5 ms·
This is a really good idea for people who are thoughtful and genuinely want to learn the truth. There problems with it in practice. Some people have made their
by roenxi 4y ago
This is a really good idea for people who are thoughtful and genuinely want to learn the truth. There problems with it in practice.
Some people have made their political ideology the foundation that they build their ego on. Any disagreement is intolerable. Others are not thoughtful enough to understand that there can be genuine disagreement in the world of both thought and action which needs to be tolerated.
These people will ruin any concept of starmanning that catches hold by using it as a passive-aggressive cudgel ("I'm sure you are a good person and therefore you will immediately cease your opposition and accept my arguments!", "I'm sure you want to be a good person and therefore can't really believe these things you are saying, which are only for bad people!", "Why are you resisting when I'm starmanning you, you must be Hitler 2.0").
But without labelling it, I do endorse the technique. Almost everyone wants the world to get better.
- synu 4y agoUnfortunately this is true, even with non-political topics. Some people will treat sincere questions trying to understand their point of view as attacks and keep escalating/trying to make it personal. In the end there isn’t a lot you can do about it, except learn when to cut bait and move on. I agree with you that it’s still worth trying.
- throwaway0asd 4y agoJust walk away. Unless you are in politics or sales you aren’t forced to convince stupid people of anything. Don’t cast pearls before swine.
- kgwxd 4y agoWhen swine have the ability to vote, everyone is in politics regardless if they want to be or not. Just ignoring them has major consequences.
- JasserInicide 4y agoNah, fuck this "everything is politics" attitude. Politics is everywhere because you make it everywhere. It's a big part of the reason why discourse is as fucked up as it is. Every discussion/encounter has to be won/lost based on your ideology.
- ParetoOptimal 4y agoViewing everything as win-loss is bad, but politics does inform or creep into the majority of things. Especially if you aren't part of the majority.
- synu 4y agoThe only reason I don't walk away instantly is that very occasionally someone does engage in good faith and it's an opportunity for me and maybe them to learn something, and that makes the rest (for the most part) worthwhile.
- haswell 4y agoThe collective consciousness of a society only changes through open dialogue. Leaving it up to the politicians is a good way for such dialogue to be inherently political. There are plenty of issues of basic human decency that can only be changed by talking to the people around you. Stopping entirely can only entrench people in their beliefs and validates the narrative that there are “sides”, and that the other side doesn’t listen. Referring to an entire group of people as swine is case in point. Politicians have their place, but so too the common conversation on the street.
- koheripbal 4y agoThis is why companies need a HR hiring process that filters out candidates who haven't yet developed the level of maturity needed to listen to contrary perspectives without taking such conversations emotionally. Such unfiltered workplaces inevitably become toxic.
- JasserInicide 4y agoI understand what you're saying, but it's ironic considering that espousing anything but leftist viewpoints in most tech companies today will instantly brand you as a hostile.
- Elinvynia 4y agoWhat viewpoints are you trying to share that aren't acceptable in most tech companies?
- rajin444 4y agoHiring candidates on race/sex and not ability is racist and harmful to building a better society.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- koheripbal 4y agoThose (most) companies do not filter out immature people who are incapable of hearing contrary opinions. It's a very common problem, particularly in tech, which has a very young employee base.
- JadeNB 4y ago> This is why companies need a HR hiring process that filters out candidates who haven't yet developed the level of maturity needed to listen to contrary perspectives without taking such conversations emotionally. The problem is that listening is a lot less flashy and glamorous than violent self-promotion. As long as the people who are in positions of power have got there by violent self-promotion, they will, from intentional or unintentional self-interest, bias the hiring process towards people like them.
- mst 4y agoThe other thing I've found is that in those cases, the toxicity of their reaction will (at least slightly) move the opinions of at least some people watching the conversation. So I tend to cut bait and move on at the point where it starts to upset me rather than the point at which the conversation itself is obviously futile. However my tolerance before I start to actually be upset is relatively high - most people would be significantly better served by bailing out earlier and I've seen too many people burning out of having such conversations entirely because of not doing that and I miss their perspective so would prefer they set boundaries that work for them. (in case you can't tell, I like being covering fire and it very definitely earns me more friends I am glad to have than enemies I would have preferred not to have)
- PragmaticPulp 4y ago> But without labelling it, I do endorse the technique. Almost everyone wants the world to get better. It is interesting to see how labeling a technique like this and assigning it a sense of moral superiority seems to invite the exact abuse you describe. I’ve noticed this with the recent popularity of “steelmanning”; Many of the explicitly-labeled steelman arguments I’ve read lately are actually just strawman arguments, but the author tries to preempt criticism by labeling it a steelman and pretending it is the most robust counter argument that could exist. Often these false steelman arguments arise when the author doesn’t understand the topic as well as they think they do but they believe that “steelmanning” automatically makes them an expert on the counter arguments.
- panarky 4y agoSteelmanning is when your interlocutor agrees with your description of their argument.
- I_complete_me 4y agoWhat a beautifully concise definition.
- roenxi 4y agoIf it isn't labelled explicitly, by and large the cudgel people can't tell when it is happening, can't mimic it & don't know how to attack. The reason they cudgel is because they can't use empathy - if they could they would, it is a more powerful tool. Plus the cudgel hurts both parties. It sounds stupid, but I believe it. The flow of a lot of arguments make sense if you assume neither side understands practical empathy (not a comment on objectives, just they can't hold 2x perspectives in mind at once so a lot of the conversation is invisible to them).
- t-3 4y agoI've become convinced that (most?) people only possess "visual empathy" - that is, they can only empathize with what they can see. I think it explains why arguments on the internet often seem to have manipulative strawmanning sociopaths on both sides.
- cupofpython 4y agoI have inadvertently been "starman"-ing people my entire life. I usually refer to it as "benefit of the doubt". I have not encountered any problems with it in practice other than that sometimes I end up talking in circles when the other person doesnt really have a strong central point to their argument (or it is just not clicking for me no matter how hard I try to understand) I think if such practices became mainstream, then people would begin to realize the difficulties involved in having a coherent conversation about a point of disagreement. The passive-aggressive cudgels you mention would fall flat because it is instantly noticeable as not fitting the necessary patterns for coherent conversation. No one needs to accept or reject the other. the point of an argument is to educate each other, answer questions, and allow each other to fit both opinions into their own world view (ex. what are the limits / specifics to your belief?). Maybe someone changes their mind during that conversation, maybe they dont. maybe someone needs to let the new information ferment in their minds and life for a bit before it clicks. that is part of giving someone benefit of the doubt maybe you are talking to someone who is venting, or in the middle of a mental episode (i mean that literally, not derogatorily), or was unfortunately born a narcissistic manipulator and cant help themselves. It doesnt matter, they cannot "win" the conversation - no one can - and the more people that realize this truth about conversations in general, the better the world will become
- laserlight 4y ago> I have not encountered any problems with it in practice other than that sometimes I end up talking in circles This is why I stopped giving people benefit of the doubt. With every uncharitable action of theirs, I tried to understand their perspective, explain mine, and discover a ground truth. Yet, they are not interested in finding the truth. They are interested in doing what they believe is to be true, regardless of whether it is true or not. They are not interested in getting educated. They have already decided that they are educated and I am wrong, just because we have different ideas. My strategy of giving benefit of the doubt in such a case turns out to be nothing but a waste of time. Therefore, I've changed my strategy. If they don't respond well to my giving benefit of the doubt, I'll confront them directly. If they insist, then they'll become an out-group to me. Starmanning no more.
- cyraxjoe 4y ago>Some people have made their political ideology the foundation that they build their ego on[...] This remind me about the idea of "holy wars" in "The denial of death" of Ernest Becker. “Since the main task of human life is to become heroic and transcend death, every culture must provide its members with an intricate symbolic system that is covertly religious. This means that ideological conflicts between cultures are essentially battles between immortality projects, holy wars.” Also something along the lines of preferring to annihilate the other before they risk to be symbolically annihilated, like if we prefer the physical death before than the death of the symbolic. For both the other (when is an ideological opponent) and ourselves. We may be physically death, but symbolically immortal.