10 ms·
Migratory monarch butterfly now endangered
- carbadtraingood 4y agoThe way we treat the destruction of species and habitat at our hands as a necessary side effect of progress is alarming. Removing a species from the planet is like removing a screw from an airplane in flight - you can probably remove a lot of screws before there's a problem, but you will eventually crash catastrophically if you keep at it.
- eljimmy 4y agoI think we as a species must rid ourselves of selfishness and greed. We need to think beyond the timelines of our own existence. Alas, I fear those traits may be too deeply rooted in our our own nature and nurture that our demise may be inevitable.
- PuppyTailWags 4y agoI want to push against the narrative that selfishness and greed is inherent. The currently dominant society might socialize its people to prioritize selfishness and greed but not all societies do and not all societies must.
- bmitc 4y agoSelfishness and greed is at the heart of humanity. Just look at every lawn covering every plot of land. They are examples of pure greed. Almost no one uses parts of their lawn regularly, and so they only exist for vanity purposes. There is a reason why many restoration and native plant proponents teach about empathy. One needs to gain empathy for plant and wildlife struggle before being able to enact change. We could solve a lot of problems almost immediately if we had even a modicum amount of collective empathy.
- downboots 4y agoIt means mostly anyone can help contributing by converting part of that lawn Native species make the most sense but there are plenty of other beneficial weeds https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beneficial_weed https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beneficial_weed Like a victory garden, but war of a different nature https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victory_garden https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victory_garden
- JKCalhoun 4y agoTo be a contrarian, perhaps the societies that prioritize selfishness end up dominating as a result. I act with optimism, teach optimism to my children. When left to my inner thoughts however I worry about the future of our species.
- angst_ridden 4y agoDominating? In the way a bacteria dominates a petrie dish until it exhausts all the resources and dies off?
- JKCalhoun 4y agoExactly.
- eljimmy 4y agoI agree, not all societies are like this. However, an argument can be made that it is inherent because it is dominant.
- zmgsabst 4y agoSpecies disappear all the time. The issue, in so much as there is one, is the speed at which that change is happening.
- carbadtraingood 4y agoNote I specifically said "at our hands" to suggest exactly this. Nature gonna nature, agreed. What we're doing is different.
- nemo44x 4y agoAren’t we nature too? Isn’t every species of living thing trying to thrive as much as possible in a ceaseless competition for space and resources? Are we the shepards of the world or just another organic life?
- carbadtraingood 4y agoNo. We were nature, but we're progressing faster than natural processes can adapt.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mistrial9 4y agoseen this with my own eyes in my lifetime, here on the West Coast of California.. powerfully emotional if you have imprinted on it at a certain age; I suspect that the vast majority of people literally have more interest in the next five minutes than those flying things.. specialists are called for..
- spankalee 4y agoI can't believe how fast this is happening. I used to see millions of them, covering and almost dripping from trees like sap, in Santa Cruz.
- time_to_smile 4y ago"'How did you go bankrupt?' Two ways. Gradually, then suddenly." -- Ernest Hemingway, The Sun Also Rises
- JKCalhoun 4y agoYep, took the daughters down the California coast near Pismo to see the migration — maybe a decade or so ago. They covered the trees, ground. In the years following when we stopped by it was grim, so few of them.
- grapeskin 4y ago> The western population is at greatest risk of extinction, having declined by an estimated 99.9%, from as many as 10 million to 1,914 butterflies between the 1980s and 2021. Insane. I wonder if recovery is even possible without devoted breeding efforts. A population this small could easily be wiped out by birds or a single storm.
- frumper 4y agoNot that the population is doing great, but last years numbers rebounded to about a quarter million. A 100x increase from the previous year. https://www.mercurynews.com/2022/01/26/western-monarch-butterfly-numbers-rebound-in-santa-cruz-but-below-historic-levels/ https://www.mercurynews.com/2022/01/26/western-monarch-butte...
- nabakin 4y agoMakes me suspect that 2k estimate was very wrong
- quietbritishjim 4y agoThat suspicion is reinforced by the fact that the second estimate is strangely specific. 1,914? Not 1,915? Perhaps that number is from some survey or count that was meant for finding trends rather than estimating the total count.
- throwaway5752 4y agoOr, looking at it the other way, the population is down 98% instead of 99.9%. It's really not that substantial of an error, and yours is a very "programmer talking about ecology" type of response. It's a terrible situation for the species and the outcome is largely the same - extinction within our lifetime - and you are quibbling about petty data concerns within the broader context.
- nabakin 4y ago> looking at it the other way, the population is down 98% instead of 99.9%. It's really not that substantial of an error An estimate that can easily confuse 2k with 250k is not an estimate to use. Now if a range was specified taking into account the variability, like 100k-2k, that would be much better. If the study did this, the article would be at fault for not being accurate. > yours is a very "programmer talking about ecology" I don't think I know everything, I simply commented on a niche forum about something I was curious. The vitriol is completely unwarranted. > It's a terrible situation for the species the outcome is largely the same - extinction within our lifetime - and you are quibbling about petty data concerns within the broader context. So what? Should I take all data on blind faith? Should I not question the validity of data when bullshit is so rampant? Stop the strawman, I never said I disagreed with the conclusion of the study, just that the single estimate was suspicious. Next time, if you actually know anything, aim to explain instead of attacking me. I can admit my mistakes and will be much more receptive.
- retrocryptid 4y agoIf you find yourself in California's Monterey Bay area (Santa Cruz, Watsonville, Salinas, Monterey) there are still Monarch habitats you can visit. It's worth seeing if you're halfway interested in nature. And if you live in the area you can plant flowers to support the Monarch migration. I learned recently you're not supposed to plant milkweed close to the established breeding habitats, just plant regular wildflowers they can feed on while they're headed to the butterfly sex party. https://www.pgmuseum.org/how-to-help-monarchs https://www.pgmuseum.org/how-to-help-monarchs
- valarauko 4y ago> you're not supposed to plant milkweed close to the established breeding habitats Overwintering sites, not breeding sites. Monarchs migrating south & at the winter roosting sites don't need milkweed since they're not breeding or laying eggs. While the overwintering sites are in Central Mexico, the breeding sites for the northern migrants is in the Southwestern US - where they do need milkweed. Exposure to milkweed while overwintering triggers breeding and laying eggs, which is disruptive to the migration pattern. Native Milkweed elsewhere along the northern migration path is beneficial, just not where they're wintering.
- questiondev 4y agoi know they really like milkweed which a lot of people kill without thinking of the environmental consequences.
- sdoering 4y agoI only know Monarch Butterflies from documentaries. Sad that I will probably not be able to witness it with my own eyes.
- pastor_bob 4y agoThese are only the migratory population. I always thought they were all migratory, but I guess some populations stick around in areas and aren't in as much danger. I see them not infrequently on the East Coast.
- whimsicalism 4y agoThere's a lot of lookalike butterflies though
- corrral 4y agoI was always told the ones in Kansas were going to/from Mexico on this migration, but I gather from Wikipedia that that was all actually happening much farther West, and ours weren't the migratory kind.
- nr2x 4y agoThe Sixth Extinction by Elizabeth Kolbert is required reading. We’re in the midst of a very rare event, that we caused, are making worse, and we don’t know what will ultimately happen.
- debacle 4y agoIf history is a guide, greed will win out and weak men will suffer at their own hands.
- ehnto 4y agoWe're really talking about humanity versus the ecosystem here though. If there is an ecological collapse, that would also mean societal collapse, and no one wins.
- johnyzee 4y agoI just read Flight Behavior, by Barbara Kingsolver, which has a plot with a backdrop of Monarch butterflies, their migration and the threats climate changes can pose to them. It's a great book, I recommend it.
- melling 4y agoWorld population in 1980: 4.4 billion World population today: 8.0 billion … We need more land, houses, cars, energy, … overfishing: https://www.worldwildlife.org/threats/overfishing https://www.worldwildlife.org/threats/overfishing Need to burn down the rainforests for cattle: https://wwf.panda.org/discover/knowledge_hub/where_we_work/amazon/amazon_threats/unsustainable_cattle_ranching/ https://wwf.panda.org/discover/knowledge_hub/where_we_work/a... Electricity generation with fossil fuels looks like it tripled: https://www.iea.org/data-and-statistics/charts/world-electricity-generation-by-fuel-1971-2017 https://www.iea.org/data-and-statistics/charts/world-electri...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- carbadtraingood 4y ago"Need". We don't need to do those things. We choose to do those things.
- melling 4y agoKeep telling yourself that right up until all the damage is permanent. “If only the people in the Amazon chose not to burn down the forest for cattle” “If only China and India didn’t burn so much coal” “If only people didn’t eat so much fish” https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons
- carbadtraingood 4y agoWhat? I'm not sure what you are saying... We don't need to eat beef, both here and in Brazil. We choose to, in both places. We, locally, need to regulate harder and push harder globally to protect things.
- melling 4y agoI’m saying that “If only we didn’t eat beef” is not a workable solution. What’s important is that people realize they are proposing solutions that sound good but are not helpful. Half the Amazon will be torched before you realize this?
- pastor_bob 4y agoI see these in Brooklyn, and I'm always amazed that they (and other butterflies) can get here. They must go over stretches dozens of miles long without any food or water.
- sk8terboi 4y agoNot here in the north, they're all over!
- de6u99er 4y agoThey'll say we had hot eeather in the past.
- beckingz 4y agoSo what can we do as individuals to help?
- trgn 4y agoPlant milkweed. They may take a few years to establish, but it's effective. We get monarchs every year now. This is in an urban area. Small conservation efforts really do make a difference. Don't be discouraged that you're not fixing the big issues. Pollinator gardens will improve biodiversity in your own little corner of the world, and that's worthwhile in and of itself.
- ehnto 4y agoThat's similar to advice I received from a raptor conservationist. More native foliage in suburbia means more bees and bugs, more bugs means more birds. They suggested a water bath and some native plants in your yard can go a long way to supporting the native wildlife the you may not even realize is in your area, until they have reason to stop by.
- kornhole 4y agoIf you have a yard in the right area, plant milkweed. I have at least 10 plants in my yard. I enjoy watching the little guys munching away until they suddenly dart off to the vines to cocoon.
- colechristensen 4y agoPlant an oak tree in your yard and a variety of flowers that attract pollinators in your garden (and specifically milk weed for monarchs) Oak trees build ecosystems because an unusually large number of species of insect and birds use them and what feeds on them for food.
- Tiktaalik 4y agoPlant butterfly friendly flowers. Vote for the politicians most aggressive on environmental issues.
- accumulator 4y ago
- chomp 4y agoCopy+pasting my comment from another thread: For those wanting to plant milkweed: not all milkweed is a Monarch host. Of the known Monarch hosts, there is minimal documentation of which is the "best" for a Monarch. It's recommended that you pick a host native to your area. Page 93 on the following document[1] includes some species that are helpful to Monarch populations, broken down by area of the United States. For those who would like to purchase caterpillar stock to increase the local population, please reconsider. Bred Monarchs have a lack of genetic diversity that you are releasing in the wild, which can tip over populations due to poor genetics. There is research that shows that planting evergreen milkweed (encouraging sedentary behavior by removing the need to migrate), or releasing captive or reared monarchs, can allow unhealthy monarchs to survive and harm the population when they would not otherwise have survived migrations[2] Studies on bugs or and species have shown that animals can adapt to captive conditions in as short as one or two generations. When this happens, researchers wind up seeing alleles that are harmful to the wild population. [3] There is also the case to be made that by releasing abundant numbers, you are potentially creating food shortages that will harm even more butterflies. Plant local natives. Don't release into the wild. [1] http://www.xerces.org/sites/default/files/2018-05/17-031_02_XercesSoc_Milkweeds-Conservation-Guide_web.pdf http://www.xerces.org/sites/default/files/2018-05/17-031_02_... [2] https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rspb.2014.1734 https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rspb.2014.173... [3] https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1365-294X.2007.03399.x https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1365-294X....
- angst_ridden 4y agoThere was a big trend to planting tropical milkweed (Asclepias curassavica) on the West Coast. Originally, it was considered a good thing. Now, because the plant's a perennial in this climate and is a good place for spreading OE spores, it's considered a bad thing. Some people advocate growing it because it's fast-growing, robust, and provides plentiful food. My understanding is that, if you do plant it, cut it well down in winter to prevent the spread of OE. In my own experience in California, the Monarchs really prefer to nectar and lay eggs on tropical rather than the native narrow-leaf milkweed (Asclepias fascicularis). We've been purging our garden of the tropical anyway. There are also some milkweed adjacent non-natives that they sort of like, e.g., Gomphocarpus physocarpus (aka Asclepias physocarpa). Again, my understanding is that the jury's out as to whether it's a good plant to have around for the Monarchs. It ceryainly is a striking plant that gets a lot of attention!
- tmountain 4y agoIs this the main species of monarch? I have them in my yard pretty regularly, but I also plant milkweed, their host plant to try and provide them with some habitat.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- angst_ridden 4y agoI think history (if there is any) will judge harshly the decision to allow the use of neonicotinids. In addition to general habitat destruction, the indisciminate obliteration of insect populations is going to bite humanity on the ass in ways we can't even imagine yet.
- philliphaydon 4y agoAre these the same type of Monarch butterlies found in NZ? https://www.stuff.co.nz/environment/127540958/new-zealands-monarch-butterflies-need-our-help-expert-says https://www.stuff.co.nz/environment/127540958/new-zealands-m...
- dkasper 4y agoYes
- dkasper 4y agoVery important to clarify this is only the migratory subspecies. The species as a whole is not endangered at all: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monarch_butterfly https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monarch_butterfly
- ralusek 4y agoI had a single milkweed potted plant on my roof. Within a day I saw a monarch on it. Within a few weeks I had about 20 caterpillars devour it. Within a few more weeks, I counted 16 chrysalises around my patio, of which 13 flew away successfully. Pretty amazing.
- nolroz 4y agoMy goodness that must have been a huge milkweed! I had three 2-3ft tall plants a while back and they were decimated by 9 just caterpillars.
- lbrindze 4y agoOne of the most interesting things I ever saw sailing was a singular monarch butterfly in the middle of the gulf-stream about halfway back from bermuda. This was over 300 miles away from any land (including bermuda). It stopped for a very brief rest (a second or two at most) and then continued flying in the opposite direction. Very unexpected and surreal but this really speaks to the sort of distances they can travel without stopping. Does anyone know how common these kind of sightings are? Very sad to find out that these butterflies are now considered endangered.
- micromacrofoot 4y agoin the Atlantic? likely it was blown off course, they're obviously very light and winds play a large factor in their migration it's not unusual to spot a monarch somewhere in the Gulf of Mexico, like an oil rig, but it's not entirely clear how many try to take that 900 mile flight... it's more likely they're blown off course and won't make it to shore unless wind conditions are just right enough to carry them
- melling 4y agoHere are some older HN discussions on the declining butterfly population. I only selected those that are at least 5 years old. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateEnd=1500508800&dateRange=custom&dateStart=1152835200&page=0&prefix=true&query=monarch%20butterfly%20&sort=byPopularity&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateEnd=1500508800&dateRange=custom&...
- lbrindze 4y agoYes this was in the Atlantic. I saw quite a few in Bermuda. I’m not sure if they migrate or just live there full time. Either way it was strange and I often wonder how it got there.
- rch 4y agoI've been told, by a local farmer / restaurant owner from Torreón, that monarch preserves in Mexico are under pressure from cartels that want to convert the land into avocado farms, through violence if necessary. Some restaurants are already taking avocados off the menu as a result, and I've been cutting them out of my diet as well (irrespective of origin). Edit: here's a link -- https://www.npr.org/2020/02/03/802359415/sadness-and-worry-after-2-men-connected-to-butterfly-sanctuary-are-found-dead https://www.npr.org/2020/02/03/802359415/sadness-and-worry-a...
- Tiktaalik 4y agoDepressing and infuriating. Local radio talking about this story interviewed gardeners that suggested planting milkweed, as if a some scattered houses will make any sort of difference. Meanwhile global climate change and widespread habitat destruction for farms and industry will doom the species. No discussion of the broader systemic issues or about how the status quo habits of our society has created this crisis.
- pamelafox 4y agoIf any of you are in California and are interested in creating a habitat for Monarch caterpillars around your home, I highly recommend Narrow-leaf milkweed. It's one of the native milkweeds and its the favorite of my caterpillars (they hate Showy milkweed). You can find nurseries with Narrow-leaf here: https://calscape.org/nurseries.php?id=434&showmap=1 https://calscape.org/nurseries.php?id=434&showmap=1 Or you can grow from seed: https://larnerseeds.com/products/asclepias-fascicularis-narrow-leaf-milkweed https://larnerseeds.com/products/asclepias-fascicularis-narr... I do both, since you can never have enough milkweed! Here's a video of a Monarch butterfly recently flying for the first time after pupating on our Salvia: https://studio.youtube.com/video/edTgi7f1NlY/edit https://studio.youtube.com/video/edTgi7f1NlY/edit
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- angst_ridden 4y agoInteresting. In my area (Southern California), the Monarchs seem to really prefer the Tropical (Asclepias curassavica). We plante it when a local Monarch enthusiast recommended it. Now that we're more educated, we've been gradually getting rid of it.
- pamelafox 4y agoAh, I never even attempted the tropical since it's not native, so I don't know how ravenous they'd be for it. I just contrast narrow-leaf to showy since those are the two commonly sold native CA milkweeds, and my caterpillars are just so incredibly not into the showy, it might as well not be milkweed.
- angst_ridden 4y agoWe were pretty ignorant when we started our Monarch garden. It was 20 years ago, and there was less readily-available information.
- 4y ago
- immmmmm 4y agoI read Ceballos the other day, a brilliant conservation biologist talking often of the 6th mass extinction, saying in an informal context that homo sapiens would not survive it. I know that kind of science, i have read thousands of articles these last years. I love dystopian Sci-Fi too. I think it's a special moment when you see the experts discussing the possible extinction of your own species, and that every dataset, every model, points a bit more towards it. And i see climatologists, Mann included, saying climate impacts are coming decades in advance. What a time to be "alive".
- mmazing 4y agoI let local native milkweed grow wild on my land, specifically for Monarchs. I saw at least 3 this morning (unlikely to be migratory, I suppose?) Hopefully my property can be a stop for some of the migratory species!
- dukeofdoom 4y agoMilkweed is a very interesting looking plant. It's pretty and ornamental, Should be more popular in gardens. Especially in city gardens.
- downboots 4y agoOur ability to simulate the world is in direct proportion to our ability to prevent existential risk.
- goosegoose 4y agoFor those commenting that this is only the migratory subspecies - yes, you are quite correct, but do note that this is the only subspecies you will see in the USA - except in the south of Florida. The non-migratory subspecies is found from southern Florida down through the Caribbean, Central America, and South America north of the Amazon Drainage.
- 14 4y agoI feel bad that as a kid we had a neighbor that would pay us to collect them so she could have them close up and paint pictures of them. We didn’t kill that many but definitely killed a few. I just went on Amazon and bought a pack of milkweed seeds to plant in my yard to make up for that mistake as a kid. I have seen quite a few of them flying around this year. Hope to see them bounce back.