6 ms·
Stranger Things is being edited retroactively by Netflix?
- mesozoic 4y agoWhat about that coffee edited out of Game of Thrones.
- fullshark 4y agoThe article even mentions Star Wars and George Lucas, something that happened 20 years ago, yet pretends this is the start of a dangerous trend. Cause it's TV (or streaming) instead of a movie / home video release I guess?
- munk-a 4y agoI'd also point at this big old list of media effected by 9/11[1] - I think the most notable one at the time was 2002 Spiderman which released a trailer containing the two towers initially that was then edited (along with the movie) to remove that landmark. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_entertainment_affected_by_the_September_11_attacks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_entertainment_affected...
- ethbr0 4y agoEditing something innocuous but associated with trauma just feels... wrong. History happened. No need to create a past and future-projected vacuum as a consequence of past events.
- alanfalcon 4y agoIt felt right at the time to many people. The two towers trailer scene was specific to the trailer according to them at the time, so not having that scene was apparently already the plan. The way the film was, I certainly never felt the lack of the towers but would have been pulled out by their presence.
- yardstick 4y agoSpiderman was edited before its release, in April 2002, after the 9/11 attacks. I’m guessing this along with the other changes to the film post 9/11 but pre release were the creators wishes and reflections after the attack. You have to remember it was less than a ~6 months after the attacks. This wasn’t history. This was the here and now and it was a massive trauma on a lot of people at the time.
- ethbr0 4y agoGranted. But we're now 20 years later. There are other, older movies with the towers in them, and yes, seeing them certainly stirs up emotions unexpected by the directors at the time. But the World Trade Center existed as a structure. And something terrible happened to it. Avoiding it now, even by omission, feels like avoiding an important part of history.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- xmprt 4y agoI'm not sure I understand what you're saying. If a movie is released today, it obviously wouldn't have the towers. And a movie released in the past right after 9/11 would edit them out because it was still fresh in people's minds and most people agree that it was the right decision. Are you saying that the movies/trailers/TV shows should be retroactively edited to re-include the towers? Isn't retroactive editing a bad thing that we want to avoid. That's what this entire post thread is about.
- bluefirebrand 4y ago> Are you saying that the movies/trailers/TV shows should be retroactively edited to re-include the towers? I didn't get that from their post at all. In fact I think you are in agreement. If your movie is set before 9/11 it should include the towers. If your movie was released before 9/11, it shouldn't be edited to remove the towers.
- enragedcacti 4y agoFor a movie coming out in 2002 and set in "the present day", I would think keeping the towers would be distracting and introduce an "alternate timeline" problem that further distracts.
- evan_ 4y agoOTOH if you don't, then you have something like the 2002 Muppet Christmas Special where they put Kermit in an "It's a Wonderful Life" scenario. We see how the world would be different if he had never been born. There's a scene set in New York where a random shot shows the WTC in the background, insinuating that Kermit was somehow responsible for 9/11. Obviously that was never the intention of the producers but it ends up being a huge distraction from the rest of the story of the special.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoIt's not easy being green.
- jimbob45 4y ago4chan's /tv/ will produce a list of 100+ examples of censorship by the streaming platforms if you go make a thread about it. To be honest, I just personally don't care because I didn't trust the streaming platform that made 'Cuties' and '13 Reasons Why' with moral matters to begin with.
- tempoponet 4y ago"Cunningham's Law" - make a post saying it _hasn't_ happened to get the truly comprehensive list.
- Dracophoenix 4y agoWhat in particular was wrong with Cuties and 13 Reasons Why? The former is an exposé on pre-teen sexualization and the latter depicts teen suicide.
- reincarnate0x14 4y agoWith purely hosted media there is no way for purist fans to ever have the "original" or whatever version of it, unlike the people who were swapping around laserdisc and 35mm versions of the unspoilt cuts of Star Wars, etc.
- rocqua 4y agoTorrents work like a charm here.
- freedomben 4y agoThat's not something that can be relied upon. I've seen numerous torrents die from all seeders dropping off, to attackers poisoning metadata thus making it impossible for any new downloaders. Torrents as a whole may seem like the cockroach that never dies, but individual torrents die all the time.
- selfhoster11 4y agoWhether the old HN claim that “storage is cheap” is true or not, preemptively downloading everything you might be interested in (or all new releases) is one solution to this problem.
- reincarnate0x14 4y agoWhich is what the data-hoarding crowd has been doing for a while. Storage is relatively cheap, you can get extraordinarily large amounts of it for a few thousand USD if you aren't super concerned about five-9s uptime and Google still lets small team-sized business customers store petabytes for basically zero additional cost if you're OK with near-line retrieval times.
- Bedon292 4y agoIn this specific case you could buy Stranger Things Season 2 on Blu-ray which would have the original version on it. But that is probably getting to be a rare case, especially since you can't buy Season 3.
- ggrelet 4y agoYeah, Kanye West was notorious for doing the exact same thing for his album « The Life of Pablo » on music services back in 2016. https://www.xxlmag.com/kanye-west-the-life-of-pablo-changes/ https://www.xxlmag.com/kanye-west-the-life-of-pablo-changes/
- Bedon292 4y agoI think the medium is the main difference. An old movie you have on tape or whatever physical media and would need to go buy an additional copy of a new version of it. Whereas something primarily on streaming can change on you without notice and you cannot go back and watch the original. Plus in the case of Lucas it was in a new "Special Edition" which contained other edits too. It was never passed off as the original version, and part of the selling point was the edits. Rather than an update in place without any notice.
- closewith 4y ago> Plus in the case of Lucas it was in a new "Special Edition" which contained other edits too. Is that true? If so, it didn't last for long. There's no way to legally watch the original Star Wars now, unless you can find a physical VHS or Laserdisc.
- Bedon292 4y agoThat's how I remember it being at least but that was in 1997. They had a whole new theatrical releases for them and all that. They even sold a DVD set with the original theatrical versions as bonus material [1]. But they have lost the "Special Edition" moniker at some point. And the edited versions are the only thing available for streaming. [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20060517020346/http://www.starwars.com/episode-iv/release/video/news20060503.html https://web.archive.org/web/20060517020346/http://www.starwa...
- jonny_eh 4y agoHere ya go, Stranger Things season one on DVD, where no one can change it: https://www.amazon.com/Stranger-Blu-Ray-Collectors-Exclusive-Packaging/dp/B076HTKKXC https://www.amazon.com/Stranger-Blu-Ray-Collectors-Exclusive...
- Bedon292 4y agoPersonally I don't mind this change just fixing a plot hole by changing a word. And yes you can buy Season 1 and 2 but what if they did it in Season 3 which you can't buy? It just so happens in this case that they did it to a season which you can buy but being able to buy seasons on physical media is becoming rare these days.
- krapp 4y agoThey didn't stop editing Star Wars 20 years ago, unfortunately. See Disney+ editing the scene between Greedo and Han Solo to make Greedo say "Maclunkey[0]" before shooting him. And yes Greedo still shoots first because we live in the worst timeline.
- saynay 4y agoMore, the author saw mention of it pop up on thier Twitter feed, so wrote an article to cash in on the current "controversy" with no actual research beyond Twitter.
- nonameiguess 4y agoEven on TV, HBO retroactively edited out George Bush's head from the spikes Joffrey makes Sansa look at in season one of Game of Thrones, all the way back in 2011. George Martin just joked about it in his interview on the upcoming House of the Dragon.
- fasteddie31003 4y agoDon't see a problem here.
- 202206241203 4y agoIt might turn into another woke crusade to make old movies inoffensive.
- commandlinefan 4y agoThat's actually what I expected the article to be about - I was honestly surprised when it turned out to be something so mundane.
- foobarian 4y agoIs that why all the Tarantino movies are suddenly half as long as they used to be? /s
- lexandstuff 4y agoTexas had 1,586 books banned from high school libraries [1] in the last year. Is that the kind of "woke crusade" you're referring to? [1] https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.cnn.com/cnn/2022/04/07/us/book-bans-pen-america-analysis/index.html https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.cnn.com/cnn/2022/04/07/us/b...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mrcheesebreeze 4y agodepends what was in the books, many "woke" books are just inappropriate for kids.
- metadat 4y agoGrab torrents of the originals while they're still available if you wish to preserve access to the unadulterated versions. Is there a better option?
- dvtrn 4y agoRetconning content on streaming services was something I was once concerned about, but eventually told myself wasn't a realistic worry. If anything it was on my mind because when it happened before (Star Wars, as someone else mentioned) I found the retconned/altered versions to just be....in my own opinion, a lesser version than what came before it. This, combined with music streaming services suddenly 'disappearing' albums (usually for licensing reasons) is what's nudging me back towards just buying and ripping physical media again (or....yeah..pirating).
- edabobojr 4y agoI find it ironic that the article itself was edited after the initial posting, per the disclaimer at the bottom. If Netflix added such a disclaimer in the credits of the episode, would that make it more acceptable to the author?
- hickvision 4y agoI can't speak to the author's views, but it would to me. There's something very disconcerting about the ability of digital media to be "memory holed", and the Streisand effect is no longer a sure thing, in the age of big tech censorship infrastructure built by popular (media) demand.
- doix 4y agoAt least with TV shows this isn't a problem. Everything is dumped on day 0 so the original releases are preserved. It wouldn't surprise me if there are hundreds of thousands of copies of the original releases floating out there due to torrents. It was actually a much bigger issue in the past. You pretty much cannot get the theatrical release of the star wars episode 4. I think the best we have are the laser disc rips. To me, that's a a bigger "memory hole", happening way before big tech.
- gaius_baltar 4y ago> You pretty much cannot get the theatrical release of the star wars episode 4. I think the best we have are the laser disc rips. There is the "Silver screen edition" of Star Wars (first of the first, even before it got the "Episode IV"), but it only happened due to enormous efforts of fans who got an original print that should have been destroyed, digitized it with a homebrew machine, and painstakingly restored it frame by frame. That's a really fascinating story.
- Flankk 4y agoJournalists have been doing this the last few years without using a disclaimer. Personally, I think it's completely different as film and music is art. If this was done with music it would be especially damaging. Imagine your favourite songs being remastered and arranged for the worst. Artists could rework unsuccessful albums, which is weird.
- ghaff 4y agoThe writers claim [1] the story is untrue and others have apparently independently verified that scenes don't seem to have changed. ADDED: They did apparently retro-edit around a plot hole but not what people were getting upset about. [1] https://twitter.com/strangerwriters/status/1551901196700590080 https://twitter.com/strangerwriters/status/15519011967005900...
- teej 4y agoIt’s all just Mandela effect and fans needing reasons to be mad. There’s a notable “off-season” effect in TV subreddits. When there’s no new content but people still want to chit-chat, crazy theories and over-analysis start to get popular.
- cwkoss 4y agoIts weird to have an article about the dangers of editing that doesn't clearly identify what the dangerous edit was. Seems like the hand wringing was about a scene the article-author incorrectly said was edited, so the article updated, but now the article is an empty shell of criticism without substance.
- bigtones 4y agoCould that same criticism not also be applied to this very news article that was retroactively edited or 'George Lucased' as the writer refers to it as.
- madrox 4y agoThis is the real story, but not a new one
- thaumasiotes 4y agoNo, because the article admits to the change: > Correction: A previous version of this article incorrectly stated that a season one episode of Stranger Things had been edited retroactively to remove a shot of Jonathan photographing Nancy while she was changing.
- vlunkr 4y agoFrom the creators: "We have George Lucas’d things also that people don’t know about" It's baffling that they are apparently aware of how much fans hate these kinds of changes and went ahead with it anyway. EDIT: People are replying with valid points about not all changes being bad. I guess this was a knee-jerk reaction to the fact that they invoked one of the worst examples of retroactive changes as a reference.
- londons_explore 4y agoSurely anyone with a pirate bay copy from a few years ago could just diff the two videos to see what they changed?
- fullshark 4y agoBlade Runner fans strongly prefer the final/directors cut. I think Zach Snyders Justice League was a hit. Lucas’s edits were just terrible.
- FiatLuxDave 4y agoSome of us Blade Runner fans despise the final/directors cut.
- vlunkr 4y agoWith Blade Runner they've also been good about keeping all versions available. Unlike Star Wars where you'll probably just have to cringe your way through that Jabbas palace song.
- staticman2 4y agoDid you know J.R.R. Tolkien rewrote the Gollum scenes in the Hobbit in a newer edition to better fit his new book series, The Lord of the Rings? I'd say a little more nuance is needed than automatically dismissing any change as bad.
- ciabattabread 4y agoWorse things have happened... like inserting ads in old reruns: https://www.slashfilm.com/516453/wtf-zookeeper-advertising-inserted-how-met-mother-reruns/ https://www.slashfilm.com/516453/wtf-zookeeper-advertising-i...
- snthd 4y agoand replacing music https://www.nytimes.com/2021/04/21/arts/television/tv-soundtracks-dawsons-creek-freaks-and-geeks.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/04/21/arts/television/tv-soundt...
- dylan604 4y agoMusic replacements is quite common for licensing purposes, and the fact people think it is shady is what's weird. The shady part is the damn music licensing process.
- dragonwriter 4y agoHaving licensing arrangements which fail to anticipate all future potential media and distribution mechanisms for all time until the heat death of the universe (or which, even if they do anticipate some of it, don't want to pay for all future potential media and distribution mechanisms until the heat death of the universe for something that may not have any resale value in a handful of years even on current media) are the cause of this.
- seanalltogether 4y agoIts really unfortunate in the case of Scrubs, the music in that show was practically part of the script.
- dylan604 4y agoThat kind of stuff really doesn't bother me. I rarely pay attention to anything like that anyways. Also, it is not uncommon, at least for theatrically released features, to have differences between territories not dissimilar to that kind of background object replaced/modified. Small details like that which have no bearing on the plot or affect the viewers take of the content will be changed. These edits help the producers track down which area a leak occurred.
- iseanstevens 4y agoI think it would be better if there were the expectation of published change logs.
- whoomp12342 4y agoOoooo a choose your own ending where if you only happen to have watched it between february and march it makes sense? No thanks.
- O__________O 4y agoThere have always been numerous “editions” in popular titles; theatrical, XYZ screen size, TV rebroadcasts, director’s cut, remastered, XYZ country, XYZ language, etc.
- unethical_ban 4y agoCool, link me to the "Original cut" hosted on Netflix of the mentioned episodes. Having different editions is fine if it is transparent, and moreso if prior versions are available.
- Imnimo 4y agoIf I publish a novel, and I identify a typo, is it "starting a dangerous trend" if I correct in the second printing?
- smiddereens 4y ago
- gqthrowaway2022 4y agocalls it a "dangerous trend" - proceeds to provide the most mundane example imaginable, changing the date of an event to not be on a character's birthday Just a complete nothing of an article. The follow-up claim is that it might sneakily start to happen in less popular series, such that nobody might even notice there had been changes. Oh, the humanity! Nobody might notice the tweaks, that sounds dangerous.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> calls it a "dangerous trend" - proceeds to provide the most mundane example imaginable, changing the date of an event to not be on a character's birthday That's the post edit version. There was a different supposed edit (listed in the correction at the bottom) that was supposedly motivated by changing political mores in the original version, except that edit didn't actually happen. The hyperventilation would be extremely silly even if the original version of the article was accurate I it's description of what edits had occurred, but it is even more ludicrous given the actual facts.
- andrewmutz 4y agoIs there anything more ironic than the fact that this article was corrected? > Correction: A previous version of this article incorrectly stated that a season one episode of Stranger Things had been edited retroactively to remove a shot of Jonathan photographing Nancy while she was changing.
- 988747 4y agoThere's a difference between correcting factual errors (or typos) and changing the story to better fit current political climate.
- 13415 4y agoI don't see a problem with changing a story to fit the current political climate better, assuming that the original version has been archived by someone somewhere. This merely seems to create new opportunities for doctoral theses in Film Studies.
- 988747 4y ago> I don't see a problem with changing a story to fit the current political climate better That's what sequels/remakes are for. Ninja edits of the originals are disgusting, especially in streaming services, when you can't expect people to have the content archived.
- frumper 4y agoWhat is disgusting about it? It's an art form and they're the artist. I fail to understand who is harmed by this.
- enragedcacti 4y agoOriginal article: > Viewers who still have physical copies of Stranger Things season one noticed something odd having gone back for a rewatch on Netflix: a scene wherein one-time weirdo Jonathan Byers (Charlie Heaton) takes spying, lewd snaps of now-lover Nancy (Natalia Dyer) from a bush has been erased on the platform. And it's not the first time the Duffers have gone back to the cutting room after the fact. > There's a difference between correcting factual errors (or typos) and changing the story to better fit current political climate. It's a good thing that in this case the factual error was the assertion of "changing the story to better fit current political climate." Without that fake bombshell (that they could have validated for $XX dollars by just buying the DVD) what is the difference between an article correction and a minor plot continuity correction?
- RajT88 4y agoFriends was found to be rendering into reruns adverts for movies which hadn't yet been released when the reruns were airing (2012 IIRC). The precedent has long been set.
- dls2016 4y ago"In episode 2F09, when Itchy plays Scratchy's skeleton like a xylophone, he strikes the same rib in succession, yet he produces two clearly different tones. I mean, what are we to believe, that this is a magic xylophone, or something? Ha ha, boy, I really hope somebody got fired for that blunder."
- gojomo 4y agoJust wait until they use deep-network actor-replacement to retroactively recast 'Frank Underwood' in 'House of Cards' to someone less-offensive than Kevin Spacey.
- ThePadawan 4y agoProbably not very familiar to the HN crowd, but in the past, Rooster Teeth has also retroactively edited episodes of the CGI show RWBY. So far, I only recall them doing this to fix animation and editing errors, but it has made viewers on Reddit get a bit Mandela Effect-y (when they thought they saw an animation error which was no longer visible in the updated version on the streaming platform).
- rossdavidh 4y agoJRR Tolkien modified "The Hobbit" to better accord with what he had developed about Gollum and the One Ring for the upcoming "Lord of the Rings". He even retconned the modification, making the original version (published in 1937) the one that Bilbo told people. This is not a new thing.
- aclindsa 4y agoWhat was changed?
- adamesque 4y ago> In the original 1937 edition of "The Hobbit" Gollum was genuinely willing to bet his ring on the riddle game, the deal being that Bilbo would receive a "present" if he won. Gollum in fact was dismayed when he couldn't keep his promise because the ring was missing. He showed Bilbo the way out as an alternative, and they parted courteously. > As the writing of LotR progressed the nature of the Ring changed. No longer a "convenient magical device", it had become an irresistable power object, and Gollum's behavior now seemed inexplicable, indeed, impossible. In the rough drafts of the "Shadow of the Past" chapter Gandalf was made to perform much squirming in an attempt to make it appear credible, not wholly successfully. > Tolkien resolved the difficulty by re-writing the chapter into its present form, in which Gollum had no intention whatsoever of giving up the Ring but rather would show Bilbo the way out if he lost. Also, Gollum was made far more wretched, as befitted one enslaved and tormented by the Ruling Ring. At the same time, however, Bilbo's claim to the Ring was seriously undercut. http://tolkien.cro.net/tolkien/changes.html http://tolkien.cro.net/tolkien/changes.html
- bena 4y agoIn the original version of The Hobbit, the ring is just a magic ring and Gollum willingly bets the ring on the riddle game. When Gollum can't find the ring, he instead offers to lead Bilbo out of the cave. In later versions, the bet was if Gollum wins he eats Bilbo, if Bilbo wins Gollum shows him the way out. It is then presented that Bilbo told everyone the first story although the second was the truth. Which is why the first version appears in The Hobbit as the conceit is that it is an account written by Bilbo or at least sourced from his writings.
- GekkePrutser 4y agoSo what was allegedly changed?? The article doesn't elaborate.
- donkarma 4y agoanother reason to "download your own media", if it happens to be true
- mgdlbp 4y agoBeen going on for a while. r/DataHoarder (of course) post for this news last week - commenters list minute changes they've noticed like reruns being cut for advertisements and copyright: https://old.reddit.com/r/DataHoarder/comments/w38e1z/stranger_things_4_creators_reveal_theyve_secretly/ https://old.reddit.com/r/DataHoarder/comments/w38e1z/strange... In other Netflix shows: - 13 Reasons Why: suicide removed,[1] song replaced (edit: coinciding with condemnation of the show by the artist[2]) - Dark: details changed for continuity with later seasons[3] [1] https://www.movie-censorship.com/report.php?ID=378736 https://www.movie-censorship.com/report.php?ID=378736 [2] https://old.reddit.com/r/CSHFans/comments/8tloai/oh_starving_was_removed_from_13_reasons_why/ https://old.reddit.com/r/CSHFans/comments/8tloai/oh_starving... [3] https://old.reddit.com/r/DarK/comments/ctbsbd/apparently_some_mistakes_have_been_corrected/ https://old.reddit.com/r/DarK/comments/ctbsbd/apparently_som...
- closewith 4y agoProbably the most famous example of change for copyright is Tour Of Duty, which lost almost all its music in syndication, most notable the theme song Paint It, Black by The Rolling Stones.
- freedomben 4y agoIndeed. Super Natural Season 1 has entirely different music on Netflix than it does on DVD due to licensing not covering a streaming clause (there were no streaming services in 2005 when the deal was done and nobody had even thought about such a thing). Season 1 has a kickass classic rock soundtrack on DVD, and with that show the music isn't just luster on top. It's actually an important part of the show/characters.
- Kye 4y agoThe same thing happened with the original Queer As Folk. I assume the reboot at least got a perpetual license.
- spicyusername 4y agoDoes it though? What, exactly, is _dangerous_ about it? Seems like its just something new, no need make such a fuss. Does every headline really need to be so apocalyptic. Like old Marcus said: Time is a sort of river of passing events, and strong is its current; no sooner is a thing brought to sight than it is swept by and another takes its place, and this too will be swept away.
- mywittyname 4y ago> What, exactly, is _dangerous_ about it? Media is going to turn into software, where customers will become beta testers because studios know they can just go back and fix any mistakes. Soon, there will be "digital deluxe" editions which contain extra scenes and you can change characters costumes. Scene-level micro-transactions. /s?
- mixmastamyk 4y agoNeat, was just getting annoyed at the ridiculous getups of Emily in Paris the other day.
- tootie 4y agoIt's not like Stranger Things is a courtroom record or SEC filing. Who cares if they want to retcon a made-up story? I think in the digital age, it should be trivial to keep records of what's changed and let people access the no-longer-canon versions if they are hardcore fans, but let the 99% of casuals just see what you want them to see. Honestly, it could make for some really interesting non-linear storytelling.
- atemerev 4y agoAccording to Buddhism doctrine, thinking of things as permanent while they are ephemeral is the chief reason of suffering. (Addendum: nothing is really permanent).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cabirum 4y agoRelease version 2 of the episode, keep the old one available. [edit] that's how book editions work
- Pakdef 4y agoIs that what they did when they removed the n-word (nigger) from Huckleberry Finn?
- Tea418 4y agoNetflix is able to track when viewers jump off in an episode. I’m wondering whether this information will be used soon to retroactively optimize the story line.
- jmyeet 4y agoThere are claims this is untrue but even if it’s true it’sa non-story and nothing new. Famously there’s Star Wars (as the article mentions) but there are plenty of others. TV shows and movies have removed episodes from circulation (eg Seinfeld), removed scenes (eg 13 Reasons Why), added scenes (pick any Director’s Cut), enhanced scenes, enhanced or changed audio, etc. Content as originally published isn’t untouchable. It’s only really a problem when the changes are bad. I mean fans of Star Wars have been clamoring for a release of the original theatrical version for 25+ years in large part because the changes are worse.
- salawat 4y agoPublished ceases tomean anything if everyone is treating everything as "in production". The point of Publishing is to render an immutable artifact fit for replication and mass distribution.
- enragedcacti 4y agoI think the point of publishing is mass distribution. The fact that it resulted in an immutable artifact and replication is just an outcome of the available technology. Not to mention this happens all the time for "immutable artifacts". I bought a copy of the original "Shrek" book only to find it was massively different from the original and edited down to be more kid friendly. I'm sure there is some way to distinguish it by copyright date or ISBN number if you already have the knowledge the edit exists, but if most consumers don't know is it not basically the same result of memory-holing the original work as time goes on?
- salawat 4y agoIt is not specifically because things like ISBN exist to allow us to differentiate between different publications ( instance of publishing) of the same title. Pretty much all institutional publishing is centered around cuts of a produced work getting a serial number. This mechanism by which further edits on a work happen without being tracked is a grave threat to library science/archival practice. Our very way of organizing information in a way that lets us keep our facts straight as a public is at stake. It should be obvious why this is a bad thing.
- datpuz 4y agoI don't really see a problem with this. It's entertainment - who cares? The real problem is when car and plane companies start treating their customers as free beta testers. Looking at you, Boeing and Tesla...
- tims33 4y agoI sort of love the idea of closing this very minor plot hole around Will's birthday. It definitely takes advantage of streaming and seems like a great use for the super deep fan base. On the other hand, what Lucas did to Star Wars sort of helped with plot around Han Solo and Jabba, but also added gratuitous special effects that didn't change the story. Maybe there can be a standard of what is acceptable for post-release media edits?
- activitypea 4y agoThe damning thing here is that the error was made in the first place. The first three seasons had 25 episodes released over five years, and apparently nobody in the production team for season 4 remembered that there was a birthday scene in one of the episodes. Either nobody working on the most expensive tv show in the world has seen the show, or, more likely, someone higher up said "who cares".
- enragedcacti 4y agoOr more likely an over-worked compositor got the task of Camcorder-ifying 8K footage weeks or days before it needed to get shipped and chose a date at random among the dozens of other creative decisions for that single shot. Those in the review process had a mountain of things to review and these scenes shot 5 years apart didn't click in their minds. In an industry where boom mics, guys wearing jeans in ancient Rome, the entire movie Cats, all make it onscreen then I really don't think we have to ascribe so much thoughtlessness or malice to this one.
- commandlinefan 4y ago> The damning thing here is that the error was made in the first place I actually thought the opposite when I first read it - I wondered "who the hell would have noticed THAT?!"
- 99_00 4y agoThey don't say why it's "dangerous". This is as close as they get. >One day patches might become as commonplace in screen media as they are in video games, and that is a truly worrying precedent for consumers and the integrity of art alike. >Correction: A previous version of this article incorrectly stated that a season one episode of Stranger Things had been edited retroactively to remove a shot of Jonathan photographing Nancy while she was changing. In the long history of narrative art (books, plays, oral), editing, changing, updating is the norm not the exception. And human civilization has survived. So I think we will also survive this.
- Borrible 4y agoSo, there is a another classic/non canon/alternative timeline/dimension/earth no.xxx/whatever/ version of a beloved fictional narrative you can choose to buy or not? Like, say, the Bible?
- gmiller123456 4y agoI'm sure it's not important to the point, but I get a chuckle out of the "retroactively editing" phrase. Pretty all editing is done retroactively. I suppose the only other option is to pause recording live.
- moistly 4y agoStar Trek original has been changed: all exterior shots & many view screen shots were replaced with modern CGI that severely clashes with the set designs. It is obvious and obnoxious, looks ridiculous, and does nothing but harm to the show.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoHuh? Looks much better and does not clash IMHO, they did their homework on the restoration. I welcomed them even though they could probably do even better. Guessing economics and luck of the draw limited the quality to just pretty good instead of excellent. But, still an order of magnitude better than the "dirty bowling balls" look of the original. Perhaps a few lighting tweaks and a rerender at higher resolution could improve it a bit at a low cost.
- olivierduval 4y agoI feel that most comments here miss the spot: the problem is NOT about a "new corrected" edition... but about the REPLACEMENT of the "original edition" by a new one ! It's like rewriting history... So, the problem is not really if it's something mundane or something really important, it's about controling our memories. I have no problem to "update" some movies, only if the original movie is not available anymore. If you can "delete" old versions, what will "truth" mean along the way ? To be more clear: how long since we will change "movies" (and history, and memories) to be conform to the taste of the day ? When you see an old movie, it can be "sexist" for example... but you can explain it wrt to the times when the movie was done. There's some "contextual" informations in every movies... and we may quickly lose this if we start editing
- mixmastamyk 4y agoBut git proponents are always telling us to rewrite history to make it more understandable? :-D
- proc0 4y agoImagine going to a restaurant, ordering something on the menu like steak, fries and salad. Instead of the typical 30 min. waiting time, the dish will now be ready in 10min. they tell you. First, you get the plate with fries, then 10min later the waiter comes by with salad, and then 10min later another plate comes around with the steak. Now imagine the chef forgot some seasoning so they run out and season your plate while you are eating. That is how it feels to buy software nowadays. Software companies, including game companies, are somehow getting away with this because it's not something people are demanding. It is so much easier to release your product half-done and then incrementally fix things with patches and updates. It's a lot harder to release a product close to 100% on launch day... yet we expect that from hardware products most of the time. Why can't software companies spend extra time making sure they have a solid product for launch, and consider things like patches and updates as failures instead of a viable strategy?
- killion 4y agoIt seems odd to not mention how Kanye basically launched a MVP of Life of Pablo and kept iterating on it… https://www.xxlmag.com/kanye-west-the-life-of-pablo-changes/ https://www.xxlmag.com/kanye-west-the-life-of-pablo-changes/ I think it’s a good thing to stop thinking of art as immutable and more of a living thing.
- lostgame 4y agoHe’s done the same thing with DONDA as well, essentially.
- moomin 4y agoI’m loving the irony that an article about the problems with retroactively editing a published work contains a retroactive edit to fix a mistake.
- divbzero 4y agoThere is some precedence for post-publication edits. They are available for many ebooks [1] and have also occurred for prominent films [2]. [1]: https://www.thebookdesigner.com/updating-your-ebook-after-publication/ https://www.thebookdesigner.com/updating-your-ebook-after-pu... [2]: https://gizmodo.com/george-lucas-was-incredibly-specific-about-how-much-he-1845456393 https://gizmodo.com/george-lucas-was-incredibly-specific-abo...
- daniel-cussen 4y ago
- iuor908u3r 4y agocreated this account just to say: i don't think that kind of language is welcome on HN. also, it's very easy to trick yourself into seeing patterns where none exist. consider talking to a mental health professional or a trusted friend about this.
- daniel-cussen 4y ago
- WebbWeaver 4y agoI'm glad people are raising awareness for this sort of thing.
- madrox 4y agoA song I listen to regularly on Spotify once got changed to a slightly different mix, and it totally messed with my brain for a while. I realize in this case it didn't actually happen, but it can and does across the internet regularly. In the cases where I do catch it with no mention of an edit, it causes unsettling dissonance. Maybe I'm starting to see why Twitter doesn't want an edit button.
- Cyberdog 4y agoThis sort of thing has apparently been a huge problem for pro wrestling fans. The WWE owns a massive back catalog of shows and pay-per-views from various wrestling companies over the years, and they have no problem with editing out music they no longer want to license, blurring or bleeping foul language or audience signs which weren't originally censored, completely removing entire segments, etc., such that even though they've made almost every program they've produced available to stream inexpensively, there's still a black market of trading old VHS rips and home video recordings of the same shows since they sometimes contain significant bits of content that are heavily-altered or completely missing from the streaming product. Netflix isn't starting a dangerous trend; merely continuing one that's been quite prevalent in the home video industry.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoOdd article. This strikes me as the same idea as one of the touted benefits of web development, that bug fixes can occur in one place and roll out to everyone. I might be concerned with outright censorship. And maybe Lucas took it a bit far? Suppose productions could get lazy. On the whole however, this does not seem "worrying" to me in the least. Bring on more 'bug fixes' I say.
- jl6 4y agoI think all’s fair as long as they use semantic versioning and make all versions available. Patch release: edit out small cosmetic issues like visible booms or bad audio levels. Minor release: correct plot holes, re-add deleted scenes, re-write cringy dialogue. Major release: soft or hard reboot, major rescore or script rewrite, upgrade to more attractive actors. The latter would clash with use of integers in movie titles to mean sequels, but they’re going out of fashion in favor of colon-delimited sub-titles anyway.
- oniony 4y agoMaybe they can edit out the HTML from the PC in the latest series.
- coding123 4y agoWhen I was younger I was pissed this scene was cut out of the Simpsons for syndication: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SHhsmtWrjEI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SHhsmtWrjEI https://www.reddit.com/r/TheSimpsons/comments/sjlqds/i_told_that_idiot_to_slice_my_sandwich/ https://www.reddit.com/r/TheSimpsons/comments/sjlqds/i_told_...
- evan_ 4y agoThe original pilot episode of Stargate: SG1 had a scene where a woman is stripped against her will by the villain. The camera lingers over her naked body for awhile while a bad puppet alien snake slithers around. The show was originally on premium cable and the network insisted that they include nudity. The producers hated the scene and the fans generally don't like it. The actress has said that she was lied to about how much of her body would be shown in the final cut. It's very tonally inconsistent with the rest of the series. When the episode re-airs on basic cable they show an alternate cut of scene which is much shorter and removes the nudity. This version also appears on some home media releases. I think that's ok, right? It doesn't change the intent of the scene. We still get that the villainous Goa'uld are evil and cruel. Anyone want to argue that no, actually, the weird alien-puppet-hissing-at-a-naked-lady scene HAS to stay in for the sake of artistic purity? Ironically the version that's on Netflix includes the full-frontal scene, and for some reason that affects the rating of the entire series: Each episode is rated M and includes a "Nudity" tag, despite no other episode containing nudity.
- layer8 4y agoI guess the Blu-rays of the first two seasons will go up in value. It’s a drawback of the decline of physical media that it becomes harder to track retroactive changes.
- seanicus 4y agoI find Netflix editing a joke out of Final Destination, which isn't a Netflix film in any way, to be far more egregious. I was surprised they could even do that legally - I assume it was done with the parent studio's permission.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoNews agencies do that now, and they are fighting internet archive at the same time. I wonder what truth will be next century :)
- foogazi 4y ago> Correction: A previous version of this article incorrectly stated that a season one episode of Stranger Things had been edited retroactively to remove a shot of Jonathan photographing Nancy while she was changing. You’d think this would easy to verify for the author - Stopped reading after this
- 2-718-281-828 4y agothat will be necessary to adapt movies to contemporary ideas of politcal correctness.
- tmaly 4y agoDoing it to fiction seems ok. Doing it to news, that is a whole different story.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 4y agoEditing old things is fine, provided they indicate what they did and when. Like a small blurb among the end credits would be fine. Editing is tool that is good or bad only to the extent the motives of the person using it are.