5 ms·
I love Signal, and I think you're spot on about what they did. But I've been having a difficult time with the direction Signal is currently going. It seems like
by godelski 4y ago
I love Signal, and I think you're spot on about what they did. But I've been having a difficult time with the direction Signal is currently going. It seems like they are just trying to create feature parity with WA and Telegram. Which, honestly they are pretty near that already and the differences aren't worthwhile. Worse, they'll always be playing catch-up, because those companies have 100-1000x the number of developers. Instead, I think Signal needs to do what it does best: protecting users. I don't think this needs decentralization, although I saw a user post a feature request that was about semi-decentralization/meshing and that seemed pretty useful.[0] If Signal can bring anonymity and censorship mitigation to the public that really gives us the full Monty. That's really what I want to see from Signal. It fits their mission and keeps their edge.
The best thing Signal has done is made everyone else adopt E2EE. Signal shouldn't be playing catch-up, they should be pushing others to follow suit. Companies like Meta say that they need data to protect users but Signal ,,demonstrates'' that this is not necessary. So continue in this direction. I know many want to just keep Signal as it is (Signal purists) but Moxie is right. The ecosystem is moving. Staying still will just get you killed.
[0] https://community.signalusers.org/t/signal-airdrop/37402 https://community.signalusers.org/t/signal-airdrop/37402
- OJFord 4y agoBut in order to do 'bring privacy to masses', don't you think they need familiar features? Otherwise it's just 'oh that weird crypto privacy nerd chat app' that the masses don't want to use.
- godelski 4y agoWhat "familiar features" is Signal missing? Honest question. It has reactions, groups, stickers (wish they linked signalstickers.org so you can get more from inside the app), replies, etc. I don't see anything that WA or iMessage has that Signal doesn't. I know WA has statuses, but every time I look at it none of my friends have posted one. Telegram has channels, but do we really need that? I honestly don't know what these features are. The only thing I hear from normal people is stickers and "but none of my friends are there." This is a genuine question because I can't figure out what others have that Signal doesn't.
- lavela 4y agoTelegram has a bot API that is great. I use it for a lot of Projects. Used to be a niche feature I guess, but nowadays I see a LOT of people using some bot for some specific feature.
- izacus 4y agoFor starters, others don't lose all your messages if your phone breaks and allow you to actually send messages from desktop and tablet platforms without constantly breaking and losing data. The "backup" system Signal has is a joke for everyone outside the paranoid community. Every messaging platform has a single chance of losing users data before they switch away. Signal does it constantly.
- px43 4y agoYou should be setting a two-week auto-delete for all your messages anyway. Archive and backup features in other apps are a massive privacy hole. These chats are supposed to be ephemeral, if you want long lasting comms that you can search through later, use email. The idea of any of my contacts logging every message I ever sent to them, and backing them up in clear text on whatever dumb cloud provider they're using this week, is a pretty scary one.
- izacus 4y agoPlease stop telling me and my family what to do with our private messages. If you want to destroy them immediately, that's fine. But stop demanding that Signal destroys pictures and messages my grandmother cares about without her own input. This arrogance is the worst cancer on "privacy" software. Essence of privacy is _control_ over data, not destruction.
- kitsunesoba 4y agoNot sure I agree with this. The problem is I don’t know what I’ll need later until I need it… old messages from months or years ago that I never expected to need have saved me multiple times for a variety of reasons by now. It’s also awkward to try to herd a conversation partner from chat to email at some arbitrary point when you think the conversation is veering in a direction where preservation is important.
- croes 4y agoIsn't telegram also from a crypto nerd
- Aeolun 4y agoHmm, it’s not that hard to get people to use it. It’s got free stickers!
- cassepipe 4y agoI guess it's great but gosh I hate stickers, to me they are over-engineered emojis.
- baxuz 4y agoThe only feature parity I want is synced chat logs and not being tied to a phone number. And Signal doesn't support it.
- shmel 4y ago>>It seems like they are just trying to create feature parity with WA and Telegram. Which, honestly they are pretty near that already and the differences aren't worthwhile. Yeah, I don't know about that. I started using Signal about 6 years ago, I think. I remember back in the day there was a stable native Telegram desktop client that just worked (keeps working without single issue for years) and web WA client that just worked if the phone is online (mildly annoying, but very rarely a problem). Over time Signal developed an Electron-based client that annoyed me every time I use it. It requires relinking to the phone, it can't decrypt messages read from mobile, it can't send messages, it can send them, but the other party can't read them. I try it again every few months hoping that they fix these problems. Instead I get stickers and reactions =/ Yeah, I get it, multi-client encryption is hard, but WA seems to solve it using the same protocol. What I experience with Signal desktop client reminds me of Jabber OTP client compatibility issues 10 years ago. I almost stopped using Signal despite shiny E2EE. 90% of my texting is from desktop. I need it to work reliably. I don't care about stickers and reactions.
- brewdad 4y ago> Over time Signal developed an Electron-based client that annoyed me every time I use it. It requires relinking to the phone, it can't decrypt messages read from mobile, it can't send messages, it can send them, but the other party can't read them. While I agree the app is a resource hog for what it is, I haven't ever had to relink my phone after the first time unless I reinstalled the app or got a new phone (duh). As for unreadable messages, I use Signal daily and have never had that issue once. I have had that issue multiple times using Whatsapp however.
- codethief 4y ago>>It seems like they are just trying to create feature parity with WA and Telegram. > Yeah, I don't know about that. […] What I experience with Signal desktop client reminds me of Jabber OTP client compatibility issues 10 years ago. Like for the sibling commentator, the desktop client has been working for me largely flawlessly. Sure, doing backups on the desktop (and restoring them) would be nice, and no longer needing a phone number or needing to link it to a phone would be even nicer. Meanwhile, though, WhatsApp doesn't even have a desktop client to begin with and their web UI is still mediocre and unsafe. And let's not even speak about E2E encryption (or the general state of security) in Telegram. So yes, I would argue most of Signal's features are more than on par with WhatsApp and Telegram.