3 ms·
It’s one of the oddest things about American “democracy” — if you survey people how they feel about medical treatment you will overwhelmingly get “medical decis
by Spivak 4y ago
It’s one of the oddest things about American “democracy” — if you survey people how they feel about medical treatment you will overwhelmingly get “medical decisions should be made by the doctor and patient [1] full stop and if a doctor prescribes it insurance pays for it no questions asked” but because the people with the real influence are insurance companies and the most politically involved are niche political groups that want to weaponize medical care for varying agendas we get minority rule.
[1] Minor asterisk being that in the case of minors blue tribe says child can override parent and red tribe says parent can override child. But that’s the bike shed when we’re all basically in agreement about the nuclear power plant dammit.
- nradov 4y agoIf medical insurance companies had to pay for every claim submitted by a doctor regardless of medical necessity or the availability of more cost-effective treatments then insurance premiums would be much higher for everyone. Would that be better? Healthcare already consumes about a fifth of our GDP. The reality is that resources are limited and demand is effectively infinite, so inevitably there has to be some level of rationing.
- tsimionescu 4y agoExcept that most of the current cost is in enforcing all of those rules, not in the medical treatments themselves. The vast majority of Healthcare expenses are the enormous administrative costs of the huge bureaucracy that insurance companies have created to ensure they are paying the least possible amount of money to their clients.
- nradov 4y agoThat is not even remotely true. Rule enforcement is a tiny fraction of overall healthcare expenditure, and highly automated.
- user_7832 4y ago> regardless of medical necessity I doubt most patients (especially in the US) go to the doctor often for things not important medically. > demand is effectively infinite I'm sorry, how do you get to this conclusion?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]