7 ms·
I just did a two week long back country road campervan trip from Tahoe down south through each of the forests... Stanislaus, Yosemite, Sierra, Kings, Sequoia. I
by latchkey 4y ago
I just did a two week long back country road campervan trip from Tahoe down south through each of the forests... Stanislaus, Yosemite, Sierra, Kings, Sequoia. It was amazing boondocking in the middle of nowhere, no cell signal and taking baths in what is left of the rivers and lakes...
Once you get past Yosemite, pretty much all of the reservoirs are empty to less than half full. Majority of the streams are gone.
It gets worse the further you head south. Kings and Sequoia are pretty much decimated forests from the fires and beetles. Dead trees for as far as you can see. Given the lack of water, I expect them to be desert in just a few more years.
There are quite a few hydro power generation stations deep in the mountains that I had no idea existed. I suspect they will close down as well. I wonder what effect that will have on California power supply over the coming years. That said, it was pretty clear that PG&E is working on updating the infrastructure as they are all over the place working on things.
If I hadn't seen it for myself, I wouldn't believe it. The extent of damage is pretty massive and it would take quite a lot of rain to 'fix' things. So much so that it would probably end up just flooding everything, creating just as much of a mess.
- DoneWithAllThat 4y agoThis is straight up hyperbole. No, those areas are not going to deserts in the next few years, or even our lifetimes.
- latchkey 4y agoI'm not saying all of the areas I went through are going to desert... but if you look at the extent of the damaged areas, I doubt that you're going to see the same forests come back again in our lifetimes. Take a look at the Pine Ridge area. As far as the eye can see, everything is gone. Driving through Sequoia, huge swaths of the trees are gone. It is 100+ degrees in the summers and no water...
- kortilla 4y agoNo water is the norm for these trees. A dam system built by humans has no bearing on that.
- thrown_22 4y agoThe Western US is a semi-arid desert: https://physicstoday.scitation.org/do/10.1063/pt.6.1.20180801a/full/ https://physicstoday.scitation.org/do/10.1063/pt.6.1.2018080... We have historic evidence that droughts have destroyed civilizations in that part of the country before. It is happening again.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 8bitsrule 4y agoVery good article, with several illustrative cites going back to 1979. The west is dominated by the [0] [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intermontane_Plateaus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intermontane_Plateaus] , much of it losing water since the pluvial lakes like [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lake_Bonneville https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lake_Bonneville] reached its greatest height 18000 years ago. "The abandoned shore lines have yielded evidence of past climatic changes second in importance only to those of the Pleistocene glaciated areas."[0] A lot of snow falls in the winter, but for a century the meltwater has had plenty of mouths to feed. A lot of the distribution plans have been based on only a couple centuries of experience.
- the_third_wave 4y agoWell, there is that ocean on the left coast which theoretically can provide all the water needed to avert problems. There is also that sun in the sky which could provide power for the desalination plants needed to turn that salty sea water into fresh water. The resulting brine contains a number of harvestable minerals as well so given the incentive there would be a possibility to stave of desertification of at least parts of the area - something which was not possible to those previous populations which got decimated by this cycle.
- SkittyDog 4y agoYou should read "Cadillac Desert", if you live in the American Southwestern state--California, Arizona, and Nevada in particular. It has significant implications for the future survivability of large-scale civilization in the region. Mark Reisner originally wrote the book in the early 1990s, and his predictions have turned out to be quite accurate over the last three decades. If you want to make informed decisions, as a voter and a resident, this is probably the single most important thing you need to get educated about.
- kortilla 4y agoIt’s hyperbolic trash though. What is happening to the Colorado river has been predicted as a possibility since the dams were built. It has absolutely no implications for the survivability of large scale civilizations in the area because the vast majority of the water goes to farming. Residential and office usage is willing to pay far more than farmers and uses significantly less. The flow rate of the Colorado river could drop by another 70% and still support everyone living here (socal, az, nv). The instance things get a little dire, farmer rights will be stripped away by the voters, they’ll pay market rate like everyone else, and the problem will be solved overnight.
- SkittyDog 4y ago> It’s hyperbolic trash though. This is rude, and unnecessary. If your own counter-argument is actually sound, why are you bothering to label Reisner's as trash? It doesn't make you more believable--it mostly just undermines your credibility, because you apparently don't trust the soundness of your arguments to stand on their own. Have you read the HN comment guidelines? I'll quote something that you might want to consider: > When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names. "That is idiotic; 1 + 1 is 2, not 3" can be shortened to "1 + 1 is 2, not 3." Right now, I have zero interest in engaging with you, because of the unpleasantly combatitive way you've chosen to approach the topic. What would even be the point of trying to have a discussion with someone who believes it's OK to speak to strangers like this? Consider rewriting your comment, and maybe we can talk about the actual merits of Reisner... As it is now, good luck, and I hope you learn a better way to interact with the world.
- ColFrancis 4y ago> Majority of the streams are gone. In Australia that's typical for many reasons. Are you sure they're not just seasonal flows?
- parrellel 4y agoNah, there's a whole ton of hydro that's been entirely consistent until now that is dropping off and messing things up. Shit the utilities have never even had to bother considering failing is approaching drop dead lines. Depending on rain August could be fun.
- steve_adams_86 4y agoEven here in wet Vancouver Island, British Columbia we have heaps of streams that are mostly gone by July. They are rain fed, the rain goes away, it’s just how some systems work. I’m not saying everything is fine with the environment. Just, this is to be expected with a large number of streams in the world. Maybe it’s not alarming in each case.
- katbyte 4y agoAre you sure you don’t mean snow fed? Lots of roaring rivers while it’s melting and then once the melt is done many shrink/nearly dry up. Thou we have a ton of snowpack this year on the coast still
- steve_adams_86 4y agoThere are both, but we have many lower mountains that rarely get snow, let alone snow pack, but they have seasonal streams that can be quite large at the bottom of the water shed. A decent example would be the French creek watershed by Nanaimo. I think it’s estimated that only 15% of the flow is from snow, with most of that portion flowing during spring. The rest is rain, mostly from higher up in the watershed. This watershed doesn’t dry up entirely, but it naturally reduces dramatically by July with many of its tributaries vanishing completely. There are many like it without that 15% melt water, some of which mostly vanish under the bed rock and gravel depositions along the creek beds. Unfortunately that’s also increasingly true, and it’s causing all kinds of species to die in watersheds that previously even supported multiple seasons of salmon runs. The last paper I read on French Creek suggested even swamps in the watershed were drying too much, killing insects and amphibians. Many streams have lost entire salmon runs due to drying too much, too often. It’s a fragile system. It seems like deforestation plays a major role in these watersheds drying out.
- Melatonic 4y agoThis is super hyperbolic - the higher up you go the more chance there is for there to be water. We had a low snow year so everything around public roads will be drier. End of the summer lots of this stuff is dry anyways. Did you do any hikes that went up to higher elevations? Have you been through this area before to know what it typically looks like? I agree its a bad year but this is not becoming a desert anytime soon
- katbyte 4y agoEnd of summer? That’s still 2ish months away.. Here in the pnw I’m still waiting for the snowpack to melt in the alpine, 1m+ In places At around 1250m.
- Bilal_io 4y agoIt really depends on where you are. The Oxford dictionary defines midsummer as June 27th. But looking at California temperature as an example, I would assume midsummer would be early July. But I am not a meteorologist nor a farmer. So it's safe to assume we're already in the second half of summer in most states.
- Workaccount2 4y agoMidsummer is a holiday, not "middle of summer". Midsummer also happens at the beginning of summer.
- katbyte 4y agoSummer is defined at June July August, we are officially just over half way with 50 days left and not close to the end of summer by any definition.
- ghouse 4y agoI just got back from a long hike in Rocky Mountain National Park outside of Estes Park, CO. Most of the hike was above treeline. We spotted a heard of elk and a local with whom I was hiking told me the elk were up there because the area had some late rain; normally that tundra is all brown by July. In the late 80s and early 90s I hiked that area every summer. I don't recall the tundra grass ever brown in July.
- ransom1538 4y agoNorth is different. Union Valley Reservoir is full. American River is high.
- latchkey 4y agoYou're right, there was a definite difference north of Yosemite. I think that is what was most striking to me.
- kortilla 4y agoReservoir levels have zero relationship to trees. Conflating all of these things just comes across as “city person went outside and fit every observable into existing tiny model of world”.
- lars512 4y agoIf you consider drought a common cause, then a potential relationship is there.
- tjr225 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Beefin 4y agoif anyone wants to learn to build their own camper van, i've documented my entire build out and navigation on a similar trip as op: http://vanlifecoder.com/ http://vanlifecoder.com/
- Beefin 4y agowe've just wrapped up a record breaking snowfall, el nino i believe. it takes time for water to rebuild, unfortunately the question is if the consumption will outpace the accumulation.