8 ms·
H. R. 4346: The CHIPS and Science Act of 2022
- sudden_dystopia 4y agoCan’t wait to see how much Nancy Pelosi made on her call options.
- Rebelgecko 4y agoHer husband exercised a bunch of NVIDIA options a few weeks ago, although I don't know how much they'll benefit from this.
- khuey 4y agoSeeing as how NVIDIA doesn't actually manufacture semiconductors, it doesn't seem like they stand to benefit at all.
- hickvision 4y ago>Seeing as how NVIDIA doesn't actually manufacture semiconductors They don't fabricate, but they do design quite a lot of them, and are even moving into the ARM CPU arena.
- khuey 4y agoYes, but the bill is subsidies for actual manufacturing and fabrication companies.
- zeruch 4y agohttps://www.capitoltrades.com/ https://www.capitoltrades.com/
- colincooke 4y agoThis bill has a ton of what looks like awesome elements inside it, I encourage folks to peruse the summary to explore a little bit. One part that people here may find exciting is the fusion research funding: > Sec. 10105. Fusion Energy Research. Subsection (a) amends section 307 of the Department of Energy Research and Innovation Act (42 U.S.C. 18645) by authorizing $50,000,000 per year for FY 2023 through FY 2027 for research and development of fusion materials. It extends the authorization for inertial fusion research and development, alternative and enabling concepts, and the milestone-based development program through FY 2027. It authorizes the establishment of at least two national teams to develop conceptual designs and technology roadmaps for a pilot fusion plant, and authorizes $35,000,000 for FY 2023; $50,000,000 for FY 2024; $65,000,000 for FY 2025; $80,000,000 for FY 2026; and $80,000,000 for FY 2027 for these activities. It directs the Secretary to establish a high-performance computation collaborative research program and an associated innovation center in high-performance computing for fusion. It directs the construction of the Material Plasma Exposure Experiment including $21,895,000 for FY 2023 and $3,800,000 for FY 2024 to carry out the project. The subsection also authorizes an upgrade to the Matter in Extreme Conditions endstation at the Linac Coherent Light Source.
- vlovich123 4y agoWhat I’d like is that the teams be rewarded with significant monetary renumeration if they achieve a milestone and curtail the subcontracting disease that permeates government purchasing.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> teams be rewarded with significant monetary renumeration if they achieve a milestone and curtail the subcontracting disease that permeates government purchasing This has a poor track record for basic research and complex technologies. The Ansari XPRIZE recipient’s SpaceShipOne is a prime example.
- modeless 4y agoDARPA Grand Challenges worked well. Created Velodyne Lidar and the team that became Waymo among others.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> DARPA Grand Challenges worked well Agreed. But the dollar amounts were small. And in many cases, every qualifying team received a grant.
- modeless 4y agoI believe most of the grant money was conditional on meeting significant intermediate milestones.
- idiotsecant 4y agoThese sorts of challenges work great for engineering problems where a little bit of money and a lot of sweat is all that is required to figure something out. Fusion research is not that- it needs very large equipment investments for decades for even the most trivial experiments. If we had tried to get to the moon with the same model we'd still be waiting!
- digdugdirk 4y agoThis gem was front and centre: "The language would also re-affirm that the purchase of stocks and dividends are not an eligible use of CHIPS funds as determined by the eligible use of funds already required under the FY21 NDAA." I looked, but couldn't find when this started becoming a thing. How has this not been common boilerplate for any and all government grants/loans/investments?
- BeetleB 4y agoI don't think this will make a difference. Money is fungible. If my operating expenses are $5B, and I'm getting $1B from the CHIPS Act, I'll simply apply that $1B to my operations, giving me $1B from the $5B to use for buybacks. Or more likely, I'll use $0.5B for buybacks and use the remaining $0.5B for operations. This way I get to do more buybacks while still utilizing the government money for accomplishing more than I could without it.
- sitkack 4y agoAny entity taking CHIPS money should be precluded from having any buybacks precisely for this reason.
- singhrac 4y agoAt least amongst a certain subgroup of the US, there's been a lot of backlash against "privatizing profit and socializing losses" (or lemon socialism). Many people pointed fingers at airlines needing a bailout in 2020 even though they had bought back shares for a decade. I guess the US is just very against the idea of equity-based bailouts (i.e. US govt owning a portion of the airlines).
- sremani 4y agoThe CHIPS act is one of the many, US will do more to re-vamp the supply chains. Slowly but surely the Trans-Pacific trade will be replaced with North American Industrial powerhouse - but before that we have to endure a deep recession and a shitty decade of inflation.
- hunglee2 4y agosuperb to see state interventionism like this in the US - for too long the 'free hand' of the market has held sway - turns out it was an ideological blocker for national progress and the long term security of the state.
- jaypeg25 4y agoDisappointing that the SBIR/STTR programs are not reauthorized in this legislation. The program expires in 2 months and certain Republicans seem hell-bent on letting it die.
- clcaev 4y agoWith rules in the last decade to admit hedge fund ownership, the SBIR/STTR program now poorly supports small businesses. It'd be nice to see the program lapse, the funds could better support other activities.
- jaypeg25 4y agoThe funds are already there. It's not an additional amount, but just a % of the overall agencies budget. I also personally don't have an issue with the VC fund ownership rules but my industry (biotech) necessitates it more than maybe others.
- clcaev 4y agoExcept that substantial VC investment is seen as a strong signal by NSF that they should fund.
- deepdriver 4y agoRepublicans are upset that Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (a Democrat) recently stripped provisions from the bill that would prevent its stimulus dollars from flowing towards China: https://freebeacon.com/national-security/schumer-stripped-security-measure-from-china-bill-republicans-are-furious/ https://freebeacon.com/national-security/schumer-stripped-se... Only conservative outlets are reporting this, and they’re not completely reliable. Then again, sometimes they scoop major stories. I don’t know whether this one’s real or overblown. Maybe someone with more info can fill in here.
- ThaDood 4y agoAsking because I would genuinely love to know. But how could they enforce a provision like that in the current globalized economy? China for good and bad is basically the worlds factory and even if a product is made in the US, chances are some of its components or raw materials came from China, so essentially to my untrained perspective seems impossible.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> how could they enforce a provision like that in the current globalized economy? The point of this bill is to begin deconstructing this aspect of the globalized economy.
- ThaDood 4y agoI understand that is the intent, but again, seems unfeasible and more then likely, impossible. So again - how does one enforce this?
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> how does one enforce this? You’re asking how the U.S. government is supposed to enforce its contracts?
- skavi 4y ago
- matt123456789 4y agoThere’s a weird rider in here that requires NASA to launch SLS multiple times per year once crewed launches start. Which is a huge rate increase from that currently planned for Artemis. https://youtu.be/U1j8WJQu_RQ https://youtu.be/U1j8WJQu_RQ Edit - sorry, annual launches.
- ajaimk 4y agoSLS should be cancelled but politicians want to keep the jobs (from the space shuttle program)
- duhast 4y agoWhy SLS should be cancelled?
- engineer_22 4y agoPresumably because it is prohibitively expensive and less capable than competitor spacecraft (SpaceX)
- duhast 4y agoCan you please elaborate on this more? What are the major differences between SLS and SpaceX?
- mrguyorama 4y agoFor starters, I don't think SLS has even gotten off the ground yet, as in literally.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dotnet00 4y agoEdit: This turned into a bit of a rant, so the short version would just be that SLS is too expensive even compared to existing rockets, let alone compared to the bleeding edge of rocket technology. SLS is not reusable, each unit requires several years of lead time to produce (so any mission on it needs to be planned years in advance), the engines were designed for reuse (part of why they're some of the most expensive engines ever built) yet are thrown away after each flight. The upgraded mobile launch tower for the upgraded SLS version has also already cost hundreds of millions without anything being built, and the current launch tower, which would only be used 2-3 times already cost $1B despite being a modified Space Shuttle tower. Furthermore, the SRBs make the vibration environment so bad they have to make screens in Orion flicker in sync with vibrations for them to be readable. Europa Clipper would've cost an extra $1B to make it robust enough for SLS (as Congress was initially pressuring them to do), it was enough justification to just go with a Falcon Heavy instead. It's extremely telling that these orders for SLS aren't coming from NASA requiring them for certain missions, but rather Congress legislating that NASA must use SLS. For example, a few months ago Congress was trying to require that from 2030 onwards, NASA fly SLS for cargo at least once a year. However, even ignoring Starship for now, SLS is $2B per launch and is extremely unlikely to have that drop by much. The upgraded version is expected to be able to carry ~130t to Low Earth Orbit. Falcon Heavy can carry 63t to LEO at a cost of $90M per launch. On the extremely pessimistic end of price estimates for Vulcan Centaur, it can do 27t to LEO for $200M. Thus it's much cheaper to do multiple flights of either of the two than to do a single SLS launch. Then on top of that, Orion itself is too heavy to get to the surface of the Moon and back anyway and a Lunar variant of Starship was the only lander which best met the requirements and which NASA could afford, so the program still relies on Starship being successful. Starship has pretty much none of the issues of SLS, it's much cheaper (it'd honestly be hard for any rocket to be as expensive as SLS is turning out to be), reusable, doesn't have the vibration issues of SLS by virtue of being fully liquid fueled (although this also isn't an issue on Vulcan Centaur, which does use some small SRBs) and is meant to refuel in space, significantly expanding its capabilities. SLS is in a bad spot compared to even other non-SpaceX rockets owing to the potential of in-space refueling. Congressman Shelby had previously banned mention of 'depot' in relation to space exploration (threatening to outright cancel the entire space technology program if they were brought up) because of how bad they would be for SLS's future. ULA had also done a study and proposal for an orbital fuel depot in 2011, due to which Boeing tried to get the physicist who was leading the project fired because of the risk to SLS. As a result, Vulcan Centaur's upper stage is effectively the same stage as was proposed in 2011 but without refueling. Comically the word depot was even censored out in NASA's final statement on the selection of Starship for the HLS contract. To refer back to the price comparison, upgraded SLS can do 48t to the Moon. But if you can refuel in LEO, you have the option of launching up to 63t with Falcon Heavy or 45t with New Glenn, then launching a transfer stage and fueling it up with another launch or two, allowing you to get the Lunar payload capability of SLS at close to a tenth of the cost. Private companies can see that the approach of the gigantic expensive one-time use rocket is not going to scale up, which is why pretty much every company is working on reuse and mission extension capabilities like orbital refueling.
- idiotsecant 4y agoThere is a Division C 'SUPPLEMENTAL APPROPRIATIONS TO ADDRESS THREATS TO THE SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES' rider in there - sort of strange. They allocate $10.3M to increase the security of the supreme court. Doesn't seem to have anything to do with the subject of the bill.
- kmeisthax 4y agoI bet you someone from the red states saw that one guy trying to off Kavagnaugh and said they'd only sign on to CHIPS in exchange for better security funding for SCOTUS. The majority gets their chip fab funding and the holdout rep gets to brag about protecting SCOTUS from "liberal extremists" or whatever. This is a trade. One thing people misunderstand about Congress is that it is primarily a negotiating body. That's why bills have so many unrelated provisions in them - these are not just laws, they are contracts between lawmakers. International treaties work the same way, too. Merely getting program Y or Z into a bill containing program X means that it's a package deal now. Either it all passes or it all fails, and the reps that pushed for Y or Z now have to vote for X, too. (This is vaguely related to the reason why the line-item veto is unconstitutional. If you could just sign X while vetoing Y and Z, that'd be like striking the data caps out of your cable contract and then suing Comcast for breach of a contract they never signed.)
- KerrAvon 4y agoYes, but one correction to your red states thing: it's not a red vs blue thing -- the Democrats in charge wanted that in the bill, for better or worse. (Personally, I think security should be out of pocket for the justices. They have the money! They have a lifetime job even if their wives participate in treason! AOC gets worse shit and less protection on a daily basis, but by all means let's armor up the people doing their best to move us to a fascist theocracy.)
- eneumann 4y agoSo the federal government wants to give these chip companies a bunch of money as long as they pinky promise to uphold the requirements of the bargain? Why does this situation sound familiar... We should, at the very least, get some ownership of these companies in return for our investment, like any other private investor might. I'm all for investing in these sorts of programs to bring manufacturing back to the US, but not like this.
- undersuit 4y agoI want more than shares. Shares are meaningless when the rest of the shareholders vote to close the factories anyways when the profitable tax breaks end. Partial ownership of the physical facilities and a say in the conditions therein then they can have the money.
- treasurebots 4y agoThe government has an implicit return on investment for the entire economy, through the power to levy taxes. Why should the government own stock in specific companies? The only likely outcome for that route is the government playing favorites even more so than at present
- eneumann 4y agoWhy should tax dollars be sent to a private company without anything but a promise in exchange? The promise of "jobs" isn't enough, as evidenced by just about every single other time that these programs (including the tax cuts) happen. Further, how are we going to hold these companies accountable for their promise? What comes to mind immediately is when we gave telecoms a bunch of wire up rural America, and they purchased and consolidated the cell providers instead. If we just write them a check, they'll do whatever they want with it. They need to be held accountable, and ownership percentage is a way to do that. Alternatively, the gov could take this money, start up a corporation of their own, and make their own fab. The language in part of this bill is that they are trying to ensure that older tech and DoD stuff is made in house. So let's make it in house. We don't necessarily need to say "we're buying intel or nvidia", but we can make the money available to any company in exchange for the ownership percentage. That eliminates the "playing favorites" issue, I would think.
- systemvoltage 4y agoHow come there is a huge divide in the House [1] but the Senate passed it with unanimous vote (all 100 senators voted Yes). [1] https://www.govtrack.us/congress/votes/117-2021/h239 https://www.govtrack.us/congress/votes/117-2021/h239 What's going on?
- bubblethink 4y agoThis is the stripped down version of the USICA/Competes act that has been languishing for the last year and a bit. The republicans on the house side did not support those prior bills either, so presumably that continues here. The senate was lukewarm with the prior bills whereas they support this stripped down version better.
- Cipater 4y agoThe House is incredibly partisan and there seems to be a strategy of bloc voting. It would be interesting to see a tabulation of the voting patterns on Dem-sponsored bills vs Rep-sponsored ones.
- dehrmann 4y agoUgh. This wouldn't have done anything for the current (but almost over) chip shortage because it doesn't pay chip makers to maintain excess capacity. I agree that there are risks with TSMC and China, but TSMC factories in any western-allied country (Japan, Mexico, Germany) would meet the strategic goals. This is just political grandstanding because it's easy to sell the idea that if we build it here, there won't be a shortage, and it makes it look like politicians are doing something before an election.
- undersuit 4y agoThe makes me angry. We're capitalist to a fault as a country. This bill just further entrenches the US government as a consumer. If this actually was critical infrastructure there should be joint or full ownership of chip foundries by the US. No, this bill just allows the companies to pocket a bunch of money, release some press articles, and a few years after the fabs are built they'll be shutdown by the companies for profit reasons and chips production will shift back to being fully produced overseas by lower paid workers. Cue the next supply crunch in 20-40 years with us giving the industry even more money.
- godelmachine 4y agoMeanwhile in another corner of the world , a city called Pune is making similar efforts albeit on a much smaller scale ($22 Bn) - https://www.livemint.com/news/india/vedanta-group-foxconn-to-invest-rs-1-6-lakh-crore-in-maharashtra/amp-11658852054164.html https://www.livemint.com/news/india/vedanta-group-foxconn-to...