10 ms·
The Asus MacBook Air, sort of
- dman 15y agoGood artists copy, great artists steal
- demallien 15y agoExpanding on this, the idea is that a great artist takes someone else's idea, but executes it so much better that the idea ends up being associated with the great artist, not the original inventor of the idea. The iPod versus other mp3 players is a good example. In this case, it suffices to look at the title of the article - the Asus is being seen as a copy of the MacBook Air, and not the definitive form of Ultrabook that all other makers are going to try to copy. If they had succeeded in stealing the idea, the article would have been talking about how the Asus was going to be the benchmark all other Ultrabooks were going to be judged against, and it would have highlighted how the Asus had filled in the weaknesses of the current champion, which is the MacBook Air. Clearly a case of copying.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- tikhonj 15y agoAsus may not have "done it right", but that doesn't mean there aren't good lightweight laptops to rival the air. I have a Sony Vaio Z. It weighs less than the corresponding 13" Macbook Air (carbon fiber! Like a Ferrari!), has better specs and an innovative design. For one, it does not look like an Air--it does not taper to a point, which is something that annoys me in both the Asus and the Air. It has an actually minimalistic design and looks gorgeous in black. However, the real innovation is in the "Power Media Dock" which--despite the silly marketing name--is actually a brilliant piece of hardware. The laptop itself does not have a DVD drive and uses an Intel HD 3000 graphics chipset. However, it comes with a dock using Intel's LightPeak protocol that contains a discrete ATI graphics card and DVD drive. This lets you have a meaty graphics card at home and a mobile one on the go--very useful. I can also plug my extra monitor and various peripherals into it so that I only need to plug one thing into my laptop when I come home. There are a couple of problems: the keyboard is "not brilliant" at best, although I've gotten used to it. I've tried the Air's keyboard and, while it was better, it was also not brilliant. Additionally, the Linux support on the laptop is spotty. However, from what I've heard, this is also true of MacBooks, so it isn't a differentiating factor. The last issue, of course, is the cost--it is closest to a 15" MacBook pro rather than the Air. However, for this, you get specs equal to a MacBook pro--including either a 1600x900 or 1920x1080 resolution. Even the lower-resolution screen--the one I have--looks fantastic. Overall, the Vaio Z is exactly what the poster is deriding the Asus for not being--innovative, capable and well-built. It is "radically better" than an Air and the only really significant downside is that it's correspondingly more expensive. It even has a rather good touchpad. Oh, and raid-0 ssds. Oh yeah. I do not regret splurging on it at all.
- joshu 15y agosadly, it is a sony. i have heard far, far too many horror stories about sony computers at this point.
- tikhonj 15y agoReally? I've heard some, but not enough to dissuade me from getting it. I also got a two-year warranty for free and I live within reasonable distance of a Sony store (they exist, I was surprised to learn), so I think I'll be able to get decent support. I also suspect that they might go to a little bit more trouble supporting the Z because it really is their top-of-the line model, but I really don't know. I've also heard bad things about Macs, but they all end with happy stories about Apple's support which is definitely a point in their favor. While I can't say anything about Sony's cheaper offerings, the Z seems well-built and sturdy. The only real issues I've had were to do with Linux drivers, but I ultimately managed to resolve those satisfactorily.
- nikcub 15y agothe best non-Mac laptops are the X300 thinkPad series. you probably have at least one friend who is a secret fan of them.
- tikhonj 15y agoThat's certainly plausible--I've heard good things about ThinkPads. Most of my friends are Linux users, so I definitely know some ThinkPad fans. However, in the "ultraportable" (horrible marketing terms strike again) category, I think the Z pulls ahead of the Lenovo X1, which I also considered. Unless I'm much mistaken, the X1 is the replacement for the X300.
- masklinn 15y agoThe best non-mac laptops are Panasonic's Toughbook C1 (inheritor of the T series). They double up as weaponry, too.
- tikhonj 15y ago
- joshu 15y agoApple actually acquired FingerWorks, which made flat touchpad keyboards. The quality is much higher than what most companies are able to use (Synaptics or whatever?)
- fuzionmonkey 15y agoThe trackpad on MacBooks are the greatest thing. I got my first Mac about a year ago and I'll never go back to a PC notebook simply because the trackpads are always terrible. Now whenever I use a PC trackpad, I'm astonished at just how bad they are, even on premium PCs. Why can't PC manufacturers get it right?
- forgottenpaswrd 15y ago"Now whenever I use a PC trackpad, I'm astonished at just how bad they are, even on premium PCs." Yesterday I had to install something on my old computer and I realized how bad the keyboard was, there it was , a piece of clunky , and cheap plastic. I have got used to mac keyboard so much. I also use the magic track pad, OMG, using wacom trackpad was terrible. "Why can't PC manufacturers get it right?" Because it takes a lot of work and money. Apple products are patented and they can't just copy them(magic trackpad uses good quality glass and aluminium instead of plastic) so they need to design new ones, costing millions of dollars per device and this only makes sense if you could sell millions overnight like Apple does.
- archangel_one 15y agoSurely Asus make enough laptops to amortise the cost of designing a decent trackpad over them? I think the problem here is the same thing that manufacturers still haven't gotten; the quality of the build is important, even though it isn't a number that you can put into a spreadsheet for a $/MHz comparison.
- Tloewald 15y agoApple's smoothing algorithm for mouse movement is something that mad PCs unpleasant to work on for me for years. Those ads I think Microsoft has got it good enough that while it's different it's no longer actively unpleasant, bu it's oe of many, many tiny things Apple sweated over back in 1984 and Microsoft didn't notice at the time. (let's not get into text edit field behavior.)
- Tloewald 15y ago
- atarian 15y agoI chuckled at the URL. I wonder if the misspelling was deliberate.
- icarus_drowning 15y agoWhat is particularly sad here is that Apple responds to market pressures just like any other company: when faced with serious challengers, they are forced to innovate and improve. When faced with a $300 million dollar movement to basically rip-off their product? I doubt they'll move nearly as quickly.
- forgottenpaswrd 15y ago"What is particularly sad here is that Apple responds to market pressures just like any other company: when faced with serious challengers, they are forced to innovate and improve." What made Apple Apple until recently was an intrinsic force(from within the company) to innovate an improve(a perfectionist and angry force that will insult and denigrate you if she did not wanted what you made, that will demand the best of you whenever the company is well or not). In life you don't have to wait for others to force you when you could force yourself for your best. E.g students that choose careers their selves (even hard ones) are way happier than those that let others to decide for them. "I doubt they'll move nearly as quickly." Your opinion is based on a prejudice "Apple responds to market pressures just like any other company". Apple had made very good products without "market pressure" that comes when things go bad, sales and. stock go down. The last decade had no pressure on Apple so your prejudice is not true.
- icarus_drowning 15y agoEh, I'd argue it responds much more aggressively and quickly when it has serious competition. Note that I didn't say Apple doesn't innovate when it doesn't have competition, I said it innovates more when it responds to market pressure, which, I think, shouldn't be controversial. Why exactly that statement is controversial is perplexing.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- thomholwerda 15y agoThe internals of the MacBook Air were designed by Intel, not by Apple. The same goes for the internals of the current ultrabooks. It's basically a reference design.
- planb 15y agoJust as the internals of the iPhone were designed by Samsung? No really, do you have any source for this? Because after reading about Steve Jobs obsession with the internal design of a device in his biography, I don't believe Apple would let another company do this.
- blackguardx 15y agohttp://www.eweek.com/c/a/Desktops-and-Notebooks/Intel-Touts-Ultrabook-Reference-Design-to-Keep-Prices-Under-1000-Report-591337/ http://www.eweek.com/c/a/Desktops-and-Notebooks/Intel-Touts-... You can pretty much guarantee that Intel designed most of that ASUS motherboard. Do you really think they copied Apple? Apple (or anyone else) couldn't make a motherboard without Intel's help.
- nikcub 15y agoThis is how it works with all the chip manufacturers and all the ODMs (from Intel Atom and Snapdragon etc. through to desktop PC's). They will announce that they have a new range of boards and chips and the marketing people will go out with some engineering people to every single consumer co and pitch the new hardware to them. Apple fanboys live in a fantasy world where every single good innovation (such as the trackpad, the A5, the touchscreen - all acquired) comes out of Cupertino, and all the crappy stuff is what other companies do - not realizing that the iphone, ipad, macbooks etc. are built around dozens of different companies - all of who work with more than just apple.
- jodrellblank 15y agoIf other companies take the same reference designs as Apple and make such lame devices from them, that's an even worse world than the "fanboy fantasy" where they make lame devices from scratch.
- sgt 15y ago"It’s sad, really, that the state-of-the-art in the PC world is attempting to copy Apple. Why isn’t Asus trying to blow the MacBook Air out of the water with something radically better?". I have an answer for this. I don't think they can create something that blows the MacBook Air out of the water. The bar has been set too high for the PC manufacturers to properly compete in design, at least for the moment.
- tikhonj 15y agoI really don't see why this is the case unless you have a very strong affinity for Apple. As I said earlier, the Vaio Z is really a much better machine overall, but has a price to match. The Lenovo X1 is also very good and I think looks better as well. Of course, I'm probably a little biased against Apple--although I seriously considered getting an Air as my new laptop recently--and have found their recent laptop designs a little garish. There is a gigantic, light-up logo in the back! My roommate had a Mac Book Pro last year and it would light up our room if he used it at night. I favor a more minimalistic, muted aesthetic--if I could, I'd get an all matte black laptop with no labels at all (including the keyboard), but I do not think anything like that exists. The new Vaio Z is close though.
- Samuel_Michon 15y ago"I seriously considered getting an Air as my new laptop recently--and have found their recent laptop designs a little garish. There is a gigantic, light-up logo in the back!" That's not a recent design. Apple notebooks have had a lit logo on the back of the lid for the last 13 years[1], starting with the PowerBook G3 Wall Street. In any case, this 'problem' is easily remedied by covering it up with a sticker. That's what production companies do[2] when they want to use a notebook in a TV show or motion picture that doesn't have 'promotional considerations'[3]. "if I could, I'd get an all matte black laptop with no labels at all" Apple's black MacBook[4] and Google's copy[5], the CR48, came close. Matte black, barely any labels. [1] http://denniswever.dyndns.org/blog/wp-content/uploads/2008/09/IMG_0823.jpg http://denniswever.dyndns.org/blog/wp-content/uploads/2008/0... [2] http://www.geeksugar.com/TV-Shows-Cover-Up-Apple-Logo-Mac-Laptops-Desktop-Computers-2835550 http://www.geeksugar.com/TV-Shows-Cover-Up-Apple-Logo-Mac-La... [3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Product_placement http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Product_placement [4] http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/f/fa/MacBook.jpg http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/f/fa/MacBook.j... [5] http://news.cnet.com/8301-31021_3-20025349-260.html http://news.cnet.com/8301-31021_3-20025349-260.html
- kayoone 15y agoApples trackpads really are one of the main selling points for me. I got my first Macbook Pro in 2009, liked it, got used to it but somehow wanted to go back to a rigid business laptop where i dont have the fear of scratching it etc. So i sold the MBP and got a Dell Latitude only do realize how much of a difference the trackpad on a MBP makes and how much i got used to its awesomeness. Today i use a MBP again ;)
- zobzu 15y agoOne the one hand, Apple takes pride in copying and enhancing themselves (then claim they did it but ok) On the other hand there are radically differently designed ultrabooks, so don't take Asus for the general norm? Oh and as many on this page I'm typing from a Vaio Z21 running Linux and of course, everything just works. Of course its way faster, yet lighter than the MBA. And while you may hate Sony because "its not hype to have a Sony dude!" its well built and works perfectly well, 20h a day so far.
- forza 15y agoHow is it that when someone takes inspiration from an Apple product it's stealing, but when Apple does the same thing it's either genius (to the point of being one mans creation) or the importance of original invention is trivilized? Being inspired is the foundation of creating new things, as almost everything new is actually taking one or more known things and combining them. What bothers me is when you take inspiration from something, claim it's your own unique invention and try to prevent anyone else from doing something with it.
- ugh 15y ago“Stealing” isn’t used once in the linked article.
- forza 15y agoI'm referring to the general discourse and the comments made by Jobs in regards to Android.
- hmottestad 15y agoIt would have helped if you said so in your original comment...since the article has nothing to do with androids but instead with the ultra-portable pc market.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- gmac 15y agoEasy. When you do something that's been done before and do it better, you get credit. When you do something that's been done before and do it worse (e.g. this Macbook Air clone), you don't.
- dman 15y agoHave you used the Asus UX31?
- zmmmmm 15y agoI find the snide and cynical tone of this kind of post sad. We seem to be at the point where offering any competition to Apple in any category is tagged as as a "rip off" when a short time ago it was just seen as healthy, even essential competition. We the consumers are the beneficiaries of competition. Why we (or this class of person) have chosen to deride it I don't understand.
- tikhonj 15y agoA cynical answer would be that it generates pageviews and discussion. If the article was just "ASUS Zenbook--it's okay but not brilliant", it would not have gotten onto hn at all, and if it did I certainly wouldn't be discussing it quite as fervently. I doubt the author consciously planned it this way; however, it's perfectly reasonable that he subconsciously wanted to make a more striking point but unfortunately came over as overly antagonistic.
- gurkendoktor 15y agoI disagree. A MacBook Air with an unusable trackpad is emphatically not okay- it's absolutely worthless, ruined by one component. (At least if you don't fall into the USB-mouse-on-a-laptop camp.) The MacBook Air was never about specs, where the Zenbook might be okay (except for weight and height).
- tikhonj 15y agoOr if you fall into the power-user camp that uses the keyboard almost exclusively like I do (this is both with a nice touchpad and even on desktops with a physical mouse). The newer touchpads like the ones on my laptop and Macs are okay, but constantly switching between that and the keyboard is ultimately slower than just using the keyboard. Once you get used to navigating around with the keyboard as much as possible--assuming your OS supports it well--the quality of a touchpad stops mattering. I am now consistently annoyed by web apps and programs that force me to use the mouse unless I really have to. Ultimately though, my point wasn't really so much about the laptop as about the tone of the article, which your post doesn't seem to address. Even if the Asus deserves derision, and antagonistic response is still not necessary, and still generates more views and comments. The worst bit is that--by virtue of replying here and commenting on the thread--I've shown that his tactics are successful.
- reidbradford 15y agoAs an owner of one of Asus's early precursors to the Ultrabook which also has serious trackpad problems (UL30VT), this makes me wonder how long Asus is going to go without correcting these basic problems. Until then the Samsung Series 9 is probably a better choice.
- ssn 15y agoI view this as a positive thing -- imitating the best seems an excellent approach. Inovation comes next.
- Newky 15y agoI know the ultrabook project is taking a lot of flak in a lot of area, but the idea excites me. A lot of people would argue that cloning is not the way to go, and even in the article the writer states that its a pity asus didn't try to do something better than apple. Why not make something equal first, we seen it with android, although I'm not saying that Android is built as a clone of iOS, but they got feature parity and then went onto more innovation. Personally as someone who loves the look and feel of the MacBook, but who for a number of reasons won't be purchasing one ( expensive for a college student, not a fan of Mac OS). An entry into the market like this appeals to me greatly. Keep it up Intel and partners!
- tikhonj 15y agoI think I have to chime in to try and counteract Apple's marketing: the world isn't actually divided into Mac/PC. Just because you buy Apple hardware--which really isn't bad--doesn't mean you have to use their OS--which is. You could install Windows or, even better, use Linux. Of course, if you're not into Mac OS, you might as well get the Asus, which means its entry into the market benefits you.Even some non-Apple clones are competition and make the market much better for everyone. As a college student, I think you'd get almost the same utility out of a nice netbook running Linux as you would an Air unless you're a heavy gamer. I have several friends who went that route and their uniformly happy and productive (unlike some of the people I know using Mac OS, although that is more a function of their not being CS people). Of course, I say this almost hypocritically as a college who did splurge on a laptop and doesn't regret it. I just had some money left over from an internship--that's my excuse.
- SandB0x 15y agoLook at how many models Asus makes: http://www.asus.com/Notebooks/AllProducts/ http://www.asus.com/Notebooks/AllProducts/ . Around 55 distinct designs. Look at how many models Apple makes: http://www.apple.com/why-mac/compare/ http://www.apple.com/why-mac/compare/ . Five distinct designs. True attention to detail is surely impossible with Asus' scattergun approach.
- dotemacs 15y agoInteresting discussion. I had to buy a laptop recently and as much as I like the look of Mac's Air it didn't have a right Control key. That just frustrated me as I use Emacs and I rely on a working right Control key so much. I know that there are tools to remap keys. Tried various ones, but at the end of the day I was trying to make Mac act as X Windows and it just wasn not smooth. So I bought Samsung's 900 3XA. Just as light, has the right Control key and all of the hardware components are supported with the latest FreeBSD 9.
- imran 15y agoNo doubt apple (read steve jobs) has taken inspiration from a lot of products and features. But apple is more onto tweaking and making it better with even effort on design and user friendliness. Everyone knew touch but apple made it useable. Take an idea or inspiration and tweak it to perfection so it becomes revolutionary and apple become genius! Think you can do it?
- ajanuary 15y agoThe trackpad on a Windows Air-style laptop could be a big win. As amazing as the Macbook trackpad is on OS X, it's still incredibly flaky on Windows.
- thomasz 15y ago> What to Submit > On-Topic: Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups. If you had to reduce it to a sentence, the answer might be: anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity. Could anyone explain why this is on the front page? The only piece of information in this rant is that there is some new Asus notebook that looks like a MB Air. Apparently at least 75 people's intellectual curiosity is very easily satisfied...
- anemic 15y agoI was wondering the same thing. To give my opinion on the matter I like the 13" Zenbook's 1600x900 resolution better than MacBook Air's 1440x900. The 13" Macbook Pro has 1280x800 which is useless to me. When running Visual Studio or Eclipse I definitely like the extra 160 pixels to have the sidebar wider without sacrificing space from the editor.
- eliben 15y agoI want a Macbook Air like laptop, but I don't want it so expensive and designed for Mac OS. I want a cheaper machine running Ubuntu? What's so bad about making this available? On a different note, the attempt to show how the internal design of Asus copies that of Apple is laughable. The PCBs look completely different, except for maybe the main fan placement. But think about the space constraints in such a device and it becomes obvious there aren't too many options!
- moondowner 15y agoNot all 'ultrabooks' look like the MacBook Air, as the article states. For example the Lenovo IdeaPad U300s: http://www.theverge.com/2011/11/8/2546923/lenovo-ideapad-u300s-ultrabook-review http://www.theverge.com/2011/11/8/2546923/lenovo-ideapad-u30... [a review from The Verge]