5 ms·
> Nothing curtails corporate power. It's also why the focus of politics is on being divisive on social issues. This is to distract the voters and prevent class
by rayiner 4y ago
> Nothing curtails corporate power. It's also why the focus of politics is on being divisive on social issues. This is to distract the voters and prevent class solidarity of the working class.
I think you’re misdiagnosing the cause. Nearly everyone I know—my circle skews highly educated and well compensated—cares more about social issues than economic ones. It’s telling that, in this crowd, Clarence Thomas gets exponentially more hate for the ways in which he’s a typical older Black man from a working class background (his views on social issues) than for the ways in which he starkly departs from that background (his economic libertarianism).
While these folks would deny they’re acting in their class interest, the effect is identical. Working class people, being less educated and less cosmopolitan, are naturally going to be more socially conservative. By making politics more about “rights” and “justice” than “wages” and “government services” you’re naturally going to divide the working class and have a powerful club to use against them.
- feet 4y agoThe more well compensated you are, the more disconnected you are from the perils of working class poverty. Most people I know who are well compensated don't see an issue with the system simply because it has worked for them I should note that these people are well compensated workers, and they are not capital owners even if they aspire to be one some day which helps solidify the ideals of capitalism working for them
- noobker 4y ago> The more well compensated you are, the more disconnected you are from the perils of working class poverty. For sure, but there's a type of blindness that comes from our culture and class expectations too. I know many service workers who make more than white collar workers. But -- critically -- the white collar workers are unaware of it. You could say the white collar workers are banking on social clout for why they feel better than the service workers they utilize, but I don't think so. It looks like straight up ignorance and willful projection. The service workers are happy to let the white-collar-fools carry on with the delusions --> it leads to big tips when the white collars need to show off and there's a payoff for workers who can put on a show of subservience while ultimately enjoying more freedom.
- wyre 4y agoI learned the word for this recently is called Embourgeoisement. It’s at least a very similar phenomenon. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embourgeoisement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embourgeoisement
- jmyeet 4y ago> I think you’re misdiagnosing the cause. Nearly everyone I know—my circle skews highly educated and well compensated—cares more about social issues than economic ones. That's because they're liberals (or, worse, neoliberals) and liberalism is about aesthetics. It's about appearing to do something without actually doing anything. I don't mean this is any kind of perjorative sense by the way. I know many people like this too. Take the Democratic Party. In response to the Dobbs leak the Demorats did... nothing. When the decision was handed down they sent a bunch of fundraising emails and texts and did... nothing. Well, other than "vote harder" messaging. The leadership has decided an issue with 75% public support is "too controversial" to tackle. Why is the Democratic Party in this situation? Because there is always a rotating villain that blocks any action. Currently that's Senators Manchin and Sinema. In past years it was Joe Lieberman. This is by design. Everyone else gets to point at the rotating villain and say they tried but they got blocked and then fundraise off [insert blocked issue here]. Now look at an issue like homelessness. The most important factor that leads to homelessness is cost of housing. The one thing that would help above anything else is a housing-first policy, meaning giving homeless people somewhere to live. But rampant NIMBYism, even in heavily blue states like California, means that's a nonstarter. This is why you'll see people fund raise for homelessness without tackling the root causes. This is what I mean by aesthetics.
- rayiner 4y agoYou can’t overlook the deliberate prioritization of certain issues over other issues. The Democratic Party is a coalition of people who agree on “bigger government offering more services” and little else. Obama as a populist and social moderate in 2008 and got Obamacare with several Senate votes in socially conservative Midwestern states. Since then Democrats tacked left on social issues and kicked the “deplorables” out of the coalition. They’re mad at Sinema and Manchin, who are holding onto seats deep in GOP territory, but should be mad at the party that lost labor and agriculture voters in South Dakota, Iowa, etc. Folks I know were talking about kicking Joe Manchin out of the coalition for being pro life before the 2020 election. About 1/4 of the Democratic Party identified as “pro life.” 1/6 (mostly Black and Hispanic people) oppose same sex marriage. 1/10 want to restrict immigrant (and that’s after Trump converted a bunch of those voters in 2016). Kick all those people out of the party and give capital owners exactly what they want.
- nradov 4y agoMany educated and well compensated people have adopted "luxury beliefs" as a form of virtue signaling, even though putting those beliefs into policy tends to harm the working class. https://nypost.com/2019/08/17/luxury-beliefs-are-the-latest-status-symbol-for-rich-americans/ https://nypost.com/2019/08/17/luxury-beliefs-are-the-latest-...
- jmyeet 4y agoThese are often called "champagne liberals" or even "champagne socialists" and is very much true. I saw this in the 2016 election. What Demorats failed to understand was the groundswell against the status quo. This is why Trump won and Hilary lost. Hilary was very much a vote for the status quo and an increasingly large number of people are angry about the status quo. To be clear, Trump didn't deliver on any of his promises (other than on judges) but it explained a lot of his support, particularly in the Rust Belt. It's also why Bernie Sanders nearly clinched the nomination. Hilary apologists like to blame her loss on any number of things (eg Bernie spoilers, Russia) but ignore the compltely obvious and actual reason: she was a terrible candidate. No one made her choose an anti-choice running mate. No one made her no campaign in Wisconsin. I remember having a conversation with someone who is liberal about the estate tax. He opposed Bernie because Bernie wanted to lower the estate tax from $10 million. Huh? Clearly that affected him and this is of course an encdote but I found in illuminating as an example of how much momentum for Hilary was about protecting the status quo.
- krapp 4y ago> What Demorats failed to understand was the groundswell against the status quo. This is why Trump won and Hilary lost. Hilary was very much a vote for the status quo and an increasingly large number of people are angry about the status quo. I mean, Trump won with several million fewer votes than Clinton. The common narrative around Hillary Clinton and the Democrats is, as you mention, the failure to tap into an anti-establishment zeitgeist that Trump did more successfully. But the numbers alone (apart from electoral votes, obviously) show the Democrats were at least as successful, if not technically more successful, than Trump at messaging. The Democrats' failure was one of tactics, not strategy.
- jason0597 4y ago> I think you’re misdiagnosing the cause. Nearly everyone I know—my circle skews highly educated and well compensated—cares more about social issues than economic ones. Of course they would. They are very well educated and very well compensated. Their needs are taken care of, economics isn't at the top of their political concerns list. However, they do not represent the majority of the US, they only represent a tiny minority. https://www.legalreader.com/low-wage-jobs-are-the-new-american-normal/ https://www.legalreader.com/low-wage-jobs-are-the-new-americ...