8 ms·
‘Zoe’ becomes the world’s first named heat wave
- michaelwilson 4y agoWas "Manchin" taken? Seriously, they should use this mechanism to call out legislators that refuse to act on client, or, even worse, block client action. They should also include international figures - "Heat Wave Bolsonaro" has a nice ring to it.
- headsoup 4y agoThis is just silly. Coming up next, names for cold snaps, tide surges, landslides and solar flares. Followed by name diversity arguments for them all. I'm not dismissing the severity of these events, but this just reeks of headline clickbait marketing material.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hgazx 4y ago>Coming up next, names for cold snaps, tide surges, landslides and solar flares. I assume that heat waves are now named by the mass media to give undeserved importance to the topic of global warming.
- LadyCailin 4y agoSo I assume then that you prefer to refer to it as the severe weather system that hit 29.8915381, -90.052772 in 2005?
- jollybean 4y agoNo, it's a good idea both pragmatically and from a communications perspective. Remember Hurricane Katrina? Names help. Specifically now that we have a material climate change problem, it helps to give a name to the problem. Snarkily, I vote for the first one to be 'Chevy Suburban'.
- kmlx 4y ago> Remember Hurricane Katrina? Names help. we remember it because of the destruction, not because of the name. you could’ve called it august 05 hurricane and it would be the same thing. e.g. 9-11
- powerhour 4y agoThe fact that we popularly call it "9-11" and not "9-11-2001" supports the idea that nicknames help, or are at least natural.
- jollybean 4y agoNo, sorry, this is wrong. 9-11 works because the tragedy was 'massive' (the biggest attack since pearl harbour and most civilian deaths ever). Any name applied to 9-11 would have 'stuck'. Moreover, 9-11 caught on at least in part because 911 is 'emergency' number in North America. Hurricane Katrina comes nowhere near that threshold. Now - it may have been giving a populist name, such as 'The Orleans Breach' or something instead of an official name. But the names really do help us remember and contextualize.
- otikik 4y agoWe already use names for tropical storms and hurricanes. It’s easier to talk about “Zoe” than to talk about “the third heatwave” or “the 23rd of October heatwave”. I am fine with it.
- throwaway0a5e 4y agoThe government and government-adjacent institutions classify and quantify these things are competing with each other for relevance, reach, budget, etc. so there's a huge incentive to scream "tonight at 11: DOOOOOOM". The media (weather included) is competing for eyeball*hours so of course they do stuff like this too. A lot of people are gonna look real stupid in 10-20yr when it becomes clear in hindsight that the solution to societal alarm fatigue was not to just increase the volume. (And I'm gonna head off the inevitable snarky comments by reminding everyone that alarm fatigue caused by alarms rightfully going off is still alarm fatigue.) People have no problem remembering the Hurricane of '38. This naming stuff is all theater. Playing PR games so you can have .05% more "resonates with the public" or whatever dumb KPI you're chasing this quarter isn't gonna slow or mitigate global warming. But it will help you be seen "doing something" which appears to matter a lot to a lot of people.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Zenst 4y agoAgreed, it just normalises them by giving them cute names.
- drcode 4y agoI'll take the named heatwaves if they would just stop doing APOCALYPSE TORNADO EMERGENCY BREAKING NEWS every time there's a mild thunderstorm here in Chicago
- somesomething 4y agoIs there a benefit to naming weather events? I'm not able to read the entire article because of paywall, so I'm not sure if it discusses this.
- ianhawes 4y agoAnecdotally, in the US we name tropical storms and hurricanes. There have been cases in the past where storms that were just as severe that did not originate in the Atlantic were never named and caused significant damage. There was a push several years ago by popular weather broadcast channels (that effectively re-package and re-sell National Weather Service data and forecasts) to begin naming winter storms in the same fashion as hurricanes. The NWS put out a strong warning to their own forecasters to NOT use those names in official materials. Then there is the trend by news media to replace “hurricane” with “Superstorm” when a storm causes a particularly high dollar amount of damage but may not have maintained hurricane force winds or simply because it hit a densely populated area. The definition of superstorm precludes any other named meteorological event such as a hurricane. But superstorm sounds better than hurricane.
- tumetab1 4y agoIt facilitates communication which is specially important when discussing wheater events that can cause harm. Example: "The Zoe heatwave is comming" "The Zoe heatwave has increased in severity" "Local Officials decided to restrict forest activies due to Zoe heatwave" By glance, or just reading titles, an average person knows about the danger and it's incomming. It's harder to get that information on unnamed weather phenomems. Example: "A heatwave is comming" "A heatwave is worse than expected" "Local Officials decided to restrict forest activies due to incoming heatwave" NOAA info on related subject https://oceanservice.noaa.gov/facts/storm-names.html https://oceanservice.noaa.gov/facts/storm-names.html
- dadoum 4y agoWhat about "ExxonMobil 1" as name ? I think it would be clearer and be more impactful.
- melling 4y agoWhy do we want to blame the oil companies? So the bad guy isn’t consumers? We need 100 million barrels of oil a day! Bottled war, plastic containers for takeout food, SUVs, … 40% of global electricity is from coal. That’s much worse than oil. We burn more coal than ever. https://www.statista.com/statistics/265507/global-coal-consumption-in-oil-equivalent/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/265507/global-coal-consu... Let’s all watch Carl Sagan from 1985 and figure out how to solve this multi-generational problem. https://youtu.be/Wp-WiNXH6hI https://youtu.be/Wp-WiNXH6hI He warned us not to use coal. Did we listen? At the very least, we can buy ourselves a couple extra decades. Update: Got immediately downvoted so clearly I can’t respond. Now I’m going to optimize my website so it uses less electricity then blog about which computer language uses less electricity. Climate change is a form of bike shedding. We talk about a bunch of irrelevant ideas rather than addressing the real issues. But hey, oil companies knew and didn’t tell us what we already knew. We’re off the hook! Let’s keep sending climate change deniers to Washington: https://www.americanprogress.org/article/climate-deniers-117th-congress/ https://www.americanprogress.org/article/climate-deniers-117...
- slothtrop 4y agoSo, oil and coal then. Unless you had a different point.
- AyyWS 4y agoPretty sure the point was that we should take personal responsibility for our actions.
- sputr 4y agoResponsibility should be placed where it can actually change something. Yes, when dealing with things in our own lives it's usually best to go with "at your own feet", not mater who the actors are, since the only person whose actions you can change are your own. But as far as climate goes, we, the individuals (who happen to not be rich at the moment) have no power to change anything. So taking personal responsibility will change nothing. Well, actually, people taking personal responsibility for the climate have possibly made it worse by redirecting the attention to themselves.
- ksherlock 4y agoMore accessible copy: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/zoe-becomes-the-worlds-first-named-heat-wave/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/zoe-becomes-the-w...
- sbmassey 4y agoThey should give the Covid variants relatable human names too
- abduhl 4y agoWe tried but the WHO didn’t like calling it the Xi variant for some reason.
- gdsdfe 4y agoFor those saying it's silly and what's the point... Which one do you remember hurricane Katrina or the hurricane of 2005 ?!
- djKianoosh 4y agohurricane 2017 Gamma or 2008 Epsilon are memorable enough and gender neutral in any language.
- gdsdfe 4y agoThat's just details the question is whether to name such events or not
- foobarian 4y agoIf my daughter was named Katrina or Zoe I would be very very upset. This is just not OK.
- gdsdfe 4y agoThat's very silly... So when you name you're daughter you go over the database of hurricanes, serial killers, etc. To avoid using that name ?!
- kortex 4y agoI bet you remember Delta and Omicron. They need not be human names.
- Izkata 4y agoThis actress begs to differ: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delta_Burke https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delta_Burke
- yucky 4y agoWhich heatwave killed 1,800 people and caused $125 billion in damage?
- defrost 4y agoThis originates with: > proMETEO Seville is a collaboration between the City of Seville; Arsht-Rock’s Extreme Heat Resilience Alliance (EHRA) Science Advisory Panel—comprising leading climatologists, social and behavioral scientists, and public health and disaster relief experts—AEMET; the University of Sevilla; Pablo de Olavide University; the Carlos III Institute; the Spanish Office for Climate Change; and El Día Después. [1] https://onebillionresilient.org/2022/07/25/heat-wave-zoe-seville-becomes-first-city-in-the-world-to-officially-name-a-heat-wave/ https://onebillionresilient.org/2022/07/25/heat-wave-zoe-sev... [2] https://prometeosevilla.com/en/inicio-english/ https://prometeosevilla.com/en/inicio-english/
- sp332 4y agoI thought we were moving away from naming storms and so on because people take their prejudices about people and apply them to the weather events. E.g. people take hurricanes named after women less seriously and are less prepared.
- pcurve 4y agoWow, you're right. Scary. https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/article/why-have-female-hurricanes-killed-more-people-than-male-ones https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/article/why-have-...
- SideburnsOfDoom 4y ago> I thought we were moving away from naming storms The UK is moving towards naming winter storms. A reason for this is this, is that the storm that hit Scotland in December 2011 was not referred to by a name, so the Scots come up with an "unofficial" name for it anyway: "Hurricane Bawbag". (1) You can find out for yourself what "Bawbag" is Scottish for, but using official names was seen as preferable. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hurricane_Bawbag https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hurricane_Bawbag
- _8j50 4y agoAnswer is simple: don't use people names. "Zetta" sounds similar but not a person name.
- laerus 4y ago"Zoe" means "life" in Greek so this must be some kind of irony.
- jl6 4y agoI actually think the Ubuntu naming scheme would be perfect for weather events. You get a date-based numbering scheme for official/catalog use, and a cute name for the media. 22.07 Zesty Zoe.
- daveslash 4y agoBoiling Billy, Firey Felix, Hot Hannah, Incandescent Ivan, Roasting Robert, Sweltry Stephen.... [Edit: spelling]
- pvaldes 4y agoA missed opportunity to call it Sandy (or, even better, Mercury)
- rvnx 4y agoThe problem is clearly overpopulation. If there were 70M people worldwide, then pollution would largely be under control, and there would be enough space, natural resources and places with comfortable weather for people to not do wars and to not have to worry about climate so much.
- kortex 4y agoEngineering solution: generate a system of valid commonly-pronounceable phonotactics (rules like consonant-vowel-consonant is an allowed syllable). Banlist any name with >N people bearing that name (there's always gonna be outliers/collisions/future names). With Toki Pona's inventory (mnptkswljaeiou), limited phonotactics (CV), and 3 syllables you get about 45 unique syllables, or 91,125 words. Add more syllables or phonotactics as needed. Affix the year - "Kalada-22". Add filters (profanity, too close to certain names, etc) as needed, you have overhead. Regenerate/reuse yearly unless retired. That should be easily enough to name every hurricane, heat wave, flash flood, tornado, pandemic, rat infestation, and mercury retrograde, while being pronounceable, and memorable enough if it becomes newsworthy.
- Proven 4y ago
- Pakdef 4y agoThey should name them like viruses...