13 ms·
Laser fusion facility heads back to drawing board
- irjustin 4y agoOf all the ideas surrounding fusion, this one I've always had the most difficult in imagining it working at any level of production. The kid in me says this was/is the coolest option. Regardless of outcome, I'm glad we were able to test the idea.
- pram 4y agoIIRC it seems impractical because it was intended for nuclear weapons research or something like that. It's a military boondoggle.
- RF_Savage 4y agoYep. It's an alternative to nuclear tests to see how the physics work in real life. Sometimes it's just nice to have something to compare your simulation results to.
- adastra22 4y agoAlso if you wanted to make really small fission bombs—like hand grenade sized—I would guess this is how you’d go around doing it.
- ncmncm 4y agoYou may guess that if you like, but it is physically impossible in this universe.
- adastra22 4y agoProject Orion used fission bombs "the size of a soda can" to power its propulsion. Designing such bombs was a big part of the military aspect of the project and how it got government funding. Now the results are still classified, of course, but it appears they were successful from a design angle. At least the scientists involved seem to think it was possible. This source gives an estimate that a 1 kg fissile mass plutonium can yield about 100 tonnes of explosive power, which is a sphere of plutonium about 2 inches in diameter: http://nuclearweaponarchive.org/Nwfaq/Nfaq4-2.html http://nuclearweaponarchive.org/Nwfaq/Nfaq4-2.html In principle there isn't really a limit to how small you can make it, just with decreasing efficiency and (with traditional implosive designs) a higher detinator-to-fissile material ratio. Things like laser implosion remove this design constraint, however, and would let you consider things like millimeter-sized pellets.
- ncmncm 4y ago1 kg is the amount of fissile material, but it needs quite a lot of high explosive around it. The file you linked says 16kg, and 28 cm by 30 cm. I suspect the soda-can sized charges you recall were conventional explosives for the small, non-nuke prototype they tried out.
- pfdietz 4y agoProject Orion did not use fission bombs the size of a soda can. It may have used bombs whose CORE was the size of a soda can, but to get that to explode requires much more high explosive (than in a typical nuclear weapon) to implode it more aggressively. That's fine, as the mass of all that high explosive acts as reaction mass.
- ISL 4y agoExperiment is the arbiter of truth -- being able to verify that aging fissile materials continue to function as-expected is very important. It really matters that nuclear weapons go bang when you want, but not when you don't. An example of why one needs to care about such things in stockpile stewardship -- plutonium's own radioactivity means that helium is effectively being born within the crystal lattice, causing damage, distortion, and swelling. It isn't a guarantee that a bomb that worked 50 years ago will work today. https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1241955 https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1241955
- 4pkjai 4y agoI’m actually okay with nuclear weapons not working when someone wants them to
- aplummer 4y agoAre you ok with them working when someone doesn’t want them to though?
- labster 4y agoOnly if they’re on Russian military bases.
- geysersam 4y agoDo you need fusion plasma simulation to achieve that? Don't think so.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> Do you need fusion plasma simulation to achieve that? Don't think so. Would you prefer to know? Or go off a hunch?
- geysersam 4y agoI'll admit it's just a hunch telling me you don't actually need experiments on extremely high temperature plasma to prevent a reaction that never naturally takes place on earth. Intuitively, simply not building a bomb seems sufficient to prevent any accidental detonations. But I'm of course no expert.
- XorNot 4y agoI wouldn't say boondoggle. The need for nuclear deterrent is back in focus, and so long as that exists then I'd much prefer we do anything but actual weapons tests.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hangonhn 4y agoWhat was the expected long term outcome of the nuclear test ban treaties? It seems unless there is some breakthrough in simulations and NIF type experiments, all countries with nuclear weapons will end up unsure of their weapons efficacy. Is this intentional? Is the hoped for outcome that no one has nuclear weapons they are sure will work and thus effectively disarming them? If not, are facilities like NIF what was envisioned by all the countries who have nuclear weapons? Thanks.
- lovemenot 4y agoI cannot speak for the people responsible for drafting those treaties, but it appears to have been a timely effort to apply multi-lateral pressure against proliferation. Put another way: for some nations to pull up the ladder. Not long-term thinking perhaps, but medium term at least. In the longer term, who could have known then or even cared how to maintain the transition to a no-test regime? What the treaties' drafters might have been thinking is now moot. Those people are long gone, it's your problem now.
- pjc50 4y agoThis is a serious albatross round the neck of nuclear technologies; if they're dual-use, they'll get lots of funding, making them look expensive, while the true purpose and feature set is obscured, making them look nonsensical.
- mavhc 4y agoThat's why we got the nuclear reactors we have today, the ones that can make nuclear weapon material
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> why we got the nuclear reactors we have today, the ones that can make nuclear weapon material No, we got ones designed to work in nuclear submarines [1]. Civil reactors don’t make weapons-grade anything. [1] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/0301421584900260 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/0301421584...
- etrautmann 4y agoIt does seem like fusion research based on tokamak or stellerator designs will yield usable power first.
- kersplody 4y agoAnd even then, we are decades away from a commercial design due to the large number of engineering challenges needing to be solved. The next major milestone is getting a plasma gain of > 5, where helium-4 interactions become the dominant source of heating and dramatically change the behavior of the plasma. This has been simulated but never experimentally archived. Hopefully ITER will achieve this by 2030. Keep in mind that continuous operation with a Q plasma gain of at least 75 will be required for a commercially viable reactor. ITER will be lucky to hit 15 with upgrades through 2040.
- ncmncm 4y agoIn other words, there will be no commercial design, ever.
- binbag 4y agoNo, that is not the right conclusion.
- ncmncm 4y agoExcept, it is. Fusion would necessarily be a lot more expensive than fission. But fission is itself not competitive, and gets less so with each passing day. So, the longer it takes before fusion is actually, technically possible, the less value there is in it.
- crubier 4y agoWhy do you think that Fusion would necessarily be a lot more expensive than fission? I don’t see any reason to believe this long term
- TomMasz 4y agoThe University of Rochester's Laboratory for Laser Energetics was working on laser fusion back in the late 70s. Despite multiple upgrades, they never achieved the goal, eventually outgrew the facility and the DoE moved on to the NIF. It really underscores how difficult laser fusion is and how important it must be to merit pouring all that money into.
- jinto36 4y agoThe LLE at least wasn't a single purpose build-abandon-dismantle project, and still operates for research. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laboratory_for_Laser_Energetics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laboratory_for_Laser_Energetic...
- nonrandomstring 4y agoReading between the lines it seems the failure to replicate results is down to a lack of precision engineering capability. Is anyone who understands the experiment in detail able to comment? Sounds like what goes on at the focal point of the laser requires nanometers of accuracy in design, position and orientation. Perhaps part of the problem is that we abandoned physical engineering and manufacture in the west in favour of outsourcing it all?
- sandworm101 4y agoFocal point isn't the problem. It is more about timing, getting all the lasers to hit at the same time. And no, this has nothing to do with outsourcing. There are no outside experts in this field.
- nonrandomstring 4y agoI see. A similar problem to aligning the detonation wave in the early plutonium bomb designs then, only with the speed of light as a constraint. Tricky.
- doctorwho42 4y agoThis is a facility that is critical to US stockpile stewardship. None of the tech or engineering or manufacturing has been offshores/outsourced. The engineering and fabrication side is just that precise. In this facility they indirectly drive the target with the lasers. So instead of uniformly heating a sphere with lasers, they heat the inside of both ends of a gold tube (holhraum). This causes a bath of x-rays to uniformly heat a glass sphere that contains your fusion fuel. That glass sphere needs to be suspended in the center of the tube, but any inconsistency can cause huge knock on effects on yield. So they hold it between two <1um thick sheets of plastic. But if you can imagine, part of the sphere will be in contact with this plastic and part will not. That adds some reduction in how uniformly you heat the glass sphere. But let's back up, how do they even make this perfect sphere of glass that is hollow? And how big is it? Well the sphere can be anywhere from 420um to 800+ um in diameter. From what I recall, the only way to make these is to drop small amounts of glass from a tall tower into water. Then do metrology on it, and toss away >90% of them right off the bat. Another issue is that some of the fuel leaks out of this hollow glass sphere over time. So timing from when you load the target from storage to actually firing the lasers can have non-zero effects on the yield. Long story short. It's really hard to convey how close to the edge of precision ICF research is to the edge of micro fabrication. Now add the fact that some of these targets need to survive going from atmosphere to ultrahigh vacuum, and not break or tear... Remember that 1um thick plastic? So yeah, no one is outsourcing this stuff. It's not being negatively effected by brain drain or lack of funding. It's just absurdly difficult to build to the designed tolerances the physics demands. Fun fact, this is why a lot of physicists got behind the ITER project. The bigger you make something, the less important the minor fluctuations are to the overall yield. :D
- sandworm101 4y agoWe should never forget who pays the bills here. Laser fusion, in the context of the NIF, means weapons research. It might seem unrelated, but using radiation/lasers to collapse metals onto hydrogen to initiate fusion is the literal core of modern nuclear weapons research. This is not about electrical energy production.
- cwillu 4y ago“Activities are about one thing and one thing only” is a fallacy. It's good to remind people about weapons research interests. It's less good to completely dismiss the interests concerning energy production, or basic scientific research. They don't go away just “omgz military funding!”
- simiones 4y agoThere are no true interests concerning energy production related to inertial confinement fusion. It is completely impossible for ICF to ever have a cost/watt that would make it even remotely economical. A coal power plant burning diamond instead of coal would almost certainly have better economic fundamentals than ICF can hope to achieve. So this is weapons research and basic physics research caked in the language of power generation.
- seoaeu 4y agoThat’s assuming they ever even make it to net positive energy output. The article carefully avoids mentioning that the lasers they use are wildly inefficient. It is very hard to break even when you lose 90% of your input power right at the start
- DennisP 4y agoBut the relevant question is, how efficient are equivalent modern lasers? NIF was built in the early 2000s and laser technology has advanced quite a bit in the past couple decades.
- Trouble_007 4y agoLawrence Livermore National Laboratory (LLNL) : https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lawrence_Livermore_National_Laboratory https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lawrence_Livermore_National_...
- sandworm101 4y agoWho are funded by DOE. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Department_of_Energy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Department_of_En... Who are in charge of nukes.
- bumblebritches5 4y ago
- upsidesinclude 4y agoThe interesting thing here is that publications like Nature continue to release this kind of nonsense. The PR campaign being run to keep these places operating must cost a much as the research
- simiones 4y agoIt's very funny to read that they couldn't even replicate the initial experiment, while there were scientific articles imagining how this could be a realistic power source given "modest assumptions" about how the hohlraums can be industrially cheaply built.
- JackFr 4y agoOmar Hurricane is an outstanding name.
- ohiovr 4y agoFusion is hard. I thought of another use for that laser: Take a small cylinder of pyrolytic graphite (it is diamagnetic, repelled by magnets) milled to be in the ideal axis and polystyrene layered in it. Then shoot it into a somewhat large ring of powerful magnets that have a trough in them to such a degree that it can trap the cylinder as it accelerates around the loop. The cylinder is propelled by successive shots of laser bursts that are not powerful enough to ablate (but close). One of the electromagnets can be quickly deactivated to allow for the cylinder to escape. Then it travels for a safe distance into very large lead target. Fusion could proceed if the speed is fast enough as the fuel is inertially kept together and friction should raise it’s temperature. If it produces neutrons, they will be absorbed by the lead. You can just collect the heat. Edit. I think the lead target would be a no go. It would be no different than a bullet hitting a soft block of lead. Better would be a block of silicon carbide with some kind of borehole made of tungsten metal with fuel packed at the end of it. So the rice sized cylinder of nuclear fuel shoots right into the borehole and before the material can squeeze itself out, it has to overcome the enormous inertia keeping it going in one direction. Might be better though if the target itself was fuel. And it would be much easier to fuse lithium dueuteride than hydrogen and carbon. I seem to recall a recent story on HN about something similar. So it isn't really a new idea. Perhaps making it run a circular course is different or that it doesn't use ablation for propulsion, it uses light pressure. I think the project was in the UK.