40 ms·
Shutdown of the court system as a possible factor in the crime wave
- bryanrasmussen 4y agohuh, well I didn't know there was a crime wave but this answers one of my questions about if people don't want to work anymore what could they be doing to make ends meet? Which I asked thinking that there was not really any significant crime right now. on edit: however the article doesn't seem to tell anything about property crimes or other things that lead to people getting money out of it, it seems more concerned with violence (which I guess should be concerned with) but then I still don't know, hey how are all these people who don't want to work getting by. It's not really the kind of problem you can assault your way out of.
- lliamander 4y agoMany property crimes go unreported if there is no expectation that thr police will do anything about it. IIRC, car thefts do tend to be reported because otherwise insurance won't pay out, and those are certainly up (at least in some areas, I don't know about thr whole country).
- lovich 4y agoThe unemployment rate is also very low. We just lost a lot of workers to covid or people figuring out how to make ends meet without work during the quarantine, like families realizing that having one parent stay home to raise the kids is cheaper than daycare even with the second paycheck. The whole "no one wants to work" narrative is a lie from companies that are unwilling to respond to market forces. Hell even if no one actually wanted to work, that's still something you have to deal with as a business the same way you have to deal with if no one wants to buy what you're selling
- WesternWind 4y agoNobody wants to work for low rates if there is an alternative.
- newfriend 4y agoIt's difficult for businesses to compete with the government printing massive amounts of money and giving it to people to not work.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoHow much money did the government give to people to not work and during which time period?
- newfriend 4y agoIt's obviously extremely difficult to give a number because of the wide variety of situations and differences by state, but it has been widely reported to be extremely generous to those who do not work. Estimates range from 50k [1] to 100k [2]. People were getting $600 per week in federal unemployment alone [3], which is more than many jobs pay. > NPR spoke to Katharine Thomas, who works the cash register at a small food co-op in Wisconsin. Thomas remembers seeing people around her lose jobs and collect the state unemployment income plus the extra federal relief of $600 a week. > "I felt very angry," she says. "I have to go to work. And I make less money, being essential. $600 a week — that's almost the whole paycheck for me. Even with hazard pay, I still don't make that much money." [1] https://taxfoundation.org/total-covid-relief-unemployment-insurance/ https://taxfoundation.org/total-covid-relief-unemployment-in... [2] https://twitter.com/MarcGoldwein/status/1371478357418909703 https://twitter.com/MarcGoldwein/status/1371478357418909703 [3] https://www.npr.org/2020/07/27/895674685/-600-a-week-poverty-remedy-or-job-slayer https://www.npr.org/2020/07/27/895674685/-600-a-week-poverty...
- lovich 4y agoOh shit is that still occurring? Weird I thought that ended a while ago but obviously if you’re this angry the government must have a line item for making sure no one works currently. No possible way that ended ages ago but is still being used as a talking point for why shitty companies can’t respond to systematic changes in the market
- lotsofpulp 4y ago
- nradov 4y agoWe didn't lose many workers to Covid. The vast majority of deaths were among the elderly. https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/cases-updates/burden.html https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/cases-updates/burd...
- SamoyedFurFluff 4y agoIn the scale of things, I could imagine a combination of the 200k people who died (those below retirement age) and the 2 million people who were hospitalized (who knows what kind of long term effects they had, also below retirement age) and also the 80 million who had symptomatic illness (how many of them have long Covid now?) we might see a needle moved in the job sector… especially if the losses are in specific professions that had more exposure to people…
- throwaway23234 4y agoApparently people are stealing catalytic converters like there's no tomorrow. Some people have been literally killed trying to stop people stealing it from their car. Mobs are literally going into malls and basically stealing everything in one specific store. Homeless people are killing people, shoving people into running trains and in a lot of cases the victims are women. Package theft (porch pirates) is at an all time high. Mass Murders (gunning down multiple people) is happening every day in the united states. But yeah I guess other than that, it's really not happening.
- markdown 4y ago
- StanislavPetrov 4y agoThe talking points of people who deny reality are wild. Is CNN a bastion of conservatism? >More than two-thirds of the country's 40 most populous cities saw more homicides last year than in 2020, according to a CNN analysis of police department data. >Ten of those cities recorded more homicides in 2021 than any other year on record. Those are Philadelphia; Austin, Texas; Columbus, Ohio; Indianapolis; Portland, Oregon; Memphis, Tennessee; Louisville, Kentucky; Milwaukee; Albuquerque, New Mexico; and Tucson, Arizona. Minneapolis tied its previous record number of homicides, with 97 in the years 1997 and 2021. https://www.cnn.com/2022/01/03/us/homicide-rate-us-statistics/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2022/01/03/us/homicide-rate-us-statistic...
- girvo 4y agoThat’s one (which the article already talked about and you didn’t even claim), now do the rest of your claims.
- jrockway 4y agoOne person being pushed in front of a train is a tragedy. A million people dying of some respiratory disease is a statistic.
- 4y ago
- bryanrasmussen 4y agoarchive.org: https://web.archive.org/web/20220721060025/https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/07/covid-court-closings-violent-crime-wave/670559/ https://web.archive.org/web/20220721060025/https://www.theat...
- mjevans 4y agoWhat if: the 'American Dream' was achievable by all when playing by the rules? Owning a home near your job, settling down with a family, having a good life. Rather than maximum value extraction from everyone under the upper crust like we're trying to approach a dystopia.
- truthwhisperer 4y ago
- PixyMisa 4y agoThe problems really start when you try to deliberately shape society so that dreams are attainable by everyone.
- namecheapTA 4y agoI worked in car sales for a long time. Basically every above average salesperson, and every mechanic over 26, owned their own home. In California. While it's probably not possible to own your own how doing every and any job, it's not like that was possible throughout history either. But if you do something at all specialized beyond just providing the lowest of manual labor, you can usually get a home. I also know the construction industry well. You can glue tile to the floor, or screw cabinets to a wall, and own your own home pretty quickly. If mechanics and slightly skilled manual labors can own homes in California, is there really a problem?
- gnicholas 4y ago> He was charged with armed robbery and aggravated assault with a deadly weapon—despite not actually attacking anyone with the pocketknife Perhaps he should have been charged with attempted armed robbery (IIRC from law school the punishment for attempt crimes is the same), but overall these charges sound right. In general, there are two kinds of assault: putting someone in reasonable fear of imminent unlawful battery, or attempted battery (even if you miss). This would have been the former. There may be specifics of the relevant statutes (in whatever jurisdiction) that made one of these charges inappropriate, but the reporter doesn't give any indication this is the case. Does anyone else (who works in criminal law, or at least remembers crimlaw better than I do) have ideas on the appropriateness of the charges?
- bagels 4y agoAggravated assault seems appropriate. The layman's understanding of assault is probably closer to battery. Assault is threatening violence, aggravated can be when done in conjunction with a weapon. Not a lawyer. Some states define these terms differently.
- GravitasFailure 4y ago"Assault" seems correct here. Broadly speaking, charges for threatening someone with a knife and then screaming you'll beat them up will usually be some flavor of "assault," be it aggravated, attempted, or whatever the exact term the relevant statute uses. The "despite not attacking anyone" is a weird framing because stealing with a threat of injury tends to be treated as a pretty serious violent crime even without actually causing an injury. Source: Way too much time as a rent-a-cop. Even dealt with a couple instances of armed shoplifting.
- gnicholas 4y agoYeah the question that lingered for me is: what makes this aggravated assault, if "with a deadly weapon" is already appended to the charge? I would think that the involvement of a deadly weapon could be an aggravating circumstance, but it seems like double-counting to up the charge in two places based on the weapon. But a quick google [1] shows that in NM, assault counts as aggravated if you're just holding a deadly weapon. So the reporting is just a bit sloppy — the charge itself doesn't reference "with a deadly weapon". It's just aggravated assault (because a deadly weapon was involved). 1: https://www.newmexicolegalgroup.com/criminal-defense/new-mexico-assault-and-aggravated-assault-felony/ https://www.newmexicolegalgroup.com/criminal-defense/new-mex...
- PixyMisa 4y ago"Possible"?
- stmfreak 4y agoGaslighting. Soros backed DAs refusing to prosecute and governments letting violent offenders out of jail early. This was obvious when they did it. Don’t let them rewrite history.
- colordrops 4y agoSounds plausible, but can you provide some evidence?
- nonch0n 4y ago
- throwthrow12 4y agoI suspect they got this from Karl Rove’s opinion piece in the WSJ today. No clue whether this is accurate. https://www.wsj.com/articles/george-soross-conservative-renaissance-district-attorneys-prosecutors-crime-recall-paaf-law-order-police-seattle-los-angeles-san-francisco-11658350969?mod=opinion_lead_pos9 https://www.wsj.com/articles/george-soross-conservative-rena...
- Gareth321 4y agoIt's hard to qualify the statement nationally, but I could provide just one example of his statement being correct. Chesa Boudin was the District Attorney for San Francisco, until his recall recently. He ran on a platform of reducing charge rates for many types of crimes. Under his watch, charge rates for DUI, hit-and-run, burglary, theft, weapons related crimes, and assault have decreased; sometimes significantly. Here are some quotes from Boudin: “We will not prosecute cases involving quality-of-life crimes." “[we will] shift our focus to . . . addressing root causes of crime.” “Jails do nothing to treat the root cause of crime,” “The challenge going forward,” said Boudin in 2019, “is how do we close a jail?” George Soros has a very clear political ideology. He has not been shy about his desire to elect left leaning Democrat candidates with similar views across the U.S. In just this instance, Soros publicly supported Boudin's candidacy; donating more than $1 million: https://www.pleasantonweekly.com/news/2022/05/29/soros-backed-pac-spends-195-million-on-local-da-campaign https://www.pleasantonweekly.com/news/2022/05/29/soros-backe... For the record, I find the "I stubbed my toe, thanks Soros" meme a little trite too. But it's no conspiracy that Soros has been supporting leaders like Boudin across the nation. That's not a conspiracy. It's public record. And it's not conspiracy that Boudin and many other leaders have run on platforms of being softer on crime. Especially "victimless" and "quality of life" crimes, in addition to their support of movements like "defund the police." Their records are public and they show consistent decline in charge rates. Whether one supports this action or not, those are the facts.
- raverbashing 4y agoInteresting, I was promised that a world without law enforcement was some kind of utopia where everone would get together just fine... It's perfectly fine to complain about police brutality. But it's almost undestandable when you know what kind of crap they have to deal with daily (as exemplified by TFA). It gets old. No surprise only the ones with too thick skin keep on. And make no mistake, the ones more affected by common criminals are the people with lower incomes. They're the ones that have to use public transport (in some places, of course), go to the sketchy shops in food deserts, where the loss of a vehicle or a phone can be catastrophic, etc
- manuelabeledo 4y ago> I was promised that a world without law enforcement was some kind of utopia where everone would get together just fine... This sounds like hyperbole, although there are some libertarians, especially anarcho-capitalists, who would believe so. > the ones more affected by common criminals are the people with lower incomes I'm inclined to agree with this, but it is also true that law enforcement, as a whole, tends to provide better service to higher earners than anyone else.
- raverbashing 4y ago> but it is also true that law enforcement, as a whole, tends to provide better service to higher earners than anyone else. Very true. They get the worse of both sides.
- newhouseb 4y agoI don’t think this is just violent crime. I am currently suing a former landlord in NYC — a lecturer at Columbia Law school no less! — for illegally withholding our security deposit in an open and shut case. We’ve been “awaiting a court date” for over a year now. We don’t need the money and were planning on donating (the significant) damages to non-profits helping people who wouldn’t otherwise have the resources to get justice, but it’s still super depressing that the court system basically gave up during COVID and doesn’t appear to be trending in the right direction to be fixed anytime soon. No doubt our legally sophisticated landlord knew this and took the bet that we would have no real recourse for over a year toward anything they did.
- secondcoming 4y agoSecurity deposits aren't held in escrow?
- georgyo 4y agoNot a third party escrow, at least for renting in NYC. It is an interest free loan to the landlord or management company for the entire time you live there. Usually it's the management companies that are really difficult to work with.
- robin_reala 4y agoShame. UK has had enforced escrow for rental deposits for 15 years and it’s basically solved the problem. https://www.gov.uk/tenancy-deposit-protection https://www.gov.uk/tenancy-deposit-protection
- bregma 4y agoWhere I live (Ontario, Canada) security deposits are illegal. Simplifies everything and levels the playing field. Key deposits are also illegal. Only thing a landlord can charge is rent (first and last up front) and its legally required to pay interest on the last month's rent (although good luck milking that from most landlords). No need for escrow since to get your last month's rent back you just don't pay your last month. There are, of course, landlords who do not follow the law. As with drug dealers, pimps, and phone companies they generally prey on the less fortunate. Legal aid and the landlord-tenant tribunals keep busy.
- zackees 4y ago
- mschuster91 4y ago> Criminologists have offered several explanations for the increase, including the rise in gun sales early in the pandemic, changes in police behavior following the protests over the murder of George Floyd, and the social disruptions caused by closures of schools and interruptions in social services. But many people who work in criminal justice are zeroing in on another possible factor—the extended shutdown of so much of the court system, the institution at the heart of public order. Why is there not a single mention of capitalist causes in the entire article? - Rents (and real estate purchase prices) have gone through the roof over the last decades - Cost of living (stuff like electricity, gas, gasoline, internet, groceries, basic food) has gone up as well and all but exploded during the last few months following the Ukraine invasion - meanwhile, for an awful lot of people on the lower rungs of society, wages haven't been going up. Minimum wages have been stuck for years, and the "great resignation" may be a good meme and a desperately needed improvement for millions of people, but still many many more millions of people are stuck in exploitative shit jobs - in parts of the country that have been left to rot by uncaring politicians, people are turning to drugs to self-medicate the sheer stress that living on the streets or without meaningful perspective in life brings with it When people are forced to turn to crime, particularly small scale crime such as stealing food, to survive (or to fund their drug addiction), well... they will turn to crime.
- noptd 4y agoGiven the number of social services and amount of support available, I highly doubt that even a sizeable minority of these crimes are survival-related.
- mschuster91 4y agoAvailability != accessibility. Many of the support mechanisms that are available by law are inaccessible in practice: - they require endless hoops to jump through (requirements for ID cards, citizenship, proving X years of residence in state/county or detailed financial or employment history when people often don't have the physical records any more) - they require a bank account or a postal address (which is often hard to meet for homeless or the unbanked) - they require a computer to fill out the application, excluding the elderly and analphabets without a support network like friends or family that help out - require personal presence for the application at times where normal people have to work or at a place that cannot be reached by public transport - the application processing takes many months, which leads to people not applying in the first place because why put in the effort if it will be in vain anyway - successfully applying for the benefits prevents them from rising up in their jobs ("welfare cliff") - successfully obtaining mental health care diagnosis and help prevents people from certain jobs or insurance The system is set up in this perverted way so that politicians can say when faced with public pressure that there is a system in place, but don't have to actually set aside the money that it would cost to serve everyone who's theoretically eligible. As a result, people turn to easier forms of making money instead: undocumented exploitative labor, prostitution or crime. And the latter two are a permanent source to feed the prison-industrial complex - it has been noted that should the cheap prison/slave labor go away, entire cities would collapse [1]. [1] https://eu.azcentral.com/story/news/local/arizona/2022/07/14/arizona-cities-would-collapse-without-prison-labor/10062910002/ https://eu.azcentral.com/story/news/local/arizona/2022/07/14...
- tomohawk 4y ago
- selfmodruntime 4y agoPlease keep your conservative nutjob talking points off of a neutral platform.
- tomohawk 4y agoPlease keep your lefty nutjob lawyers out of the prosecutors offices.
- newaccount2021 4y ago
- yieldcrv 4y ago> I took the opinion that the cost to society was greater from the consequences of not moving these cases and keeping the courtroom locked down too long than from an outbreak of COVID everyone still alive punching the air right now
- giantg2 4y ago"Criminologists have offered several explanations for the increase, including the rise in gun sales early in the pandemic" I wonder what the explaination is here. I would think that the increase in sales would be an effect from the perception of increased violence, especially given the sales are background checked. Articles talking about the increase in gun ownership during the pandemic tend to talk about how those people were getting a gun because of the increase in violence. I hear there could be an increase in thefts, but haven't seen the numbers for that. I could see that being a feedback mechanism, but would be secondary to the original cause.
- selfmodruntime 4y agoIf we disconnect ourselves from the political anglosphere it's well agreed upon that easier access to deadlier weapons has an immediate effect on levels of crime, violent or not. [1][2] Humans are impulse decision makers. Easy access to the needed tools just decreases impulse resistance. The simplest way this can be observed is in suicide. Lax rules for the access to deadly firearms has a direct effect on suicide rates. [1]: https://www.vox.com/2015/8/27/9212725/australia-buyback https://www.vox.com/2015/8/27/9212725/australia-buyback [2]: https://www.zeit.de/zustimmung?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.zeit.de%2Fgesellschaft%2Fzeitgeschehen%2F2021-02%2Fusa-toetungsdelikte-kriminalitaetsrate-anstieg https://www.zeit.de/zustimmung?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.zeit.de...
- giantg2 4y agoWhere is the link to non-violent crime increase? I didn't see that in those links. I've seen the studies about stuff like suicide being more successful with access to easy methods. But my question is whether the attempts also increase. Also, this study (not a news article with potential biases) seems to disagree with the effects of the gun buyback reducing firearm deaths. https://www.ojp.gov/ncjrs/virtual-library/abstracts/australian-firearms-buyback-and-its-effect-gun-deaths https://www.ojp.gov/ncjrs/virtual-library/abstracts/australi...
- nradov 4y agoThe big crime increases in my area have mostly been non-violent, mostly shoplifting and catalytic converter thefts. I don't think gun sales caused that (unless people are struggling to pay their ammo bills).
- chiefalchemist 4y agoPossible factor? Perhaps. And if so, it would make a case that punishment is still a useful tool in modern society. There's nothing better. But what if the most significant factor is modern society itself? Prior to the pandemic we had: - significant cronic poverty - those a notch or two up live pay cheque to pay cheque with little or no job security, iffy health care, and so on - the number of people and families in such peril continues to grow - the article also mentions drugs (i.e., pain killers)[1] - etc. See Matthew Desmond's "Evicted" for more details. https://evictedbook.com/ https://evictedbook.com/ Then on top of this sad social situation we added a gloom & doom pandemic? And thru that we were led by a virologist (not a sociologist). Here's an appropriate example: Fauci did the commencement speech at Princeton Univ a couple months back. He received a standing ovation. Of course he did...the wealthy / elites had been otherwise spared of significant short and long term damage. But that small group is an exception, and certainly not the majority. Yet they continue to remain ignorant of the realities of the world outside their bubble. Long to short, when are we going to look in the mirror and ask: - What about collateral damage? - We were at war (with Covid) and evey war has collateral damage, yet we refuse to look, to ask. Why is that? [1] drugs aren't a factor, it's the courts?? That's absurd.
- dncornholio 4y agoThe most striking thing: Family thought prison could actually help. I don't know but to me, prison is the last thing I want my family to go through. Even if it is to get clean or whatever. You don't want them to have a criminal record. This is the problem. Also prescribing too strong drugs. Then there's this line: > He was charged with armed robbery and aggravated assault with a deadly weapon—despite not actually attacking anyone with the pocketknife They add "despite not actually attacking anyone with the pocketknife". Like that is a necessary thing? I don't know but this article is just way off.
- public_defender 4y agoThis article suffers from a credulous belief in the efficacy of criminal courts which, in addition to not being borne out by any data, is harmful and regressive. I am disappointed that it has a Pro Publica byline and I wonder how that happened. First of all, criminal courts do not (and are not supposed to) lower crime. In their current form, the criminal courts are a principal agent of mass incarceration. Their existence perpetuates the social stratification and economic disparities created by chattel slavery. In law school, they used to teach that criminal punishment has four fundamental rationale: retribution, incapacitation, rehabilitation, and deterrence. Of those, deterrence has long been considered debunked. There's some debate about it, but here's the rub: the debate usually involves a researcher claiming that very short sentences or non-incarceration outcomes (like mandatory engagement of services) can lower recidivism. I'm not aware of anyone seriously arguing in the 21st century that violent crime sentencing has a material deterrent effect. Even if deterrence is wholly debunked, it's not surprising that folks like judges and prosecutors constantly cite it because it's the only rationale which supports the false narrative that criminal prosecution makes society safer. That narrative has been a key strategy in mobilizing votes for those officials, who are usually elected in contests with very low voter turnout. Yet this is a whole article about "the violent crime wave" and the only primary source cited is Mark Kleiman, who was a vocal advocate for alternatives to incarceration (and against long prison sentences), but also whose primary work was about marijuana anyway. Everyone else is a stakeholder who has interest in keeping courts open and getting them "back to normal" rather than reconsidering the system. To reframe this article honestly, we should look to the quotation from the Seattle public defender, who said that the solution is actually to charge fewer crimes. The hook the reporter uses is the story of a man who was arrested for armed robbery, a felony that carries a nine year prison sentence, and incarcerated pretrial. Then he was murdered by another incarcerated person. This man never should have been charged with armed robbery--it was a stretch given the facts. The way to prevent this crime would be to have offered him substance abuse, housing, and/or employment assistance before he resorted to desperation. Once he was arrested and charged, the government had a duty to keep him safe. During the pandemic, all jailers have known that they cannot keep incarcerated people safe, but they largely have not consented to or allowed release for both political and existential reasons. Therefore, to blame here are: 1) The state for not funding basic services, 2) The prosecutor for charging a felony and arguing for detention, 3) The judge for allowing detention while knowing the prisons are unsafe, 4) The sheriff for architecting deadly confinement conditions in the pandemic, 5) The Atlantic (which never seems to know better) and Pro Publica (which really should) for printing this piss-poor article. It's also worth mentioning that court delay is the norm, rather than some artifact of the pandemic. The article imagines a prior state in which people had confidence they would be swiftly brought to trial, but that's never been true in the modern age. It's a canard. It is true that court delays increased in the pandemic, but irresponsible in the extreme to draw a causal link with the increase in murders and other violent crime during the pandemic.
- say_it_as_it_is 4y agoThe Atlantic is acting as if it has played no role in the lawless society that liberals created with their own activism. Shutdown of the court system doesn't matter when criminals aren't arrested. Forget about tried and true policing strategies, too.