5 ms·
Electricity generation is also affected by weather in two ways. Firstly, by the droop in the wires which are built to weather tolerances much as railways are, a
by ggm 4y ago
Electricity generation is also affected by weather in two ways. Firstly, by the droop in the wires which are built to weather tolerances much as railways are, and if you get outside the tolerances then the risks of problems increase.
Secondly, within a limit of my understanding, the efficiency of a turbine system hot-to-cold is affected by the climate it operates in. The ambient temperature, humidity and pressure affects the final stage.
Both things might mean that in times of high heat and humidity, the electricity supply system is least able to cope with increased demands for cooling systems, which will themselves draw more power fighting the weather.
Separately the HVAC systems for the DCs will have been designed for a specific climate, with margins. I guess the sustained change in night and daytime temps and humidity has hurt their efficiency too, in this window of time. They'll be fine when the weather system passes through, as will the supply network.
Met Office says both overnight and daytime peak temps for the inland south have been records. Thats where a lot of ICT infrastructure is.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Scoundreller 4y agoWe’re also just under a month from the summer solstice (in N. Hemisphere: June 21). London is at 51 degrees North, so the day is pretty long at 16 hours right now. IE: less of that relieving overnight low.
- mnd999 4y agoFortunately it rained last night and the temperature dropped pretty quickly.
- kumarvvr 4y ago> Secondly, within a limit of my understanding, the efficiency of a turbine system hot-to-cold is affected by the climate it operates in. The ambient temperature, humidity and pressure affects the final stage. Usually this is only partially true. Systems have enough margin to account for such conditions (cooling pumps have to pump more water to compensate for higher temps). Also to note that the output of a turbine can be kept constant. Only the efficiency will come down slightly.
- ggm 4y agoI wasn't sure about the slightly. What I read elsewhere indicated that for safety reasons, gas and coal fired steam turbines back off load when the ambient heat rises. I had assumed it was the output cool/evaporate efficiency but it might be something else.
- tjmc 4y ago> Separately the HVAC systems for the DCs will have been designed for a specific climate, with margins. Exactly right. For a Tier IV data centre that margin is ASHRAE N=20. For London City until recently that was only 34.5C (dry bulb).
- bschne 4y agoInteresting rabbit hole! Does that mean the margin is defined to contain once-in-twenty-years extremes?
- tjmc 4y agoThat’s right. However these estimates are now being regularly exceeded. Going forward, it would probably be wiser to do what the mining industry does here in Australia - still design to a reasonable extreme temp, but also specify that the equipment must run at a much higher temperature at a derated capacity. Here that’s 50C ambient.
- fulafel 4y agoEven disregarding climate change, a 5% chance each year that your equipment will fail to handle the weather seems lacking for a high-availability facility. (You'll factor in many other this type of figures together, so your total risk budget would be higher still).
- ThePadawan 4y agoThirdly, there's also drought related issues - here in Switzerland, a nuclear power station had to reduce its capacity because it could not take in enough water from the local river without endangering the fish stock therein.
- asdff 4y agoSo many governments, agencies, orgs, etc, are getting caught with their pants down with changing climate bringing more extreme weather conditions, because capitalism favors maximizing profit and considering tolerances too wide as an expense. It's cathartic seeing the capitalists lack of foresight burn them time again, but also sad, knowing the response to this will be just buying slightly better HVAC and other systems, which will be globally sourced no doubt and burn carbon to produce and probably damage some ecosystems in the resource gathering process. Then when temperatures get even hotter its time to buy new systems etc. Once again capitalism favors this outcome, because it allows multiple sales opportunities over time with the potential to increase monetization at every one, versus buying one system that can handle wider temperature swings and being done with it potentially forever if its made to be repairable/upgradeable. Even if you invented such a thing and sold it out of your garage, GE or whoever your competitors would be would ensure you have difficulty sourcing necessary parts or coming to market or getting word out to your potential customer base. Investors you need to afford to grow under these conditions would expect you to play the game and start cutting costs and engage in the rat race, or be replaced. It's going to be hard to work our way out of climate change with the degenerate, consumptive nature of capitalism mining the planet while sucking resources from the wider economy where this salvation is to be invented, to the top that will always be able to afford to hole up and hide away from whatever disasters befall the working people.
- qeternity 4y agoYou can blame capitalism all you want, but the issue is deeper. This is a well studied market failure called tragedy of the commons. People and markets have not been paying the true cost of their consumption, which has resulted in overconsumption of fossil fuels. Your whole premise ignores the billions of people who happily use electricity and fuel everyday and happily ignore the consequences. These same people then (literally) riot when prices go up by a relatively small amount. People are greedy. They want more for less. We can disagree about the best form of economic association, but it’s disingenuous to ignore the reality that climate change is driven by the masses.
- nicoburns 4y ago
- usrusr 4y agoSounds like yet another argument for investing in that energy storage low-hanging fruit of thermal reservoirs. Datacenter cooling does not need a huge delta from ambient, the advantage of pumping against nighttime ambient over pumping against daytime ambient would be huge. Datacenter cooling should be dispatchable demand.
- baxtr 4y agoWhat does that mean? Could you expand on that?
- corint 4y agoAt a guess, it'd mean building large slabs of concrete, or tanks of water, or other cheap item with large thermal inertia. Ideally you'd cool these down overnight, or at a period with cheap power, then under regular external temperatures you'd use these to reduce the need for cooling at periods of high power cost. Or, when it's very warm outside, these would work in tandem with the cooling systems to cope with a hot day, with the hope being that overnight you'd catch up, without needing to interrupt workloads.
- bob1029 4y agoI feel like we could do this for homes & businesses too... How big of a thermal battery (assume we are freezing water) would you need to store the cooling capacity of a 5 ton HVAC system running for 1 summer day? Perhaps we could design a new generation of heat pumps with this approach in mind.
- usrusr 4y agoKey difference: homes and small businesses buy electricity at a fixed rate, large datacenters are big enough for dynamic prices. In a market that doesn't completely abandon fixed rate prices this isn't really possible for smaller customers, because offering dynamic rates requires some trust that the consumer doesn't abuse the fixed rate by dynamically selecting whatever is cheaper at the time. This trust can only be established for consumers large enough for people checking the numbers and perhaps even the occasional audit.