3 ms·
I thought the wording was clear, but I meant doing it with no chance of getting stuck in an error state. Finite money can't properly implement a martingale. I
by Dylan16807 4y ago
I thought the wording was clear, but I meant doing it with no chance of getting stuck in an error state.
Finite money can't properly implement a martingale. It can implement this strategy.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoBoth are simply strategies with downsides. This strategy is just as broken. Properly applied to betting it goes broke in the long run too. it is identical to proportional betting, a strategy that makes no money on average with an infinite bankroll, and will eventually bankrupt you with a finite one. The description is also flawed in the blog. If anyone offers you a 50/50 bet to win $50 or lose $33,take it. Given that it's posted by financial advisors , The blog is probably intentionally misleading
- Dylan16807 4y ago> Both are simply strategies with downsides. This strategy is just as broken. A strategy like "always bet 10% of your bankroll on a coin flip" doesn't break. Whether it makes or loses money in the long run depends on the specific returns, but you can keep doing it indefinitely. You can't keep doing a martingale indefinitely. Bad luck doesn't just lose you money, it makes the strategy itself explode. Once that happens you can't recover even if you have good luck or a house edge.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoThe same happens when you apply real world standards to a 10% bet. You eventually will go below the minimum bet with an infinite sample size. Martingale eventually stops because you don't have an infinite bankroll. Proportional betting eventually stops if you can't gamble less than a penny. Neither strategy can give long-term profit on a neutral EV bet
- Dylan16807 4y ago> The same happens when you apply real world standards to a 10% bet. You eventually will go below the minimum bet with an infinite sample size. If the EV is exactly neutral, that's never going to happen in the real world. While martingale will fail moderately quickly in most setups. And saying "ignore minimum bets" is far less egregious than "pretend you have infinite money". Also neither strategy is specific to neutral EV.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoEven martingale can be pretty sustainable in the right real world conditions. Your chances of going bankrupt are like 1 in a million of you content playing penny games with a 10K bankroll. I think the more interesting and testable question is about the claims of turning Neutral EV games profitable. for example, the blogs claim that proportional betting can do just that, turn neutral EV coinflip profitable. It only holds up with a number of bogus and unstated conditions.
- Dylan16807 4y ago> Even martingale can be pretty sustainable in the right real world conditions. Your chances of going bankrupt are like 1 in a million of you content playing penny games with a 10K bankroll. But it fails for any bet where you'd care about the money, unlike this strategy. > for example, the blogs claim that proportional betting can do just that, turn neutral EV coinflip profitable. It only holds up with a number of bogus and unstated conditions. There's different kinds of expectation. The EV for a single iteration is positive, but the EV for leaving money invested indefinitely is neutral. This makes the title somewhat misleading, but it's still an interesting question. How can you make money in a compounding way when basic reinvestment cuts your returns to zero? There are no unstated conditions that I can see. The model is trivial.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoApplied to stock, the main unstated conditions is the game conditions are actually positive EV for every bet, not neutral like they implied.