4 ms·
THIS, but even more so. Electric ships sound cool, but shipping is giga-scale global infrastructure. The mines, battery factories, electric motors, dockside e
by bell-cot 4y ago
THIS, but even more so. Electric ships sound cool, but shipping is giga-scale global infrastructure. The mines, battery factories, electric motors, dockside equipment, etc. needed to do this at scale don't exist. If they did, the national power grids sitting behind most major ports could not reliably take the additional load.
So, yes, start small. As in: "Here is one self-contained, mostly self-managing battery, inside one cargo container. We'll modify the electrical system on one ship, so that this battery can connect to it, and looks (electrically, and to the ship's control systems) like one extra generator in the engine room. Once we see how well that works, and fix round 1 of bugs and crew training issues, then we'll try to scale up to 10 ships."
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoMaybe we could build out the ships, the battery factories, the dockside equipment, the new generation capacity and the grid upgrades at the same time? Is it really a problem that the dockside equipment doesn't exist if the electric boats don't exist either? We'll all feel foolish if we turn round in the year 2050 with a global fleet of electric container ships ready to go and then we start arguing about who was supposed to build the sockets to plug them in.
- treeman79 4y agoCalifornia can’t even build a train that’s useful without blowing obscene amounts of money. https://www.forbes.com/sites/chuckdevore/2020/02/26/californias-high-speed-rail-project-devolving-from-political-pork-to-an-ego-monument-to-trump-resistance/amp/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/chuckdevore/2020/02/26/californ...
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoBig things cost a lot of money. I expect better arguments than "$X billion is a lot of money" and "theyre only doing it to spite Trump" if someone wants to argue against a big infrastructure project. Rail is a good and useful thing. The USA should probably have more of it. I have no real knowledge about this specific project, but my priors are that any "crazy", "green" project from California is perfectly fine, sensible governance that is probably saving lives, the environment and money, and that the people screaming about it don't know what they are talking about. But I'm open to credible info to the contrary. (A quick glance at Wikipedia tells me that the people of California think it's a good idea, and that the people who don't are generally older and republican leaning, which pretty much meshes with my priors, so I'm fairly confident it's a good thing overall).
- treeman79 4y agoBy this logic we shouldn’t question how much we spend for anything.
- MontyCarloHall 4y agoCalifornia HSR is projected to cost $100B for 500 miles. That’s $200M/mile. By comparison, the 160 mile LGV Méditerranée in France cost €3.8B in 2001 [0]. That’s roughly €25M/mile. Even after accounting for exchange rates and inflation, that’s still roughly an order of magnitude cheaper. Yes, big things cost a lot of money, but they shouldn’t cost 10x more what they cost in other industrialized countries. High speed rail is great, but it should not be funded with a blank check. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGV_Méditerranée https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGV_Méditerranée
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoI glanced at Wikipedia earlier to learn about the California project and they claim that despite costing x2 or x3 what similar European and Chinese efforts cost, that's mostly due to the cost of land and 3 mountain ranges being in the way. It also mentions that it's costing less per mile than HS2 in London. So if this is extravagant waste, it's not that extravagant.
- MontyCarloHall 4y ago>I glanced at Wikipedia earlier to learn about the California project and they claim that despite costing x2 or x3 what similar European and Chinese efforts cost This is based on an outdated cost estimate that's roughly 2x lower than the current projected cost. From Wikipedia: >In July 2014, The World Bank reported that the per kilometer cost of California's high-speed rail system was $56 million, more than double the average cost of $17–21 million per km of high speed rail in China and more than the $25–39 million per km average for similar projects in Europe at the time. That was in 2014. Costs have ballooned 2x to $125M/km; this has not happened in Europe or China. >the cost of land and 3 mountain ranges being in the way If you want to control for mountain ranges, consider the Suseo–Pyeongtaek branch of Korea's high speed rail network, opened in 2016. It's a 38 mile line, 31 of which are in a 50 meter deep tunnel. It cost ₩4.18T (approximately $3.2B), which comes out to ~$85M per mile. Again, 80% of the line is in a 50 meter deep tunnel. That's still less than half the cost per mile of California HSR, which will not be 80% underground. There is simply no excuse for the inflated costs of CHSR. >It also mentions that it's costing less per mile than HS2 in London. So if this is extravagant waste, it's not that extravagant. HS2 is notorious for being a boondoggle with massive cost overruns. Not exactly a flattering thing to compare to.
- bell-cot 4y agoPerhaps...in an ideal world, with a centrally planned economy, and extremely powerful central authority. OTOH, recent history suggests that centrally planned economies don't work all that well, especially when they attempt complex "great leap forward" projects. The reality is that global shipping is controlled by huge patchwork of corporations, political authorities, etc. Most of them very focused on the short-term. And greedy for money, power, & political benefits. Similar for the national power grids, mining industry, battery industry, ...
- tomatotomato37 4y agoBarring internal labor politics, infrastructure immediately near docks and rail shouldn't be an issue to upgrade as the sheer scale of modern cargo vehicles means you could get all the resources for such in a single load. Also I believe most ships are "hybrids" anyway, in that their props are driven by motors directly connected to generators on their engines, since when you are dealing with engines that are literally two stories tall creating a matching gearbox becomes quite difficult. As such the biggest pain point will be battery capacity, but if we are willing to forgo the logistical difficulties of super-massive ships can be brute-forced with lower quality batteries in even more massive ships.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Scoundreller 4y agoWhile trains are typically hybrids like that, I don’t think ships are. So they’re optimized for cruise and horribly inefficient while accelerating or decelerating. But it’s a propeller in water so it just spins inoptimally which isn’t as bad as a steel wheel doing the same.