3 ms·
Annual reminder: the reason Larry Page originally started Google wasn't to solve search or become rich, it was to develop a sustainable source of income to prod
by dekhn 4y ago
Annual reminder: the reason Larry Page originally started Google wasn't to solve search or become rich, it was to develop a sustainable source of income to produce infrastructure for ML research and hire motivated ML researchers to develop the technology point where it would become AI in an externally recognizable way (say, a computer program that could play some interesting game better than anybody else, or solve a long-standing scientific problem). Everything else- search, ads, social, cloud, etc- all of those were tangential.
The first 15-20 years of google didn't really have any interesting machine learnign at all. There was SmartASS, SETI, and later Sibyl, which are really just large-scale variations on "build a model that predicts a value that allows us to make profit in a very specific area". There were other things, like Phil and later Rephil. Inside Google (not DeepMind), things didn't really get going at scale until somebody stuffed a bunch of GPUs into a workstation and showed you could train voice recognition really fast- that lead to the early, extremely high quality Android voice recognition and improved quality of the existing voice models.
Around the same time, Jeff was experimenting with distributed CPU training, and at that point, the ban on GPUs in Google servers was lifted, although because Google couldn't source enough GPUs, they decided to start a program to make their own alternative (TPUs). This has led to a revolution within Google and DeepMind (and X) allowing a flourishing of research into many directions that would have been more or less impossible just 5 years ago.
larry wasn't completely wrong in his long-term goal, but he got bored and promoted himself out of google, leaving sundar to deal with the messy details of implementing the singularity while also keeping the stock price up.
- kareemsabri 4y agoSo why'd he try to sell Google to Excite in 1999 for $1M. https://techcrunch.com/2010/09/29/google-excite/ https://techcrunch.com/2010/09/29/google-excite/
- dekhn 4y agoDunno- we never discussed that. also, note that the author of the article (MG Siegler), and the founder of Excite (Joe Kraus) both ended up as venture capitalists working for GV. Edit: the CEO of Excite at the time said the issue was that Larry wanted Excite to rip out all their search servers and replace them with Google (which would have been an inside-out acquisition, where the acquired company takes over the acquiring company): Bell, currently with General Catalyst Partners, recalls Google’s asking price between $250,000 to $500,000 and 1% of Excite. He says the issue was not in the financial terms but in the larger deal points. “Larry page insisted that we have to rip out all of the Excite search technology and replace it with Google,” Bell said.
- kareemsabri 4y agoI'm not sure that's an inside-out acquisition as Larry Page would not have control of Excite in any meaningful way. My point was more that if a guy wants to start a company to create passive income to fund his massively ambitious research projects, he would need the foresight to know the company would be massively successful, like throw off enough cash to pursue projects that would appear frivolous successful, and I don't think the Google founders had that foresight. Obviously I wasn't there, but trying to sell it to multiple suitors (they were also open to selling to Yahoo as late as 2002 afaik) indicates they didn't. My understanding is nobody knew search would be as lucrative as it it today. Not to say you're fabricating your story, I'm sure they said that, but perhaps it's some revisionist history.
- skybrian 4y agoInteresting if true. What's a good source for the part about Larry Page's motivations?
- dekhn 4y agoMe. I used to attend private meetings with a bunch of scientists and him and spent a fair amount of time talking to him (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Science_Foo_Camp https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Science_Foo_Camp). It's pretty hard to get him talking but I was very patient. Back when I started, Google was fairly small and it was easy to hang out around the founder's area in 43, and occasionally I'd have coffee with Jeff Dean and Sanjay Ghemawat and Larry and Sergey (and Rob Pike and a few other brilliant folks) and we'd bullshit and I'd ask a bunch of questions about how search worked in 1999 (which is when I started using it).
- noncoml 4y ago“Trust me bro” is not a reliable source, no matter I how important or famous someone is. Edit: believing one’s anecdotal story is different to accepting the original assertion of the OP as true. Not saying they are lying, just take it with a pinch of salt.
- dekhn 4y agoFeel free to disbelieve me. But I think I got a pretty good read on the situation having talked to a wide range of the original players and a fair number of xooglers and googlers who frequent this site have probably interacted with the old leadership enough times to know what their real motivations were.
- ocdtrekkie 4y agoHow do you feel Google today squares with the Larry Page you met who said advertising funded search engines were inherently unethical?
- 4y ago
- psi75 4y agoI believe all this, and it's terrifying. If AI emerges in the private sector (and therefore under the control of rich people) we might as well give up on the entire human experiment, because the AI will be put toward malevolent ends and we, as a species, shall fail. The good news is that we probably won't see AGI for at least 50 years. There's a decent chance of capitalism being over by then.
- spacephysics 4y agoThe capitalism that’s lifted more people out of poverty than any other system in human history. Hopefully it’s not over.
- Reki 4y agoJust because paperclips are useful doesnt mean we should keep making more of them forever.
- GauntletWizard 4y agoThe nice thing about capitalism is that it has controls on it, like "Who wants to buy the products", and "Does everyone think that corporation's leader is an asshole and will buy from competitors" that a command economy doesn't.
- psi75 4y agoIt really doesn't. The vast majority of economic activity in our system is driven by coercion and need, not want and certainly not freedom. People don't show up to jobs where they take orders from idiots for an exact lower bound of 40 hours per week (but, in practice, often more) because they're freely choosing to do so.
- FpUser 4y agoIt did and the best time has passed. Right now we have rich getting richer poor getting poorer and middle class evaporating. The way it works it may no longer serve the purpose. Not like there is any viable alternative. We have finite resources and ever growing population. Unless these factors are mitigated somehow (dirt cheap infinite energy for example) we do not have much to look forward to.
- cpeterso 4y agoWhy were GPUs banned in Google servers? Cost? Security?
- dekhn 4y agoGoogle acquired a company in 2007 which had expertise in multicore at the time multicore was really improving quickly. One of the acquired principal engineers wrote a manifesto saying that GPUs were a waste of time because they didn't solve problems like speeding up search (it's probably still around) or the other things Google was spending a lot of cycles on (ML training). It was a great example of a technical leader being completely wrong about one of the directions of the future and the technical solution to it. Now, I should say that multicore machines are still highly relevant and complement GPUs nicely- but the manifesto happened at a time to convince leadership to avoid making strategic deals with nvidia at a critical time.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]