9 ms·
Inside the Irish Republican Army (1994)
- tptacek 4y agoIt's interesting, because this was reported out in 1993, and includes things like: Similarly, the telephone grid is scanned at a rate exceeding one million calls per minute for conversation suspected of being useful to the IRA. The moment a trigger word or phrase is uttered, the line is tapped and a detective put on the case. My Belfast friends keep correcting my perception of this snooping. [...] How plausible was that in 1993? Scanning dialed numbers, sure, but voice recognition?
- zekrioca 4y agoMaybe tens of hundreds of officers listening to multiple calls?
- walterbell 4y ago> How plausible was that in 1993? Keyword detection was alleged in 1980s, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ECHELON https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ECHELON & https://techcrunch.com/2015/08/03/uncovering-echelon-the-top-secret-nsa-program-that-has-been-watching-you-your-entire-life/ https://techcrunch.com/2015/08/03/uncovering-echelon-the-top...
- tptacek 4y agoThe ECHELON keyword searches were against faxes and cables (and even then, the reporting breathlessly noted the tens of keywords they could search for at a time, and the carefully managed dictionaries). Against a whole country's voice phone traffic?
- walterbell 4y agoAI pioneer Oliver Selfridge was a source for Duncan Campbell's 1980s reporting, so there was at least one competent scientist involved, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oliver_Selfridge https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oliver_Selfridge. If it's still an open question after three decades, perhaps we'll never know.
- AlecSchueler 4y agoThe most surprising part is that the technology could understand a Belfast accent. Even in 2022 Siri says "Hello" back to me when I begin a question with the word "How..."
- mhoad 4y agoIt almost certainly did not operate in any way similar to how it was described in the article. See my other comment but I highly suspect this was a much simpler solution in real life. I don't think there was any monitoring of "code words" at all or even any automated voice detection. It just seemed that way to outsiders because all they ever saw was the correlation without actually understanding the capabilities behind the scenes.
- mr_toad 4y agoDragon dictate was released in 1990.
- motohagiography 4y agoWasn't there something around it where it didn't make it to market after, or got bought and suppressed? I worked for someone who worked on it, and I remember his view was it got sabotaged somehow. 1993 was peak ECHELON conspiracy theory and really, that was an era of fax machines and mostly rare 300-1200baud modems. Commercially available hardware included the Cray EL90, and the Sun SPARC lines. Knowing what we do now, as a capability, even just trolling through basic fax OCR, aided by some traffic analysis, and a reduced list of potential targets (early social graph analysis), it seems plausible that a probabilistic and unreliable fishing expedition version of this existed - and then after some "limited hangout" leaks, there was also plausibly something on the traffic analysis side that detected anyone exercising any opsec capabilities at all in response to it, and then they focus workflows on those people. It's as simple as getting phone records into a Sun workstation, sending an asset into the area to a pub to spread the rumor calls are being monitored, looking for a change in behavior in the data, then focusing on whoevers records change after your asset is sent in. Not saying this happened, but if you're in the threat hunting business, it seems like a pretty obvious low cost win within the capabilities of the tech at the time.
- stickfigure 4y agoTechnology wasn't quite that primitive. 9600+ baud was common in the early 90s. The USR HST modem launched in 1986.
- wikfwikf 4y agoThere was a huge financial fraud involving a Belgian company, Lernout & Hauspie, which acquired many of the other startups doing voice recognition and then went bust. The guy who built Dragon NaturallySpeaking and owned Dragon Systems was paid in ultimately completely worthless shares of L&H. The technology was bought out of bankruptcy and successfully commercialized. One of the two guys involved in the fraud claimed he was a victim of a CIA conspiracy, although the other one admitted the fraud.
- sgt101 4y agoLooking for a short list (closed vocab) of words is far easier than going for the tens of thousands of words that something like transcription requires. Also you can accept quite high false positives. A HMM is adequate.
- shirro 4y agoAT&T deployed a speaker independent keyword based system called VRCP in 1992 that automated some operator assisted calls. So keyword recognition at utility scale was plausible but there is a difference in scale between some fancy IVR tech and scanning millions of phone calls.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoThere were ICs in 80s consumer electronics that could do primitive recognition of prerecorded words. These could have been adapted to monitor all calls and flag them for human monitoring.
- bouncycastle 4y agoHmm.. Analog "Vocoder" technology was invented in 1939 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vocoder https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vocoder So I'd imagine that by 1993 it would have been possible to do analog voice coding, digitize the codes, and then a mainframe could scan through the codes which are just "envelopes of the bandpass filters". (Just a guess)
- mhoad 4y agoIt’s kind of unclear from the article where this claim even comes from. Was this something the journalist claimed to somehow know or was it something that the PIRA had told him? Neither of them would be in a position to know especially at the time it was written, but it has all the hallmarks of the kind of “the enemy is 10ft tall” stories that tend to turn up in the fog of war. The next part of that quote (in the article) though certainly suggests that the PIRA had perfectly good evidence to suggest that SOMETHING like this was happening based on their experience of actively manipulating it to their advantage. It sounds reasonable as a concept without having to back up the specific technical claims of how the monitoring itself actually worked or it’s particular capabilities. I could for example see it as something much closer to a manual operation IRL that just targeted the phones of know and suspected members along with payphones in certain areas and it would have appeared the same way to them. They weren’t actually a particularly large organisation IRL and those passing operational messages over a public phone network was even smaller. I’d hazard a guess that it’s not actually THAT difficult to put together a target list for surveillance that would narrow the scope down to something fairly reasonable. You aren’t actually looking for full coverage in this scenario you’re looking for a good signal to noise ratio and it ends up becoming a question of which calls are “unusual” and you could get a long way to answering with metadata alone, long before you ever thought to pass the actual contents of the call to an analyst.
- Rebelgecko 4y agoVery interesting article, does anyone know if the photos that go with it are available anywhere?
- mhoad 4y agohttps://youtu.be/9qbkbMLF2XY https://youtu.be/9qbkbMLF2XY
- anewpersonality 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lettergram 4y agoBoth sides in any conflict are going to have valid reasons to be hateful, want revenge, etc. There are three options: 1. Force one side to capitulate 2. Eliminate the opposing side 3. Call a cease fire and everyone walks Both 1 and 2 failed after many years. So they went with number 3. It appears to have worked.
- MomoXenosaga 4y agoThe whole shit show could have been avoided if the UK had just organised free and fair elections in the 1920s. Instead the British had to oppress the Catholics for generations creating the civil war that inevitably flared up. The IRA was the British fault.
- czstar 4y agoThe British Army got away with heinous murders too. So did loyalist terrorist groups. At some point both sides need to move on if peace is to be obtained. I like what Ghandi said: An eye for an eye makes the world blind.
- olliej 4y agoI don’t recall the British bombing school buses, or libraries, or pretty much any place where people congregated. The IRA were terrorists. Pretending that they’re not only really stopped in the US after 9/11, presumably because it became harder for supporters in the US to explain why targeting groups of civilians was an acceptable strategy.
- BrianHenryIE 4y ago> I don't recall The British army opened fire on a civil rights march, killing 14 people, all of whom were unarmed. It is the most significant day of the Troubles. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bloody_Sunday_(1972) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bloody_Sunday_(1972)
- cromulent 4y agoThanks for this. I'm currently reading We Don't Know Ourselves [1] and this is a great sidebar. There were over 10000 bombings during the Troubles [2]. Hard to imagine now. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/books/2021/sep/20/we-dont-know-ourselves-by-fintan-otoole-review-sweeping-account-of-irelands-evolutions https://www.theguardian.com/books/2021/sep/20/we-dont-know-o... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_bombings_during_the_Troubles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_bombings_during_the_Tr...
- nibbleshifter 4y ago> “Nah, it’s just weird, maybe… But I look forward to when me and the family can go to a King Willie parade and enjoy ourselves and the music, you know, like we do in Armagh on St Patrick’s Day. Is that crazy?” Still largely can't do this, even in 2022, without the rather serious risk of severe injury or worse.
- biorach 4y agoWell.. It depends,East Belfast, yeah. Rural areas, I hear a lot of the parades a these days are low key with little hardliner involvement and safe enough
- HeckFeck 4y agoI've known many curious Catholics to watch the parades in rural areas. No one in the lodges is bothered by it. But yeah, inner city is different.
- nibbleshifter 4y agoTbf most of the PUL folks I know are from around ... That area. Have a few good friends in around Lurgan who reckon I'd have a great time, but also reckon I'd end up in several bags after.
- bell-cot 4y agoAh, yes, the IRA. Two special things about them, for me... Decades ago, I knew a very nice, educated Irish-American gentleman, who'd grown up over there. Deep knowledge of European history, fascinating to listen to for hours, etc. But if he had a drink or two, he'd re-tell the story of the Proudest Moment of his life: Back in Ireland, when (thanks to his Sherlock Holmes knowledge and insight) he had managed to "out" several Protestants as such - in circumstances rough enough that being outed immediately lead to their being murdered. IANAL, but he showed nothing resembling regret, and never asked anyone to keep quiet about it. For me, he was a pretty visceral education in just how nice and educated someone can be...and yet still be so malicious as to boast of murdering complete strangers. Talking about the War on Terror(tm) with folks (say, 99% of modern Americans) who really don't know squat about European history, the IRA can be extremely useful as a real-world example - where both sides are white Christians. When folks who claim to educated, unprejudiced, etc. make moralistic statements about government policies or situations involving Arabs, Islamic extremists, etc. - just re-cast the situation with the IRA, in the UK, during the Troubles. Are they comfortable with what they said, in that context? Generally no. Their reactions can be pretty educational.
- alephnerd 4y agoI don’t know why you are being downvoted. My parents grew up during a similar ethno-religious insurgency and the scars of growing up not knowing whether your parents or siblings would get back home safe because of sociopathic individuals on a powertrip continue to haunt them and our entire family to this day. When exclusive affiliations consumes your entire identity, this can become a dangerous combination Also, a meta commentary @dang - why are a number of comments against the IRA being downvoted? There were no saints in the Troubles and it’s startling to see comments opposing an actual sectarian terrorist group being downvoted to oblivion.
- bell-cot 4y ago> I don't know why you are being downvoted. Ditto, though I'm more inclined to suspect my War on Terror comment. "Terrorist" - similar to "witch", "*igger", "atheist", "commie", "homosexual", and a number of other terms which change over time - seems mostly a label to stick on a person or group in order to proclaim that it is "okay" to hate, dehumanize, commit atrocities against, etc. them. For all too many folks, their "Licence to Hate" is one of their most precious possessions.