4 ms·
Electric cars could totally be designed to be re-ignite-proof. For example, you'd have the battery pack detect a breach - for example through a lack of pressur
by londons_explore 4y ago
Electric cars could totally be designed to be re-ignite-proof.
For example, you'd have the battery pack detect a breach - for example through a lack of pressurised coolant.
That would then trigger each battery cell to have a PTC resistor discharge it - that could be entirely mechanical.
The PTC resistors would discharge the battery in a few hours, maintaining the battery temperature at say 120C. As water is doused onto the battery, it will boil off.
As soon as the battery temperature cools below 120C, then every cell is guaranteed to be discharged.
- kayodelycaon 4y agoHow well do these safety feature survive 2,000+ºF fire burning next to them?
- dymk 4y agothere’s a period of time between normal operation and 2000 degree fire where this could be detected
- DoingIsLearning 4y agoPCB solder will reflow at about 240°C or 470°F so provided you have a thermal resistant container around the pcb it will probably outlive the fire long enough to fail-safe, these kind of hardware mitigations will probably latch with a latency in the microseconds scale.
- marcosdumay 4y agoBadly. How well does gasoline containers survive it? If you have a 2000°F fire, you probably have buildings collapsing and a lot of fire everywhere surrounding it. As long as things do not explode, you can't make it much worse by any action. And exploding is something the batteries don't do.
- KaiserPro 4y agoSo in a thermal event, where integrity of the coolant is compromised, you want to dump more heat into the system? Its not just the electrical issues at play, its the fact that hot battery fluid burns spontaneously with exposure to air (I suspect also water, but I'm less sure about that)
- londons_explore 4y agoA PTC resistor only dumps heat if the system isn't already hot. PTC resistors can be designed which will survive a car fire. It's a good way to ensure that the only way the system can appear safe (ie. cold) is when all batteries are discharged, therefore preventing re-ignition. Obviously you could also have an external energy dump for that purpose (for example power up the cars 5 kw resistive heater for 10 hours), but that's both far slower than boiling water at scale, and won't work after major damage which is likely after a car fire.
- KennyBlanken 4y ago> The PTC resistors would discharge the battery in a few hours, maintaining the battery temperature at say 120C Thermal runaway in lithium ion batteries starts at 100C and is a significant danger at 60C. Maybe learn more about subjects before you come up with all these opinions on how things should be done.
- londons_explore 4y agoOnly in unpressurized cans. Pressurized sealed cells can have much higher thermal range, which is why nearly all EV manufacturers use them. For example, even DEC can be made safe to 175C at 3 bar[1]. 3 bar isn't a lot for a liquid filled metal can. [1]: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/a/ae/Vapour_pressure_diethyl_carbonate.svg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/a/ae/Vapour_p... Obviously they can still suffer thermal runaway, but it happens at much higher temperatures.