4 ms·
That example seems clear cut from both ethical and constitutional perspectives. If juveniles use your property to commit crimes, that property is rightly in jeo
by jeffbee 4y ago
That example seems clear cut from both ethical and constitutional perspectives. If juveniles use your property to commit crimes, that property is rightly in jeopardy.
- notch656a 4y agoI'm not sure that's true, but if it is that is absolutely terrifying and I hope it is rectified at once. I think this would lead to the seizure of all public parks in my city.
- jeffbee 4y agoI guess like all libertarians you will be surprised to learn that there is a separate body of jurisprudence around public property, separate from private property law.
- notch656a 4y agoI am rarely surprised to learn anything anymore in the various laws used to part the common joe of his property.
- indymike 4y agoGoogle civil asset forfeiture. It is absolutely nuts.
- Dylan16807 4y agoWhen "use" is "was inside of", how the fuck can you call that ethical?
- njharman 4y agoSo person breaks into your house and squats it, or shoots up there, bith crimes. Your house should be forfeit? What "ethics" you following?
- KennyBlanken 4y agoI think there's a fundamental difference between "someone breaks into your house and commits a crime" and...purposefully allowing someone use of a gun or vehicle, or negligence leading to said use (ie, leaving your car running in front of a convenience store, and then someone stealing it and going on a high speed joyride, running a red light t-boning a minivan, killing a family of four), and someone, with no negligence on your part, using property of yours to commit a crime. If you leave your gun on the floor of your car, someone smashes the window and steals it and shoots up a convenience store: you should be charged criminally and subject to civil liability. If someone breaks into the gun safe in the trunk of your car and shoots up a convenience store? No crime, no liability - you took reasonable precautions.
- Dylan16807 4y agoA gun comes with special obligations to protect it. If someone borrows your car, or steals your left-running car, I don't think you should have have any criminal liability or risk of seizure. (Assuming you didn't conspire ahead of time, of course.)
- notch656a 4y agoWhile I agree with you on someone stealing your car, I don't see the gun and the car as so different as you do. You can easily kill people with a car or box truck, and possibly in greater number. Blaming someone because their car or gun was stolen sounds a lot like victim blaming to me. And to the comment about breaking the window, I'd like to point out that most safes are practically as easy to break open as a window is. I recall buying one safe, and another customer explained to me in detail how they had pried one open in only a few seconds.
- indymike 4y ago> Blaming someone because their car or gun was stolen sounds a lot like victim blaming to me. This is punishing one of the victims.
- indymike 4y agoWhy should I be responsible for some other parent's kid committing a crime with my property? So the fact a kid commits a crime erases my rights?