5 ms·
The Art of Abduction
- texaslonghorn5 4y agoBook title is a bit startling/clickbaity, so here's a bit of the summary for context: > A novel defense of abduction, one of the main forms of nondeductive reasoning. With this book, Igor Douven offers the first comprehensive defense of abduction, a form of nondeductive reasoning. Abductive reasoning, which is guided by explanatory considerations, has been under normative pressure since the advent of Bayesian approaches to rationality.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- actually_a_dog 4y ago"A novel defense of abductive reasoning" would be a better choice of titles all around.
- _jal 4y agoI was hoping for some edgy economic model wherein ransoms were pareto-efficient or something, but this was fun, too.
- gnicholas 4y agoI'm thinking more Coase than Pareto for that particular scenario.
- chrnola 4y agoInteresting cover choice for that title too.
- asdftemp 4y agoif hoofprints in snow were legible as a book cover, an allusion to the Name of the Rose would be even better :)
- jfarmer 4y agoThat'd be doubly appropriate since Umberto Eco said that C.S. Peirce "is undoubtedly the greatest unpublished writer of our century." Peirce's Notion of Interpretant (1976) https://www.jstor.org/stable/2907146 https://www.jstor.org/stable/2907146
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dagipflihax0r 4y agoIt's a lot of words. People who cannot explain things well tend to use a lot of words. The author cannot explain things well. You just witnessed the art of abduction! (Just kidding. It's worth knowing what abduction is and recognizing it.)
- aaron695 4y ago
- routerl 4y agoThe types of reasoning: 1. Deduction - given premises and inferential rules, produces conclusions; as certain as possible. 2. Induction - given premises and conclusions, produces inferential rules; statistically probable, but a single counterfactual observation means throwing out the whole thing (e.g. black swans). 3. Abduction - given conclusions and inferential rules, produces premises; no guarantee of certainty. Any time we retrospectively tell a story of how something came to be, that we did not immediately observe, we're applying abductive reasoning. It relies on the same inferential rules as deduction and induction, but applied in reverse.
- riedel 4y agoThanks, never thought about it this way: It seems like the NP of reasoning. If you know the solution everything seems much easier.
- michael_j_ward 4y agoFor others like me that wondered "Wait is proof by induction not induction?" > Although its name may suggest otherwise, mathematical induction should not be confused with inductive reasoning as used in philosophy (see Problem of induction). The mathematical method examines infinitely many cases to prove a general statement, but does so by a finite chain of deductive reasoning involving the variable n, which can take infinitely many values. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematical_induction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematical_induction
- ebingdom 4y agoI think there might be a loose connection. When you want to prove something using mathematical induction, you must come up with an "induction hypothesis". This requires cleverness which could possibly be described as the product of inductive reasoning (in the philosophical sense). Essentially it amounts to finding a general principle that can be specialized to prove each of the inductive steps. The main difference to me is that, with inductive reasoning (in the philosophical sense), you converge on a general principle but it might be wrong—it is only probable. Mathematical induction is the tool needed to close the gap—to turn a hypothesis which could be wrong into a bulletproof mathematical theorem. Of course, if your induction hypothesis didn't turn out to be right, you won't be able to complete the proof. I use the Coq theorem prover to write induction proofs all the time, and often you have to try out different induction hypotheses until you get one that finally works. The process my brain goes through to come up with these induction hypotheses feels like "inductive reasoning" in the philosophical sense as I understand it.
- civilized 4y agoI've long felt that Bayesian logic is the formal undergirding of abductive reasoning, so I'd like to know what abductive reasoning is supposed to be over and above Bayes rule + decision theory.
- zwkrt 4y agoHuh, I didn’t know about abduction. It’s the form of logic that you use if you play Wordle. You can’t prove that you have the right answer, only that your answer explains everything that you see.
- pjscott 4y agoThat sounds strictly inferior to Bayesian reasoning (both to me and to my Wordle program), so I’m curious what advantages abduction has, if any. (If there are philosophers reading this: do you have any good, non-paywalled links defending abduction from the usual Bayesian criticism?)
- stu2b50 4y agoThe book that is the parent submission is classified as "open" and you can click on the pdfs for each section to, well, read each section. It seems as good a source about the benefits of abduction as any.
- pjscott 4y agoOh! I had assumed that it was closed. Thanks!
- geysersam 4y agoCould it be more computationally tractable compared to Baysian inference?
- zwkrt 4y agoDo you think that abduction is just a more realistic name for “bayesian inference where I had to make up some of my own priors”? To computer program, playing Wordle seems like a perfect application of completely solid bayesian inference. All the data is there, the space is finite. But humans have to at some level resort to abductive reasoning since we can’t do all that math in our heads. Most people that play wordle would just tell you “this guess felt like the right one”
- ARandomerDude 4y agoI thought this was going to be an article about kidnapping. It wasn't.
- bschne 4y agoFrom the introduction :) > 1.1 Why You Should Want to Know About Abduction > If you are consulting this book with malicious intent, looking for ways to expand your criminal pursuits, I encourage you to stop reading and to better your life. (...)
- voidhorse 4y agoLooks like an interesting book. I’ve heard abduction described as “analogical reasoning” or “metaphorical reasoning” which is definitely not as rigid as deduction or induction but arguably more important—without analogies I’d doubt we’d ever learn anything. If you’re interested in the topic check out the works of Charles Sanders Pierce (he coined the term abduction). He was a logician and semiotician and is still criminally underrated. Other than Wittgenstein, he’s pretty much the only logician I’m aware of who extensively wrote compellingly about topics outside of logic and was able to make logic itself feel relevant and meaningful in everyday life. Most logicians/analytical philosophers are either entirely silent on other topics or fall completely flat when they attempt to venture beyond logical subjects. (there are others too, Russell sort of comes to mind, as well as a few others, but Wittgenstein and Pierce are in a class of their own. They are the two writers who I feel not only helped me understand some concept in a field but actually profoundly altered how I think about thinking—I guess I’d include Heinz von Foerster in this category too)
- motohagiography 4y agoMost of my comments are abductive reasoning but I call it breadth first reasoning or fearless ignorance, where an analogy potentially has a similar superficial "shape," and that shape could be a homomorphism in more formal contexts that gives you a fast path to hypothesis about what must also exist if the analogy were consistent. It's irritating to people with depth in a field because it ignores their concrete tools and experience and presents them with hypothesis' without any direct experience. Cranks usually think abductively as well, and what makes the difference is enough physical domain competence to use it well instead of just baffling other laymen and annoying more knowledgable people. If I'm interpreting correctly.
- totetsu 4y agoMy university philosophy 101 critical reasoning course taught us to use this kind of abduction or reverse deduction to take the conclusion of somebody's argument and infer what premises might be needed to support it but are not being stated or are hidden or unexamined. A a very useful skill when in discussion with someone else who studied critical reasoning X'D
- jonathanstrange 4y agoWe've been working on abduction at our institute for a while. My take on it is that there is no abduction as a logical inference. Although he portrayed it as a third type of inference in some of his writings, C.S. Peirce thought the same, he emphasized many times that abduction is indeed an art and ultimately a psychological phenomenon. The problem with abduction is that it doesn't have a justificatory value on a par with those of deduction and induction. Deduction forms the basis of mathematics and is basic enough to be intuitively acceptable when you learn logic. In turn, induction is mostly justified deductively. Finite discrete probability theory is purely deductive. Under the assumption that a process is stochastic (e.g. that a die is fair when it is thrown), probabilities follow deductively. Probability theory for infinite and uncountable domains are straightforward generalizations. There are only few leaps of faith when doing inductive inference, (1) when you transfer conclusions from a smaller to a larger population, (2) apply the law of large numbers, or (3) make reasonable guesses about an underlying probability distribution. There is no such justification for abduction. Even just hypothesis generation, the narrow sense of "abduction", is way more complicated than induction and deduction. Theory selection, the broader aspect of "abduction" that has been labeled "inference to the best explanation" since Harman's horrible 1965 paper, is even more complicated. Both IBE and abduction require and involve deductive and inductive reasoning, but there is no indication that they can be fully justified deductively and inductively. The best you may get is an account that describes some form of theory discovery as a logical or probabilistic description of a supposed cognitive mechanism, and then the discovered theory might be proved deductively or confirmed inductively. Defenders of abduction have claimed that we select hypotheses not just on the basis of their likelihood but also based on other properties like theory virtues ("loveliness" in Lipton's terms). That might be true but doesn't concern the justificatory value of the inference. In the end, the only hypotheses we're interested in (and should be interested in, from an epistemic point of view) are the ones that are most likely to be true. Hence, theory virtues, loveliness, plausibility, etc., all just have a justificatory value insofar as they increase the subjective probability that a hypothesis is true, and in that respect they are really just heuristics. Some Bayesian takes on abduction and IBE get this right and I have nothing against them. I just wanted to mention that many, if not the majority of philosophers of science do not consider abduction a third type of inference and fairly skeptical about it, for the above reasons and a few more.
- rbanffy 4y agoThe title made me think of Pixar’s Lifted. https://youtu.be/LVLoc6FrLi0 https://youtu.be/LVLoc6FrLi0
- throwaway81523 4y agoFor those of you wondering what abduction is, the wikipedia article is decent. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abductive_reasoning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abductive_reasoning
- teekert 4y agoIt looks like an ebook that is free, is there a epub to download somewhere?
- tpoacher 4y agomy 2 cents: Deduction: p( C | do(P,R) ) Induction: p( C | do(P), R ) Abduction: p( P | do(C), R ) where C stands for conclusion, P for premises, R for prior assumptions / remaining possible statements in the universe of discourse not covered by the premises and conclusion. Deduction can only take values in {0,1}. Deductive arguments are valid when that probability is 1, invalid when that probability is 0, sound when do(P,R) can be shown to be 1, and unsound when it cannot. Typically when trying to show that do(P,R)=1, we may assume or try to show that it can be simplified to do(P). Whether it can or not is often the source of soundness errors. Inductive arguments are effectively probabilistic reasoning about the posterior probability of the conclusion (i.e. a process equivalent to Bayesian inference, with regard to statements in the universe of discourse and their probability). Abductive arguments are statements of [high] likelihood, with the intent of exploring/generating/identifying [high-likelihood] data (i.e. useful premises). It can be compared to Maximum Likelihood Estimation in statistics. Quite often, R is simplified to be null (i.e., the universe of discourse is limited to only what we already know). The intent is typically to generate a subset of premises to act as a new, more manageable universe of discourse for subsequent deductive or inductive reasoning, when the original full universe of discourse would be intractable.