4 ms·
No, it's like people read the book, went home, and wrote it down again. The original book is now back in the shop and the publisher is free to sell it. How can
by toyg 15y ago
No, it's like people read the book, went home, and wrote it down again. The original book is now back in the shop and the publisher is free to sell it.
How can you "lose" a sale that you don't know you'd get? I bet 6000 downloads for an unknown writer of zombie-pulp wouldn't have happened without the £0 price tag. We can argue about it all day, but the fact is that there is no direct loss, and if there is an indirect one, it's still very, very hard to quantify.
- pbhjpbhj 15y agoI find your argument poor in the extreme but to say "there is no direct loss" is wrong even at extremely confined levels of directness. Your argument hinges on the idea that he wouldn't have made a single sale and would still have expended time and effort in promotion of the work if he knew it were being given away for free. The difficulty in quantifying the cost is largely irrelevant IMO. Either Amazon are guilty or not and if found guilty the court I'm sure has an equivalent case of similarly priced works being given away for free that they could use to model the award given to the appellant (eg mp3.com $25k per work/CD made available). Such an award should be in terms of punitive damages.
- slowpoke 15y ago>The difficulty in quantifying the cost is largely irrelevant IMO. If you cannot quantify any damages, you are not entitled to any compensation. It's as simple as that, really. Or are you seriously going to argue that "there could have been possibly maybe with a certain unknown probability which I cannot prove" is a sufficient claim in court (or actually, anywhere else as well)?