4 ms·
Being declared dead is automated, so why is resurrection such a nightmare?
- GuB-42 4y agoThere was a story where an employee was fired by mistake. It was an automatic procedure and he had all his access revoked, computer and physical. No one could un-fire him, the only solution was to hire him again as if he was a new employee.
- jagged-chisel 4y agoThe good news is that you get the new employee salary increase instead of the token half-inflation-rate increase.
- 13of40 4y agoThe down-side is you get to find out whether they would hire you again if you weren't already on payroll.
- googlryas 4y agoBad news is all your accrued vacation days are wiped clean
- NamTaf 4y agoWhy aren't they paid out upon termination? Is that not standard policy in the US? You earnt them, after all. Just as they can't take back your earnt wages, they can't take back your earnt leave.
- thfuran 4y agoI don't think it's required by law. Edit: I guess a fair number of states do have laws for that, though unlimited vacation still gets around that.
- benreesman 4y agoFortunately, we’ve fixed the glitch.
- jkepler 4y agoYou took my stapler.
- LocalH 4y agoA quite macabre example of "computer says no"
- ncmncm 4y agoNice rejoinder to the mid-20th-century assertion about runaway automation that "we can always just turn it off". Not when it would be against the law to turn it off.
- thedanbob 4y agoFalsehoods that programmers believe: - Someone declared dead will never be declared alive again
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Joeri 4y agoThis applies to so many systems that have irreversible status transitions. I have seen this again and again over my career as a developer. A foolproof system is designed and then some fool of a user puts it in a different state from reality, after which it requires all kinds of tricking the system to make it match the observable universe. By now this should be system design 101: the system should always have an override to move a record from any state into any other state.
- SoftTalker 4y agoI try to design systems on an accounting principle. Every persistent state change is basically a journal entry, and you can always create a new entry to correct a prior entry.
- moralestapia 4y agoThis is almost always the right decision and it applies to pretty much any thing that needs to record anything. It also is one of the few down to earth use cases for a blockchain.
- alasdair_ 4y ago> It also is one of the few down to earth use cases for a blockchain. Please no. It may be really difficult to get a human beaurocrat to fix something but can you imagine what it would be like if there was a smart contract that wasn’t coded with this possibility in mind?
- 4y ago
- worker_person 4y agoIndia has the same issue. Apparently bribing an official is an easy way to settle a dispute. Without the messiness of actually killing someone. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uttar_Pradesh_Association_of_Dead_People https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uttar_Pradesh_Association_of_D...
- ev1 4y ago> > his uncle had bribed a government official with ₹300 to have his nephew declared deceased, in order to inherit Lal Bihari's ancestral land holdings of about 1 acre (0.4 ha). Subsequently, Lal Bihari lost his home. ..... In 1994, the Azamargh district magistrate, Hausla Prasad Verma, declared him to be once again alive. Bihari did, however, allow his uncle to continue farming the land he had stolen Wow, I would not have been nearly as kind there at the end.
- ncmncm 4y agoCf. Doc Daneeka in Catch-22, listed (as a courtesy so he could collect flight pay) on the flight manifest of a bomber that crashed, and that he was not counted to have parachuted out of. His persistent existence was resented by company officers, and eventually his wife.
- asr21 4y agoThe People need to use tombstone logic with a field as markAsDead.
- mike_hock 4y agoUse of an object after the destructor has been called is UB.
- zen_1 4y agoTime to introduce governments to placement new.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoLove Dabbsy's stories. There's a traditional way to screw over co-workers. On a day they are not in the office, scrawl "DECEASED" on all their mail, and drop it in the outbox. It's said to take years to undo. That long predates computers. The Motorhead vid was a bit sad, though. R. I. P., Lemmy.
- Stratoscope 4y agoI think this is the first of his stories I've read, and what a treat. I love this part of his autobio at the end: > He still stings from having to provide proof to the French authorities that he was not a bigamist prior to getting married. Most countries have such a thing as a Wedding Certificate but in France, there is also an official Certificate of Unmarriedness, and it is a right old bugger to find someone to draw one up when you’re not French. In the end, he persuaded a British consul to sign a letter stating that the aforementioned – a person he didn’t know and had never met – was, as far as he could guess, probably not already married, perhaps, maybe, I dunno, I hope not. The French authorities accepted it without further question. Back to the story, sometimes here in California we have the opposite problem, where someone really is dead, deceased, an ex-person, pushing up the daisies, kicked the bucket like Jimmy Durante [1], but no one will let him Rest In Peace. Every week or so I get a piece of mail with an offer for guaranteed issue of a life insurance policy for an acquaintance who died a few years ago. He never actually lived at my address, but through a chain of events his forwarding address was set to here. Since they are so insistent, I am tempted to fill in one of those applications on his behalf and see what happens. Maybe they will bring him back to life? After all, they do call it Life Insurance. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w00Kab17aeI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w00Kab17aeI "Did you see it? He (slap) sailed right out there!"
- CTDOCodebases 4y agoThe mechanics of birth/death registrations was once covered in a Blackhat talk. https://youtu.be/9FdHq3WfJgs https://youtu.be/9FdHq3WfJgs
- drdaeman 4y agoWell, people die all the time, so the process of registering such events is well known - it had to be repeated millions of times, and thus is typically well implemented and optimized. But people are falsely declared dead, or get revived after being declared dead quite infrequently, and that's why this process is typically not automated and sometimes even entirely missed.
- closeparen 4y agoDead people's identities are also great targets for e.g. spies, illegal immigrants, and money launderers, so governments have a strong interest in making sure the identities of the deceased get turned off promptly and thoroughly.
- FpUser 4y agoIf I am a victim why should I give a flying fuck about the reasons. It is their error and they must fix it ASAP. It is their fucking for job which we pay.
- thfuran 4y agoI'm quite sure that there is no one in the world whose job is only and specifically to assist you in being declared un-deceased and that, even if their were, they wouldn't have the authority to entire enact the process. Any person you interact with is going to have additional considerations beyond fulfilling your immediate request and the organization(s) they work with or for also will have additional priorities. How could you possibly expect everyone else to drop all other work to complete your request totally without regard for any of their other priorities?
- FpUser 4y agoI admire your attitude. Government knows these thing happen. If it is rare then it can be part time responsibility of some government employee. Appropriate authority can be given. When government wants something it always finds a way. Your attitude is - they know it will happen, it is rare so fuck it and lets ruin few lives so some government fucker does not have to strain all 2 brain cells they have left. Btw when bad things happen to "important people" suddenly it gets fixed in no time.
- LeoPanthera 4y agoThe more curious parts of my brain are wondering whether being offically declared dead and not fixing it would have any advantages.
- jamiek88 4y agoIt seems a great hack for a new life. Declare yourself dead and start again!
- incompatible 4y agoI'm sure it works on Hacker News, but creating a new identity can be harder elsewhere.
- makeitdouble 4y agoMoving to another country is a safer choice: you get to choose the level of “deadness” you are to your surroundings, if you just cut all ties nobody’s going after you. And you can start a new chapter somewhere you never existed in the first place.
- alasdair_ 4y agoYou could probably commit a crime, get bail, and then submit proof that you were dead to get away with it?
- jkepler 4y agoI suspect you'd have to never cross a border/barrier where ID was required, and you would need to pay cash (or bitcoin) in-person for everything, as you would be cut-off from the banking system. You'd probably also be limited to earning cash in work that didn't require your nonexistent legal identity.
- NullPrefix 4y agoDead men don't have any obligations to pay taxes. Just saying.
- mrtweetyhack 4y ago
- vba616 4y agoThe first part of the title reminds me of a previous employer, where offboarding was not automated. I know, because I recall a project to systematize and consistently revoke access to everything for anyone that left. My point is: automating a process may not make the opposite process easy, but when it's manual, I'd kind of expect things to be no better and maybe worse. If you don't even know exactly how a person was declared defunct, it can't be any easier to resurrect them.
- Tagbert 4y agoNot at the same level but I recently had to fight for 4 months to get my office location corrected after it was incorrectly recorded. I work in a company office in Seattle but was reporting to a boss in London. I changed jobs within the company and started to report to a boss in Chicago. What I hadn’t realized was that someone marked me as working in the Chicago office. Sounds like no big deal but then they started witholding state income taxes for Illinois out of my paycheck. My actual home office in Seattle is in a state with zero state taxes so it made a big difference. It took a month to realize that it had happened, then it took another month to get someone who could change me back to the correct state. Of course they were saying that I would need to wait until next year to file taxes and request that Illinois payback the witholdings. I managed to find some Illinois state tax regulations explaining a process to clawback overpaid taxes and sent that to our payroll team. Finally, after around 4 months, they issued me a check for $3,000.00 for the overpaid taxes. That was a surprisingly complex process even though this is a fairly modern tech company. Can’t imagine what a more traditional company would have been like. It also taught me to keep a closer eye on that automatically paid paycheck to watch for anything odd.