6 ms·
Yeah, I think that's hard to say without taking into account the issue of social media algorithms. These algorithms purposefully amplify some of the most toxic
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
Yeah, I think that's hard to say without taking into account the issue of social media algorithms. These algorithms purposefully amplify some of the most toxic content out there, so I think gaming the system to harm democracy would be considerably more difficult if social media feeds were just a chronological list of friends' posts.
Even without the algorithm, though, I also believe that humans just aren't evolved to have some kinds of discussions asynchronously, remotely behind a screen. I've found myself needing to disconnect from social media because it leads me to having negative feelings about people that I know I like. E.g. after the overturning of Roe v. Wade there were some posts by family members who I know and love, even though I know we don't share the same politics. After seeing their posts the first thought that went through my mind was "WTF is wrong with these people??" But if we had been discussing it face-to-face, I'm sure we would both have been more respectful of the other person's viewpoint, or at least would have agreed to disagree and move on.
Everyone has seen it (and probably done it) - said something extremely hostile in an online forum that we would never say face-to-face.
- ifyoubuildit 4y agoTo refine the analogy a little more then: regarding the algorithms, maybe it's more like direct democracy but with a really powerful propaganda department (that's run by a sort of evil AI) influencing lots of votes? I very much agree with everything else you said.
- marcosdumay 4y agoWhy stand with the direct democracy? It's not like people decide anything that matters.
- twblalock 4y agoThe content promoted by the algorithm results in higher user engagement because people like it. If they didn’t, the algorithm would have been changed to promote other kinds of content instead.
- zozbot234 4y agoIt turns out that people are more likely to engage with content they don't like, at least when it comes to factional politics. So that's what ends up being promoted the most.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoDefine "like it". Many people also drink themselves to death or OD on heroin because they "like it". I don't think it's that hard to differentiate between things people do for enjoyment that they think of as a positive influence, and addictive substances that can fleetingly make people "feel better" but are extremely harmful. Most addicts may say they enjoy getting high, while even simultaneously talking about how drugs have ruined their lives. The fact that social media companies have hacked the same brain pathways doesn't mean the answer should be "it's fine, they all like it!"
- Karrot_Kream 4y agoYes and different cultures have different appetites for these vices. For example, in East Asia it's much more acceptable to gamble than it is in most Western countries. In most of Europe it's more acceptable to do drugs than it is in the US, and the US finds it much more acceptable to do drugs than East Asia does. In East Asia it's common to be openly drunk, at night, in public. In the US it's much more acceptable to enjoy firearms than it is in Europe or East Asia. There's no easy answer to "this is toxic, we should ban it." Everyone has a different definition of toxic. Cultures form around different norms. Social media, like HN, spans multiple continents and cultures. I don't think you'll ever be able to get all of the userbase of any of these sites to agree on what is toxic and what is not. I'm of the opinion that the user should be able to: 1. Audit their algorithmic recommender to see which bin they're bucketed into. 2. Adjust the weights on the recommender But anything more, any form of broad agreement on toxicity, is asking for humans around the world to land at a single definition of what is good and what is bad.
- soco 4y agoControversial content is the one getting promoted more. More often not because of the content itself, but because of the amount of comments (read, fights) attached to it.
- q-big 4y ago> These algorithms purposefully amplify some of the most toxic content out there No, these algorithms (often) purposefully amplify content that increases the engagement rate or "average time on page" metric. It's just that toxic content coincidentally often has high values on this metric: - if you agree with the content, you stay on the page longer to read more of what you love - if you disagree with the (toxic) content, you perhaps invest a lot of time to post strong counterarguments (increases engagement rate and average time on page)
- thr0wawayf00 4y agoSo, the previous point still stands. These algorithms purposefully amplify content that increases engagement, which often happens to be toxic. Ergo, these algorithms often purposefully amplify toxic content.
- chiefalchemist 4y agoThe algorythm doesn't care what its amplifying, only that the amplification increases engagement. Toxic is a correlation, not a causation.
- prophesi 4y agoIf it's known to be a correlation, then it's disingenuous to say they're innocent for simply wanting to amplify engagement.
- q-big 4y ago> If it's known to be a correlation, then it's disingenuous to say they're innocent for simply wanting to amplify engagement. But if it's know to be just a correlation, it is a defamation to claim that this was done on purpose ("purposefully").
- prophesi 4y agoIf you know exposure to radiation causes cancer, then you shouldn't let people continue to mine despite simply wanting more uranium or what have you for philanthropic purposes.
- woweoe 4y agoI think it is also partially because many people have become accustomed to having a left-leaning media that espouses a certain viewpoint. So in yesteryear the viewpoint might have been very liberal New York or LA, and nowadays it is possible to see a similar "bias" on news outlets like Reddit where the moderation has turned everything into certain left-wing viewpoints US-centric echochambers. A lot of the internet forgets that FOX News is technically a young media network. And the fact is that most Americans are actually on the fence on the abortion issue, although most people are also against a full-on ban against abortion which the media is focusing on. The media has been presenting a very narrow view in the past, and now you are just getting exposed to the full spectrum of viewpoints on the internet. Reddit I think is the best counterargument against further moderation of social media. The moderation outside the US at least is wholly haphazard and out-of-touch with mainstream views in said localities. For example if a left-wing American were to actually go around asking how Scandinavians themselves viewed their socialist paradise nordic welfare state as being viable, the response would be something that might be against left-wing interests, and they would be banned on Reddit. Similarly the way the media has supported Muslims and the on-the-ground Islamophobia in Europe and Asia are widely apart, and most of these people would be blanket-banned on Reddit as well.
- UncleOxidant 4y agoThe algorithms seek to maximize engagement. And it turns out that rage is one really good way to maximize engagement. After being on twitter for a bit over 14 years I deleted my account in May when I realized this is what the algorithms were doing. I'm still detoxing from twitter, but I feel like quitting has been very beneficial for my mental health. > Even without the algorithm, though, I also believe that humans just aren't evolved to have some kinds of discussions asynchronously, remotely behind a screen.... But if we had been discussing it face-to-face, I'm sure we would both have been more respectful of the other person's viewpoint, or at least would have agreed to disagree and move on. Yes, this. But what I fear is that heavy use of social media is causing our face-to-face interactions to change for the worse as well. People seem to be getting less respectful in face-to-face interactions as social media led the way towards making it easy to dehumanize the other.
- Karrot_Kream 4y ago> The algorithms seek to maximize engagement. And it turns out that rage is one really good way to maximize engagement. I used to think this was only a property of algorithms but I'm not convinced anymore. Any number of link aggregator sites I'm on with no algorithmic surfacing of content, Reddit (at least on the old site), HN, Lobsters, Tildes, etc all have the same effect. Everyone comments on and engages with the rage inducing post. Nuanced, sanguine conversations get maybe an upvote or two but are just a few posters talking. This tracks with my experience on forums back in the '90s where huge hellthreads would spawn and have people arguing for weeks, and every archive of Usenet flamethreads that I've seen. I don't think the algorithms are helping, but I think this is just a property of socializing in the large. Humans, when socializing in person, have a lot of context. When my friend rants "relationships are terrible they are just adults emotionally manipulating each other" to me, and I have the context of knowing my friend just had a bad breakup, I know the place this is coming from. When someone posts this on Twitter, everyone is up in arms because there's no context. There's other properties of socializing in the large that I suspect leads to the patterns we see in online discourse, but I'm beginning to think that the algorithms are the minor part.
- UncleOxidant 4y ago
- drewcoo 4y ago> t humans just aren't evolved to have some kinds of discussions asynchronously, remotely behind a screen Evolution does not have an intended purpose. > I've found myself needing to disconnect from social media because it leads me to having negative feelings about people that I know I like That sounds a lot like heated face to face interactions. I guess that's why they call it "social" media! People can take responsibility for their feelings and actions. Or they can find a scapegoat like social media. There's a long human tradition of scapegoating, after all.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y ago> Evolution does not have an intended purpose. I never said it did. What's your point? I'm just emphasizing that humans have clearly evolved to have social constraints in face-to-face interactions that haven't evolved in async, remote interactions (which is unsurprising). > That sounds a lot like heated face to face interactions Except it's not, and that's my whole point. Yes, of course people can have heated face-to-face interactions, but it's undeniable that people can be a lot nastier, quick to judge, be belligerent, etc. in remote interactions vs. in-person. And it's not just social media. Louis CK has a great bit about how he can be a total asshole when driving in traffic in a way that would be completely unacceptable/insane if he did it in an elevator, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x8062QEFk5g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x8062QEFk5g . The same dynamic applies in online interactions.