that situation and withdrew a bunch of money from my various bank accounts while the suit was pending for a couple years. This was 100% legal. (And in the end the suit was dismissed anyway.) All assets are subject to seizure, whether they are in a bank or not.
- mindslight 4y agoI'll give you the "no matter how frivolous", which crucially pulls in the idea that the legal system is making a respectable judgement. Like if you were sued and lost due to some ridiculous theory of liability, the general complaint about fraudulent conveyance would be true, but it wouldn't be correct to call that a "frivolous" suit. And sure, "all assets are subject to seizure", except that assets legible to the system are much more at risk, whereas assets that are private will remain yours. If you see the legal system as an attacker rather than defining it to be always just, then this distinction matters. Relatedly, I'd trust the technical operation of bearer tokens more than the legal operation of an offshore trust, especially with the small amounts of wealth us plebs tend to have.
- paulpauper 4y agoso if you have 100k in the bank and someone falls on your property and sues, you can withdrawal all the money? I don't think it works that way. If you lose it will show intent to hide money.
- function_seven 4y agoWhere did I put the $100k when I withdrew it from my account? Did I convert it to gold bars and stash it at my buddy Ricky's house? Did I deposit it into my brokerage account? Did I pay my lawyer with some of it and buy a car with the rest? Let's say I'm buying a rental property, and during the closing process I'm served with this lawsuit. Are you saying it's illegal for me to close that sale? Only one of those examples would be suspicious to the court, and only if I was attempting to claim insolvency during the proceeding or in dragging my heels on a judgement.
- paulpauper 4y agoWhere did I put the $100k when I withdrew it from my account? Did I convert it to gold bars and stash it at my buddy Ricky's house? Did I deposit it into my brokerage account? Did I pay my lawyer with some of it and buy a car with the rest? You would have to answer to that under oath. It's called a Debtor's Examination, assuming you lose, or fail to answer the lawsuit, or it does not get dismissed. A bank account statement showing a large withdrawal shortly after being served would be a major red flag. The idea behind asset protection is to move the assets to a secure place or set up protections before you get sued.
- nobody9999 4y ago>so if you have 100k in the bank and someone falls on your property and sues, you can withdrawal all the money? I don't think it works that way. If you lose it will show intent to hide money. Yep. Been there. Done that. I killed someone with a vehicle and was sued over it. While the lawsuit proceeded, I was under no obligation to or take special measure to record how I disposed of my property while the lawsuit was pending. That's because I (or anyone else) can fill out a form saying "PaulPauper owes me twelve gajillion dollars because he caused me harm in some way." You can pretty much sue over anything. But filing a lawsuit doesn't force the defendant to hand over control of their finances/resources. Yes, in some criminal cases assets can be frozen by prosecutors. But in a civil lawsuit, there's none of that -- as someone claiming you owe them money isn't the same as actually having a judgement against you requiring that you pay. I tell you what, go ahead and sue me. Pick a reason. It doesn't really matter. As long as you utilize the correct format and pay for the filing that's it. Lawsuit filed. The idea that a civil lawsuit deprives you of the right to dispose of your property as you see fit is risible at best.