9 ms·
A global grid was my favourite solution until recently. The problem is that it needs the combined cables to have cross section in the order of a few (3?) square
by ben_w 4y ago
A global grid was my favourite solution until recently. The problem is that it needs the combined cables to have cross section in the order of a few (3?) square meters (at 640 kV), and that in turn is in the order of 52 years of global copper production (we make more aluminium than copper but Al is a worse conductor).
Using even higher voltages makes everything much easier, and the cables’ combined cross sections may need to be less (depending on how much lower the maximum demand at night is) or more (depending on future increases in daytime demand).
Downside is that’s still order-of a few trillion dollars, close to the same as the cost of 36 TWh of batteries (i.e. global overnight only), and we’re likely to make those batteries anyway for the electric cars and when their condition deteriorates enough to be taken out of the cars they're still good enough for grid storage.
- walrus01 4y agoI don't know of any long distance HV AC or DC transmission lines that use copper. It's all aluminum already.
- tclancy 4y agoI’ve heard it’s all ball bearings but that may be outdated.
- dotancohen 4y agoMeaning that coal transported by train is still a major energy source? Globally that is still accurate unfortunately.
- adrianmonk 4y agoIt's a reference to the movie Fletch. The main character is an investigative reporter. In one scene, he poses as an airplane mechanic. The real airplane mechanics are not very convinced, and he tries playing it off by saying, "It's all ball bearings nowadays." https://youtu.be/SjJYNZirQCU https://youtu.be/SjJYNZirQCU
- adaml_623 4y agoThe good news is that humanity has saved up a few trillion for emergencies. The bad news is that it's been saved up and hidden in tax havens. Pity
- kortilla 4y agoWhat a bad take. The US alone effectively created that much money out of thin air during the pandemic. All of the countries combined printed far more. Doing the same for an energy project that might actually pay back (unlike the covid losses) is far less disruptive. Finally, the amount of money hidden away in tax havens by the rich is nothing compared to this. Don’t drag down something as important as the climate crisis with some smooth brained class warfare.
- InvertedRhodium 4y agoWhat a one sided take - there's no reason that both can't be real problems.
- billiam 4y agoPeople that charge class warfare just don't want anything to change. Wealth accumulated by the rich mostly by burning dinosaurs is just as fictitious as any QE from the Fed.
- pydry 4y agoIt's only fictitious if Jeff Bezos is comparing his wealth to your wealth. Try to tax it away and use it for something that would benefit everyone and suddenly it becomes a lot less abstract to him.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoIt would become a lot less real too. The wealth of people who mostly get it from stock ownership is a complete fiction, driven by the scarcity of shares on the open market. If Jeff Bezos dumped his entire holding in AMZN shares, the whole company would be worth a lot less. Not due to any sort of magical effect of Jeff Bezos, but due to the market being flooded with supply.
- lotharcable 4y agoMoney != Wealth You can go ahead and force every billionaire to sell off everything they own and hand it to the government and all you end up with is a one time boost to government tax receipts. That's it. One time boost. Next year those billionaires will be gone. There won't be new ones. And it won't create any more food. It won't solve shortages. It won't create more solar panels. It won't create 1 mile of copper lines. Because when the government goes and says "I need 40 million acres of solar panels"... Who is going to do that? Where is that going to come from?
- WalterBright 4y agoThe communists have repeatedly done the equivalent, which is nationalizing industries. It never, ever produced better results.
- walrus01 4y agoGovernment owned, government built, government run regional monopoly electricity generators in North America are already the absolute cheapest dollars per kilowatt hour in the continent. It's not communism. I am referring to hydro quebec, and to the hydroelectric dams in central Washington State. Would you claim that if we had let the free market build those hydroelectric dams using private capital instead, that we would have better results right now?
- WalterBright 4y agoI read recently that Mexico was nationalizing part of its electric grid and user prices were expected to rise as a result.
- WalterBright 4y agoFound it: https://www.wsj.com/articles/mexico-energy-cfe-obrador-11655000527 https://www.wsj.com/articles/mexico-energy-cfe-obrador-11655...
- 4y ago
- zbrozek 4y agoWhile your house wiring is typically copper, transmission and distribution wiring isn't. That's very-often aluminum. And as you point out, we make a huge amount of the stuff.
- ben_w 4y ago20.6 MT copper/year vs 64 MT aluminium/year, even using both that's still equivalent to about 17 years of current global production (which is a big but not impossible change over the timescales desired), but the price is still painful.
- zbrozek 4y agoAluminum has higher specific conductivity than copper by mass. So if you think you need 1 MT of copper conductivity, you can do the job with 0.5 MT of aluminum. Aluminum is also quite abundant. Rate limits will be political rather than production. That's not to say this is a realistic idea or that it's worth doing, just that it isn't unthinkable on a resource basis. https://www.anixter.com/en_us/resources/literature/wire-wisdom/copper-vs-aluminum-conductors.html https://www.anixter.com/en_us/resources/literature/wire-wisd...
- kortex 4y agoAluminum production is also tightly coupled to electricity production, so cheaper power could lead to cheaper aluminum in a positive feedback loop.
- eternityforest 4y agoI doubt copper would be used in that kind of thing. It's worse, but not that much worse. Energy storage might not be an issue in a decade or so. There's no law of physics saying they can't make batteries without conflict metals. Eventually someone's going to invent a battery made of some cheap hydrocarbon you make by the tanker car, or that compressed Co2 turbine system will turn out to be the real deal, or they'll figure out magnesium air, etc.
- ncmncm 4y agoA clear majority of utility storage will not be batteries, just because cheaper methods will be favored. The cheapest will rely on E = Fx, where F is air pressure, or gravity, or buoyancy. But liquified anhydrous ammonia, despite being more costly to make, will be extremely popular because it is easy to transport and store, and is fantastically useful for many purposes.
- eternityforest 4y agoI think that depends on battery tech. If they get magnesium air or metal free organic flow working I would imagine it would probably be chosen over mechanical methods. Ideally I suspect you don't really want utility storage anyway, you want something so cheap, small, and renewable you can do point of load storage and have a bit of grid independence, and not need as much transmission infrastructure.
- ncmncm 4y agoPoint of use storage costs a lot more.
- pfdietz 4y agoCopper is used in applications where the conductor is volume constrained. Transmission lines are not volume constrained, they are mass constrained. Aluminum is superior there: its electrical conductivity divided by density is higher than copper.
- elihu 4y agoI'm curious if anyone knows the cost/benefit analysis of HVDC over aluminum cables versus using high-temperature superconductors like ReBCO tape. Maybe supply of yttrium is a bottleneck preventing large-scale use of ReBCO? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rare-earth_barium_copper_oxide https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rare-earth_barium_copper_oxide
- pclmulqdq 4y agoHigh voltage solves a lot of materials problems for wires. I assume that almost everything about superconductors is expensive to do, not just the raw materials, which makes it too costly (in both energy and money) to use them as wires.
- elihu 4y agoI assume there's a really high fixed cost involved in creating a cable installation that's insulated and continuously chilled to liquid nitrogen temperatures, but maybe there's a break even point if the amount of current you're moving is large enough? I mean, if you're comparing with an aluminum or copper cable with a cross section measured in meters, that isn't cheap either. There might not be a break-even point. Maybe ReBCO tape is just more expensive per amp it can transport than ordinary conductive metals like aluminum. Maybe HVDC lines can be boosted to arbitrarily high voltages such that you never need huge cables in the first place.
- lazide 4y agoThe issue as well is catastrophic failures. Superconductors get VERY exciting VERY quickly if they ever quench, and that is a property of the current and superconductor. You can't carry infinite current. They may be more efficient, but they come with a whole host of challenges that make them difficult to use over long distances or in uncontrolled environments, which is pretty much what you'll have to deal with for long distance utility level power transfer.
- Aeolun 4y agoWe don’t need to shift all necessary electricity from one end of the earth to the other right? Just the shortfall that a large number of batteries cannot deal with overnight.
- nine_k 4y agoSuperconducting power transmission was first implemented back in 2014 [1]. Some progress has been made since then [2]. I bet we'll eventually see more of that, with superconducting materials steadily becoming more pliable and affordable, and liquid nitrogen being pretty cheap. Maybe we'll see hundreds of miles of such lines. It looks to me more realistic than land in Western Europe becoming cheap enough to install a gigawatt of solar panels here and there. [1]: https://www.extremetech.com/extreme/182278-the-worlds-first-superconducting-power-line-paves-the-way-for-billions-of-dollars-in-savings https://www.extremetech.com/extreme/182278-the-worlds-first-... [2]: https://energycentral.com/news/shanghai-opens-world-leading-superconducting-cable-operational https://energycentral.com/news/shanghai-opens-world-leading-...
- ben_w 4y agoI like superconductors, and I certainly hope they'll become viable, but "hundreds of miles" is a factor of at least 120 short of what's needed, and land for a GW of PV isn't that expensive even in western Europe, especially as PV can be present in pastureland at the same time as the animals.
- Emma_Goldman 4y agoA lovely idea, but it will not happen anytime soon because states consider energy independence to be of existential geopolitical importance.
- rocqua 4y agoDid you take into account that transmission cables are usually hollow? Due to the skin effect, most current runs through the edge of a cable, so by hollowing out the cable you can remove a part that doesn't carry much current.