5 ms·
Which is what D can do. D can (and does) interact successfully with C++ classes and member functions. Even templates!
by WalterBright 4y ago
Which is what D can do. D can (and does) interact successfully with C++ classes and member functions. Even templates!
- LorenDB 4y agoHonestly, the only thing lacking with D (for me) is the lack of good support from Qt (which I think is something Qt should tackle by making the moc multilingual). But I agree with Walter. D already did what Carbon is trying to do, but the syntax is easy enough to pick up in a weekend.
- jcelerier 4y ago> Honestly, the only thing lacking with D (for me) is the lack of good support from Qt (which I think is something Qt should tackle by making the moc multilingual) it's possible to do Qt without moc even in C++ with https://github.com/woboq/verdigris/ https://github.com/woboq/verdigris/, why wouldn't it be possible from D ? it should be even easier considering that D traits allow reflection of member and function names, etc.
- varajelle 4y agoIt is possible, but nobody did it.
- arinlen 4y ago> it's possible to do Qt without moc even in C++ with https://github.com/woboq/verdigris/ https://github.com/woboq/verdigris/, why wouldn't it be possible from D ? You're talking about an entirely different thing. While OP was referring to the current state of D's ecosystem and the impact that missing key frameworks have on hindering adoption, you're arguing about the theoretical possibility of writing a framework with a language, which really does not address OP's point.
- detaro 4y agoNo, you are misunderstanding their point. If the problem of using Qt from D is that you need the MOC, then the fact that you can work around the need for MOC and use Qt without it seems quite relevant?
- chc 4y agoThe initial complaint was that it did not have "good support." I think it is fair to say that having to spend a significant amount of effort to work around a lack of support is not "good support."
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- LorenDB 4y agoIndeed, that is what I meant. I would like to see Qt allow some sort of language-abstracted moc so I can just install Qt and a set of Qt bindings and then use them. Just because I can work around the moc doesn't mean that I can easily and productively use Qt from D.
- jcelerier 4y agoBut .. how would that work ? What does "language-abstracted" means for something which is specifically about a language ? E.g. moc in c++ looks for your classes with a Q_OBJECT macro to generate the matching reflection & metaobject data in a .cpp: how does that work in a language that doesn't have preprocessor macros, or maybe even classes, e.g. Scheme or some BASIC dialect ? In addition, moc is only necessary for languages that do not have proper reflection & code generation facilities - if they do, it's entirely unnecessary as the metaobject code can just be generated in-language as part of the bindings you're mentioning. E.g. consider the python Qt bindings: they don't need a moc. Same for D.
- kinjalkishor 4y agodlang would have been a very serious contender to C++ had it been fully nogc, stable & lean. Also dlang unnecessarily suffered low adoption in start due to competing stdlibs, trying to be both Java & C++ at once.
- kinjalkishor 4y agoI am still a big fan of both dlang & pascal & very hopeful of dlang's Bright future ahead.
- vintagedave 4y ago+1 to Pascal here! Underrated language.
- WalterBright 4y agoIf you use the @nogc attribute, D is fully nogc.
- kinjalkishor 4y agoYes it is very useful addition. Hopefully stdlib will also be fully nogc soon. Of all available options I am most hopeful of dlang. While it doesn't still have taken off it still is improving a lot & has high chances of increased usage. (Python also took years).
- WalterBright 4y agoIt doesn't need to be fully nogc. Not using the parts that use the gc will cripple nothing. You'll know which ones use the gc because they won't compile with @nogc.
- dymk 4y ago@nogc is fine, if you're okay with not being able to use large swaths of the standard library, and by extension, most popular D libraries.
- WalterBright 4y agoD has also taken a big step forward in being able to directly import C code. You can do things like: import stdio; and it will compile stdio.h with the builtin C compiler, making all the declarations in it available to your D code.
- skl131313 4y agoD doesn't do it very well. Carbon doesn't require you to write your own interface. There's also problems with extern(C++) not correctly generating the appropriate assembly. Lots of ABI bugs as it's rolling it's own implementation instead of using LLVM.