4 ms·
Wow, this is pretty dystopian. "You have money that we didn't know about so you have to explain yourself, or we will assume you acquired it illegally and take
by kelnos 4y ago
Wow, this is pretty dystopian. "You have money that we didn't know about so you have to explain yourself, or we will assume you acquired it illegally and take it from you". That's not due process. That's not innocent until proven guilty. (Yes, I know UK legal standards are different than the US's, but I believe these things to be rights people should universally have.) That's not rule of law; that's rule by thugs.
I guess that's strictly "better" than the nearly-zero-recourse civil forfeiture travesty we have here in the US, but... still not great.
- potatototoo99 4y agoAlmost every country has some form of this law. Sometimes the money is confiscated, other times it is treated as a taxable event at the highest rate possible, etc.
- tialaramex 4y agoIn what way is this not "Due process" ? The presumption of innocence does not mean you're entitled to obstruct investigators. "But you haven't proved that I'm guilty" also doesn't work to stop detectives entering your home with a search warrant.
- Phrodo_00 4y agoFrom OPs explaination, if you won't explain how you got the money it'll be forfeited. That's the opposite of presumption of innocence. I'm ok with having large amounts of cash with no obvious legitimate source triggering an investigation, but that's not what's happening.
- brewdad 4y agoThe UK doesn't have a 5th Amendment.
- Phrodo_00 4y agoYeah, because they don't really have an actual consolidated constitution, but the presumption of innocence is one of the principles of English Common Law (see Woolmington v DPP), as well as being one of the rights in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. They just sneak past it by not actually sentencing you of a crime.
- int_19h 4y agoUK has parliamentary sovereignty, so any presumed common law right only exists until the Parliament passes a bill that effectively nullifies it.
- Dylan16807 4y agoIf you target the very wealthy, it's a very tiny burden to make them do paperwork to explain the origin of their money. In a situation like that, you can achieve due process without presumption of innocence.
- Phrodo_00 4y agoThis can be used for values over £50000, though.
- Dylan16807 4y agoThat's probably not a great threshold, but for now I'm more worried about where it has been used than where it could theoretically be used.
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoSuppose you have a $30k salary, and one day $10,000,000 million appears in your bank account. Maybe someone in your town was killed on the same day. Is it unreasonable that law enforcement asks how did you aquire an amount of money that is greater than you could ever earn in your lifetime? it's nearly the same mechanism as what was used against alcapone to jail him for inocme tax evasion -> he had access to absurd amount of wealth, and there is no way the could have aquired it legally.
- RajT88 4y agoAgain - this is not what's happening. Triggering the investigation is fine and reasonable. Confiscating the wealth without evidence of a crime is the issue. Civil Asset Forfeiture in the US is regularly confiscating not tens of millions of dollars, but mere thousands of dollars for the simple reason of it being in cash. And this case is even worse - the cash was not on anyone's person out in public, but in a safe deposit box, not doing anything in particular.
- nicoburns 4y agoI think it's much better than Civil Asset Forfeiture. Civil Asset Forfeiture regularly ends up confiscating money that the owner can readily prove they have via legitimate means. This won't happen here. It's only if you can't come up with a good reason that your money will be confiscated (and that process is happening through a court not just with a random police officer).
- cout 4y agoThe issue with CAF is not forfeiture of assets without evidence of a crime; with CAF there is evidence of a crime, but not necessarily evidence that the forfeited asset is related to the crime, with little or difficult legal recourse to recover the assets. Sometimes the case is never brought to trial [1]; in other cases the owner of the assets is never even charged with a crime [2]. When the forfeiture creates a financial burden [3] or the asset has the potential for depreciation [3], the accused may have even a financial incentive to settle rather than go to trial. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31446215 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31446215 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8588268 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8588268 [3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10365463 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10365463 [4] https://cre.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/03/37_2_3_Federal_Forfeiture.pdf https://cre.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/03/37_2_3_Federal_Fo...
- marbletiles 4y agoIt's not "you have money we didn't know about", it's "you have an amount of money that requires explanation". It's more like "we see a lot of smoke coming out of your house, satisfy us there isn't a fire or we're coming in with the hoses". Viewing that through the "innocent until proven guilty" lens is like trying to argue the fire crew have to stay outside until they see actual flames
- ozim 4y agoIANAL but I think throwing "innocent until proven guilty" around might not be valid outside of criminal justice.
- int_19h 4y agoWait till you learn about ASBO. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-social_behaviour_order https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-social_behaviour_order