7 ms·
The first car ad shows what changed, what hasn’t
- jhowison 4y agoOne of the comments on that article refutes that claim: That is not the first car ad, although the claim has long been made. https://www.macsmotorcitygarage.com/americas-first-automobile-ad-sorry-no/ https://www.macsmotorcitygarage.com/americas-first-automobil...?
- hairofadog 4y agoAdjacent to this topic, I was recently thinking about how little commercial air travel has changed in the past 50 years. You can no longer smoke on an airplane, which is great. Security is a nightmare, which is less great. Has anything else changed?
- kevinventullo 4y agoI believe it is far more convenient as there are now many more direct flights and they’re much cheaper after adjusting for inflation.
- hamrickdavid 4y agoNot a ton has changed for the better - but a few things have: 1. Ticket prices have come down in real terms (especially with the advent of low cost airlines) 2. Fuel economy on newer jets has improved 3. Increased number of routes and frequencies 4. Lie flat seats in business and above on long haul 5. WiFi on planes 6. In-flight entertainment - both seatback units and video over WiFi
- ghaff 4y agoAnd you don't need to basically go into a travel agent and get a piece of paper that is incredibly hard to replace if lost. In general, travel information is a lot more frictionless. Flight cancelled, bags lost? There's an app for that. And in general, clothing expectations mean I have to check bags a lot fewer times. As you say, seating is better if you're willing to pay for it but I've never bought WiFi on a flight. It's one of the few opportunities I have to really read anyway.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoFlight information online is huge. Just yesterday[1], we had to pick someone up at the airport when their flight was 10 hours late. We got to do our waiting not at the airport. That's a game changer. [1] Well, we were supposed to pick them up yesterday. They actually arrived today. 10 hours late on an afternoon flight is like that.
- Aloha 4y agoAirplanes no long crash into the earth at an alarmingly frequent rate. Like they used to sell life insurance at the airport because of both the perception of how unsafe things were and the reality of it - per Wikipedia, in 1969 there were 21 air crashes or incidents - the vast majority of which had fatalities, in 2019, there were 12, the vast majority of which had none - this on top of an order of magnitude more flights in 2019 vs 1969 - the disparity grows even further when you look back into the 50's.
- eru 4y agoAbout the first and third ones, see https://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/AirlineDeregulation.html https://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/AirlineDeregulation.html
- lazycouchpotato 4y agoThe significant "cool" things I can think of is internet on planes, and being able to take a shower on certain first class flights. https://youtu.be/84WIaK3bl_s?t=424 https://youtu.be/84WIaK3bl_s?t=424
- ghaff 4y agoI don't find Internet on flights a particular convenience and, if you can take showers at airline clubs, that's not a big deal either. And I've never taken advantage of in either case.
- drdaeman 4y ago> I don't find Internet on flights a particular convenience YMMV. I love being able to stay in touch with my folks or scroll HN/Reddit while I'm in the air with nothing to do but read a book or try to nap. > take showers at airline clubs That video is about Emirates First Class, where one can take a shower during the flight. This kind of convenience costs somewhat obscene amount of money, most people here I guess aren't the target audience.
- ghaff 4y agoWell, nothing to do but read a book sounds delightful.
- loloquwowndueo 4y agoReading beats doomscrolling any time, airplane or not.
- bobthepanda 4y agoLie flat seats are probably more important. Sleeping upright in a chair, even a very comfortable chair, sucks. Lie flat seats are a significant change in improvement, such that flying business today might actually be a better experience than first used to be.
- rwc 4y agoSafety! That's the biggest change. https://news.aviation-safety.net/2017/12/30/preliminary-asn-data-show-2017-safest-year-aviation-history/ https://news.aviation-safety.net/2017/12/30/preliminary-asn-...
- Aloha 4y agoYou hit the nail on the head there.
- slg 4y agoThere is no mention of terrorism on that list, but I think that is a safety related improvement that largely goes unnoticed. Yes, the TSA is generally mismanaged security theater, but overall security is so much better than it was 50 years ago. I don't think people realise how common hijacking where in the late 60s and early 70s. There was literally a hijacking every week or two. Now they are incredibly rare. There hasn't been a major one in the us in the 20+ years since 9/11.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- autoexec 4y agoSeat width and leg room have decreased to pack in as many people as possible. They don't offer peanuts because the increasing numbers of people developing peanut allergies have made it too deadly. Passengers used to dress up for air travel, but now they dress for comfort. Alcohol used to be served for free. Passenger violence has increased. They started making people pay for bringing luggage in the 2000s, first with checked bag fees and then carry on bag fees.
- czstar 4y agoI remember flying during regulation and I wish we’d go back to those days. Flying back then was so much better.
- tahoeskibum 4y agoIt was also a lot more expensive back then. Today you can pay first class and get better service. Ultimately this is what happens when air travel gets democratized: people focus on low costs.
- autoexec 4y agoAlternately, they add or increase costs for features that were once free/affordable until most people are priced out of them. Between those two forces (airlines cutting services in order to make flying available to more people, and airlines turning once standard features into high priced "premium" features to line their pockets at the expense of most travelers) the effect is pretty much the same: Most people who want to fly have no option, but to find the most affordable rates where they can expect to get substandard service while only a small number of very wealthy people get what used to be granted to everyone with a ticket. Air travel was once a luxury experience at a luxury price, and things had to change to open it to more people, but things like standing seats (https://www.cnn.com/travel/article/standing-up-airplane-seat-testing/index.html https://www.cnn.com/travel/article/standing-up-airplane-seat...) and fees for carry on bags are certainly not necessary and are just airlines abusing passengers for profit.
- decafninja 4y agoWasn't air travel mostly restricted to the wealthy back then?
- pessimizer 4y agoThe main thing it dismisses is the "faster horse" myth. People wanted to DISPENSE WITH A HORSE.
- sonofhans 4y agoThe point of the quote — “If I had asked people what they wanted, they would have said faster horses.” — is that until the motorcar existed most people would not have been able to imagine it. This ad does nothing to contradict that.
- eru 4y agoThe 'ad' itself is sort-of a myth, too. The 'faster horse' was just a quip that Ford made. Nothing anyone ever actually said they wanted.
- squarefoot 4y agoThe quote however shows that sometimes it takes an invention, or an inventor, to jump from an old context to a newer one without the market asking for it. A similar one regarding computers could have been like "Had I asked people what they wanted, they would have replied bigger abacuses", that is, it requires some genius (besides courage and deep pockets) to realize when it's time to rethink about the problem and jump to a better solution that is a lot more than the previous one on steroids.
- eru 4y agoNot sure. There was a pretty incremental path from earlier mechanical computing devices, like Pascal's Pascaline https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pascal%27s_calculator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pascal%27s_calculator towards more and more sophistication. Then you have electromechanic devices https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mechanical_computer#Electro-mechanical_computers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mechanical_computer#Electro-me... then the first fully electronic devices, etc. There were some groundbreaking innovations happening in reality, but merely sped up the process; without them incremental progress would have eventually gotten us there, too. In general, in a high dimensional space incremental progress is incredibly powerful. That's how we train neural networks, and that's how evolution works. Courage and genius still help speed things up, when you can get them. But they are seldom absolutely necessary. Slightly related: https://www.econlib.org/library/Columns/y2016/Boudreauxprosperitypool.html https://www.econlib.org/library/Columns/y2016/Boudreauxprosp... has a good point about pool noodles. Pool noodles were a minor invention at some point. Nobody really needs pool noodles to get through the day, but they do provide a bit of utility (otherwise people wouldn't buy them). Lots of small and incremental improvements in the economy look like pool noodles. But taken together they really add up.
- addicted 4y agoThe article claims that the ad is a lot more wordy than ads today, which they attribute to decreased attention spans. Which may have something to do with it, but I suspect the real reason in this case is that the ad looks like an article. It looks more like an unattributed sponsored post than an ad.
- gumby 4y agoWhether that was the original (which I doubt) those old car ads remind me of old home computer ads from the late 70s and 80s. “keep your recipes on this thing and chuck out the cookbooks”
- Archelaos 4y ago> The first automotive ad appeared July 30, 1898, in “Scientific America” by Winton Motor Carriage Company, based in Cleveland. 10 years too late! The first car ad was placed in the Mannheimer Zeitung by the inventor of the automobile Carl Benz himself in 1888.[1] [1] Here a reproduction: https://p6.focus.de/img/fotos/id_1066249/mobil-autoentwicklung-werbegalerie-geschichte-1880-1.jpg?im=Resize%3D%28800%2C1081%29&impolicy=perceptual&quality=medium&hash=9ff3d8e4eefef70f6567cb8c46dc4ab6e3463efa1b3d3cbdee95d240145399f3 https://p6.focus.de/img/fotos/id_1066249/mobil-autoentwicklu...
- hammock 4y agoWhat’s it say?
- anshumankmr 4y agoHere's what I got from Google Lens + Translate' >New patent motor car powered by gas by Benzin Benz & Cie., Rheinische Gasmotorenfabrik Mannheim. Hödite Huszeichung (honorary diploma) Russtellung Glogan 1888, Exhibited at the Engine and Working Machines Exhibition in Munich from September 12, 1888, The Wünchener Blatter wrote about this day: Neacke Rodriften, 16. Exptember in power. m seitswaldinen Kuskettung finben felt geften meberte ture traveled with the zaten tirton Motormagen zer uma Bens & Co in Wambrim de fbatt. The car is a wide frofecially Raleide unit ninlegbare Regeba with red on 200 Jim, b at ben Tricodes grisert meter tam inter or Rnd Sipe in Wagrutesten a finely crafted Ben is motor attached, the rear wheels in Serblubeng Bee By a Drud on a under the electricity Dave fann on relatively fine lace lower and continued jo ben gebode values His rite a dit is the ones in Kirjan Teabe jatirentea ute Scarpe Nakristen, 18. Seitenber Det Benyfde Latent Motorwagen, tet in about nocderes burch concerns a simple Borritung, delih merah wab Kebritomaldinen Ehrling cartells it, let act an emitag fine rite Grebehet in a Nt Etot ad gour with voruglafrem Exels, The fel fame gabing made generally antant and the love and flatte it in diditon soatm. From wan ab finben saalid Google Translate is having no luck with this. Can some native German speaker help?
- pragmatick 4y ago