38 ms·
Severely deficient autobiographical memory (SDAM) in healthy adults (2015)
- RandomWorker 4y agoI feel like I have this. Can’t remember anything from the past, but my spouse remembers exactly every tiny detail from years ago.
- JaimeThompson 4y agoAre you able to form mental images in your head? I'm wondering if people who can't have more trouble with such things.
- warp 4y agoThere is a study here which looks at that: https://t.co/xYJvPJRUCj https://t.co/xYJvPJRUCj ( "Memories with a blind mind: Remembering the past and imagining the future with aphantasia"). I assume I have aphantasia, and I have bad episodic memory -- so to me linking the two makes sense. However, I don't remember (hah!) if the study linked above was able to establish that link as well.
- InvaderFizz 4y agoNot GP, but I experience the same thing. Wife remembers everything, I only remember extremely significant events, and not that much about the fine details. My capability for creating visual scenes is great, I really enjoy books because of the vivid scenes they paint in my mind. My visual memory of events is often literally fuzzy and in the third person(out of body, spectating myself in the scene).
- haswell 4y agoI am aphantasic, and have virtually zero memory of my past beyond a few fragments here and there. I’ve often wondered if the two are connected.
- v64 4y agoTo offer a counterexample, I have aphantasia, but have very detailed memories of my childhood. I have no problem recalling details like the full names of all my elementary school teachers, when I met most of my friends in school, and details about field trips we took. That being said, I only have visual aphantasia, so it may be that remembering these peoples' voices or what places smelled and sounded like may be helping those memories. I dated someone without aphantasia who was amazed at my childhood recall compared to her own. It turned out she later discovered she had SDAM.
- germinalphrase 4y agoI have a very vivid imagination (and utilize it professionally), but my time/date/name recollection is quite poor. I also score quite high on imagistic/spatial thinking, fwiw.
- driggs 4y agoI believe that deficiencies in Episodic Memory can be related to Aphantasia. My hypothesis is that when people with high mental image visualization recall an event, they are re-experiencing it in a sense, and therefore reinforcing its details (or details as remembered, at least!). A person with aphantasia recalling that event does not re-experience it in a way that triggers this feedback loop, not as efficiently or completely at least. I have very detailed memory about facts, places that I've been and seen, including spatial models; but how many times I've visited a place, who I was with on which trip, which events occurred on which visit, these details quickly become obscured and lost.
- towaway15463 4y agoFrom personal experience, I don’t think aphantasia and lack of episodic memory are related. I have a poor memory for personal experiences as far as what was said or how I felt and often don’t remember things from a first person view but I have very strong visual mental imagery and spatial reasoning. This results in most of my memories of experiences being 3rd person or “fly through” where I can clearly picture the environment I was in, the people who were there, and myself but seen from other perspectives as if observing a scene. I realize that my memory of all the details isn’t perfect and that they are largely filled in by my prior knowledge or even imagination but it is still accurate enough for the important things. It’s not very useful though and I often wish I could remember what people say or even what I said.
- driggs 4y agoIf you have "very strong visual mental imagery", then by definition you have no personal experience with aphantasia.
- towaway15463 4y agoYeah I was saying I didn’t but I also don’t have good episodic memory so my point was that they aren’t directly connected at least for me.
- pitaj 4y agoAs a counterexample: I have good mental image capabilities, but have a terrible episodic memory.
- swayvil 4y agoSame here. She remembers all this stuff over decades. I can barely remember last week. Sometimes I wonder if there's something up with my brain. Yes, I am actually pretty good at other brain stuff. Software and design and such. Good at concentration. And there's that "absent minded professor" archetype to consider. On the third hand, working outside in this heat can bake the brains right out of your head.
- lazide 4y agoPersonally, I’ve noticed I’ll cycle between something like this (absent minded professor) and very aware with a good memory of events, times, and sequences. For me, it’s largely based on type of mental load, anxiety, and degree of rest and exercise. Low stress, mental load low and mostly oriented towards people, and good diet and exercise and I’ll be able to remember almost every moment and recall and integrate it into a coherent narrative quite easily. Mental load high and focused on abstract deep concepts? Higher anxiety? Less exercise and not as good nutrition? Where am I, and who are you?
- dQw4w9WgXcQ 4y ago> Sometimes I wonder if there's something up with my brain. Yea it's called being a man. Biologically speaking men statistically have far fewer connections between the two halves of their brain. Your wife basically has a gigabit link between her two halves while you're on 56k, which contributes to the intensity of her integrated story-telling experience. On one hand this often gives women better recall, but it also generally enables men to ignore intense experiences better (i.e. easier to block out the cross-chatter) and soldier forward. > Yes, I am actually pretty good at other brain stuff. The results establish that male brains are optimized for intrahemispheric and female brains for interhemispheric communication. -- https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3896179/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3896179/
- Foobar8568 4y agoBasically the same, maybe with a twist, I feel that my brain is optimizing my memory for my current "activities". I can recollect anything related to my current jobs, up to 15years ago might be still recallable, but anything else will be just bribe of information. And no need to ask me the name of my best friends/girl friends etc during my teenagehood -earlier, just blank.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- layer8 4y agoThis may be related to how much you have communicated with others about your experiences and events vs. how much your wife has. And not only communication, but how much time spent with inner reflection about recent events. This should play an important role in solidifying memories and making them persistent.
- claytongulick 4y agoI'm in the same boat. I can remember old Win32 C APIs and details like DDX that I haven't used in 20 years, but I frequently make gaffes with my wife, not remembering things that are important to her. I can remember the paper, pages and formatting of old Sam's and Wrox technical manuals, I can visually recall the exact shade of blue of the old DOS Borland C compiler, and the look and feeling of the pages in favorite books I read as a teenager. But my wedding is just a series of fragmented images all mixed up with outher things. I remember the night my wife and I met only in "narrative form". She, on the other hand, can remember events like that in crystal detail, she can describe everyone that was there, what they were wearing, etc... I read this study with a sense of comfort, nice to know it's not just me. Based on some of the comments here, I think it would be interesting to see if this sort of thing is a trend with different sexes.
- wruza 4y agomy spouse remembers exactly every tiny detail from years ago “Cause you don’t care!”
- jasonhansel 4y agoOne annoyance: it looks like their p-values weren't adjusted for multiple comparisons, which seems like a problem given the number of different comparisons they made in e.g. the fMRI results. If I'm doing my math right: if they applied the Bonferroni or Sidak corrections to the fMRI results, then only one of those comparisons would still be significant.
- sudden_dystopia 4y agoI can remember a lot of things from my childhood but there are things I simply have no recollection of from a time when I should have been old enough to remember them. Things that my younger sister remembers but I do not. This was rather distressing but I am happy to see I am not alone.
- tra3 4y agoSaved for later reading, this was interesting in the intro though: > For example, when given randomly selected dates or event cues from their past, HSAM individuals can effortlessly recall many details of what happened, even if trivial (e.g., what they had for dinner) without the use of mnemonic aids. They are neither savants nor calendar counters (although they possess extensive calendar knowledge from their own lifespan) and they are distinct from other types of superior memorizers who possess vast learning and retention of meaningless information This is the opposite group from the study, that is the group that has superior autobiographic memory. I find this incredible because I’d have to work hard to remember what I had for dinner 3 days. I’d normally do it by unspooling my memory to identify what the day was about to try to find some context. This only works up to a couple of days. Maybe a week. But there’s no way I’ll remember anything from 2 weeks or more in the past. Anyway, I thought this was amazing.
- rapnie 4y agoMakes me wonder. If you ever are interrogated by police or in a court room.. "Where were you on the night of 22 January 2020?" and "Can't you also remember that you went to ..?". Now if you were guilty the night may have left quite an impression in memory. Not guilty, and you likely answer to every question "Dunno, your honor", making you look really suspicious in the eyes of onlookers.
- lumost 4y agoI suspect that one of the activities a lawyer does in this case is prepping you to answer these questions. Rather than "dunno" the answer could be "It was an unremarkable night, I ate dinner at home, watched netflix, and went to bed". Odds are the browser history/location history on your phone would provide corroboration for the above if needed.
- SV_BubbleTime 4y agoAlong that, you would do your own investigation. Look over texts, emails, calls, credit card charges, and use discovery from the other side like location data, surveillance footage, and etc. This is ALSO why you don’t ever talk to police. You talk to lawyers. If a cop were to ask you the same “where were you at” question, it’s probably better to not answer at all.
- DontchaKnowit 4y agoHonestly I had a really solid memory for the most part until I started doing drugs and drinking. College is a giant blur. I remember many many insignificant events in fine detail but putting together a timezone of events I impossible. E.g. which classes and when. Etc Now that I've layed of the drugs and reduced my alcoholism to socially normal levels my memory is a lot better.
- mmcgaha 4y agoI have memories from my early childhood that I will not share with others because the only logical conclusion they could draw is that I am full of shit. My youngest daughter appears to be the same and I caution her about how it looks to others. The weird part is that my memory is at best normal in all other regards.
- wjnc 4y agoCan you explain without telling the memory? So you mean like age 1-2-3 year old memories? I’ve got a few of those that seem unrelated to family pictures or stories told on later dates. My dad had a few very early memories and one of my children has for sure. He once vividly described the car we had until he was less than 1 year old. I wouldn’t discount the pre 6 year old memory, although I’ve read and noticed that at that age a large filter follows.
- lazide 4y agoAre they backed up by any evidence or related memories from others? Sometimes some folks have near photographic memories of things others don’t, other times they believe they do and their brain has filled in the gaps with what feels like extremely vivid detail - but when cross checked against evidence or others, it becomes clear those memories could not possibly be true.
- colordrops 4y agoWhat does "vividly recall" here? I remember different events from my past with differing levels of clarity. For almost none of them do I have a chronological memory of the event, but rather snapshots of bits and pieces, some clear and some not. I'm 47 and this has gotten worse with time. I've only been able to perfectly recall events up into my early 20s. Always thought this was normal.
- camtarn 4y ago"Each case reported a lifetime inability to recollect events from a first-person perspective". "The SDAM cases reported here have a lifetime of practice in compensating for their lack of first-person, autonoetic connection to their own past with non-episodic processes (supported by, for example, rehearsing events and reviewing photographs)" They tested this by asking participants to recall and describe past events in as much detail as they could, then scored the transcribed recollections based on whether they were internal experiences (things they could sense, emotions they felt, etc) or external ('semantic facts (factual information or extended events that did not require recollection of a specific time and place), autobiographical events tangential or unrelated to the main event, repetitions, or other metacognitive statements (“I can׳t remember”) or editorializing (“It was the best of times”).') They also scored the recollections on how detailed they were. So, as a somewhat speculative example, presumably somebody with SDAM would be able to tell you that they went to the fairground with two friends, and it was sunny, and it was fun - because they have a photo with those two friends at the fairground in the sun, and one of the friends later told them it was fun. But they couldn't tell you what other bits of the fairground looked like, that it smelled of cotton candy and hot trash, what it felt like to go down the hill on the roller-coaster, how hot and thirsty they got waiting in line. I have somewhat deficient autobiographical memory - I have zero recollection of a lot of things from my past, and for others I just have a snapshot of them, like a photo with some vague feelings attached. But I'm still capable of experiencing at least some of my memories in first person, so I wouldn't qualify as having SDAM.
- swayvil 4y agoMaybe it's an attention thing. Attention is like a flashlight in a dark room full of furniture. One of those focusable flaslights that you can twist from spot to flood. When the flashlight is spot you illuminate that chair brightly. Every detail in high contrast. But you don't see the couch or the coffeetable. When the flashlight is flood you see everything in the room, but dimly. Longterm memory is like the coffeetable. If you're focussed on the couch then you aren't gonna see the coffeetable. Women seem to prefer the flood. Men the spot.
- rapjr9 4y agoIt may have to do with rehearsal of memories. Some people go over and over their past, recount it often in stories told to others, discuss it with people who were there at the time. Others don't dwell on the past, don't often review it, and focus on now. It may require some repetition to engrain memories long term and keep them fresh. Although other research suggests that every revisit of a memory alters it somewhat, is a rethinking of it, and the rethinking is remembered instead of the original. Eyewitness testimony in court is notoriously unreliable. Everyone has their own contexts and remembers events in light of those contexts, rather than what actually happened. One person remembers it was a fun party, another that it was a dreadful party.
- joecool1029 4y agoI dunno, I have excellent autobiographical memory with the exception I can't tie the events to specific times, I just know how/what happened. Like I can tell someone it happened and if I have a log of it digitally I know exactly where to search, like minute conversations from 15 years ago. I'm a man who's also ambidextrous and ADHD'd. I don't file, I collect and search.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rvr_ 4y agoTruth is, our lizard brains are always forgetting the good stuff that happened but remembering every detail of some random shameful event nobody, except you, cares about.
- can16358p 4y agoProbably evolutionary: our brains have evolved into hardcoding those memories to avoid getting into that bad situation again.
- derefr 4y agoOr, to put that another way: of what practical use is a memory of being content? It has no informational content to feed to your predictive model of the world. Memories of unexpectedly getting rewards are quite salient, of course, because those train you to get more rewards.
- civilized 4y agoCan they study the type where you only remember the most embarrassing and negative things? I've had a lot of positive experiences but I have no vivid recollection of anything except the few dozen most negative experiences of my life.
- techwiz137 4y agoOk, this is me. My experiences start to merge with those of others, I cannot be 100% certain that something I am remembering now really happened or if it happened to someone else who shared it with me. There are certain elements I cannot remember from say 10 years ago or 5. I forgot the names of some of my classmates, I sometimes forget words I shouldn't. My memory is a mess.
- can16358p 4y agoWhile I have many memories from my childhood, there's a hard limit around 7 years old. Just like the very early universe is hidden behind an opaque plasma to electromagnetic radiation for observing, I can't, and have never (including at my childhood ages like 8-9) remembered anything before 7 years old. It's just not there. Many people around me have no trouble remembering like their 3 years old, don't know if it counts.
- antisthenes 4y agoI've lost this ability after a traumatic brain injury (TBI).
- _moof 4y agoSort of related, just curious: Does anyone else mostly remember things from a third-person perspective? When I recall past events the mental images are almost always from outside myself. Thought I read somewhere that this is common but I can't remember where (har har).
- joecool1029 4y agoNo, but I can visualize it that way. When recalling spaces and events I can usually replay it as I saw it (first person) I assumed 3rd person visualization after the fact is reinterpreting the original memory and more subject to corruption/influence.
- dboreham 4y agoNot to be confused with: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_Atomic_Demolition_Munition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_Atomic_Demolition_Muni...
- wrs 4y agoIf this “deficiency” is a new discovery, how was “normal” defined in the first place?
- _tom_ 4y agoBy everyone assuming that other people were like them. Aphantasia, inner monologues, episodic memory - people have started discussing their internal thought and capabilities and we are discovering we are more different than we thought.
- projektfu 4y agoWhen I'm up against a person with a great long-term episodic memory I feel like they're gaslighting me. I can't remember yesterday. However I don't think I'm like these people. I don't take notes or review photos. I just accept that I'm going to make people unhappy that I don't remember events and people very well.
- fallingfrog 4y agoI have vivid memories of places I’ve been and things I’ve done, but I have absolutely no idea when any of those events occurred. I don’t remember what order I lived in what house, although I could draw you a picture of each of them. Same with my job history, I keep it written down in case I have to fill it out on a job app, and if I lost that piece of paper, I wouldn’t be able to tell you when I had any past job more accurately than +\- 5 years. I don’t know when my car’s registration is due - I remember registering it lots of times, but other than visual cues (I remember it being sunny so it was between may and August) I have no idea which memory is the most recent or when that was. I don’t remember appointments or due dates; I tend to just work on a project till it’s done. I start at the beginning, keep going till I get to the end, then, stop. People ask me for time estimates on how long programming tasks will take and honestly it’s kind of hilarious that they expect any kind of accurate answer considering that without writing down the dates I worked on it I wouldn’t have any idea if my estimate was accurate even after doing the work. So what basis do I have to even guess? But I remember the wind in my hair and the color of the sea from when I sailed a boat on the ocean by myself once decades ago. I just sort of live in an endless perpetual now with no distinct future or past. I don’t know where that puts me in this spectrum.