6 ms·
How the Colosseum was built and why it was an architectural marvel
- mdp2021 4y ago> In 70 A.D., Vespasian ordered the construction of the new amphitheater in the city center [on the site of Nero’s estate, Domus Aurea, which featured an artificial lake and a 98-foot bronze statue of himself, the Colossus of Nero ...] It was also an innovative architectural and engineering wonder, the largest and most complex permanent amphitheater of the ancient world. Made primarily of concrete, 3.5 million cubic feet [100,000 cubic meters] of travertine, and similar amounts of marble, stone and timber, the Colosseum rose to 157 feet [50 meters] (roughly the height of a 15-story building), with capacity for an estimated 50,000 to 80,000 people [... with] four entrances for the political and religious leaders and 76 for the ordinary citizens [...] The Colosseum’s greatest innovation, says Nathan Elkins [deputy director of the American Numismatic Society and author of 'Monument to Dynasty and Death: The Story of Rome’s Colosseum and the Emperors Who Built It'], was its use of concrete > Gladiators, animals and soldiers, who engaged in all types of combat within the Colosseum, were transported from the understructure of the arena via a complex system of lifts, trap doors and pulleys. The amphitheater could even be flooded to allow naval reenactments to take place [...] It featured other innovations as well, including a sophisticated drainage system used to siphon off water used to stage mock sea battles in the arena. Sailors were employed to operate an overhead retractable awning, which could be rolled out to protect spectators from rain or Rome’s blistering heat. The complex network of chambers and tunnels beneath the arena floor, called the hypogeum, housed props, scenery and participants when not in action. And the amphitheater’s ingenious system of trap doors, pulleys and lifts facilitated dramatic entrances for scenery and combatants alike, allowing even elephants to appear as if from nowhere > the Colosseum is also the father of all modern outdoor sports stadiums. The Colosseum’s use of arches to support the structure, the elliptical shape and the organizational system used to control the entry and exit of fans based on the location of their seats are staples of most modern stadiums It seems that the book is freely available at academia.edu : https://www.academia.edu/40177511/N_T_Elkins_A_Monument_to_Dynasty_and_Death_The_Story_of_Romes_Colosseum_and_the_Emperors_Who_Built_It_Baltimore_Johns_Hopkins_University_Press_2019_ https://www.academia.edu/40177511/N_T_Elkins_A_Monument_to_D...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- adrian_b 4y agoNo, at that link one can find only the table of contents.
- mdp2021 4y ago> only the table of contents I just created an account and verified: the "Download PDF" button downloads the coverpage and first internal. It may probably be available with the "Download full PDF package" - which requests an account upgrade.
- ogogmad 4y agoPeople keep saying the word "concrete". I'm going to embarrass myself by asking what concrete is, and what it isn't. I've looked it up and it seems to be a paste which can be made into any shape, and which then sets into stone. So its main properties are that it can be set into any shape, and when it hardens, it hardens into something strong and reliable. Further questions: - Is there a difference between cement and concrete? What's their relationship? Cement is also a paste which hardens into rock. - Is there a difference between mortar and concrete? What's their relationship? Mortar is also a paste which hardens into rock. - What is the difference between concrete and stone? I guess the closest thing to "setting" stone is chiselling it, and that clearly takes longer than pouring and setting concrete. So the main feature is that you can shape it without chiselling it.
- prestoooooo 4y agocement is the binder, usually made of lime, which is mined from limestone. concrete is cement plus other materials such as gravel. stones are naturally forming solids made from minerals. this should help get you started. wikipedia is your friend.
- ogogmad 4y agoI've looked this stuff up on Wikipedia before asking. There's too much information. A bit like your answer: Detail without explanation. It's like wading through descriptions of gear mechanisms before learning what a wristwatch is. This article got the closest to answering my question: https://www.thespruce.com/difference-between-cement-concrete-and-mortar-2130884 https://www.thespruce.com/difference-between-cement-concrete... The summary is that cement is a constituent of mortar and concrete, which is never used on its own, but is only used to make the latter two. Mortar is used to "glue" bricks together. Concrete is a substance which can be made into lots of different shapes before hardening. Where is the summary misleading? [edit: Changed the word "cement" in the 2nd last sentence to "concrete". That was an accident.]
- HPsquared 4y agoConcrete is cement + sand + stones. It's basically stones held together by mortar. You need to have a sufficient range of particle sizes to fill in the gaps between the stones. An individual stone is strong and has no voids. A pile of stones is weak because it has voids, the stones can roll around each other, and don't have much contact area. In concrete (and asphalt, etc.) the voids between the large stones are filled with sand. The gaps between the sand grains are then filled with cement, which is even finer. You end up with a solid mass of material with minimal voids and all the particles fixed in place. Concrete is stronger than mortar because a larger portion of it is solid material (the interior of the stones is solid, whereas the "mortar" contains voids between the sand grains).
- giuliomagnifico 4y agoThe Ancient Rome I think was a beautiful place, but now it’s a bit of mess. And I’m saying that as an italian, there are lots of troubles with the Italian capital: garbage and fires, lots of wild boars, public transport doesn’t work, etc… I prefer to visit some similar ancient monuments in the south Italy like the Taormina ancient theater, the Valle dei Templi, the Alberobello Trulli, etc…
- mdp2021 4y agoYou should very certainly reinstate representative democracy: where you vote for a candidate and are systemically entitled to reasonable direct relation with them. (You know, what was in place before. Let us not dwell into uncomfortable details.) And complain directly through the open channels. Or, create pressure groups.
- JohnJamesRambo 4y agoWhat do they have now?
- mdp2021 4y agoParties decide the "members of Parliament". It amounts to a completely different political system also in practical terms.
- giuliomagnifico 4y agoRoman, in the last 10/15 years, have tried three different politicians, from three different parties. Situation is almost the same.
- mdp2021 4y agoThat strengthens the position I advanced, that you should change strategy - and adopt an active one.
- 4y ago
- buggythebug 4y agoIt's really small in person and thus farts out
- WilTimSon 4y agoIf size is the only thing that matters to you in a building or structure, I guess you'd admire the Burj Khalifa. Although, incidentally, that's also a bit of an engineering marvel. Perhaps start with something simpler, the Pentagon or something like that. Pretty large.
- mdp2021 4y agothe Burj Khalifa The Burj Khalifa _is_ a certain marvel. Most interesting I find the way they conceived the foundations as a clever and effective system of friction. I must recommend the documentary hosted by Richard Hammond for the "Big!" series (2020), episode Tallest Building On Earth. Probably in terms of occupied surface it is not that much, but some find it helpful when a construction (even "comparatively modest") is conveniently placed in an open air museum as big as a city.
- dboreham 4y agoJust in case readers are confused by this: it's not really small.
- buggythebug 4y agoit's a lot smaller in person than how big people think it is
- mdp2021 4y agoThere are plenty of other areas where size may actually matter, and Romans never complained.
- mdp2021 4y agoReplying here with the data about "the worth of its size": -- the very numbers reported here introductorily estimate a maximum of 80,000 capacity for the Colusseum, and -- a search for "size of stadiums" shows that the Wikipedia page starts listing from 40,000 - up to 100,000 to 132,000 for just a dozen constructions, and -- the Colosseum was built between 72 and 80 AD. This must give an idea of the actual worth of the endeavour.
- jkcorrea 4y agoOff topic: I'll be visiting Rome & this beautiful structure in a couple weeks (extended layover). Does HN have any recs, historical or otherwise?
- danparsonson 4y agoYou've probably heard this already but go to see the Trevi fountain - it's just there in the streets, you don't need a ticket; and in fact, a walkabout of that whole area is beautiful. I also really enjoyed an afternoon walking around St Peter's Basilica in Vatican City - the museum is stuffed to the gills with ancient relics that the catholic church 'collected' from around the world, and the architecture of the building itself is awe inspiring.
- atmosx 4y agoMy favorite sight in Rome. It’s by all means majestic :-) especially in the evening.
- gbrindisi 4y agoThe Sistine chapel and Vaticans Museums at least once in a lifetime. I suggest taking a guided tour and book in advance (as everything in Italy).
- dboreham 4y agoPantheon.
- exitheone 4y agoThe inside of the st Peters basilica was probably one of the most awe inspiring things I have ever seen. And I'm saying that as an atheist purely appreciating the architecture and scale of the insides.
- jghn 4y agoCouldn’t agree with this more. It blew me away on a way that no other building ever has
- ykevinator2 4y ago
- neonate 4y agoTo get around regional access restrictions... https://archive.ph/6hyVS https://archive.ph/6hyVS
- goldfeld 4y agoAlthough desecrating in memoriam, and paling in comparison to, the Temple, with which material it was built. It is a bit revolting to think and compare what went inside the holy temple walls and what went within the colosseum's, so tbat it makes for a poor and sad mediocre thing, if a construction marvel. To glorify it is to exalt a pretty prison or torture chamber, worse yet, because it was for fun. For fun!
- 13of40 4y agoI think I read that something like half a million people died in the shows at the colosseum. Imagine the reputation it must have had while it was operating - like a real-world version of The Running Man.
- notorandit 4y agoOne thing that it is not mentioned in the article is that there has been another "coliseum" test, built a few years earlier in Capua (currently Santa Maria Capua Vetere). Same architecture, same techniques. Only a little bit smaller to accommodate the most renown gladiator school of the Empire.
- ncmncm 4y agoI just like that the foundation was 13 foot-thick concrete.
- elif 4y agoI'm not sure why it waited until the end to mention slave labor, and even then only mentioning it to discredit without evidence the prevailing belief that many of the slaves were Jews.