8 ms·
The Great Green Wall
- hunglee2 4y ago
- m0llusk 4y agoThe idea of limiting the expansion of the Sahara desert with mass tree plantings started gaining traction back in the 1950s. The people most closely associated with this idea are British. Qaddafi died when he was mutilated by other Libyans.
- calibas 4y agoOther Libyans who happened to be backed by NATO. Qaddafi was no saint, quite the opposite, but that shouldn't give Western countries a free pass to go directly interfere in Libyan politics. It has very little to do with helping Libyans, and much more to do with the fact that Libya happens to be located on the largest oil reserves in Africa.
- finiteseries 4y agoAmerican and British naval forces fired over 110 Tomahawk cruise missiles, while the French Air Force, British Royal Air Force, and Royal Canadian Air Force undertook sorties across Libya and a naval blockade by Coalition forces. French jets launched air strikes against Libyan Army tanks and vehicles. The intervention did not employ foreign ground troops. The effort was initially largely led by France and the United Kingdom, with command shared with the United States. Both Libyan officials and international states and organizations called for a no-fly zone over Libya in light of allegations that Muammar Gaddafi's military had conducted airstrikes against Libyan rebels in the Libyan Civil War. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_military_intervention_in_Libya https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_military_intervention_in_...
- ping00 4y agoSorry, not sure why you expanded on this particular event. Could you explain if I missed something? :)
- finiteseries 4y agoI doubt you’ve missed HN having a slightly higher standard of commentary than other social media sites, and non moderators’ parts in keeping it that way. Being irrationally Americentric while simultaneously condescending to Europeans in characterizing the Libyan intervention as “US” gets both basic recent history wrong, and promulgates US > EU sentiment worryingly present on HN. I’m doing my part, would you like to know more?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dang 4y agoPlease don't post unsubstantive and/or flamebait comments to HN. We're trying for a different quality of discussion here. If you want to write something substantive and relevant about that, or anyone/anything else, that's of course fine. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- hahamrfunnyguy 4y agoChina has been doing something similar to try to slow the spread of the Gobi desert. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pSn6S-H7m-8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pSn6S-H7m-8 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Green_Wall_(China) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Green_Wall_(China)
- fourthark 4y agoAnd they have more of an incentive to think in the long term and follow through.
- gumby 4y agoWhy should they have more of an incentive to think for the long term?
- ospider 4y agoAlthough I don't like dictatorship, they do have a stable process in doing this through at least 3 administrations.
- gumby 4y agoThat is true of the green wall as well. And in the US plenty of projects (from interstate highway to James Webb telescope) pass through more than three administrations.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ncmncm 4y agoMaybe you mean they have more cultural inclination?
- affgrff2 4y agoWhy do I feel so pessimistic about this?
- tjr225 4y agoHow old are you?
- singularity2001 4y agoMaybe because it's too little too late and it can't stop the ever growing pressures of overpopulation. But then since each degree of climate change adds a significant 7% humidity to the atmosphere, I have a faint hope that one year a torrential rain will turn the sahara into a green savanna again.
- danaris 4y agoNeither our planet in general, nor its comfortably-livable surface area, are overpopulated in the aggregate. We have enough resources to provide for everyone here now, and everyone likely to be here within the next several decades—at which point, according to the best predictions I've seen, overall population growth should be slowing or stopping.
- jeromenerf 4y agoI find the initiative somehow formidable, commending hope and thus the fear of seeing it fail.
- lbriner 4y agoBecause you are a pessimist? Even if it only half works, it is worthwhile, which is why lots of anti-climate change action is worthwhile. Add up all the little bits and maybe it delays catastrophic climiate change long enough to get some new ways of solving it, or long enough for a younger generation to take it more seriously, maybe it makes the rise in temperatures slightly more bearable, the sea rises slightly less or the species extinctions fewer in number. Certainly a better investment than the 4x4s, overseas holidays and technology that lots of rich people spend their money on!
- lettergram 4y ago8000-10000 years ago the entire desert this wall is supposedly going to block was green. https://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/what-really-turned-sahara-desert-green-oasis-wasteland-180962668/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/what-really-tu...
- singularity2001 4y agoThen came the first instance of catastrophic human steered overgrazing
- lettergram 4y agoThat’s not true at all lol, complete BS. For one, the amount of grazing required for that is absolutely larger than anything we have today. We exited an ice age, which created conditions which helped to create pastures. Climate change has been happening far longer than humans have impacted it (not saying humans aren’t impacting it). Further, grazing makes fields more robust if done property. Grasses will grow faster to compensate and the poop enhances the conditions to create fields.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nerdponx 4y ago> the amount of grazing required for that is absolutely larger than anything we have today Who's to say that there wasn't more grazing (by area) back then? > Further, grazing makes fields more robust if done property. I'm not a farmer, but I know that this depends a lot on what is doing the grazing. Sheep for example apparently graze the grass down really far, and prevent the growth of bushes and tree saplings that are otherwise important for balancing the ecosystem. In the US in the 1800s, there was outright armed conflict between sheep and cattle ranchers over this issue: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sheep_Wars https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sheep_Wars And as far as I know, England and Scotland lack trees specifically because overgrazing prevented forests from regenerating after being cut for timber: https://youtu.be/nAGHUkby2Is https://youtu.be/nAGHUkby2Is
- justinzollars 4y agoDoing this is the opposite of being a doomer. I love the concept of terraforming the desert and desert walls. This is positive, inexpensive and we should do much more of this.
- ch4s3 4y agoYeah, I’m not sure it will work but I like that it’s proactive and unlikely to have any negative effects other than opportunity cost.
- justinzollars 4y agoyup!
- Comevius 4y agoPlanting trees without any sense of how they would become a viable ecosystem is pointless. Forests are complex ecosystems. Businesses do this because it's the cheapest sustainability strategy. These are economic project that not only don't put a single dent on climate change, they make it worst. The easiest solutions are often the worst.
- googlryas 4y agoHow does this make climate change worse? Isn't it possible for a complex ecosystem to develop without knowing exactly how it happens? My compost heap hosts a fairly complex ecosystem - more complex than I understand, and I created it merely by heaping my yard waste and food scraps in the corner of my lot. If someone gave you $15B, how would you use it to put a dent in climate change?
- Comevius 4y agoIt makes it worst by letting businesses write off pollution. Entire industries are becoming carbon neutral, on paper at least. Ever wondered how building 10 billion electric cars will save the planet? You can't put a dent on climate change until you find a way to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. That's what matters. Trees have to last a 100 years to be effective carbon stores.
- c54 4y agoI couldn't find details about the logistics and design of the GGW itself. I know the similar Chinese project largely failed because they planted a monocrop of trees in perfect grid formation, which turns out doesn't create a self-sustaining forest. Is this mistake getting fixed with the GGW? Are they planting a diversity of native drought-tolerant species over a varying timeline to allow for trees of different ages?
- kleton 4y agoIndeed, there is a "technical brief" on their site, which has no technical details but a lot of information about how they can get funding from World Bank and other NGOs. https://static1.squarespace.com/static/564a15a0e4b0773edf86e3b4/t/6152fd627c3cb34be41dbe29/1632828805698/Technical+brief+GGWA+sept21_clean.pdf https://static1.squarespace.com/static/564a15a0e4b0773edf86e...
- phtrivier 4y agoIs the project independantly assessed by anyone ? (UN, press, etc... ?) Of course I'm on the "doubting" side (bad habit), but I can't wait for being wrong about doomism once in a while
- Biologist123 4y agoThis project is not thought to be going well. https://www.lifegate.com/africas-great-green-wall-a-bursting-dream https://www.lifegate.com/africas-great-green-wall-a-bursting... Having worked within the sector, there was a clear lack of interest in or budget for monitoring - so claims of success must be met with requests for verifiable evidence, which is never forthcoming.
- tinco 4y agoWouldn't a project of this size be easily monitored with publicly available sattelite imagery? If there was funding, you could structure it purely based on the imagery, for example a country could receive ~1M$ for every 10px of green that was not green at the start of the project. And another ~1M$ if those pixels are still green 5 years later, and perhaps some diminishing recurring payment afterwards to ensure the projects survival.
- Biologist123 4y agoThe problem is this: 1. Tree survival is an issue before the trees become “visible” from space. 2. Project funding typically lasts 3-5 years at a max. 3. In the organisations which run this type of project, there is an “I’ll be gone, you’ll be gone” staff problem: flawed projects are funded and staffed by people who know they won’t carry the can for project failure. 4. To be very realistic, funders of these projects don’t care. Indeed, corruption might be a feature rather than a bug.
- tinco 4y agoAh that's unfortunate. I'm sure there's technological solutions to point 1, but that's pretty irrelevant if the other three points are true. It seems a bit ridiculous if a project funding is 3-5 years, if it's supposed to be a permanent solution. Are corrupt funders really such a large share of money for these projects? Is it industrial companies using non-profit funding to grease wheels for their endeavors?
- gumby 4y agoAllegedly it has already had an effect on rainfall but I haven’t found anything refereed on the topic (not that I tried too hard — not my day job). Also the effect is allegedly improved monsoon in some places (at the cost of drought elsewhere). I’d think that the cost alone would have given rise to some interesting papers, were it actually happening. All that being said, I’m still encouraged by some efforts, though they remind me of protectors trying to repair the ramjets at the edge of the ringworld.
- monetus 4y agoThis has been ongoing / in the works for a long time and the methods they are embracing now are more likely to succeed in the long term. A mono-culture of out-of-place trees, it is not. It is country by country so there are some problems around coordination and equal funding iirc
- spaceman_2020 4y agoThey say that 15% of the work is complete. Is there any way to see this on Google Earth?
- greggeter 4y ago
- robert2020 4y agoEven if we’re all going to hell, greener Africa sounds nice, regardless.
- divbzero 4y agoI came here expecting an article about Fenway Park.
- chadk 4y agoI really wish them well. Dr Nakamura Tetsu worked for 30 years in Afghanistan and was able to make huge changes there, so I know it is possible. https://chadkohalyk.com/2021/03/24/nakamura-tetsu/ https://chadkohalyk.com/2021/03/24/nakamura-tetsu/ The one thing my pessimist outlook (and something that might be reflected in other takes here on HN) is that Nakamura was adamant about focusing on local needs. He gave short shrift to global programs and NGOs. What made him different, and what I think made him successful, was that he _listened_ to the people.