9 ms·
Do breastfed children have higher IQs? The answer is annoyingly hard to uncover
- gpt5 4y agoOne thing to note about children's IQ is that, contrary to intuition, environmental factors tend to play a smaller overall role as the child mature into adult. Instead, their genetics seem to play a larger role. As the children mature, the heritability of their IQ grows from roughly 0.45 to 0.8 (similar to height) [1]. The fact that the age of the child at the time of the IQ test is such a large factor is often not accounted for in research, which creates inconsistent results. Ideally, breastfeeding research would compare the IQ at adult age of children that were breastfed for different durations, normalized against their parents IQ. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heritability_of_IQ#:~:text=Early%20twin%20studies%20of%20adult,for%20late%20teens%20and%20adults https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heritability_of_IQ#:~:text=Ear....
- Retric 4y ago“Various studies have found the heritability of IQ to be between 0.7 and 0.8 in adults” However, it’s important to realize that environment is generally fairly constrained in these studies. A Twin study is hardly comparing Sierra Leone with Japan, or the Netherlands with North Korea. Extremes like iodine deficiency, disease, or fetal alcohol syndrome are similarly excluded.
- gpt5 4y agoHeritiblity of a trait is not traditionally determined in twins studies but can be done on any random sample of the general population. FWIW, you see the similar trend in adopted children - as they grow older, their IQ trends from being close to their adoptive parents to getting closer to their (completely uninvolved) biological parent.
- Retric 4y agoComparing random members of the general population has both genetics and environmental factors. To isolate the role of either genetics or the environment you need to then control the other factor thus twins for genetics or unrelated people who grow up in similar environments. But both of those comparisons run into problems if these differences don’t represent the full scope of differences with the added issue of similar environments not actually being identical.
- gruez 4y ago>However, it’s important to realize that environment is generally fairly constrained in these studies. A Twin study is hardly comparing Sierra Leone with Japan, or the Netherlands with North Korea. Extremes like iodine deficiency, disease, or fetal alcohol syndrome are similarly exclude. except if you look at the other comparisons made (eg. "Unrelated children—Reared together—Adults "), the correlation factor can go quite a bit lower than 0.7-0.8 (eg. 0.04). The fact the correlation can go this low casts doubt on your theory that the environment is "constrained".
- Retric 4y ago0.04 seems unusually low I have seen studies more in line with this one: “Same person (tested twice) .95 Identical twins—Reared together .86 Fraternal twins—Reared together .55 Biological siblings—Reared together .47 Unrelated children—Reared together .30 Parent-child—Living together .42 Adoptive parent – child – Living together 0.19 Identical twins—Reared apart .76 Fraternal twins—Reared apart .35 Biological siblings—Reared apart .24” So siblings reared apart had less correlation than unrelated children living together.
- gpt5 4y agoUnfortunately, these numbers don't state the age of the child when they were tested, so they are not very useful.
- pyuser583 4y agoThey don’t state lots of other things. Like what “raised separate” means. Was one raised in a Soviet gulag while the other was raised in an Israeli kibbutz?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cornel_io 4y agoThis is a universal complaint that can apply to almost any heritability study. And I'm not aware of any situations where a further investigation found it to be devastating to the original conclusion (mainly because actually covering all the edge cases you're calling out is somewhere between "cost prohibitive" and "impossible"). That makes me think it's just a generic "I don't like this conclusion so I'll criticize it" Joker card that people play, and not a legitimate debunking.
- Retric 4y agoIQ is unquestionably extremely influenced by genetics. I am simply bringing up the context when people want to toss out specific numbers.
- wisty 4y agoAn adult is less constrained by their home environment, and more constrained by a combination of their genetics and the planet they live on.
- AlchemistCamp 4y ago> A Twin study is hardly comparing Sierra Leone with Japan, or the Netherlands with North Korea. Extremes like iodine deficiency, disease, or fetal alcohol syndrome are similarly excluded. Sure. To take this line of reasoning to its conclusion, an environment that has no oxygen or is otherwise uninhabitable, would prevent any human from living or having any mental abilities whatsoever. In this sense, environmental influences would completely dominate genetics. Similarly, changing 50% of a human's DNA would have them live life as a stalk of wheat. What's your point?
- cm2187 4y agoOn that topic, an interesting discussion in the latest Lex Fridman: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hppbxV9C63g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hppbxV9C63g
- CrHn3 4y agoDo you consider breastfeeding to be an environmental factor? Breastmilk contains the most microRNA of any body fluid[1] and has the potential to modulate gene expression, so there may be ways breastfeeding affects the genome that we don't understand yet. How long a child is breastfed is associated with epigenetic differences in children.[2] Breastfeeding is negatively associated with the methylation of LEP. Childhood obesity is associated with lower cognitive performance.[3] 1. AAP talk on long term breastfeeding epigenetic effects: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-bUeSqPOCTc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-bUeSqPOCTc 2. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32443666/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32443666/ 3. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/oby.22192 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/oby.22192
- j7ake 4y agoIf people have looked this hard and have found only tiny effects like 2 or 3 iq points, it suggests the effect is probably closer to zero due to scientists tendency to lean towards significance. Maybe one way to think about it is this: walk into an elementary school and interact with kids in a classroom for any amount of time you want, access all their test scores. Then guess which kids were breastfed and which were not. I would bet that you wouldn’t do much better than chance.
- aikinai 4y agoThe only way you would beat chance would be if breastfeeding were the primary predictor of some sort of observable behavior. Obviously it’s not. But there’s a wide range between zero and the primary factor.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- swores 4y agoThat seems a rather pointless way to think about it, unless you think any science that can't be proven with a brief conversation with someone isn't worth considering. Would you try to judge how many kids in the class have inherited higher risk of heart disease by listening to their heart beats for a few minutes? If you spent a day with a class of kids you'd probably (unless asking them specific questions about it) not be able to guess any specifics of their parents' different parenting techniques, does that mean that parenting doesn't matter and kids should just be ignored when not being fed?
- j7ake 4y agoOne can definitely figure out which kids were coming from troubled homes. Teachers often notice outlier behaviours and report them to higher ups to get help for these children. The effect of having loving parents completely dominates whether you breastfeed or bottle or formula.
- 4y ago
- bigcat12345678 4y agoBrestfeeding is definitely better than fomula for our 2 kids. The older one had not enough breastfeeding and had much more minor illness over the years. The younger one had all breastfeeding during the early time and only had 2 illness in the similar time period. As for others, I cannot comment yet. Let's see.
- quickthrower2 4y agoThat is just down to chance. I reckon it has more to do with genetics/hygiene and their school cohort. Also covid is going to skew this a lot! Not just the virus but the societal reaction to it, norms, etc.
- xbar 4y agoOr it's absolutely deterministic in this case. I don't think we have enough data.
- bigcat12345678 4y agoWell, our pediatrician told us that breastfeeding milk brings more antibodies to the infants. That's one thing definitely helps with fending off minor illness.
- cycrutchfield 4y ago
- bigcat12345678 4y agoNo, this is a terrible suggestion. Also n=2 and controlled experiment are so generic that it becomes a joke itself. And a paper? Wow, you probably never read a paper. A high school course report would be more meaningful than a few sentences. Overall, I am absolutely abhorred by the lack of intelligence of this comment.
- swores 4y ago
- thatfrenchguy 4y agoNever understood the fascination of Americans for breastfeeding (and the crazy crazy associated shame for mothers who don’t breastfeed in the upper middle class): the data is garbage (as this article shows, , there’s no studies, and entire high income countries like France or China have low breastfeeding rates, and kids in those countries are obviously not stupid.
- aldebran 4y agoUhh what? How did you get this? In my experience it’s been the opposite. There’s stigma around breastfeeding in public. People aren’t breastfeeding and using formula because of a lack of education and the associated stigma.
- vlunkr 4y agoI don’t think this has been the case for the past 15 years or so. In young parent culture, there is absolutely stigma against using formula. I think these studies are a big part of it. There’s pressure from doctors and hospital staff to breastfeed when you have a new baby, and a key part of the sales pitch is increased IQ. It’s not hard to see how that causes serious guilt for moms who use formula.
- aldebran 4y agoWhen we had kids (party recently), there was education about breastfeeding but I did not see pressure and zero mention of IQ. They did have tables showing the nutrients in Breastmilk vs formula. That itself was scientific. No judgement either way. In fact they did mention they understand some families can’t or decide they don’t want to. Of course this is anecdata.
- hollandheese 4y agoThen you had a great hospital! My wife and I had our child in late 2020, and our experience was vastly different and much like vlunkr said. Ours UCSF, pressured and pressured my wife to breastfeed even though her milk was having massive problems coming in. Instead of allowing formula they only allowed donor breast milk supplementation by tubes that were taped to my wife's nipples, to attempt to prevent "nipple confusion".
- arbitrage314 4y agoWhat about breastfeeding from the nipple vs drinking pumped breast milk? Or breastfeeding from a wet nurse vs breastfeeding from one's biological mother? Sounds like we still know so little, but I'd be curious about these two questions as well.
- toxicFork 4y agoAnother issue is that IQ is not representative of intelligence.
- petra 4y agoThat's the wrong question to ask. Breastfeeding is important for attachment and mental health, see: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1459116/#:~:text=Breastfeeding%20may%20assist%20attachment%20development,influence%20of%20breastfeeding%20on%20mothers https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1459116/#:~:tex....
- isatty 4y agoThe author is only tackling the IQ studies. I think the multitude of other benefits (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breastfeeding https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breastfeeding) aren’t really debated because it’s proven medically. In the absence of health issues to the mother, breastfeeding is always preferable.
- klipt 4y agoCo sleeping is also good for attachment and mental health (and probably the default for most of our ancestors), but we discourage it due to worries about SIDS...
- blub 4y agoCo-sleeping in an attached cot is encouraged in some European countries AFAIK. And I know families that have used the same bed; even we did that on some days, it can be quite nice :-) It’s important to never drink alcohol or go to bed impaired in any way.
- quantified 4y agoI don't think it's SIDS so much as smothering that's the issue, is it? It was such a blessing. We got better sleep (tried it both ways), kid got fed more efficiently so wake time was shorter, nice bonding. Neither parent was so heavy a sleeper as to be a danger, no one was intoxicated either.
- allisdust 4y agoMany of the asian countries where co-sleeping is the norm have lower incidence of SIDS. The SIDS seem to be a bigger risk when the parents consume alcohol/other intoxicants.
- aljungberg 4y agoI have to agree with the argument that the prior should be that breastfeeding is beneficial and we would need massive and strong evidence to the contrary to change that position. It is an expensive process so it must have an evolutionary advantage. The analysis presented here seems convincing in the sense that we don’t have good evidence that breastfeeding increases IQ. But from what I remember there is good evidence that it improves the baby’s immune system among many other things. So bottom line is in the absence of massive amounts of strong evidence against breastfeeding, by default you should favour it. And if in the end the IQ effect isn’t real at least you improved your baby’s health (and hence survival chances). If you have the option to breastfeed, go for it. And as the article stated, if for whatever reason you cannot or will not you probably don’t need to feel too bad about it because the effects while positive are at the margin to the best of our current knowledge and formula is getting better every decade.
- rayiner 4y agoThe analysis is actually quite different. Bottle feeding has massive advantages for division of labor among parents. I did all the night feedings for my first two kids so my wife could get some much needed sleep. She didn’t have to pump which is often so much trouble it’s not worth it. Moreover, they now associate me with being the nighttime parent, so when they’re sick or having trouble sleeping I’m the one they come to, not mom. Losing that flexibility would be worthwhile only if there was strong evidence that breastfeeding had advantages that can’t be replicated with formula. On that front it should be noted that the vast majority of GenX and older millennials were formula fed, as breastfeeding rates plummeted in the 1970s and 1980s. If there was a massive impact from that it would have been apparent.
- namecheapTA 4y agoIt just feels weird to run this random experiment on my current child. Is evolution/biology wrong, and this processed stuff from the store better?? You'd have to have shocking amounts of studies to convince me it's better to have a baby eat that fake stuff than a mother's breast milk. And finally, I think it's incredibly selfish to argue about equitably splitting feeding times, at the likely expense of your child's health and growth. Young adults and men seem to be less healthy than ever. Plummeting testosterone, crazy rates of allergies, increased suicide rates, high depression.... But your right, if feeding them processed junk was bad, we'd see signs of it by now.
- jkwuan 4y ago100 bucks says this dude just had a kid and his wife isn't breastfeeding and he's trying to feel better about it
- tylerchr 4y agoIf his way of "trying to feel better about it" was to critically analyze and summarize 30 (or maybe 100) years of published research on the subject, then he's a hero in my mind. I'd choose to take that over your 100 bucks any day of the week.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- BXLE_1-1-BitIs1 4y agoFor all those new parents worried if the kid is getting enough breastmilk: if the diapers are getting soaked, the answer is yes.
- braingenious 4y agoCan anybody TL;DR this? I tried scrolling past the thousands of words to find a conclusive sentence and it basically just said “Why does nobody know about this?” This does not elicit faith that the author has any insight whatsoever. Edit: I’m not particularly motivated by talk of IQ in general because the groups that get fixated on it rarely have overlap with my own interest in human cognition. I’ve found this stuff to often be sensationalist navelgazing nothingness at best.
- xbar 4y agoTLDR: breastfeeding has a lot of benefits but IQ is not consistently correlated in the literature. I find IQ topics go as you suggest, generally. Parenting topics around IQ are a slightly different beast: middle-class American parents (at least) are obsessed with making their baby smarter than your baby. It has been a thing for 35+ years. Something about the competitiveness of the boomers in the mid-80s spiked a baby IQ frenzy that has only worsened. I think the author is very smart at selling Substack Subscriptions to post-COVID moms.
- braingenious 4y agoThank you!
- cdf 4y agoDear prospective parents, esp first time parents, hoping to be perfect parents, I just want to tell you, after 4 kids, just do what works for you. Your sanity has a bigger influence on the well being of your child than any single factor like religiously breastfeeding. Breastfeeding is incredibly convenient when the mom is not working, and cost efficient. But if it becomes impossibly inconvenient or costly, eg while mom is working, dont beat yourself up if you have to resort to formula to bridge the gaps. Also, baby formula marketing would lead you to believe that formula with omega3 will make your babies smarter too. That's probably the lie you should disbelieve in. Raising a confident well adjusted child is more important to me than high IQ, and there is no objective way to measure that.
- madduci 4y agoThis is true on so many levels. As a parent myself, I confirm it 100%
- YZF 4y agoNothing wrong with wanting to be a good parent... But yes, everyone will have (conflicting) advice for you but you are the parents. Nature will do its thing anyways.
- xbar 4y agoI won't argue with you. But I will change the emphasis. If you can breastfeed your baby, do it. Give it a real go. But if it is leading to a true loss of sanity, let it go. I've raised 3 and breastfeeding was a part of each baby's start. There were reasons why none of them made to the promoted 1 year target. But I saw real benefits that I associate with breastfeeding in each child up to today.
- lotophage 4y agoIs all breast milk made equal? Is it not possible that some mothers milk is deficient for some reason (diet, genetics, health issues etc)? It's not usually tested after a child is born.
- CrHn3 4y agoNo. There is variability in the nutrients, microRNA it contains, the microbiome and levels of heavy metals. Diet before, during and after pregnancy can affect the nutritional composition, and it can be low in vitamin D, iodine, iron, and vitamin K. Vitamin D and K are usually supplemented (K is given at birth). Some women (around 30% iirc, can't find the number atm) do not have B. infantis because of low gut diversity, which is really important for infant gut health and long term immunity. Infants are usually exposed during vaginal birth, so babies born by c-section are at risk for not having B. infantis colonize their gut. Breastmilk can be a source of B. infantis. Some communities with heavy environmental contamination have had lead levels as high as 41.1 ppb [1]. Baseline heavy metal content for most areas tends to be more in line with formula. 1. https://jpnim.com/index.php/jpnim/article/view/040223 https://jpnim.com/index.php/jpnim/article/view/040223
- pengaru 4y agoUnrelated to the IQ question, AIUI not all formula is created equally. One of the things that caused Robert Lustig [0] to go down the "fructose is a poison" rabbit-hole was he had parents with obese infants coming to him for help. What he found was the WIC-provided formula these mothers were giving these children was full of fructose making the infants obese. I think you'd struggle to produce a similar outcome via breastfeeding. [0] https://profiles.ucsf.edu/robert.lustig https://profiles.ucsf.edu/robert.lustig
- khrm 4y agoBreastfeeding isn't only beneficial for babies. Even mothers who can express will benefits from it. Reduces `type 2 diabetes` risk. https://www.nmcd-journal.com/article/S0939-4753(13)00274-3/fulltext https://www.nmcd-journal.com/article/S0939-4753(13)00274-3/f... It reduced the risk of reduced risk of breast cancer, ovarian cancer, and endometrial cancer. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4670483/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4670483/ Do I need to mention maternal bond as well as weight loss? Instead of dieting or stuff like that, it's a more healthier option.
- khrm 4y agoAlso, influences of Milk Formula companies in research on benefits to babies and mothers can't be neglected. Just see the 1970s Nestle scandal. https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Professionalism/The_Nestl%C3%A9_Infant_Formula_Scandal https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Professionalism/The_Nestl%C3%A...
- pawsforthought 4y agoQuite. When there’s a profit motive behind one of two things being compared, and the other is the way things have been for quite literally millions of years, skepticism towards the former should be turned up to full. See also sunscreen [1]. [1]: https://www.outsideonline.com/health/wellness/sunscreen-sun-exposure-skin-cancer-science/ https://www.outsideonline.com/health/wellness/sunscreen-sun-...
- rsanaie 4y agoThis applies to any other long term study of whether X affects Y in human. Now replace X with coffee, wine, fruits, medicine... and replace Y with IQ, cancer risk, mental health, ....
- Foobar8568 4y agoConsidering milk formula as a healthy choice (choice here is the keyword, by necessity is another topic) is just madness.
- usgroup 4y agoWHO page on breastfeeding: https://www.who.int/health-topics/breastfeeding https://www.who.int/health-topics/breastfeeding Too clever by half springs to mind with this article.
- telebell 4y agoEmily Oster has reviewed the literature pretty comprehensively and the best evidence we have is that breastfeeding has some short term benefits over formula, especially if you live somewhere without safe water. But no significant long term benefits. Bf is really hard for a lot of women, and other women (me) don’t enjoy it. It’s really painful in the beginning, means that I’m solely responsible for feedings and night wakeups, puts me at risk of mastitis, thrush and postpartum depression (probably exacerbated by lack of sleep), requires me to stay close to home for months. There’s nothing special about breastfeeding apart from this feeling people have that “natural” is better. You probably wouldn’t limit your own food intake to what’s “natural” - what you can kill or grow within walking distance of your home - why would you limit your baby’s in the same way?
- Balgair 4y ago> ... and postpartum depression (probably exacerbated by lack of sleep) I remember back in the early 2010's there was this 'hack' going around where you could manage to only sleep for 2 hours or something a day, but you had to grab sleep every 4 hours for 15 minutes to get the REM cycle in. I'm likely totally off on the schedule, but the gist was very little sleep. Recently, a sibling became a parent and I was reminded of that 'hack' and told them. My sibling just laughed and said 'Oh, so nerds discovered motherhood huh?'.
- hafr 4y agoThis may be a related interesting read: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4077166 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4077166 My interpretation is that after removing the social bias which is usually prevalent in related studies and discussions, not much of an effect can be observed.