4 ms·
Celsius seems to have been either a ponzi scheme, or a group of morons doing dumb speculative investment on margin, or (most likely) both, but I'd like to point
by vkou 4y ago
Celsius seems to have been either a ponzi scheme, or a group of morons doing dumb speculative investment on margin, or (most likely) both, but I'd like to point out that MakerDAO is down 70% YTD, Aave is down 60%, Uniswap is down 60%, etc, etc.
You'd have been better off just buying bitcoin on margin (Since BTC is only down 53% YTD).
The point of this post is that you can't make something out of nothing. None of these tokens/firms/etc have any idea of how they can make money in the crypto space, because there is no way to make money in the crypto space - because it doesn't produce anything. It's all just negative-sum speculation, and shitcoins investing into other shitcoins, and it all evaporates as soon as the Fed tightens its purse-strings.
Miners make money, people selling shovels make money, everyone else is just trading baseball cards around.
- TimJRobinson 4y agoTheir tokens are down, but you don't have to buy them to use the platform, they're basically like shares in a company. I constantly use all those platforms without ever buying their tokens. AMZN being down 30% in the last 6 months has no impact on how useful Amazon or AWS are as products.
- Wertigoyr 4y agoWhat does there platform provide then?
- basch 4y agoCurrency exchange. P2P Lending. Money services.
- nradov 4y agoBut the problem is that it's not real currency and you can't do anything useful with it beyond trying to trade it to a bigger idiot.
- whatisweb3 4y agoSome people want USDC, some people want non fungible assets, some people want ETH, some people want an ERC20 that backs an idea or organization. DeFi let’s these users manage these assets without placing them in the hands of a single actor. Saying nobody wants ETH or USDC is like saying nobody wants AMZN or AAPL shares. What you really mean is that you are not interested in those assets.
- nradov 4y agoThose are not "assets" in any meaningful sense. You're just making things up.
- whatisweb3 4y agoETH or USDC are as much “assets” as stocks, gold, bonds, property, domain names. Humans and social consensus made all of this up.
- junofan 4y agoGoldfinch is doing ok. It’s a financial system—what do you expect?
- yokem55 4y ago> but I'd like to point out that MakerDAO is down 70% YTD, Aave is down 60%, Uniswap is down 60%, etc, etc. The health of the protocols is only very marginally connected to the value of the tokens that govern them. Even if the $UNI token went to zero, the liquidity pools and swap contracts would still work fine. $MKR and $AAVE are a little more complicated because if the governance tokens got too cheap, the protocols could be hijacked and some of the lending parameters could be set to 'broken' values, resulting in liquidations that didn't need to happen. But as of now, the protocols are still working as designed.
- vkou 4y agoThat's wonderful. But what are all these loans used for? Arbitrage? Trading other coins around? It's turtles all the way down - there's nothing that generates value at the bottom.
- dcolkitt 4y agoWe could easily put real economic assets and loans on-chain. The legal frameworks exist On-chain yields are now low enough and “real-world” interest rates high enough that there’d be demand. Delaware courts can and have enforced corporate entities governed by software. The problem is that all of this is currently illegal, because The SEC and Gary Gensler have made zero effort to build a regulatory framework for securities as tokens.
- nradov 4y agoThat is entirely hypothetical and there is zero benefit to putting real economic assets and loans on-chain.
- vkou 4y agoWe could, and we could also build cars that run on peanut butter. We don't, because there is no point to it, because it costs too much, and because it solves problems that have already been solved. It's not going to magically make inflation or interest rates go away. You are correct that the legal system would still be around, and will still be able to do pretty much everything that it's doing now. It's not illegal, because it's not actually in the realm of the SEC. What you describe - the background implementation of finance isn't an investment, it's just boring clerical work. [1] If there were a better way to do it with blockchains, people would adopt it. Unfortunately, blockchains do not solve the hard problems in this space, but they do make the easy problems both hard and expensive. [1] Yes, it's regulated, but the regulation allows for improvements. The regulation isn't the problem - getting everyone's workflows that are accustomed to how this clerical work is done is the problem! Nobody will switch to a system that's not better, and blockchains are not a better system for this [2]. [2] And if they were, no currently existing blockchain would be a better system for this. If stock clearing or whatever would somehow work better through a blockchain[3], there's no reason to do it on a blockchain that has already been pre-mined, and is being traded around by speculators. Why pay them a first-movers tax, when you can just fork and spin up your own? The hashing power of anything but BTC and maybe the ETH networks isn't sufficient to prevent attacks on something as important as this - so the existing coin ecosystems have zero value for this usecase. The organizations adopting this would have to control the hashing power, as well - and at that point, why pay third-parties for it? [3] It wouldn't.
- tsimionescu 4y ago> You'd have been better off just buying bitcoin on margin (Since BTC is only down 53% YTD). It's also funny to note that you'd have been better off just buying Turkish Lyra, which is "only" down ~29%. Most fiats, at least in Europe, are down waaaaaay less than that, of course. So much for crypto as a store of value.
- aaaaaaaaata 4y agoWill we catch you right here next year, or the year after when it's at a new all-time high, saying the opposite?
- tsimionescu 4y agoAt worst I may be silent if that happens, but I have never believed in the long term value of crypto, even when friends and family members invested.
- aaaaaaaaata 4y ago> At worst I may be silent Considering your expertise in the area, this sounds like "at best".
- tim333 4y agoYeah if you'd put $1000 into bitcoin five years ago, at current prices you'd only have $10,000 left. So much worse than leaving it in the bank.
- tsimionescu 4y agoI responded to a comment about YTD, not 5 years ago.