4 ms·
"the dictum that truth always triumphs over persecution, is one of those pleasant falsehoods which men repeat after one another till they pass into commonplaces
by dredmorbius 4y ago
"the dictum that truth always triumphs over persecution, is one of those pleasant falsehoods which men repeat after one another till they pass into commonplaces, but which all experience refutes. History teems with instances of truth put down by persecution. If not suppressed forever, it may be thrown back for centuries."
– John Stuart Mill, On Liberty (https://www.utilitarianism.com/ol/two.html https://www.utilitarianism.com/ol/two.html)
- throwawaylinux 4y ago
- dredmorbius 4y agoDisinformation and misinformation are noted tactics used by those who would seize control of levers of power and use them to their own ends as well. Control over information is a fundamental tool of power and warfare (cf: Arendt, Mill, von Clausewitz, Machiavelli, Sun Tzu, and many others). Ascribing it to any one faction, or presuming all factions seeking power are uniform and unified, is another fallacy (broad brush) . Those who seek to base power on democratic principles, for the maximum number and good, have at least a more altruistic objective to their credit.
- throwawaylinux 4y agoFortunately I didn't ascribe or presume any such thing. > Those who seek to base power on democratic principles, for the maximum number and good, have at least a more altruistic objective to their credit. Those who seek power within ostensibly democratic systems aren't basing power on those systems though, they're trying to gain power by the means available to them. And those who claim they are out to do good with power are deserving of no particular credit for it.
- dredmorbius 4y agoYou did: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32103825 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32103825 (https://archive.ph/qJQFO https://archive.ph/qJQFO) We can look to what the past accomplishments (consistent with present actions), and stated goals are. Many see significant differences. Blair said it well: “The Party seeks power entirely for its own sake. We are not interested in the good of others; we are interested solely in power. Not wealth or luxury or long life or happiness: only power, pure power. We know that no one ever seizes power with the intention of relinquishing it. Power is not a means, it is an end. The object of persecution is persecution. The object of torture is torture. The object of power is power. Now do you begin to understand me?” https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/8327593-the-party-seeks-power-entirely-for-its-own-sake-we https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/8327593-the-party-seeks-pow... Where actions are power-seeking and rationales, justifications, and/or inspirations are grossly inconsistent, Blair's description seems to fit.
- bigDinosaur 4y agoBlair being Orwell. It amused me to think of Tony Blair saying what you quoted though.
- throwawaylinux 4y agoNo, I did not: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32103825 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32103825 I never "ascribed it to any one faction", nor did I "presume all factions seeking power are uniform and unified". You may retract your false assertion and furnish me with an apology at your earliest convenience. > Where actions are power-seeking and rationales, justifications, and/or inspirations are grossly inconsistent, Blair's description seems to fit. And we can certainly look back over history to show that governments, including allegedly "democratic" governments, and corporations and the wealthy who have lied and deceived and conspired to commit atrocities and crimes, wars, coups, invasions, genocides, slavery, and plundering others of their wealth and natural resources. It's not the carpenter who wonders why her business has to shut down or the dad wondering why his 6 year old may not go to school that society needs protecting from. It's the people who lie to go to war for oil and arms dealers.
- artificialLimbs 4y agoIt is under the banner of "for the greater good" that the most horrific atrocities in history have been commited.
- dredmorbius 4y agoWe can look not just at the banners but the actual deeds. And many of the banners are not in fact claiming "for the greater good" but something quite different.
- Dylan16807 4y agoCitation needed.
- aeonik 4y agoThis is one particularly well-known case study: https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/nejmp048136 https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/nejmp048136
- Dylan16807 4y agoIt might have been a factor in some of the early eugenics programs. The worse parts were not "for the greater good", they were causing massive harm on purpose.
- TimPC 4y agoBut everyone believes in some censorship so it’s disingenuous to claim one side believes in free speech and others don’t. Both sides want to censor harmful activity it’s just a question of what bar of harm they are using. Some people want to censor only things like child porn. Others want to censor things like the TidePods challenge too. Still others want to censor quack cures that don’t work that people might die from using in place of actual treatment. The problem with bad free speech is that people aren’t accountable to it. If you convince someone of a quack cure and they try it and die as a result even if they have proof they tried it because of what you said it’s very difficult to hold you to any legal accountability. The net result is speech that has freedom from responsibility.
- throwawaylinux 4y agoAre you implying I was being disingenuous or claiming one "side" believes in free speech or others don't? I wasn't aware that I was even talking about "sides". > The problem with bad free speech is that people aren’t accountable to it. If you convince someone of a quack cure and they try it and die as a result even if they have proof they tried it because of what you said it’s very difficult to hold you to any legal accountability. The net result is speech that has freedom from responsibility. I don't know what "bad" free speech is or why people wouldn't be accountable for it. People absolutely should be accountable for damage to others caused by their actions (including speech). That is the foundation of the civil legal system and does not mean you can't have free speech. > If you convince someone of a quack cure and they try it and die as a result even if they have proof they tried it because of what you said it’s very difficult to hold you to any legal accountability. The net result is speech that has freedom from responsibility. Well fraud and other things should be able to cover a lot of situations like this. A lot of the rest should be covered by the listener taking responsibility for themselves too. And what is left... I don't claim to be perfect or immune to abuse. I don't see how you are constructing an argument though. "Here is a bad hypothetical thing that I'm alleging that free speech might allow to happen". So... what's exactly the point here? What does that make free speech worse or better than? Does government and corporations mass censoring people stop them from lying to one another or convincing each other of fallacies? And it can just as easily be spun the other way too here's my hypothetical -- if the US government and their corporate owners and media sycophants had not lied and bullied and intimidated and effectively censored people into not speaking out against the war in Iraq, trillions of dollars and hundreds of thousands of lives might have been saved. My position isn't that "free speech" is perfect, or that it has to be absolute without limits or not at all because that would apparently be hypocritical. It is that those with the means and power to enact censorship have also been the ones responsible for lies, atrocities, theft, wars, and injustice. And that we shouldn't be comfortable with censorship whether its directly by the government or by corporations at the behest of the ruling class who happen to own the government. And that people shouldn't be fooled (for the nth time) by their crocodile tears and pleas about the greater good and how they are in it together with us (and therefore they need to keep us quiet).