9 ms·
Archive.org Seeks Summary Judgment in Lawsuit Filed by Publishing Companies
- sbr464 4y agoI stand with archive.org
- jw1224 4y agoWhilst they were objectively “wrong” in their actions, what they did was clearly for the greater good. Requesting a summary judgment reminded me of that. Respect to the IA for upholding their position.
- worik 4y ago> objectively “wrong” How so? Can you explain? Are libraries, too, "objectively wrong” in that analysis? cheers
- r3trohack3r 4y ago> Given the impact of the public health emergency, the Internet Archive decided to ease its book lending restrictions and allow multiple people to check out the same digital copy of a book at once. https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2022/07/14/cucd-j14.html https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2022/07/14/cucd-j14.html Libraries can rent books they’ve purchased. Generally they can’t fire up the photocopier and make copies of books they’ve purchased.
- Mezzie 4y agoActually, sometimes you are able to. ILL in academic libraries or special collections/archives sometimes requires doing so (e.g. because the original material is bundled in a giant 10 year journal binding). That said, legal agreements between research libraries and academic publishers are basically opaque dark magic.
- pxeboot 4y agoAnecdotal, but every library I have ever been in had a copier that patrons could use to make copies of books for a couple cents per page.
- JoshTriplett 4y agoLikewise.
- sp332 4y agoSome copying is covered by fair use. Making a whole copy of a book, especially in a way that might limit the copyright owner's profits, usually doesn't count. I've seen signs in libraries like this one https://www.shopbrodart.com/Library-School-Equipment/Signage/Wall-Mount-Signs/_/Brodart-Sign-Shop-CA-Photocopy-Copyright-Restrictions-Sign/ https://www.shopbrodart.com/Library-School-Equipment/Signage... warning about copyright infringement.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nulbyte 4y agoThose signs may seem scary, but they're just stating a basic fact that everyone already knows: If you commit copyright infringement, you have committed copyright infringement.
- margalabargala 4y agoThat's a relatively new development, though. Historically libraries were responsible for making copies of the works they held.
- cdev_gl 4y agoWhen I buy a physical book, I can lend that book to a friend. I own the book. When a library buys a physical book, they can loan that copy out to patrons. They own the physical book. For over ten years now, libraries have taken a single physical book, scanned it and removed the book from circulation, and lent out a single ebook. This has been a common practice founded on an interpretation of fair use laws, which allow format shifting (recording a vhs to DVD, for example) and lending, and also copyright laws which explicitly mention the legality of digitizing books for accessibility reasons, to serve the visually impaired. This "one physical book in storage equals one ebook" lending is the "controlled digital lending" the archive does, and is the issue at stake in this suit. Publishers argue that libraries should not be allowed to lend any ebook except those which they set a specific lending limit to- charging the library a fee every X number of checkouts or every X number of months. This is obviously not how lending physical books works- the library can buy a hardcover and loan it out to patrons, repairing the spine and binding over and over, eventually moving it to a special collection for viewing on site when it's hundreds of years old and can't be handled. As a seperate, and legally shaker issue, the internet archive created the "national emergency library" during the pandemic. The logic here was that nearly every library in the country was closed, there were within those libraries physical copies of these books that weren't being lent out, and so the same concept as controlled digital lending could apply. This move by the archive was signed onto and supported by thousands of libraries around the country, who agreed that their uncirculated physical copies could stand in for the extra copies checked out of the archives emergency library. It's important to note the archive does not loan any book published in the last five years, period. This is a self imposed limitation that your neighborhood library does not work under, but it means that the "lost sales" publishers allege were not of new books. Nobody ever got screwed out of bestseller status because too many library patrons read their book, and that goes doubly so in this case. All that said, the issue isn't whether the internet archive messed up with it's national emergency library. It's whether the whole concept of loaning a book is limited to printed copies, and thus ebooks must be repurchased by libraries ad nauseum-- or if libraries can keep a physical copy in a storage room and loan out a digital copy one at a time, exactly as they do now. Bottom line, our libraries (and especially their ebook collections) will be much poorer if this decision goes to publishers.
- 4y ago
- jw1224 4y agoFrom what I understand, they broke the terms of a legally-binding contract with the publishers. They were allowed to act as a “digital library” — and lend out copyrighted works for free — but only one “copy” of the file could be released at a time. This makes more sense for real-world libraries (where books are physical objects with manufacturing costs) but this doesn’t really translate to digital files. During the pandemic, when real-world libraries were shut, the Internet Archive took it upon themselves to give away an unlimited number of copyrighted works. Libraries are a net public good to society, and unexpectedly we found ourselves without them. The Internet Archive was uniquely positioned to share knowledge and educational materials with the world, free of charge, at a time when many people had no other access to them.
- sp332 4y agoThey do not have a contract with the publishers. Their normal CDL policy (one digital copy loaned out per physical book in the archive) is legal under fair use. The publishers also have a motion for summary judgement, which would prevent them from doing this. The publishers would rather rent them a digital copy for a lot of money, that is either time-limited or has a cap on the total number of times it can be checked out before the Archive would have to pay again.
- worik 4y agoThat is a good answer
- basilgohar 4y agoLegality and morality may be misaligned. It is important to never equate the two in a society of man made laws. This is doubly true when wealthy and powerful interests have so much ability to influence laws through legalized bribing (i.e., "lobbying").
- SamReidHughes 4y agoPiracy isn't for the greater good. Copyright is.
- teddyh 4y agoWell, that’s very much debatable: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_copyright https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_copyright http://www.dklevine.com/general/intellectual/againstfinal.htm http://www.dklevine.com/general/intellectual/againstfinal.ht...
- charonn0 4y agoThe greater good that both serve is the availability of creative works. Copyright serves it by rewarding authors of new creative works. Piracy serves it by increasing availability of existing creative works.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mistrial9 4y agoIA is not disregarding copyright, nor the publishers.. instead IA is changing the rules.. rules in which money does pay a role. A simple lens of conservative -> we want the rules to operate as they have, and liberal -> we want to change the rules .. might apply here. Casting aspersions with the land-mine word "piracy" does not increase the intellectual level of the discussion, nor is it even accurate here IMO.
- TylerE 4y agoSo, if I get pulled over doing 200, do I get to just tell the cop ‘I’m in a hurry, I changed the rules’.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- SamReidHughes 4y ago
- YPPH 4y agoA party applies for summary judgment to be entered when, speaking in very general terms, the other side's case is not reasonably arguable. That is, no reasonable jury/judge could find for the other party. It doesn't have anything to do with morals, it's a procedural process that avoids the need for an expensive trial to defend a hopeless claim. Of course, a party might lose a summary judgement application but ultimately win at trial.
- jw1224 4y agoThe general consensus I’ve read on HN is that the IA is pretty clearly guilty. But they’re the ones seeking the summary judgment in their own favour. Hence I respect their position, for taking a moral stance despite not having much of a legal leg to stand on.
- indymike 4y agoHN is generally a bad predictor of what courts will do.
- metadat 4y agoSee also the discussion from two days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32141358 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32141358 (713 points, 208 comments)
- colejohnson66 4y agoFor non lawyers: a request for summary judgment is something any lawyer will do, possibly multiple times in a case. And the vast majority of the time, they’re denied. It does not mean that their case is a slam dunk or anything; just that they want the judge to prematurely end the matter in their favor. It’s almost a useless motion, but because it has worked sometimes, your lawyer would be stupid to not try it. In other words, an article saying that a party requested summary judgment doesn’t really mean anything. I’m almost certain the other party filed one as well.
- sp332 4y agoThey did, and it's to prevent the Archive from lending out digital copies at all. https://www.eff.org/document/hachette-v-internet-archive-hachettes-memorandum-suimmary-judgment https://www.eff.org/document/hachette-v-internet-archive-hac...
- SnowHill9902 4y agoIt’s said that it avoids objections of inadequate counseling at a higher court. How true is that?
- tiahura 4y agoThat doesn’t sound “American”legal. In the US, summary judgment is a procedure used in civil cases, typically one party seeking money from the other. Ineffective assistance of counsel is a criminal concept.
- rhino369 4y agoNot for civil cases. To win on summary judgment, there essentially has to be no genuine dispute of facts. So you often do not bother filing for summary judgment. It's more appropriate when the dispute can be decided on purely legal grounds that don't need a juries input.
- kelnos 4y agoAh, so basically the Internet Archive is asking the judge, "hypothetically, assuming we did everything they are accusing us of, we assert that the law would still be on our side, yeah?" Whereas if the Internet Archive suspected what they were being accused of wasn't legal, summary judgement wouldn't be appropriate, and they might want to go to trial to try to prove their case that they aren't actually doing what they're being accused of?
- boomboomsubban 4y agoHuh, seeing their full argument written out makes the temporary CDL policy make a lot more sense. They were already contracting with other libraries to increase the amount of out-of-circulation copies they could lend, and with 90,000 libraries closed they assumed removing any restrictions would still keep them well under the amount of out-of-circulation copies available. And they were likely right, if "The Lion, The Witch, and The Wardrobe" only had 888 lends at most a few books would reach anywhere near the total out-of-circulation copies. It makes the publishers argument look less like "we were robbed" and more like "we should have made even more cash off the pandemic."
- O__________O 4y agoCDL being “Controlled Digital Lending”
- ctxc 4y agoThank you
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoCompare to Aereo which was leasing subscribers a dedicated antenna and DVR to distribute OTA television.
- jefftk 4y agoAnd famously lost in the Supreme Court: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Broadcasting_Cos.,_Inc._v._Aereo,_Inc https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Broadcasting_Cos.,_In....
- aidenn0 4y agoExcept libraries have special carve-outs for copyright, while the communications act requires broadcaster consent for "multichannel video programming distributors." Ultimately the lesson of Aereo is that it is incredibly difficult to predict court rulings when in anything close to a gray area. Aereo had a viable case after the Fox v. Cablevision precedent, but ultimately lost.
- sva_ 4y agoI think that the Internet Archive is one of the greatest libraries of human knowledge and internet culture in the world. Next to resources such as the Library Genesis, Sci-Hub, and probably the Wikipedia, these together might be the most important collections of human knowledge in the world. There's almost no-one else who has an incentive to archive that kind of information, if there isn't an economic incentive. And as soon as those primary sources go bankrupt, there's no-one to keep that data available. So I realize that this is a thorn to publishers, but I think that the interests of humanity far outweigh their personal financial incentives. I applaud all those, who put themselves into the line of fire of those who just care about themselves, rather than the goal to preseve the wealth of human knowledge. So thank you, to all of those who do, even in light of all the difficulties it might cause in your lives. Edit: I see these libraries similar to the library of Alexandria, which burnt down around 48 bc. People nowadays have the ability to preserve that knowledge, with equipment that isn't unattainable to the general public (especially with distributed storage). Not everyone, but a huge number of people can now prevent the next burning down of the biggest library in the world. And I think that's a great thing.
- AuthorizedHelp 4y ago
- ok_dad 4y agoIf it’s stealing then why isn’t anyone missing anything of value, other than the American public who couldn’t go to libraries for months? Fuck the publishers, whether or not their bought and paid for laws are with them in this.
- AuthorizedHelp 4y ago
- shkkmo 4y agoCopyright violation is not theft.
- bobsmooth 4y agoThe IA really messed up when they knowingly violated copyright. The best case scenario now is they pay a reasonable sum to the publishers that doesn't cause long term harm.
- scrollaway 4y ago
- hamsterbase 4y agoThat's why I choose to save the webpages as mhtml , webarchive. Then use the tools developed by myself to search, annotate, and read. All webpages is in my nas. keep them forever.
- O__________O 4y agoAre you archiving everything automatically or manually. If automatically, how so?
- lazyjeff 4y agoIf you want automatic archiving, check out https://irchiver.com/ https://irchiver.com/ for Windows. It runs on client-side so gets an archive from your point of view, i.e. including Facebook content and partially-filled out forms, etc.
- photochemsyn 4y agoI've used the IA library a few times, sometimes for textbooks. I wonder if the publishers aren't just trying to do this in the name of keeping control of their lucrative student textbook market (a lot of textbooks can be loaned out via IA, and they're all ridiculously overpriced, i.e. $150 for a book that has minimal value and yet is required to complete the coursework). It's really kind of pathetic, all the mechanisms the system has created to extract wealth from students and their parents. If you wanted to create evidence for the argument that investment capitalism is essentially parasitic, the whole 'higher education' program we've got in the USA could well be Exhibit A (Exhibit B being the health care program).
- kelnos 4y agoTextbooks are such a racket. Way overpriced for what they are, and then the resale market is often nonexistent, as new editions (which add/change very little, but professors will end up requiring) come out all the time and make the older ones worth nothing.
- tadfisher 4y agoI was poor in college, and couldn't afford the (up to) $250 per textbook. So, I cheated. I found the previous edition for cheap on Amazon, and looked up answers to the work sections on some cheating sites. I didn't do it for the answers, though; I did it to reverse-engineer the new question numbers. As in, the only difference between a $40 book and a $250 book was that the publisher had randomized the question order in the work sections. The worst one by far was one I could only find in Mandarin. Google Translate helped a ton, but it was missing about half of the questions, so I ended up photocopying part of a classmate's textbook to get them. This actually landed me in the Dean's office; apparently our library had a strict policy prohibiting the photocopying of textbooks. Luckily the dean was understanding, but I'll never forget the lesson: capitalism is a fucking bitch sometimes, and to play clean you have to be willing to get dirty.
- autoexec 4y ago> Luckily the dean was understanding Actual educators probably hate this shit almost as much as students do. Unauthorized learning should be not a punishable offense. I assume the professors who insist on the newest editions of textbooks are either getting kickbacks (certainly true when they wrote the book) or they were forced to by the school's policy and someone higher up is getting paid by publishers.
- shkkmo 4y agoA lot of people seem to have some confusion about what this lawsuit is about. This is not just a lawsuit about the NEL (National Emergency Library) initiative (which stands on shakier ground), but about the whole concept of CDL (Controlled Digital Lending). Publishers are trying to use ebooks to accomplish their long standing goal of collecting revenue each time a book is lent by a library. They have tried to get this added to copyright law for physical books by Congress multiple times and have failed. Large publishers refuse to sell libraries ebooks that can be lent out over and over, preferring instead to license ebooks with a limited number of lends or a fee per lend. With CDL, libraries scan their own physical books, remove those books from circulation, and lend that digital copy to one user (per book they own that is not circulating.) While publishers like to claim that CDL is an obvious copyright violation, it is untested legal ground as to whether CDL qualifies as fair use or not. To me, the ideal outcome is that courts uphold CDL as fair use, but holds the IA responsible for playing fast and loose with the NEL program.
- matwood 4y agoThis is a good summary. One other thing to note is that not all publishers are like the big 4-5. Many mid level and smaller publishers will sell libraries perpetual single use or sim use copies, sometimes after an embargo period.
- whatshisface 4y agoThe document argues that the NEL was fair use in IV. B. Here is part of what they say: >In those unique circumstances, the Internet Archive reasoned that the technical controls limiting the number of concurrent lends to the number of non-circulating copies Internet Archive or its partner libraries had on hand was not necessary. Id. ¶ 71. Given the massive number of books sitting idle on library shelves, doing so would not increase the number of copies of books in circulation above the number of copies libraries had bought and paid for. Id. ¶¶ 92–95. The Internet Archive still imposed the full array of other protections—lending books for limited periods, using DRM software to protect the books from being kept outside that loan period, and so on. Id. ¶¶ 34–35. And under those unique circumstances, lending books in that way was fair use. As with CDL, analysis of the data reflects that the publishers did not actually lose out on any revenues as a result of the NEL.
- EarlKing 4y agoNormally this would be the part where I give an insightful commentary on the nature of fair use, the various carve-outs for libraries, the balance of rights, and so on... but I just got done having to torrent something I paid good money for so frankly screw the publishers.
- sbr464 4y agoCould they capture the contents of the process and use the results to their advantage/argument? Or would it work against them? (I’m for archive.org, just curious).
- mgdlbp 4y agoMost of the other court documents from the case are available here: https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/17211300/hachette-book-group-inc-v-internet-archive/?order_by=desc https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/17211300/hachette-book-...
- autoexec 4y agoThat looks like an awful lot of billable hours have gone into this useless lawsuit already. I hope the costs of this isn't hurting archive's ability to keep doing what they do.
- Mindwipe 4y ago> I hope the costs of this isn't hurting archive's ability to keep doing what they do. It absolutely is. I hope the board will step down after they inevitably lose this case badly.
- 300bps 4y agoDear Copyright Holders: LeVe the Internet Archive alone. Sincerely, Everyone
- kelnos 4y agoMy worry here is that judges will not see it their way, and side with the publishing companies (if not now, then perhaps on appeal). The Internet Archive could end up facing massive legal fees and monetary judgments against them, causing them to shut down. Is the risk of loss of Archive.org itself worth the benefit of having this library lending program in the first place? Would it have been possible to "firewall" the lending group into its own entity, such that the rest of Internet Archive would be protected from something legally catastrophic happening?
- cratermoon 4y ago"Imagine there was no such thing as a library, and that members of the current neoliberal policy consensus were to sit down today and invent it. They might create complicated tax expenditures to subsidize the poor purchasing and reselling books, like the wage support of the earned income tax credit. They might require people to rent books from approved private libraries, with penalties for those who don’t and vouchers for those who can’t afford it, like the individual mandate in the latest expansion of health care. They might come up with a program where they take on liability for books that go missing from private libraries and thereby boost profits for lenders themselves, like federally backed private student loans. Or maybe they’d create means-tested libraries only accessible to the poor, with a requirement that patrons document how impoverished they are month after month to keep their library card. Maybe they’d exempt the cost of private library cards from payroll taxes, or let anything calling itself a library pay nothing in taxes." https://www.dissentmagazine.org/online_articles/citizen-coupon https://www.dissentmagazine.org/online_articles/citizen-coup...
- dang 4y agoRelated: Tell HN: Internet Archive is facing a Big 4 Publishers lawsuit - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32141358 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32141358 - July 2022 (209 comments) Activists rally to save Internet Archive as lawsuit threatens site (2020) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31703394 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31703394 - June 2022 (32 comments) Help preserve the internet with Archiveteam's warrior - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30524842 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30524842 - March 2022 (51 comments) Internet Archive responds to publishers’ lawsuit - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23998115 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23998115 - July 2020 (348 comments) My thoughts in response to the lawsuit against the Internet Archive - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23931183 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23931183 - July 2020 (232 comments) EFF and heavyweight legal team will defend Internet Archive against publishers - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23691297 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23691297 - June 2020 (263 comments) Activists rally to save Internet Archive as lawsuit threatens site - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23485182 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23485182 - June 2020 (393 comments) Lawsuit over online book lending could bankrupt Internet Archive - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23391662 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23391662 - June 2020 (260 comments) Publishers File Suit Against Internet Archive - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23379775 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23379775 - June 2020 (346 comments) Internet Archive responds: Why we released the National Emergency Library - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22731472 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22731472 - March 2020 (145 comments) Internet Archive’s National Emergency Library Harms Authors - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22716923 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22716923 - March 2020 (48 comments)
- drallison 4y agoArchive.org (the Internet Archive) is doing important, critical work to build and maintain an archival copy of everything. If you have not used the system, spend some time and discover the gems that are included in its collection. https://archive.org https://archive.org Offer suggestions and get involved. On July 15th I attended the Archive Open House and spoke with Brewster about the ambitious plans through the coming year and the next few decades. There is a lot that needs to be done. The Archive needs your moral, political, and monetary support. To donate: https://archive.org/donate https://archive.org/donate .