3 ms·
I don't use peer reviews as a proxy for paper quality. Many great papers had terrible peer reviews, and vice versa. Enough that it's not really a predictor of
by dekhn 4y ago
I don't use peer reviews as a proxy for paper quality. Many great papers had terrible peer reviews, and vice versa. Enough that it's not really a predictor of anything.
- jhbadger 4y agoIt's an imperfect measure to be sure (peer reviewers are humans), but it's the best criterion anyone has ever come up with so far. It certainly weeds out a lot of cranks (even if it on rare occasions mistakes a novel genius for a crank), and isn't that robust to deliberate fraud (peer reviewers generally look for errors in analysis or lack of needed controls rather than look for faked data).