4 ms·
Why are the business practices bad? Details, please.
by pfdietz 4y ago
Why are the business practices bad? Details, please.
- yetanother-1 4y agoMany explinations are available on the web, but it comes down to the dependence on these seeds and thus on the producer of them.
- pfdietz 4y agoHow is that different from use of hybrid seeds, which have been available since forever and don't breed true? The solution to dependence is to have multiple suppliers. One can always use an older variety of seed. If the complaint is that the benefits are going to the company that made the seeds rather than the farmer, then how is that different from any other patented technology? The farmer is never going to be worse off, since he can always just use older varieties if the cost > his benefit. Perhaps your actual argument is that this will reduce food prices, driving out producers who don't keep up with the latest advances. But again, how is that different from any other improvement in agricultural technology? Is this just more European objection to the steamroller of US industrial agriculture?
- MonkeyMalarky 4y agoSuing small farmers for copyright infringement isn't very nice.
- pfdietz 4y agoYou are aware you're spouting bullshit there, right? First of all, copyright isn't the applicable IP; patents are. Second, no farmer has ever been sued for accidental contamination with patented GMOs. There have been cases where farmers deliberately tried to concentrate trace contamination, but the courts properly recognized the deliberate nature of that. These urban legend arguments are one of the reasons I view the entire anti-GMO movement with a very jaundiced eye.
- Dylan16807 4y ago> Second, no farmer has ever been sued for accidental contamination with patented GMOs. There have been cases where farmers deliberately tried to concentrate trace contamination, but the courts properly recognized the deliberate nature of that. Yes, deliberate use of the patented gene/interaction. That's still suing small farmers, doing farmer stuff, for IP infringement. So it's not bullshit.
- pfdietz 4y agoThe farmer deliberately attempted to concentrate the gene. The only reason he would do this is to try to violate the patent. This was not an innocent action. Your argument here is like blaming a homeowner for catching a burgler.
- Dylan16807 4y agoI didn't say it was innocent. But he's still doing pretty normal farming stuff. > Your argument here is like blaming a homeowner for catching a burgler. Nah, burgling doesn't work like IP rights. The analogy is hopelessly broken.
- pfdietz 4y agoNo, in the case I'm thinking of he was doing something that wasn't normal at all. He was taking a field of mostly Roundup vulnerable soybeans and spraying it, killing off most of the plants, concentrating the ones that happened to have picked up the patented gene. There is no interpretation of what he was doing that wasn't clear and intentional violation of patent law. And thus he lost in court.
- Dylan16807 4y agoTaking plants and doing X to concentrate a trait is normal farming stuff. He definitely violated the patent but it doesn't make it a good thing that the patent works that way, and it doesn't make suing him a good thing.
- xwdv 4y ago