3 ms·
Good write up on a very disturbing case of blatant academic fraud. Some of the methods mentioned that were used to discover it are pretty simple - prior compre
by lazide 4y ago
Good write up on a very disturbing case of blatant academic fraud.
Some of the methods mentioned that were used to discover it are pretty simple - prior compression artifacts showing borders around sub areas of a large graph, indicating cutting and pasting of elements, etc.
What I don’t get, is why the underlying data doesn’t get included and any graphs just generated from that? Why have an actual embedded image and that’s all good?
- sooheon 4y agoWestern blots are analog -- the captured image is the underlying data.
- gspr 4y agoCould one imagine imagining equipment cryptographically signing the images they spit out? (Sorry if this is a super naive HN-esque comment – the topic is far outside my field, and I don't mean to actually suggest this as a solution, I'm just curious.)
- _Wintermute 4y agoThat's definitely possible. These sort of images are typically re-arranged to fit nicely in a figure for publication. It's now more common that any figure that has a western blot within it, you also have to provide the raw unaltered image. Though this wasn't standard practice at the time. As someone in the field, western blots are terrible for a number of reasons. Even if you get nice bands and you're honest about what you show. The companies that make the antibodies for these commonly sell people duds that will bind to a number of unknown things, and people blindly trust that since the website said it's specific for protein-XYZ, that's what they're measuring.
- searine 4y agoThis type of data is 'old school' molecular biology. Creating those blots is a grind. It takes hundreds of hours to set up those experiments and they often don't work, or go wrong, and you have to do it all over again. The people who are good at making these are usually the people who aren't really up to date with the whole 'computers' thing. Yes, there would a hundred ways to easily verify the provenance of data from an image of a blot all the way to publication. However, this area of research is very slow to incorporate the latest computer tech.
- pmyteh 4y ago[Be aware that your comments appear to be default-dead. I've vouched for this one, but you may want to contact dang to ask for your account to be unflagged: I can't see anything objectionable in your post history so it's probably a false-positive].
- searine 4y agoThanks for letting me know. Mods couldn't figure out why either and fixed it.
- pcrh 4y agoUnfortunately, it seems that in this case it is the author of the article published by Science (Schrag) who is remiss and has written a poorly-researched article. See the link I provided elsewhere in this thread.