6 ms·
A while back I raised a bit of a furor here saying that a duplicate could be made and launched at a tenth of the cost. A lot of people said I don't know what I'
by WalterBright 4y ago
A while back I raised a bit of a furor here saying that a duplicate could be made and launched at a tenth of the cost. A lot of people said I don't know what I'm talking about, that little money would be saved.
But it seems patently obvious. After all, 10 technologies don't have to be reinvented. No research would need to be redone. No test rigs would need to be redesigned and duplicated. And on and on.
The most bizarre argument against building a duplicate was there wouldn't be anything extra worth looking at. Yet I watched the NOVA episode on the scope last night, and everywhere they look where we thought there was "nothing" turns out to be crammed with 10,000 galaxies and stars.
- baxtr 4y agoWe could probably deploy 100k of them and still see only a tiny fraction of the universe.
- skykooler 4y agoTaking pictures the level of the first image released, it would take about 3700 years for JWST to image the entire sky.
- zabzonk 4y agoI take your point, but it does seem to have actually worked.
- WalterBright 4y agoObviously a great deal of the cost also came from making sure it would work, because there wouldn't be another. What if 10 were built, each with only a 10% chance of success? What would that have cost? After all, it doesn't need the expense of being man-rated.
- zabzonk 4y ago> What would that have cost? No idea. Do you? Genuinely interested, particularly regarding methodology. Not intending at all to be insulting.
- WalterBright 4y agoLook at SpaceX's rockets. They cut costs by what, 10x? over NASA's? A part of that was not trying to build 100% the first time, but to accept failure and iterate. My dad told me that Pratt&Whitney made the most reliable aircraft engines by putting them on a test stand and running them at full power until they broke. The engineers would figure out why it failed, redesign the part, stick that on the engine, and continued running them at full power. It's straightforward, inexpensive, and it works.
- noizejoy 4y agoCould it be, that iterating fast through additional failures may be harder to finance with public funds, because the general public hasn’t caught up with the recognition of failing early and often being a good thing?
- WalterBright 4y agoGovernment programs fail all the time, and they just get a budget increase. Hire the salesmen who accomplish that.
- noizejoy 4y agolol - you do have a point there!
- dekhn 4y agoSurely you can see that the P&W approach is only going to discover a subset of problems that will affect the engine in the wild. For example, engines don't run at 100% power during the full flight, and they go through heating and cooling cycles. It also doesn't address failure modes due to manufacturing problems specific to a single engine- for example, turbine blades are manufactured with serial numbers and you can go back and get detailed process and QA for that specific item to understand what went wrong and why it failed and how to not do that during manufacture again. Then there's all sorts of complex failures that aren't addressed by single engines: " Prior to this crash, the probability of a simultaneous failure of all three hydraulic systems was considered as low as one in a billion. However, statistical models did not account for the position of the number-two engine, mounted at the tail close to hydraulic lines, nor the results of fragments released in many directions. Since then, aircraft engine designs have focused on keeping shrapnel from puncturing the cowling or ductwork, increasingly utilizing high-strength composite materials to achieve penetration resistance while keeping the weight low" (I'm not disrespecting P&W- I'm sure they have more tests than just "100% power until it breaks, fix and repeat")
- mmazing 4y agoWhat is the measure of success though? Successful launch and arrival at the observation point? The 6 month setup period before observations can be made? I contend that success here is a full mission that yields science data over decades of observation. If we cut down the acceptable error rate so we can launch early, how does that impact longevity?
- zmgsabst 4y agoI think the question is, imagine we built 10 — and got an outcome like: 2x — failed to deploy, mission lost 4x — early operation error, 6mo lifetime 3x — lower performance, 3 year lifetime 1x — mission successful, 10 year lifetime …do we get a better deal building them with larger faults, at a lower cost? A lot of expense is in developing technologies, assembly tooling, and test rigs — all of which is easier if we don’t need them to be as assured because only 1 in 10 needs to succeed.
- WalterBright 4y agoRight. And if they are launched serially, you've got a chance to correct mistakes in the previous launches. Odds of success increase with every launch.
- mmazing 4y agoYeah, makes more sense when I think about it like that. Thanks!
- prpl 4y agoWhat is the timescale you are thinking of for 10% chance of success? 10% first light success is different than 10% 10-year survey success. There’s physically not enough infrastructure (clean rooms, testing facilities, vacuum chambers, etc…) nor skilled manpower available to NASA to be able to build more than one in parallel, so that would add to the cost significantly.
- WalterBright 4y agoWhat's being done with that infrastructure (clean room, testing facilities, vacuum chambers, etc..) right now? Nothing? Of course, the sensible thing to do is to build the test equipment, procedures, train the testers. Then test #1. Then test #2. Then test #3. That's what everybody does. The cost of the Saturn V rocket was amortized over many launch vehicles, despite a host of new technologies that had to be developed for it, despite much of it being hand-built.
- zabzonk 4y agoBut the cost of grinding the mirrors?
- WalterBright 4y agoConsider the cost of designing the mirrors, designing a machine to grind the mirrors, testing the machine, and verifying the grind of the mirrors. All that adds to the cost of the first mirror, and adds $0 to the second.
- zabzonk 4y agoBut the grinding machine costs (which is significant if you have 10 of them) and the grinding process takes a lot of time and cost (if you have 1 machine x 10 mirrors). I don't think these NASA/JPL guys are quite as dim as you seem to suggest (but you have more info) and they may have done a little cost/benefit analysis before embarking on the project.
- wolverine876 4y agoWe already had the discussion. Could you link to it? Is it worth having it again?
- WalterBright 4y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30730726 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30730726
- wrycoder 4y agoOlbers' Paradox[0] resurgent. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Olbers%27_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Olbers%27_paradox
- toss1 4y ago>>A lot of people said I don't know what I'm talking about, that little money would be saved. Those are the ignorant ones. It isn't quite a "Those who know don't speak and those who speak don't know" situation, but this is just blindingly obvious to anyone who has done any R&D to manufacturing and risk assessment. Heck, even just having a duplicate on the ground to debug could save the mission (since there isn't one, let's hope it doesn't come to that). On one-off projects of any size, the design, prototyping, testing, & refining the design just overwhelm the cost of fabricating the final parts — and they do it by orders of magnitude. Just for the carbon fiber parts I work in daily, the initial R&D test program for a sizeable (scale of 1 m^2) part might cost $25K, the first mold $12K, the first part sells for $3K, the second part $2K and the fifth part 1.7K. To get to volume production in the 100s, there's probably another dev program & set of molds, and the 300th part out the door might sell at $1200.
- WalterBright 4y agoWhen I worked in engineering at Boeing, the cost of a forged part was the cost of the tool&die machinist making the die. The incremental cost of doing the actual forging was a rounding error. The dies do wear, and the parts get larger and larger until they're out of spec and a new die is sunk.
- googlryas 4y agoFirst rule in government spending: why build one when you can have two at twice the price? Only, this one can be kept secret. Controlled by Americans, built by the Japanese subcontractors.
- bornfreddy 4y agoThere should be a movie with this plot.
- motoboi 4y agoNever now if people are joking saying that but oh boy!
- sammyjoe72 4y agoYeah it would make for a great twist, like say if some crazy terrorist decided to blow it up.. “don’t worry we have another”
- mrexroad 4y agoOnly if there’s windsurfing with dad
- WalterBright 4y agoThe plot of the movie "Contact".
- SkyMarshal 4y agoWanna take a ride?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jacobr1 4y agoDidn't we do that with hubble? We built 1 hubble, but many more "hubble-like" spy satellites and found out about them when they were donated back to nasa to put toward civilian use.
- jmyeet 4y agoI'm not sure you're correct. Consider fabbing chips. Fabs spend an awful lot of time verifying the produced chips. I've seen estimates that verification cost exceeds fabrication cost. How much of the development cost of JWST 2.0 would be spent on verification? I honestly don't know but I would guess it's high. Another factor: part of making a production process is predicated on how many you'd build. We had a process for making Saturn-V rockets based on the number of Apollo missions we planned for. If you then up and decide you need 500 Saturn-Vs you might have to go through a whole new process for something that will scale that high. Yet another factor: the launch vehicle. If you decide to do JWST 2.0 in 10 years, what launch vehicle will you use? The same one might not exist so the new mission will have to be designed for what is available. And another: materials science changes. We don't make the same materials that we did 50+ years ago for good reasons but those materials are a key part of the design of something like Saturn-V. So I imagine JWST 2.0 would be cheaper but 90% cheaper? I'm not convinced.
- dylan604 4y agoI can't wait for JWST 2.0, but we're only talking about JWST #2. We're not talking about upgrades, just another copy. I mean, it should be easy, right? It's in the cloud so to speak, so just spin up another instance and push to a different region. No problemo.
- saalweachter 4y agoThe obvious number to make is 5; currently we only have one at L2. What about L1, L3, L4 and L5?
- MereInterest 4y agoThe advantage of L2 is that is stays in Earth's shadow at all times. None of the other Lagrange points have this benefit.
- WalterBright 4y agoWhy does it need the sun shield, then?
- somat 4y agoI always thought they should have planed to build and launch two of them in case something happened to the first(unlike hubble we cant get people out to L2), if you are building one, then building the second is relatively cheap.
- nsxwolf 4y agoThe universe at this distance seems very homogeneous. Won't looking at different parts of the sky just yield more of the same? It seems like you'll just see the same things over and over again in any patch of sky.
- ISL 4y agoOne of the hypotheses that can be tested better than ever by JWST is precisely this: Is the very-distant universe homogenous? Modern cosmology assumes-so, but it need not be true.
- spindle 4y agoStrongly agree, except that "assumes" can be unpacked a bit. There are various reasons why cosmologists think the distant universe is homogeneous, and some of them (not all) are closely based on evidence, most notably the approximate homogeneity of the cosmic microwave background, which is (in a sense) further away than anything the JWST can see.
- DiogenesKynikos 4y agoJWST is not particularly well suited to testing homogeneity. Survey telescopes that observe a large fraction of the sky are much better suited to that task. Homogeneity has been very well tested out to a redshift of a few by surveys like the Sloan Digital Sky Survey and the Dark Energy Survey, each of which have observed thousands of square degrees of sky (there are about 41k square degrees in total). And as another commenter notes, the CMB (at redshift 1100) is homogeneous (to one part in 10k).
- astrange 4y agoWe would like that to be true, but it seems like it might not be. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Axis_of_evil_(cosmology) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Axis_of_evil_(cosmology) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CMB_cold_spot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CMB_cold_spot
- jasonwatkinspdx 4y agoYou got much more detailed explanations in that thread. It simply doesn't scale like that. These are extremely bespoke systems, and the entire process is gated on vendors and facilities that are both unique in the world and under high demand. There is simply no way you get a 2nd unit at the kind of discount you're assuming.
- WalterBright 4y agoI didn't those explanations compelling. The cost of the design and development of the JWST was surely enormous, along with the design and construction of test facilities. None of that needs to be repeated for #2. Just for fun, buy two IKEA flatpacks for, say, bookshelves. Build one, then the other. I bet you spend half the time building the second, even though you're doing exactly the same thing, by hand. Reminds me of when in March 2020 I was also told I didn't know what I was talking about when I pointed out how a Covid vaccine could be made available in 6 months rather than the conventional 18 minimum times. The vaccines were available in 7 months. The airplane I worked on the design of, the Boeing 757, would have cost at least 100 times as much per-plane if it was a one-off design.
- majormajor 4y agoI assume the 757 was designed to be produced in bulk. It's not clear to me that designing something that needs to be assembled successfully once vs twice vs 10 times doesn't introduce some more cost tradeoffs in itself. Just around tolerances and yield even, how many pieces are required to be made to give one complete set of parts that all work together vs 10 complete sets that all work together. I could see some extra pain and assembly from having to get more permutations of part variances all working together and validated. A while back, at least, a lot of the testing processes for space components were VERY manual so you'd either need to invest more for automation or accept linear costs on all the extra production/verification. This is partly quibbling over trivial details - I would imagine the savings is closer to 50-75% than 90% - but at a certain point those differences in tens-of-percentage points are lots of billions of dollars. Here's the real kicker to me: why spend even an extra 10% up-front before even deploying one of them? Why not spend the marginal costs on building an additional unit only if the first fails? Then you can learn from the failure too? And if it works the first time, those billions can be spent elsewhere instead.
- TheMightyLlama 4y ago“Why build one when you can have two at twice the price” ~ S.R. Hadden. Contact
- spacemark 4y agoA tenth the cost? No. Half the cost? Possibly but even that is a stretch. A huge amount of the work effort (and funding) would have to be repeated. All the testing, validation, hardware-specific characterization and calibration, troubleshooting, and attendant analysis. Not to mention partial redesign since many of the parts used are no longer produced and the tooling long gone. Source: just my perspective after 20 years working on space systems.
- WalterBright 4y ago> tooling long gone But of course. I meant before that happened, i.e. planning to make some siblings.
- OrvalWintermute 4y agoOther elements that drives substantial cost is the move to push things to commercial industry to do fabrication, and their internal training gaps... Case in point: When there are 3 people on a planet that know how to create a specific sensor, and they happen to be NASA civil servants, JPL employees, Professors in Academia, or from a boutique non-profit like Aerospace or Mitre...in many cases the govt will decide to push the fabrication to commercial industry to create it, instead of the elite teams that created the most recent groundbreaking sensor. This causes huge cost overruns as the commercial teams fumble around [1] and in some cases, even get paid despite dropping a satellite [2] One of the funny fixes to this for NPP, was assigning a government "hall monitor" experienced in safe satellite testing to oversee test operations, and gig them for every infraction of safety protocols. [1] https://www.defensedaily.com/npoess-has-more-than-1-billion-added-cost-overrun-pentagon-threatens-funds-freeze-if-paperwork-undone-screws-on-viirs-sensor-break-must-be-replaced/congress/ https://www.defensedaily.com/npoess-has-more-than-1-billion-... [2] https://spacenews.com/another-factory-mishap-damages-noaa-n-prime/ https://spacenews.com/another-factory-mishap-damages-noaa-n-...
- spindle 4y agoWhat a good thought. I'm sure a second one would have been much cheaper than the first one if they'd built it at the same time. Now, many of the teams and facilities that did the work have dissolved back into the academic and industrial aether and would need to be reformed. But, as you say, they'd have less research to do a second time.
- pas 4y agonot at the same time, after the first one has been verified. basically after the manufacturing, calibration, tuning, assembly, etc. techniques have been perfected to the required degree plus, it would make sense to try to repeat this a few times always trying to 80-20 it. (I mean intentionally trying to "half-ass" the next iteration. spend less on it than on the previous one, and try to get the best out of that budget - with the same tech of course.) the big problem is that ... it doesn't make much sense to do this. JWST delivers the data for the science it was intended and ... for the new questions that we'll raise we'll probably need some even more specialized observatory.