4 ms·
I'm a strategic thinker. I have been, almost my entire career. I write software that lasts decades, and have authored systems that took ten years to mature. Th
by ChrisMarshallNY 4y ago
I'm a strategic thinker. I have been, almost my entire career. I write software that lasts decades, and have authored systems that took ten years to mature.
The issue is that I have almost never been allowed to express, communicate, or implement my strategies.
"Strategic thinking" is an ego thing. Only "big bosses" are "allowed" to "think strategically." If those of us, down in the trenches, "dare" to think strategically, we're being "uppity."
What a nightmare. At my last company, I foresaw the problems that eventually resulted in the company falling down (and my team being made redundant), at least a decade in advance. I remember being called a "Cassandra," and also being told that it "wasn't specific enough."
For example, when the iPhone first came out, I borrowed one of my employees' new iPhone, and took it up to Marketing. I said "This is gonna be trouble."
I was laughed out of the office.
Ten years later, the company's business was in shambles; almost entirely because smartphones ate their lunch. I remember hearing people whining about "How could we have foreseen this?"
These days, I write software on my own. I don't have anyone telling me "Go away kid, yer bodderin' me."
It's been working well.
- vasco 4y agoOk, you walked into Marketing and said "This is gonna be trouble". What would happen next? Was the person looking at you even able to decide anything about what Marketing was working on? When you foresaw this huge danger to your employer, ten years in advance, you didn't keep mentioning it to people, or if change companies to somewhere that you know, you don't have the knowledge that is gonna fail for sure due to your foresight?
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y ago> Was the person looking at you even able to decide anything about what Marketing was working on? VP? Probably. > When you foresaw this huge danger to your employer, ten years in advance, you didn't keep mentioning it to people It only takes a couple of slaps to make us shut up[0]. They didn't want to hear from me, so I stopped trying to tell them stuff. Simple. In this case, what I did, was start learning about the iPhone, and start doing coding on my own, once Apple allowed us into the system (They didn't actually publish the iOS API for a while). I actually wrote a number of apps that would have integrated our products with the iPhone, as the years went by, but ... you guessed it ... they were ignored. I considered them as practice. I remember once, one of my Japanese peers saying "You know, I sometimes see something, and say to myself 'Chris mentioned this, like three years ago.'." But he never listened to me, at the time I was mentioning that. In fact, even after telling me that, he still refused to listen. I knew the company was being steered into the rocks, and was not allowed to help correct the course, so I spent my time, preparing a lifeboat. I don't have to justify to anyone, why I stuck around. If I have to explain, they wouldn't understand. Ego is a powerful force. We will utterly destroy ourselves, in order to salve our own insecurities. > change companies That seems to be everyone's answer, these days. I guess I'm stupid. I have not found it an attractive choice. [0] "A new idea is delicate. It can be killed by a sneer or a yawn; it can be stabbed to death by a joke or worried to death by a frown on the right person's brow." -Charles Browder
- sthatipamala 4y agoPeople have said similar things about me as your Japanese peer. What follows is tough love for myself so take it for what its worth: If no one listens to me when I'm right, that's my problem, not theirs. Everyone has their own incentives and motivations. If my goal is to actually effect change, the onus is on me to translate my strategy into a plan that is executable by self-interested, messy human beings.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoI don't consider that tough. I'm much harder on myself than that. There were many factors to consider. Factor One, was that I am not Japanese. Even though I had a level of "insider trust," that is very rare for westerners, I wasn't "one of them." Second, if you are familiar with the way Japanese companies run, hierarchy is crucial. Once you are informed that your input is not welcome, you are expected to just shut up, and fall into line. Pick up a musket, and kneel on the front row. Even if you know you are doomed, you shut up and aim. This has caused many problems. The Fukushima disaster was exacerbated by it. Another factor, was that I am not Marketing. "Staying in your wheelhouse" is something that is not unique to Japanese companies. The VP I mentioned was not Japanese. I was ignored, because I wasn't Marketing. I could have been an intern in Marketing, and I would have had more cred. I should also mention, that this was the same VP, that, in the 1990s, I mentioned that digital imaging was going to dominate, gave me a lecture about how film was never going to die. He was able to reverse course, quite quickly, on that one, though. The iPhone thing was a second chance. He didn't recover from that. And, of course, there's the old "It's not a problem, if we can't predict it 100%, ten years in advance," or "If you complain, you also need to have the solution." That second one is a killer. Many disastrously bad "solutions" come about, because the issue had not been explored enough, when the "solution" was presented. Sometimes, it is best to not have an answer, until you understand the question.
- ghostbrainalpha 4y agoIf you told execs with 100% certainty that a problem would kill a company 10 years from now, many wouldn't care, even if they totally believed you. Most execs don't see themselves at that company in 10 years time, so that type of problem just doesn't register for them.
- wahnfrieden 4y agoI suggest trying working with others as partner owners, instead of working in organizations of people who are compensated according to hours in seat
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoThis is true. I tried that, after the wheels came off my old company, but, you know, I also found out that us "olds" aren't particularly attractive in today's tech scene. It's OK. I just stopped trying to work for others, and have been quite happy, working with people that can't afford to pay me.
- marcosdumay 4y ago> I remember being called a "Cassandra," It's off-topic, but, why do people throw that as if it's an offense? They are certainly not self-identifying as stupid ones that will refuse to see real problems.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoBecause it is meant as an offense. It is designed to make it plain that our input is not welcome. The whole idea is to belittle someone else, and stop them from coming to you, with their ideas. To be fair, there are people who get waaaaayyyy too obsessed with "not a problems." I have worked with many of them, over the years. In fact, I just got off a video call with one that suggested that we scrap our entire, near-ship-ready app, because we are not sure how well it will scale for millions of users, and it is highly doubtful that it will have more than a few thousand users, for the next three or four years. This is an app that has been under development for two years, and is looking very good. I completely understand why what I said to Marketing was not received well. Part of it was practicality. Changing course is difficult, expensive, and risky. Even a high-level person would be crazy to do it on a whim. But the bigger part was ego. I know the people involved. In this community, tecchies are valued and listened to, but, if you are a small, technical team, in a marketing/sales/service company, you get used to being treated like Moss and Roy. What is a good idea, though, is to evaluate who is bringing the news, and what it would take to start examining the issue. If my company had done that, then they would have been well-prepared. That's something that many companies are spectacularly bad at. Instead, they stuck their fingers in their ears, and sang "La-la-la-I-can't-hear-you."
- danielmarkbruce 4y agoThis doesn't read well. If you want to be heard, communication skills matter.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoWell, that's something I'm fairly good at. A quick shufti at my writing will settle that. I covered it below. I actually totally understand why it was ignored. I don't agree with the reasons, but I needed to accept them, anyway. I did what I could, to prepare myself, and my team, while still performing the assigned duties. We did as well as could be expected. I stuck around, to the end, because it was my duty to my employees. My employers needed to deal with the problems they insisted on owning.
- danielmarkbruce 4y agoYou've managed to mention how good you are at several things. Your favorite word seems to be "I". It doesn't read well. You might be a brilliant engineer, but the communication on display is bad. Just saying "I'm a strategic thinker" will turn off a large % of people. That's 101 as far as interacting with humans goes.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoOh, I don't humblebrag. I won't get into why, but let's just say that my ethical position does not work with it. There's things I'm good at, and things I'm bad at. I don't shy from mentioning either. Anyone that has worked with me, is aware of how I work. Feel free to judge me. You certainly won't be alone. I miiiiggghttt suggest maybe doing a bit of research, first. I make it fairly easy.
- danielmarkbruce 4y agoJust judging what's been written. You might be a brilliant person, and a good one on top of it. All I'm saying is what's been written doesn't read well. Most people won't research others, they'll just see what's written (or said) and if that is a turn off, they'll shut down. If you have good ideas it's worth taking a little effort to understand the machines and systems you are dealing with (humans and organizations) so you can get those ideas broadly understood/accepted.